# A Glimpse at the Eighteenth Century: From John Bernoulli to Lagrange

- 1.2k Downloads

## Abstract

This essay tries to answer the following question: “What happened to Mechanics between Newton and Lagrange?”, hence during what is commonly called the century of the enlightenment or *Age of Reason*. This period where knowledge and learning are the main incentive for intellectuals—of which philosophers and scientists are most representative—, witnessed an evolution that went from the mechanics of point particles (or massive objects seen as such) with Newton to the first elements of continuum mechanics in the hands of Euler and Lagrange. The most famous contributors between these scientists are Jacques (Jacob) Bernoulli, John (Johann) Bernoulli, Daniel Bernoulli, Pierre Varignon, Jean Le Rond d’Alembert, Pierre de Maupertuis, and Leonhard Euler. We peruse the works and the contributions to the formulation and consolidation of various principles by these “mechanicians” on the basis of primary sources—sometimes with original English translations—and accounting for comments by Lagrange and more recent historians–mechanicians such as Jouguet and Truesdell. This period is marked by a great emphasis placed on the notion of living forces, the exploitation of the principle of virtual work, and the expansion of the calculus of variations, which all characterize the “continental” development of the principles of mechanics as opposed to the Newtonian vision. This essay is a prerequisite to the examination in other essays of all what was to be expanded in the thermo-mechanics of continua during the nineteenth century.

## Keywords

Mechanics Living forces Bernoulli Virtual work D’Alembert principle Euler Lagrange equations Calculus of variations## References

- 1.Ampère AM (1806) Démonstration générale du principe des vitesses virtuelles dégagée de la considération des infiniments petits. J Ecole Polytechnique 13 ème CahierGoogle Scholar
- 2.Anderson JD (1997) A history of aerodynamics and its impact on flying machines. Cambridge University Press, New YorkGoogle Scholar
- 3.Antman SS (1995) Nonlinear problems in elasticity. Springer, New YorkCrossRefGoogle Scholar
- 4.Bernhard H (1983) The Bernoulli family. In: Wussing H, Arnold W (eds) Biographien bedeutender Mathematiker, BerlinGoogle Scholar
- 5.Bernoulli J (John) (1727) Theoremata selecta pro conservatione virium vivarum demonstranda et experimenta confirmanda. Comment Acad Scientarium Imperialis Petropolitanae 2:200–207Google Scholar
- 6.Bernoulli J (John) (1735) De vera notione virium vivarum earimque usu in dynamicis, ostenso per exemplum, propositumi. Comment Petropolit Acta Eruditorum, Lipsiae (Leipzig), p 21Google Scholar
- 7.Bernoulli J (John) (1739) Hydraulica, nunc primum detecta ac demonstrata ex fundamentis pure mechanicis. BaselGoogle Scholar
- 8.Bernoulli J (John) (ed) (1742) Opera Omnia (Complete works, Four volumes). Bousquet, Lausanne and GenevaGoogle Scholar
- 9.Bernoulli D (1738) Hydrodynamica, BaselGoogle Scholar
- 10.Bernoulli D (1748) Remarques sur le principe de la conservation des forces vives pris dans un sens général. Histoire Acad Royale des Sci et belles lettres de Berlin 4:356–364Google Scholar
- 11.Capecchi D (2012) History of virtual work laws. The Science Historical Studies Series, vol 42. Birkhauser-Springer, MilanoGoogle Scholar
- 12.Carnot LNM (1803) Principes fondamentaux de l’équilibre et du mouvement. Deterville, Paris (Second extended edition of «Essai sur les machines en général, 1783», Deterville, Paris)Google Scholar
- 13.Clairaut A (1745) Sur quelques principes qui donnent la solution d’un grand nombre de problèmes de dynamique. Mémoires Acad Sci Paris (1742), pp 1–52Google Scholar
- 14.Dahan-Dalmenico A (1990) Le formalisme variationnel dans les travaux de Lagrange. In: La «mécanique analytique de Lagrange et son héritage», vol I, Acta Acad Scient Taurinensis, Suppl. No. 124:81–108Google Scholar
- 15.D’Alembert JLR (1743) Traité de dynamique, 1st edn. David, Paris (Reprint of the second augmented edition (1758) by Gauthier-Villars Publishers, in two volumes, Paris, 1925; also Facsimile reprint by Editions Gabay, Paris, 1998)Google Scholar
- 16.D’Alembert JLR (1744) Traité de l’équilibre et du mouvement des fluides pour servir de suite au traité de dynamique. David, ParisGoogle Scholar
- 17.D’Alembert JLR (1752) Essai sur une nouvelle théorie de la résistance des fluides (Competition essay for the 1750 prize of the Academy of Berlin)Google Scholar
- 18.D’Alembert JLR (1761–1780) Opuscules mathématiques (8 volumes). David, ParisGoogle Scholar
- 19.D’Alembert JLR (1779) Eloges lus dans les séances publiques de l’Académie française, ParisGoogle Scholar
- 20.D’Alembert JLR (1780) Sur quelques questions de mécanique. Opuscula Matematica, Tomus VIII, Mémoire 56, p 36Google Scholar
- 21.D’Arcy P (1747) Principe général de dynamique. Mémoires de l’Académie des Sciences, pp 348–356 (published 1752)Google Scholar
- 22.Dugas R (1950) History of mechanics, Editions du Griffon Neuchatel, Switzerland (Dover reprint, New York, 1988)Google Scholar
- 23.Euler L (1748) Recherches sur les plus grandes et plus petites qui se trouvent dans les actions des forces. Mémoires Acad Sci Berlin vol 4, p 149Google Scholar
- 24.Euler L (1752) Découverte d’un nouveau principe de mécanique (1750). Mémoires l’Acad Sci Berlin 6:185–217Google Scholar
- 25.Euler L (1757) Principes généraux de l’état d’équilibre des fluides. Mémoires de l’Académie des Sciences de Berlin, 1:217–273 (Memoirs presented to this Academy in 1755)Google Scholar
- 26.Euler L (1776) Nova methodus motum corporum rigidorum. Novi Com Acad Sci Petrop 20(1775):189–207 (also, ibid, 20:208–238)Google Scholar
- 27.Fourier JB (1798) Mémoire sur la statique contenant la démonstration du principe des vitesses virtuelles et la théorie des moments. J Ecole Polytechnique 5ème cahier:20–65 (Also in Œuvres complètes, Ed. G. Darboux, vol 2, pp 477–521, Gauthier-Villars, Paris)Google Scholar
- 28.Jouguet E (1924) Lectures de mécanique: La mécanique enseignée par les auteurs originaux. Gauthier-Villars, Paris (Facsimile reprint, Gabay, Paris, 2007)Google Scholar
- 29.Lagrange JL (1762) Essai d’une nouvelle méthode pour déterminer les maxima et les formules des intégrales minimum indéfinies. In: Serret JA, Darboux G (eds) Œuvres de Lagrange (1867–1892), vol 1, pp 335–362, Gauthier-Villars, ParisGoogle Scholar
- 30.Lagrange JL (1762) Application de la méthode exposée dans le mémoire précédent à la solution des problèmes de dynamique différents. In: Serret JA, Darboux G (eds) Œuvres de Lagrange (1867–1892), vol 1, pp 151–316, Gauthier-Villars, ParisGoogle Scholar
- 31.Lagrange JL (1788) Mécanique analytique, 1st edn. 1788, Vve Desaint, Paris, 2nd edn. Vve Courcier, Paris, 1811 (Facsimile reprint of 4th edition with notes and comments par J. Bertrand and G. Darboux, Gabay, Paris). English edition: Lagrange JL (1997) (trans: Boissonnade A, Vagliente VN (eds)) 2nd edn. Springer, Dordrecht, 1811Google Scholar
- 32.Lagrange JL (1798) Sur le principe des vitesses virtuelles. J Ecole Polytechnique 5:115–118Google Scholar
- 33.Lagrange JL (1965) Reprint of the second volume (3rd and 4th edn.) of Lagrange’s Mécanique analytique (exclusively Dynamics) with notes by Joseph Bertrand and Gaston Darboux, Librairie Scientifique Albert Blanchard, ParisGoogle Scholar
- 34.Maugin GA (2012) The principle of virtual power: from eliminating metaphysical forces to providing an efficient modelling tool. Cont Mech Thermodynam 25:127–146CrossRefMathSciNetGoogle Scholar
- 35.Maugin GA (2013) Piola and Kirchhoff: On changes of configurations. Preprint, UPMC, Paris (also Chap. 4 in the present book)Google Scholar
- 36.Maupertuis PLM (de) (1740) Loi de mouvement et de repos de la nature. Mémoires Acad Sciences de Paris. Also: Œuvres de Maupertuis, vol 4, pp 1–28, Bruyset, Lyon (1746)Google Scholar
- 37.Maupertuis PLM (de) (1744) Des lois du mouvement et du repos. In: Œuvres de Maupertuis, vol 4, pp 29–64. Bruyset, Lyon (1746)Google Scholar
- 38.Pfeiffer J (2005) Le traité de géométrie de Varignon et l’apprentissage mathématique du jeune d’Alembert. In: Recherches sur Diderot et sur l’Encyclopédie, No.38, Avril 2005, pp 125–150 (edited by Société Diderot, Langres, France)Google Scholar
- 39.Truesdell CA (1968) Essays in the history of mechanics. Springer, BerlinCrossRefzbMATHGoogle Scholar
- 40.Truesdell CA (1984) An idiot’s fugitive essays on science. Springer, New YorkCrossRefzbMATHGoogle Scholar
- 41.Truesdell CA, Toupin RA (1960) The classical theory of fields. In: Flügge S (ed) Handbuch der Physik, Bd III/1, Springer, BerlinGoogle Scholar