Abstract
The concept of levelized energy costs responds to the necessity of disclosing the future consequences of present decisions. This incorporates what price should be charged per unit of energy sold in order to recover the total life cycle cost of energy production. This chapter charts the effectiveness of levelized cost formulas over time depicting how the perspectives for electricity generation in the UK and in France have evolved. While cost comparisons in the 1950s were almost exclusively focused on the eventuality of nuclear power catching up with the competitiveness of coal power, in the 1960s, things became thornier as nuclear hopes fell short of expectations and also because a new competitor—oil-fired power stations—made significant strides in the marketplace. The final conclusion points out that whereas in periods of relative price stability, all concerns center on reductions in the part of the formula accounting for capital costs, in periods of higher volatility, the focus switches to trends in the forecasting of fuel prices. Depending on the historical circumstances, the levelized energy costs formula was viewed either through the lens of “yesterday’s costs”—the most up-to-date estimates of existing equipment and installations—or through the lens of “tomorrow’s costs”—the likely evolution of fuel prices.
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Bibliography
Archival Sources
National Archives (NA), London
NA.- Cabinet Papers (1955) A programme for nuclear power. Minister of Fuel and Power—Geoffrey Lloyd, Feb 1955
NA. EG-1-60 (1955) White paper correspondence and reports, 31 Jan 1955
NA. EG-20-3 (1974) Iain K. Forster, Fuel policy, June 1974
NA. POWE 14-740 (1954–1955) Documents and correspondence on the trend Report. 17 Jan 1955
NA. POWE-14-741 (1953) Atomic energy for civil purposes: note by the Ministry of Power. Note of meeting in BEA offices. Letters to Lord Cherwell. 4–11 May 1953
NA. POWE-14-1407 (1963–1965) Estimated costs of power stations. 18 Mar–3 Apr 1963
NA. POWE-14-2744 (1972) Construction costs of CEGB fossil-fired power stations 1950–1972. 20 Dec 1972; Note of a meeting to discuss energy policy in Thames House South, Millbank, Wednesday 21 June 1972
Archives Nationales de France (ANF), Fontainebleau
ANF. Box 19910737 Dossier 3 (1959) Gibrat, R. La filiére des reacteurs de puissance a uranium naturelle, graphite et gaz sous pression, allocution faite a Essen le, 25 Sep 1959
ANF. Box 19910737 Dossier 1 (1970) VI plan, Groupe prospective de la commision de l’enérgie, L’offre de pétrole, 14 Jan 1970
Archives Eléctricité de France (AEDF), Blois
AEDF. 800545 File 27243 (1970) Centrales françaises en service et en construction, 25 Mar 1970
AEDF. 800621 File 27319 (1971) M. Autesserre, Le probléme central de l’ environnement pour EDF. 18 Aug 1971
AEDF. 800629 File 27327 (1956) D. Jung. Intervention des centrales nucléaires
AEDF. 800624 File 27322 (1971) Resumé des principales parametres economiques relatives aux tranches nucléaires, 14 Avril 1971
AEDF. 943408 File 39726 (1958) Étude technique des centrales thermiques. EDF—Direction de l’Équipement
References
Ailleret P (1954) Les perspectives d’intégration de l’énergie nucléaire dans les moyens de production d’énergie électrique. Revue Française de l’Energie 51:203–211
Arent DJ et al (2011) The status and prospects of renewable energy for combating global warming. Energy Econ 33(4):584–593
Benn T (1990) Against the tide. Diaries 1973–1976. Arrow Books, London
Brussière E (ed) (2003) Georges Pompidou face à la mutation économique de l’ Occident 1969–1964. PUF, Paris
Clapp BW (1994) The environmental history of Britain since the industrial revolution. Longman, London
CEGB (1973–1974) Statistical yearbook. Central Electricity Generating Board, London
Coase RH (1960) The problem of social cost. J Law Econ 3:1–44
Cochran TB et al (2010) Fast breeder reactor programs: history and status. Available via http://fissilematerials.org/library/rr08.pdf. Accessed 22 May 2012
Cockcroft J (1953) Nuclear reactors and their applications. J Inst Electr Eng 100(3):117–120
Cockcroft J (1957) The development of nuclear power. J Br Inst Radio Eng 17(5):245–252
Cooke S (2009) In mortal hands—a cautionary history of the nuclear age. Bloomsbury, New York
Davies R (1984) The sizewell B nuclear inquiry: an analysis of public participation in decision making about nuclear power. Sci Technol Human Values 9(3):21–32
Dürr M (1996) Le tournant nucleaire d´Eléctricité de France. In: Morsel H (ed) Histoire de l´électricité de France, vol 3. Fayard, Paris, pp 693–783
Economic Statistics Database—ECONSTATS (2010) Economic statistics for France and Great Brirtain. Available via http://www.econstats.com/. Accessed 3 Oct 2012
Frenken K, Leydesdorff L (2000) Scaling trajectories in civil aircraft (1913–1997). Res Policy 29(3):331–348
Foasso MC (2003) Histoire de la sûreté de l’énergie nucléaire civile en France (1945–2000). Dissertation, Université Lumière–Lyon II
Gorman HS, Solomon BD (2002) The origins and practice of emissions trading. J Policy Hist 14(3):293–320
Gowing M (1978) Reflections on atomic energy history: the rede lecture. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Grubler A (2010) The costs of the French nuclear scale-up: a case of negative learning by doing. Energy Policy 38(9):5174–5188
Hall P (1986) Governing the economy: the politics of state intervention in Britain and France. Oxford University Press, New York
Hecht G (1998) The radiance of France—nuclear power and national identity after World War II. MIT Press, Cambridge
Hinton C (1957) The axel axson Johnson lecture. Ingeniörs Vetenskaps Akademien, Stockholm
Hinton C, Brown FHS, Rotherham L (1960) The economics of nuclear power in Great Britain. In: World power conference, Sucs. Rivadenevra, Madrid, pp 1–24
Howland N, Daigle C (ed) (2011) Foreign relations of the United States, 1969–1976, V. 25, Arab-Israeli crisis and war. State Department—Bureau of Public Affairs, Washington. Available via http://history.state.gov/historicaldocuments/frus1969-76v25. Accessed 15 Oct 2012
Jukes JA (1955) The cost of power and the value of plutonium from early nuclear power stations. In: Proceedings of the U.N. international conference on the peaceful uses of atomic energy, Geneve, vol 1, pp 322–326
Komanoff C (1981) Power plant cost escalation: nuclear and coal capital costs, regulation and economics. Komanoff Energy Associates, New York
Lamiral G (1988) Chronique de trente années d’équipement nucléaire à Electricité de France. AHEF, Paris, tomb I
McCabe MJ (1996) Principals, agents, and the learning curve: the case of steam-electric power plant design and construction. J Ind Econ 44(4):357–375
Perdan S, Azapagic A (2011) Carbon trading: current schemes and future developments. Energy Policy 39(10):6040–6054
Picard J-F et al (1985) Histoire de l’EDF. Comment se sont prises les décisions de 1946 à nos jours. Dunod, Paris
Robens L (1972) Ten year stint. Cassell, London
Ringquist EJ (2011) Trading equity for efficiency in environmental protection? Environmental justice effects from the SO2 allowance trading program. Soc Sci Q 92(2):297–323
Roberts F (1999) 60 years of nuclear history-Britain’s hiden agenda. Jon Carpenter Publishing, Oxfordshire
Sheail J (1991) Power in trust: the environmental history of the Central Electricity Generating Board. Clarendon press, Oxford
Skjærseth JB, Wettestad J (2009) The origin, evolution and consequences of the EU emissions trading system. Glob Environ Polit 9(2):101–122
Trainer T (2012) A critique of Jacobson and Delucchi’s proposals for a world renewable energy supply. Energy Policy 44:476–481
UKAEA (1957) The nuclear power programme. Atom 5:5–17
Williams R (1980) The nuclear power decisions: British policies, 1953–1978. Croom Helm, London
Wilson C (2012) Up-scaling, formative phases, and learning in the historical diffusion of energy technologies. Energy Policy 50:81–94
Yvon J (1955) La Pile de Saclay, expérience acquise en deux ans sur le transfert de chaleur par gaz comprimé, par J. Yvon communication du C.E.A. à la conférence de Genève, août 1955. Centre d’Études Nucléaires, Geneva
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 2014 Springer International Publishing Switzerland
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Madureira, N.L. (2014). Levelized Electricity Costs. In: Key Concepts in Energy. Springer, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-04978-6_9
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-04978-6_9
Published:
Publisher Name: Springer, Cham
Print ISBN: 978-3-319-04977-9
Online ISBN: 978-3-319-04978-6
eBook Packages: EnergyEnergy (R0)