Abstract
Sweden attracted much attention as an interesting socioeconomic role model already in the 1930s, especially after Marquis Childs published his famous and influential book, The Swedish Middle Way (1936). Childs’ main argument was that the “Swedish model” was a successful “socialist” policy with a growing cooperative sector—as a counterbalance to the private sector—and effective crisis management. Of special interest to him was the building of cheap homes for the working class undertaken by the common good (public and cooperative sector). This was accomplished through strong and decisive government intervention in economic life, especially to fight mass unemployment with Keynesian-style policy tools.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution.
Buying options
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Learn about institutional subscriptionsNotes
- 1.
Landsorganisationen.
- 2.
SAP has adopted new revised programs at eight congresses: 1905, 1911, 1920, 1944, 1960, 1975, 1990, 2001 and 2013.
- 3.
Hyresgästernas sparkasse- och byggnadsförening (Tenants’ Savings and Construction Association.
- 4.
- 5.
Almost 900 thousand Swedes emigrated to America between 1865 and 1910, a big number in relation to the population of Sweden, which was two million in 1865 and 2.7 million in 1910 (SCB 1969).
- 6.
The maximum pension amount (per year) was 150 crowns for men and 140 crowns for women. In comparison, the average wage for an industrial worker was 1300 crowns per year at the time.
- 7.
Lenin’s visit does not seem to have had any impact on the succeeding events in Stockholm.
- 8.
The eyewitness, Nils Horney, reporter from the major social democratic newspaper, gave the account in his memoirs published in 1969 (quoted in Ohlsson 2014).
- 9.
One of them was a speaker at the event, Per Albin Hansson, later to become Prime Minister of the SAP government in 1932.
- 10.
- 11.
In 1921, it changed name to the Swedish Communist Party (SKP).
- 12.
Quoted in Therborn 1986.
- 13.
Wigforss became the Minister of Finance and Engberg the Minister of Education, in the social democratic government that started its 44-year-long rule in 1932. Wigforss was the Minister of Finance for 18 years. Möller was the Minister of Social Affairs for 17 years.
- 14.
See also Introduction by Paul Krugman to The General Theory of Employment, Interest, and Money, edition 2006. http://www.pkarchive.org/economy/GeneralTheoryKeynesIntro.html
- 15.
HSB, The Tenants Association, which is part of the cooperative movement, had been founded already in 1923.
- 16.
Bostadssociala utredningen.
- 17.
Svenska Arbetsgivareföreningen.
- 18.
In the aftermath of the 1968 student unrest, many new radical groups (even parties) saw the light, and the Saltsjöbaden Agreement came under attack again as “class collaboration”.
- 19.
This is just a brief summary of a 77-page document!
- 20.
But Richard Sandler, the chairman of the commission, submitted a report that was just aimed at summarizing the work of the commission.
- 21.
The Liberal Party, the Center Party (Farmers Party), and the Conservative Party.
- 22.
PHM stand for Planhus Hållnings Motståndet = Planned Economy Resistance. PHM was actually invented by the social democrats and used as an invective in the heated discussions.
- 23.
As chief editor of Dagens Nyheter, the largest opposition daily newspaper.
- 24.
Alf Ross (1899–1979) was a respected legal and moral philosopher. His books were often referred to in political science. His most important book was perhaps Why Democracy? (1952).
- 25.
Ohlin had in 1944 claimed in an article that Folkpartiet (the LP) is a “left party” and that it has – in opposition to the Right Party – driven forward universal suffrage and many economic and social reforms (Lewin 1967, p. 297).
- 26.
The popular saying goes: “while it was Per Albin Hansson who created Folkhemmet, it was Ingvar Kamprad (IKEA) who furnished it.”
- 27.
The 30 years of rapid economic and social development after the war (1945–1975) is not unique to Sweden of course. In France, the same period is referred to as Les Trente Glorieuses.
- 28.
Meidner himself refers in this context to the British Labor Party’s (or rather Beveridge’s) definition: “full employment is the situation where there are permanently more jobs to fill than those who can fill them” (Meidner 1993).
- 29.
The party had changed its name to the Center Party in 1957.
- 30.
In a report from 1946 on the future demand for labor in Sweden, a whole section was devoted to the need for an “immigration policy” (Ahlberg and Svennilson 1946).
- 31.
The origin of the oil crisis was the Yom Kippur War between Israel and Egypt and Syria (October 6–25, 1973).
OPEC stopped its oil deliveries to the United States and Western Europe, with big repercussions on the world economy. The golden years with high growth rates were over.
- 32.
Göran Therborn, a young academic, got an important influence with his book A New Left (Therborn 1966).
- 33.
Fackföreningsrörelsen CitationRef CitationID="CR95">1975</CitationRef>:21 (quoted in Sjöberg 2003).
- 34.
Fackföreningsrörelsen CitationRef CitationID="CR95">1975</CitationRef>:21).
- 35.
The LP changed names several times. Between 1934 and 2015, it was called Folkpartiet (The People’s Party. The LP is used all the time in this chapter for sake of simplicity.
- 36.
Tham later joined the Social Democratic Party and became in 1985 also minister.
- 37.
Anders Johnson: Liberala misstag och svek vi minns (Liberal Debatt, 28 mars 2016) https://www.liberaldebatt.se/2016/03/liberala-misstag-och-svek-vi-minns/
- 38.
SOU 1979:8, Löntagarna och företagens kapitaltillväxt (The Wage Earners and Company Capital Formation).
- 39.
Referring to the “planning debate” just after the war.
- 40.
Government Bill 1983/84:50.
- 41.
He was observed (by a photographer) writing in his notebook: “wage earner funds are shit, but now we have pushed them all the way bit by bit” (in Swedish: “löntagarfonder är skit men nu har vi baxat dem ända hit”).
- 42.
MBL = Medbestämmandelagen.
- 43.
After winning the elections, the new government made a “super-devaluation” of 16%. However, it proved to have no long-term impact. After just 3 to 4 years, the inflation (and wages and salaries) continued to increase more in Sweden than in the rest of Europe.
‘
- 44.
- 45.
Kanlihushögern (the Right Wing of the Government) was the nickname (or perhaps rather the invective) referring to the group of young economic advisors at the Ministry of Finance (“Kjell-Olof Feldt’s boys”). In 2019, a book was published about this time (Lindgren, editor 2019), with contributions by many of those involved.
- 46.
The Postwar Program and the Party Programs of the Social Democratic Party.
- 47.
LO had an article in their journal entitled “The government abandons the equalization policy,” and the Minister of Foreign Affairs warned in an article in the party paper Arbetet that “Rightist ideas begin to gain foothold in the party” (Elmbrant 1993).
- 48.
The press often referred to the War of the Roses, when the left and the right in the party started fighting.
- 49.
It would be called the “Tax Reform of the Century.”
- 50.
See, e.g., Lindbom (2011).
- 51.
The coalition government: The Moderates, the LP, the Center Party, and the Christian Democrats. An extreme right party also got seats in the Riksdag (New Democracy) for the first time.
- 52.
Among these, George Soros, the multibillionaire.
- 53.
SAP got 45.3% of the votes, the Green Party 5.0%, and the Left Party 6.2%.
- 54.
It was Göran Persson who, as Minister of Education, in 1989 was behind a disastrous “communalization” of the school system in Sweden (discussed below).
- 55.
Sweden has 290 communes and 20 regional councils (the latter primarily responsible for hospitals and other health care).
- 56.
The rapid expansion of corporations (“risk capitalists”) establishing schools (especially high schools) seems to have taken at least some of the bourgeois initiative takers by surprise. “There was nobody who could imagine corporations in front of us,” says Beatrice Ask, a member of parliament from the Moderate Party (LO 2018).
- 57.
Håkan Svärdman: Urholkningen av. socialförsäkringen försämrar jämlikheten (Dagens Arena 17/1/2017). http://www.dagensarena.se/opinion/urholkade-socialforsakringar-forsamrar-jamlikheten/
- 58.
The Conservative now called themselves “The New Moderates,” also referring to the party as “the new labor party” (sic), with Fredrik Reinfeldt as leader and Prime Minister.
- 59.
In 2014, SAP formed a new government with the Green Party (supported by the Left Party). In 2017, the government suggested that the stop law be reinstated. It did not pass because of the votes of the bourgeois opposition and (new in the Riksdag) the right wing SD (Sweden Democrats).
- 60.
- 61.
Aftonbladet August 14, 2001.
- 62.
In 2014, SAP formed a new government with the Green Party (supported by the Left Party). In 2017, the government suggested that the stop law be reinstated. It did not pass because of the votes of the bourgeois opposition and (new in the Riksdag) the right wing SD (Sweden Democrats).
- 63.
In Sweden of today, it is increasingly difficult to get full-time contracts, especially for women.
- 64.
Katalys produced during 2017–2019 a series of reports that were critically constructive of the dismantling of the Swedish welfare system as we have known it.
- 65.
The urban population grew from 38% to 73% of the total, between 1931 and 1969, in less than 40 years.
- 66.
The Gini has a scale from 0 to 1; the lower the coefficient, the more equality.
- 67.
Disposable income is factor incomes (wage and capital income) minus taxes plus transfer payments (cash social security benefits).
- 68.
Capital income consists of interests and dividends and capital gains (buying and selling property and other assets).
- 69.
Two-tier health systems exist in many countries. As a matter of fact, it is rather rule than exception.
References
Adler-Karlsson G (1969) Functional socialism. A Swedish theory for democratic socialization. Prisma, Stockholm
Ahlberg G, Svennilson I (1946) Sveriges arbetskraft och den industriella utvecklingen (Swedish labor force and industrial development). IUI, Stockholm
Allelin M, Kalifatides M, Sjöberg S, Skyrman V (2018a) Ägande- och förmögenhetsstrukturen och dess förändring sedan 1980 (Ownership and wealth structure and its change since 1980). Katalys Institute, Stockholm
Allelin M, Kalifatides M, Sjöberg S, Skyrman V (2018b) Välfärdsmodellens omvandling: Det privata kapitalets utvidgning i den offentliga sektorn (Transformation of the welfare model: the expansion of private capital in the public sector). Katalys Institute, Stockholm
Ankarloo D (2012) Välfärdsmyter. Visst har vi råd att finansiera tryggheten (Welfare Myths of course we can afford to finance social security). ETC, Stockholm
Antman P (1999) Möllers andra agenda—om offentliga tjänster och socialisering. http://www.antman.se/publicerat/mollers-andra-agenda
ARB (2001) Socialdemokratins program 1897 till 2001. Arbetarrörelsens arkiv och bibliotek, Stockholm
ARB (1944) Arbetarrörelsens efterkrigsprogram—de 27 punkterna med motivering (1944), (The post-war program of the labor movement). Arbetarrörelsens arkiv och bibliotek, Stockholm
Åsard E (1978) LO och löntagarfrågan (LO and the Wage-Earner fund question). Rabén & Sjögren, Stockholm
Åsard E (1985) Kampen on löntagarfonderna (The struggle over the Wage-Earner funds). Norstedts, Stockholm
Belfrage C, Kallifatides M (2017) Financialiseringen av Sverige: På väg mot nästa kris (The financialization of Sweden: heading towards the next crisis?). Katalys Institute, Stockholm
Berggren C (n.d.) Socialdemokratin och efterkrigsprogrammet (Social democracy and the post-war program). http://www.marxistarkiv.se/sverige/fk/kommunist_om_efterkrigsprogrammet.pdf
Borg-kommissionen (2010) Välfärdens framtida finansiering (The financing of future welfare). http://arenaide.se/borg-kommissionen-valfardens-framtida-finansiering/
Calmfors L, Sánchez Gassen NE (eds) (2019) Integrating immigrants into the Nordic labour markets. Nordic Council of Ministers, Copenhagen. http://norden.diva-portal.org/smash/get/diva2:1317928/FULLTEXT01.pdf
Childs MW (1936) Sweden: the middle way. Faber & Faber Ltd, London
Crouch D (2018) Bumblebee nation: the hidden story of the New Swedish model. Karl-Adam Bonniers Stiftelse, Stockholm
Dagens Nyheter (2019) “OECD: I Sverige betraktas lärarna som servicepersonal” (OECD: In Sweden the teachers are regarded as service personnel). Dagens Nyheter, Stockholm (3 December 2019)
de Vylder S (1996) The Rise and Fall of the “Swedish Model”, UNDP: Human Development Report Occasional Papers 1996-04
Ekdahl L (2002) Löntagarfonderna—en missad möjlighet? (The Wage earner funds—a lost opportunity?). Samtidshistoriska institutet, Söertörns Högskola, Huddinge
Elmbrant B (2019) Marknadens tyranni (The Tyranny of the market). Leopard Förlag, Stockholm
Elmbrant B (1993) Så föll den svenska modellen (The fall of the Swedish model). T. Fischer & Co, Stockholm
Elmér Å (1975) Från fattigsverige till välfärdsstaten (From poverty Sweden to the welfare state). Aldus, Stockholm
Esping-Andersen G (1985) Politics against markets—the social democratic road to power. Princeton University Press, Princeton
Esping-Andersen G (1990) The three worlds of welfare capitalism. Princeton University Press, Princeton
Esping-Andersen G (1994) After the golden age: the future of the welfare state in the new global order. UNRISD, Geneva
Esping-Andersen G (2009) The incomplete revolution. Adapting to women’s new roles. Polity Press, Malden
Feldt K-O (1991) Alla dessa dagar i regeringen 1982–1990. Norstedts, Stockholm
Feldt K-O (1994) Rädda välfärdsstaten! Norstedts, Stockholm
Feldt K-O (2012) En kritisk betraktelse om socialdemokratins seger och kris. Albert Bonniers förlag, Stockholm
Forslund A (1997) The Swedish model: past, present and future. In: Giersch H (ed) Reforming the welfare state. Springer, New York
Galbraith JK (1987) Economics in perspective. Houghton Mifflin Company, Boston
George DAR (1992) The political economy of Wage-Earner finds: policy debate and Swedish experience. Queen’s University, Department of Economics, Kingston (Canada): Working paper No. 839
Gertten F (2019) “Push. Landlords without faces, apartments without tenants”. A documentary exploring the new unlivable city. https://www.wgfilm.com
Government Bill 1983/84:50. https://data.riksdagen.se/fil/CE1965E4-9D0A-4BB1-B1FB-93BD7AA365CD
Government of Sweden (2017) The Swedish model. Ministry of Finance, Stockholm. https://www.government.se/information-material/2017/06/the-swedish-model/
Greider G (2018) Liten bergspredikan för socialister (Little Sermon on the Mount for Socialists). Ordfront, Stockholm
Greider G, Linderborg Å (2018) Populistiska manifestet (The populist manifesto). Natur och Kultur, Stockholm
Greider G (2011) Ingen kommer undan Olof Palme (Nobody can get round Olof Palme). Ordfront Förlag, Stockholm
Hansson G (2018) Reformism och Utopism. Wigforss, efterkrigstid och socialdemokratins framtid (Reformism and Utopism. Wigforss, post-war time and the future of social democracy). Arkiv Förlag, Lund
Hägg G (2005) Välfärdsåren (The welfare years). Månpocket, Stockholm
Jacobsson U (2004) Rehn-Meidner modellen in memoriam. Ekonomisk Debatt No.5
Johnson A (2016) Liberala misstag och svek som vi minns (Liberal mistakes and deceits that remember). Liberal Debatt, 28 March 2016). http://www.liberaldebatt.se/2016/03/liberala-misstag-och-svek-vi-minns/
Kallifatides M, Belfrage C (2017) Finansialiseringen av Sverige. Stockholm: Katalys No. 38
Karlsson R, Wentus P-E (2013) Löntagarfonder—rörelse kontra politik. http://arkiv.rodarummet.org/2013/08/24/lontagarfonder-rorelse-kontra-politik/
Keynes JM (1936) General theory of employment, interest and money. Macmillan, London
Klockare S (1967) Den svenska revolutionen 1917–18 (The Swedish revolution). Prisma, Stockholm. Korpi, Walter?
Krugman P (2006) Introduction to the general theory of employment, interest, and money, edition 2006. http://www.pkarchive.org/economy/GeneralTheoryKeynesIntro.html
Lapidus J (2018) Vårdstölden—hur den privata välfärden tar från det gemensamma (The health care theft—how private welfare steals from the common good). Leopard, Stockholm
Larsmo O (2002) En näve från svensk revolution (A fist from a Swedish revolution), Dagens Nyheter, 5 May 2002
Lewin L (2017) Ideologi och strategi (Ideology and strategy). Carlssons, Stockholm
Lewin L (1967) Planhushållningsdebatten (The planning debate). Almqvist & Wiksells, Stockholm
Lindberg E (2017) Pensionssveket- En rapport om ett ohållbart pensionssystem (The retirement betrayal). Stockholm: Katalys, Nr. 36
Lindbom A (2011) Systemskifte? Den nya svenska välfärdspolitiken (Systemic change? The new Swedish welfare policy). Studentlitteratur, Lund
Lindellee J (2018) Beyond retrenchment. Multi-pillarization of Swedish unemployment benefit provision. PhD dissertation, Lund University
Linderborg Å (2001) Socialdemokraterna skriver historia: Historieskrivning som ideologisk maktresurs (The social democrats make history- historiography as an ideological resource of power, 1892–2000. PhD dissertation, Stockholm: Atlas
Lindgren-Åsbrink M (2019) Kanslihushögern- Frälsare eller dödgrävare (The Government Right Wing -Savior or Gravedigger?). Tiden, Stockholm
Listerborn C (2018) Bostadsojämlikhet (Housing inequality). Premiss, Malmö
LO (1975) Fackföreningsrörelsen (The LO journal), Number 1975:21
LO (2018) Skolindustrin. Hur mångfald blev enfald (The School Industry. How Diversity Became Folly). http://www.lo.se/home/lo/res.nsf/vRes/lo_fakta_1366027478784_skolindustrin_pdf/$File/Skolindustrin.pdf
Lundh C (1987) Den svenska debatten om industriell demokrati 1919–1924 (The Swedish debate on industrial democracy, 1919–1924). PhD dissertation, Lund: Arkiv
Lundberg E (1985) The rise and fall of the Swedish model. J Econ Lit 23(1):1–36
Meidner R (2005) Spelet om löntagarfonderna (The game about the Wage Earner funds). Atlas, Stockholm
Meidner R (1998) The rise and fall of the Swedish model. Challenge 41(1):69–90
Meidner R (1993) Why did the Swedish model fail? The Socialist Register
Meidner R (1981) Collective asset formation through wage earner funds. Int Labour Rev 120(3):303. May-June 1981
Myrdal G (1961) Planhushållning i välfärdsstaten (Planning in the welfare state). Tiden, Stockholm. Also published as Beyond the Welfare State, Yale University Press 1963
Myrdal Alva and Gunnar (1934) Kris i befolkningsfrågan (Crisis in the population question), Stockholm
Nordic Council of Ministers (2019) Lars Calmfors. http://norden.diva-portal.org/smash/get/diva2:1317928/FULLTEXT01.pdf
OECD (1992) Review of Education Policy in Sweden: Examiners Report and Questions
Offer A (2016) The market turn: from social democracy to market liberalisation: https://www.economics.ox.ac.uk/materials/papers/14929/149decemberoffer.pdf
Ohlsson PT (2014) Svensk Politik (Swedish politics). Historiska Media, Lund
Olsson U (1991) Planning in the Swedish welfare state, studies in political economy, No 34, Spring 1991
Pelling L (2019 The Swedish face of inequality. https://www.socialeurope.eu/the-swedish-face-of-inequality
Pérez C (2002) Technological revolutions and financial capital. The dynamics of bubbles and golden ages. Edward Elgar, Cheltenham
Piketty T (2014) Capital in the Twenty-First Century. Harvard University Press, Cambridge
Piketty T (2019) Capital and Ideology. Harvard University Press, Cambridge
Pontusson J, Kuruvilla S (1992) Swedish Wage-Earner funds: an experiment in economic democracy. Ind Labor Relat Rev 45(4):779–791. (July 1992, Cornell University)
Pontusson J (1992) The limits of social democracy: investment politics in Sweden. Cornell University Press, New York
Ross A (1952) Why democracy? Harvard University Press, Cambridge
Schön L (2012) An economic history of modern Sweden. Routledge, London
Sjöberg S (2003) Löntagarfondsfrågan—en hegemonisk vändpunkt (The Wage Earner fund question: a hegemonic turning point). PhD dissertation, Uppsala: Uppsala University
Sjögren G, Wadensjö E (2012) Income distribution among those of 65 years and older in Sweden. IZA, Bonn. http://ftp.iza.org/dp6745.pdf
SCB (1969) Historical statistics for Sweden. Population 1720–1967. Statistiska Centralbyrån, Stockholm
SCB (2017) Kapitalinkomster ger ökade inkomstskillnader. https://www.scb.se/hitta-statistik/statistik-efter-amne/hushallens-ekonomi/inkomster-och-inkomstfordelning/inkomster-och-skatter/pong/statistiknyhet/slutliga-inkomster-och-skatter-2015/
SNS (2011) Välfärdsrapport 2011. Inkomstfördelningen i Sverige. SNS, Stockholm. https://wwwsnsse.cdn.triggerfish.cloud/uploads/2016/08/vr-2011_inlaga_0.pdf
SOU (2016) Ordning och reda i välfärden (Order and remedy in the welfare) Number 2016:78
Spross L (2017) A dilemma for the welfare state: managing the costs for shorter working hours. PhD Dissertation, Labor History, 58(1):26–43
Stephens EH (1980) The politics of workers’ participation. Academic Press, New York
Stöber N, Suhonen D, Therborn G (2018) Klass, identitet och politisk mobilisering (Class, identity and political mobilization). Stockholm: Katalys No. 40
Sunkara B (2019) The Socialist Manifesto, Basic Books, New York
Svärdman H (2017) Urholkningen av socialförsäkringen försämrar jämlikheten (The erosion of social security deteriorates equality). http://www.dagensarena.se/opinion/urholkade-socialforsakringar-forsamrar-jamlikheten/
Therborn G (2018) Kapitalet, överheten and alla vi andra (The capital, the rulers and all the rest of us). Arkiv, Lund
Therborn G (1966) En ny vänster (A new left). Prisma, Stockholm
Therborn G (1986) The working class and the welfare state. A historical-analytical overview and a Little Swedish Monograph. https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/14903688.pdf
Timothy A. Tilton, (1979) A Swedish Road to Socialism: Ernst Wigforss and the Ideological Foundations of Swedish Social Democracy. American Political Science Review 73 (2):505-520
Tingsten H (1941) Den svenska socialdemokratins idéutveckling (The development of Swedish social democratic ideology) (I and II). Tidens Förlag, Stockholm
Viktorov I (2006) Fordismens kris och löntagarfonder i Sverige (The Crisis of Fordism and Wage Earner Funds in Sweden). PhD dissertation, Stockholm: Stockholm University
Whyman P (2006) Post-Keynesianism, socialisation of investment and Swedish wage-earner funds. Camb J Econ 30(1):49–68
Wigforss E (1952) Socialism i vår tid (Socialism in our time). Tiden, Stockholm
Wigforss E (2013) Kan dödläget brytas? (Can the deadlock be unlocked?) Selected writings of Ernst Wigforss. Karneval förlag, Stockholm
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Annex Tables
Annex Tables
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 2020 Springer Nature Switzerland AG
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Brundenius, C. (2020). Social Democracy and the Fate of the Swedish Model. In: Brundenius, C. (eds) Reflections on Socialism in the Twenty-First Century. Springer, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-33920-3_3
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-33920-3_3
Published:
Publisher Name: Springer, Cham
Print ISBN: 978-3-030-33919-7
Online ISBN: 978-3-030-33920-3
eBook Packages: Economics and FinanceEconomics and Finance (R0)