Advertisement

The Russian National Subcommission of ICMI and the Mathematics Education Reform Movement

  • Alexander KarpEmail author
Chapter
  • 117 Downloads
Part of the International Studies in the History of Mathematics and its Teaching book series (ISHMT)

Abstract

In this chapter, the history of the formation and functioning of the Russian National Subcommission is examined against the background of, and in connection with, the whole reform movement in mathematics education that developed in Russia and, even more broadly, the movement that sought political changes in the country. The following topics are addressed: the formation of the subcommission, the subcommission’s reports, Russian participation in international conferences and congresses, Russian commissions associated with reforms in mathematics education, and National Congresses of mathematics teachers. In writing this chapter, archival materials were used, as well as numerous articles from the journals and newspapers of the period.

Keywords

Russian National Subcommission Reform Reports First Congress of mathematics teachers Second Congress of mathematics teachers International meetings 

Notes

Acknowledgment

The author expresses his gratitude to the Harriman Institute for supporting his work on the reports of the Russian subcommission.

Publications of the Russian National Subcommission

  1. B.S. and V. Kondratiev. 1911. Ecole primares et les Ecoles normales and les gymnases du garcons. St. Petersburg.Google Scholar
  2. Mikhelson, Nikolay, Dmitrii Goriachev [Goriatchev], Pavel Koturnitsky [Kotournitzki], and Alexey Gattsuk [Hartzouck]. 1912. Les gymnases de jeunes filles et dans l’Institut Superieur Pedagogique des jeunes filles, les gymnases des jeunes files de l’arrondissement de Varsovie, les ecoles industrielles. St. PetersburgGoogle Scholar
  3. Mlodzeyevsky [Młodzievsky], Boleslav K. 1915. Rapport sur l’enseignement mathém. aux Cours Super. des femmes à Moskou. Pétrograd.Google Scholar
  4. Popruzhenko [Poprugenko] Mikhail, and Zakharii Maksheyev [Makcheyev]. 1911. Rapport presentés à la déligatión russe. St. Petersburg.Google Scholar
  5. Possé, Constantine. 1910. Rapport sur läenseignement mathématique dans les Universités, les écoles techniques supéricures et quelques unes des écoles militaires en Russie. St. Pétersburg.Google Scholar
  6. Rapport sur l’enseignement des mathématiques dans les écoles de Finlande: Rédigé par une commission institueé par le Sénat Impérial de Finlande. 1910. Helsingfors.Google Scholar
  7. Vogt, Karl V. 1911. Bericht uber den mathematischen unterricht an den russischen realschulen. St. Petersburg.Google Scholar

Other References

  1. I Vserossiiskii s’ezd prepodavateley matematiki [The First Russian National Congress of Teachers of Mathematics]. 1911a. Pedagogicheskii sbornik 7: 93–95.Google Scholar
  2. I Vserossiiskii s’ezd prepodavateley matematiki [The First Russian National Congress of Teachers of Mathematics]. 1911b. Pedagogicheskii sbornik 10: 392–393.Google Scholar
  3. A.L. 1914 Otchet o Vtorom Vserossiiskom s’ezde prepodavateley matematiki v Moskve [Report on the Second Russian National Congress of Teachers of Mathematics in Moscow]. Pedagogicheskoe obozrenie 4: 31–40.Google Scholar
  4. Alexandrov, Ivan. 1912a. Pamyati V.B. Struve [V. B. Struve in memoriam]. Matematicheskoe obrazovanie 3: 134–136.Google Scholar
  5. Alexandrov, Ivan. 1912b. Pamyati V.B. Struve [V. B. Struve in memoriam].Vestnik opytnoi fiziki i elementarnoy matematiki 556: 97–99.Google Scholar
  6. Beke, Emanuel. 2014. Results obtained in the introduction of differential and integral calculus in upper grades of secondary institutions. International Journal for the History of Mathematics Education 9: 35–70.Google Scholar
  7. Belliustin, Vsevolod K. 1912. K reforme prepodavaniya matematiki [Toward the Reform of Mathematics Instruction]. Pedagogicheskoe obozrenie 3: 36–39.Google Scholar
  8. Bernstein, Sergey N. 1909. K voprosu ob izmenenii programmy po matematike v sredney shkole [On the Question of Changing Mathematics Curricula in Secondary Schools]. Pedagogicheskii sbornik, November: 371–388.Google Scholar
  9. Bilimovich, Anton D. 1907. Reforma prepodavaniya matematiki v Germanii [The Reform of the Teaching of Mathematics in Germany]. Kiev: Tipografiya Kievskogo universitetaGoogle Scholar
  10. Bondarev, Sergey I. 1914. Vtoroy Vserossiiskii s’ezd prepodavateley matematiki [The Second Russian National Congress of Teachers of Mathematics]. Russkaya shkola 3: 70–73Google Scholar
  11. Borovik, Vasil’ N. 1970. Pedagogicheskoe nasledie akademika D.M.Sintsova [The Pedagogical Legacy of the Academician D.M. Sintsov]. Author’s Dissertation Summary Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Candidate of the Pedagogical Sciences]. Kiev: Kiev State Pedagogical University.Google Scholar
  12. Bychkov, Boris P. 1975. Mezhdunarodnoe dvizhenie za reformu prepodavaniya metematiki v sredney shkole [The International Movement to Reform the Teaching of Mathematisc in Secondary Schools]. Kishinev: Shtinitsa.Google Scholar
  13. Chistyakov, Iosaf I. 1914. 2-y vserossiiskii s’ezd prepodavateley matematiki [The Second Russian National Congress of Teachers of Mathematics]. Matematicheskoe obrazovanie 1: 48–50.Google Scholar
  14. Chlen s’ezda [Participant in Congress]. 1914. Matematika v nachsal’noy shkole na vtorom vserossiiskom s’ezde prepodavateley matematiki [Mathematics in Elementary Schools at the Second Russian National Congress of Teachers of Mathematics]. Pedagogicheskoe obozrenie 1: 46–52.Google Scholar
  15. Chlen Vtorogo s’ezda [Participant in Second Congress]. 1915. Is vospominanii o 2-m s’ezde prepodavateley matematiki [From Recollections about the Second Congress of Teachers of Mathematics]. Matematicheskoe obrazovanie 7-8: 1276–1281.Google Scholar
  16. Commission Internationale de l’Enseignement Mathématique. Liste Complète des Publications du Comité Central et Sous-Commissions nationals. 1920-1921. L’Enseignement Mathématique 21: 319–339.Google Scholar
  17. Delo Russkoy natsional’noy podkomissii, vkhodiaschey v sostav Mezhdunarodnoy komissii po prepodavaniiu matematiki [File of the Russian National Subcommission of ICMI]. 1909-1915. Russian State historical archive, f. 734, op. 4, d. 85.Google Scholar
  18. Doklad komissii, izbrannoy Moskovskim matematicheskim kruzhkom dlya rassmotreniya proekta program, vyrabotannogo Komissiey pri Ministerstve narrodnogo prosvescheniya [Report by the Commission Elected by the Moscow Mathematics Circle to Examine the Plan for Curricula Developed by the Commission of the Ministry of Education]. 1916. Matematicheskoe obrazovanie, 4: 101–110.Google Scholar
  19. Doklady, chitannye na 2-m Vserossiiskom s’ezde prepodavateley matematiki v Moskve [Reports Delivered at the Second Russian National Congress of Mathematics Teachers in Moscow]. 1915. Moscow.Google Scholar
  20. Gushel’, Revekka Z. 2002. K stoletiiu sozdaniya Mezhdunarodnoy komissii po prepodavaniiu matematiki [On the Centennial of the Formation of ICMI]. Pervoe sentiabria: Matematika 2.Google Scholar
  21. Gushel’, Revekka Z. 2003. O mezhdunarodnom dvizhenn po reformirovaniu matematicheskogo obrazovaniya v nachale XX stoletiya [On the International Movement to Reform Mathematics Education at the Beginning of the Twentieth Century]. Matematicheskoe prosveschenie 7: 39–44.Google Scholar
  22. Filippovich, Filipp V. 1912. Pervyi Vserossiiskii s’ezd prepodavateley matematiki [The First Russian National Congress of Teachers of Mathematics]. Shkola i zhizn’, 5: 2–3.Google Scholar
  23. Ignatiev, Pavel N. 1933. Education. In Russia. U.S.S.R. A Complete Handbook, ed. P. Malevsky-Malevich, 651–676. New York: William Farquhar Payson.Google Scholar
  24. Izvol’skii, Nikolay A. 1916. Po povody novogo proekta program matematiki v sredney shkole [On the New Plan for Mathematics Curricula in Secondary Schools]. Matematicheskoe obrazovanie 4: 110–117.Google Scholar
  25. Kagan, Veniamin F. 1911. O reforme prepodavaniya matematiki v srednikh uchebnykh zavedeniyakh Frantsii i Germanii [On the Reform of the Teaching of Mathematics in Secondary Education Institutions in France and Germany]. In Elementarnaya matematika. Arifmetika I algebra, authored by Émile Borel, I-XLVI. Odessa: Mathesis.Google Scholar
  26. Karp, Alexander. 2008. “Ne sootvetstvuet sovremennoy postanovke geometrii” (ob odnom epizode iz istorii matematicheskogo obrazovaniya). [“Does Not Correspond to the Modern Understanding of Geometry” (An Episode from the History of Mathematics Education]. In Problemy teorii i praktiki obucheniya matematike, ed. by Viktor V. Orlov. St. Petersburg: RGPU.Google Scholar
  27. Karp, Alexander. 2010. Reforms and counter-reforms: Schools between 1917 and the 1950s. In Russian mathematics education: History and world significance, ed. by Alexander Karp & Bruce Vogeli, 43–85. London-New Jersey-Singapore: World Scientific.Google Scholar
  28. Karp, Alexander. 2012. Andrey Kiselev: the Life and the Legend. Educ. Matem. Pesq 14(3): 398–410.Google Scholar
  29. Karp, Alexander. 2017. On the Russian national subcommission of the ICMI. In “Dig where you stand” 4, ed. by Kristín Bjarnadóttir, Fulvia Furinghetti, Marta Menghini, Johan Prytz, Gert Schubring, 149–166. Rome: Edizioni Nuova Cultura.Google Scholar
  30. Karp, Alexander. (Ed.). 2018. Otchety rossiiskoy natsional’noy podkomissii mezhdunarodnoy komissii po matematicheskomu obrazovaniu [Reports of the Russian National Subcommmission of the International Commission on Mathematics Instruction]. St. Petersburg: Lema.Google Scholar
  31. К.М. 1900. O predlagaemoy v Anglii reforme v prepodavanii matematiki [On the Reform of the Teaching of Mathematics Proposed in the Great Britain]. St. Petersburg: Tipografiya Morskogo Ministerstva.Google Scholar
  32. Koyalovich, Boris M. n.d. Otchet Predsedateliu Uchenogo Komiteta Ministerstva Narodnogo Prosvescheniya o komandirovke v Milan [Report to the Chairman of the Ministry of Education Scientific Committee about the Trip to Milan]. Russian National Library, Manuscript Department, f. 359, # 120.Google Scholar
  33. Kropotov Alexander I. 1967. Nikolay Yakovlevich Sonin. Leningrad: Nauka.Google Scholar
  34. K sozyvu tret’ego vserossiiskogo s’ezda prepodavateley matematiki [Toward the Convocation of the Third Russian National Congress of Teachers of Mathematics]. 1915, Pedagogicheskii sbornik 8, 138–140.Google Scholar
  35. Kulisher Alexander R. 1914a. Vtoroy Vserossiiskii s’ezd prepodavateley matematiki v Moskve [The Second Russian National Congress of the Teachers of Mathematics in Moscow]. Shkola i zhizn’ 6: 9–11.Google Scholar
  36. Kulisher Alexander R. 1914b. Uchebnik geometrii. [Geometry Textbook]. Part 1. St. Petersburg: P.V.Lukovnikov.Google Scholar
  37. Kulisher Alexander R. 1915. Matematika na vseshveitsarskoy vystavke 1914 goda v Berne [Mathematics at the Swiss National Exhibition of 1914 in Berne]. Shkola i zhizn’ 17: 2–5.Google Scholar
  38. Kulisher Alexander R. 1922. Uchebnik geometrii. Kurs edinoy trudovoy shkoly. [Geometry Textbook. Unified Labor School Course]. Berlin: Gosudarstvennoe izdatel’stvo RSFSR.Google Scholar
  39. Lankov, Alexander V. 1949. K istorii voprosa o reforme prepodavaniya matematiki [On the History of the Question of Mathematics Education Reform]. Matematika v shkole 6: 1–4.Google Scholar
  40. Leifert, Leonid A. (Ed.). 1931. Metodika matematiki dlya pedagogicheskikh tekhnikumov [The methodology of teaching mathematics. Textbook for Pedagogical schools]. Moscow-Leningrad: OGIZ.Google Scholar
  41. Markushevich, Alexey I. 1950. O povyshenii ideino-teoreticheskogo urovnya prepodavavniya matematiki v sredney shkole [On Raising the Conceptual-Theoretical Level of the Teaching of Mathematics in Secondary Schools]. Matematika v shkole 1: 1–4.Google Scholar
  42. Materialy po voprosu ob uluchshenii postanovki prepodavaniya matematiki v srednikh uchebnykh zavedeniyakh Kavkazskogo uchebnogo okruga [Mateirals Pertaining to the Issue of Improving the Organization of the Teaching of Mathematics in the Secondary Educational Institutions of the Caucasus School District]. 1913. Tiflis: Upravlenie Kavkazskogo uchebnogo okruga.Google Scholar
  43. Materialy po reforme sredney shkoly [Materials Pertaining to Secondary School Reforms]. 1915. Zhurnal Ministerstva narodnogo prosvescheniya December: 245–283.Google Scholar
  44. Metel’skii, Nikolay V. 1967. Progressivnoe nasledie dvizheniya za reformu prepodavaniya matematiki [The Progressive Legacy of the Mathematics Educcation Reform Movement]. Author’s Dissertation Summary Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Candidate of the Pedagogical Sciences. Minsk: MGPU.Google Scholar
  45. Metel’skii, Nikolay V. 1968. Ocherki istorii metodiki matematiki [Sketches of the History of Mathematics Methodology]. Minsk: Vysheyshaya shkola.Google Scholar
  46. Mordukhay-Boltovskii, Dmitry.1912. O pervom vserossiiskom s’ezde prepodavateley matematiki [On the First Russian National Congress of Teachers of Mathematics]. Warsaw: Tipografiya Uchebnogo okrugaGoogle Scholar
  47. Mordukhay-Boltovskii, Dmitry. 1914. Vtoroy vserossiiskii s’ezd prepodavateley matematiki [The Second Russian National Congress of Teachers of Mathematics]. Warsaw: Tipografiya Uchebnogo okruga.Google Scholar
  48. Mrochek Vatslav R. 1912. Itogi pervogo vserossiiskogo s’ezda prepodavateley matematiki [Outcomes of the First Russian National Congress of Mathematics Teachers]. St. Petersburg.Google Scholar
  49. Mrochek, Vatslav R., and Filipp V. Filippovich. 1910. Reforma prepodavaniya matematiki [The Reform of Mathmematics Education]. St. Petersburg: Tipografiya Montvida.Google Scholar
  50. Na leningradskom matematicheskom fronte [On the Leningrad Mathematics Front]. 1931. Moscow-Leningrad: Gosudarstvennoe sotsial’no-ekonomicheskoe izdatel’stvo.Google Scholar
  51. Nazarenko, T. 1926. Opyt uvyazki matematiki v komplekse [Experience with Connecting Mathematics to a Complex]. Radyanska shkola 6, 61–65.Google Scholar
  52. Ob uchastii Rossii v Mezhdunarodnoy komissii po prepodavaniu matematiki [On Russia’s Participation in ICMI]. 1909–1916. Russian State historical archive, f. 733, op. 145, d. 288.Google Scholar
  53. O sluzhbe A.R.Kulishera [On A. R. Kulisher’s Service]. 1912. Russian State historical archive, f. 25, op. 1, d. 2505.Google Scholar
  54. Pavlovskii, Ivan .F. 1890. Istoricheskii ocherk Petrovskogo Poltavskogo kadetskogo korpusa. [A Historical Sketch of the Petrovsky Poltava Cadet Corps]. Poltava: Tipografiya gubernskogo pravleniya.Google Scholar
  55. Polyakov, Alexey P. 1914. Mezhdunarodnaya konferentsiya po prepodavaniiu matematiki, sostoyavshayasya v Parizhe s 1 po 4 aprelya (novogo stilya) 1914 goda [The International Conference on Mathematics Instruction, which Took Place in Paris from April 1 to April 4 (New Style), 1904]. Matematicheskoe obozrenie 6: 256–268.Google Scholar
  56. Popruzhenko, Mikhail G. 1904. Oskudenie [Impoverishment]. Vestnik opytnoi fiziki i elementarnoy matematiki 361: 3–7.Google Scholar
  57. Popruzhenko, Mikhail G. 1912. Pervyi vserossiiskii s’ezd prepodavateley matematiki [The First Russian National Congress of Teachers of Mathematics]. Pedagogicheskii sbornik 2: 268–278.Google Scholar
  58. Popruzhenko, Mikhail G. 1914a. Vtoroy vserossiiskii s’ezd prepodavateley matematiki [The Second Russian National Congress of Teachers of Mathematics]. Pedagogicheskii sbornik 7: 41–50Google Scholar
  59. Popruzhenko, Mikhail G. 1914b. Vtoroy vserossiiskii s’ezd prepodavateley matematiki [The Second Russian National Congress of Teachers of Mathematics]. Pedagogicheskii sbornik 10: 266–276Google Scholar
  60. Popruzhenko, Mikhail G. 1922. Nachala analiza [Elementary Analysis]. Moscow: Gosizdat.Google Scholar
  61. Popruzhenko, Mikhail G. 1939. Sbornik geometricheskikh zadach [Collection of Problems in Geometry]. Leningrad: Uchpedgiz.Google Scholar
  62. Posse, Konstantin A. 1914. Mezhdunarodnaya komissiya po prepodavaniyu matematiki. Konferentsiya v Parizhe 1–4 aprelya 1914 g. [International Commission on Mathematics Instruction. Conference in Paris, April 1–4, 1915]. Vestnik opytnoi fiziki i elementarnoy matematiki 607: 198–205.Google Scholar
  63. Posse, Konstantin A. 1915a. Otzyv zasluzhennogo professora K.A.Posse o predlozheniyakh, izlozhennykh v rezoliutsiyakh, prinyatykh vtorym Vserossiiskim s’ezdom preposavateley matematiki [Response by Distinguished Professor K. A. Posse to Proposals Formulated in the Resolutions Passed by the Second Russian National Congress of Teachers of Mathematics]. Zhurnal Ministerstva narodnogo prosvescheniya 3: 21–34.Google Scholar
  64. Posse, Konstantin A. 1915b. N.Ya. Sonin. Nekrolog [N. A. Sonin. Obituary]. Zhurnal Ministerstva narodnogo prosvescheniya 6: 105–124.Google Scholar
  65. Posse, Konstantin A. 1915c. [Review]. Zhurnal Ministerstva narodnogo prosvescheniya 1: 110–114.Google Scholar
  66. Raikov, Boris. 2011. Na zhiznennom puti [On Life’s Way]. Volume 1. St. Petersburg: Kolo.Google Scholar
  67. Rezoliutsii 2-go vserossiiskogo s’ezda prepodavateley matematiki [The Resolutions of the Second Russian National Congress of Teachers of Mathematics]. 1914. Matematicheskoe obrazovanie 1: 50–52.Google Scholar
  68. Shcherbina, Konstantin M. 1908. Matematika v russkoy sredney shkole [Mathematics in Russian Secondary Schools]. Kiev:Tipografiya Imperatorskogo universiteta sv. Vladimira.Google Scholar
  69. Shokhor-Trotsky, Semen I.1911. K reforme prepodavaniya matematiki [Towards the reform of mathematics education]. Russkaya shkola 3: 117–142.Google Scholar
  70. Shokhor-Trotsky, Semen I.1912. K reforme prepodavaniya matematiki [Towards the reform of mathematics education]. Russkaya shkola 2: 119–143Google Scholar
  71. Sheremetevskii Vsevolod P. 1895. Matematika, kak nauka, i ee shkol’nye surrogaty [Mathematics as a Science and Its School Surrogates]. Russkaya mysl’ V: 106–125.Google Scholar
  72. Sintsov, Dmitry M. 1908. Chetvertyi mezhdunarodnyi matematicheskii kongress v Rime 6-11 aprelia [The Fourth International Mathematical Congress in Rome, April 6-11]. Vestnik opytnoi fiziki i elementarnoy matematiki 460: 73–81.Google Scholar
  73. Sintsov Dmitry M. 1910a. Mezhdunarodnaya komissiya po prepodavaniu matematiki. Matematika na vystavke v Briussele [International Commission on Mathematics Instruction. Mathematics at the Exhibition in Brussels]. Vestnik opytnoi fiziki i elementarnoy matematiki 524: 193–199.Google Scholar
  74. Sintsov Dmitry M. 1910b. Mezhdunarodnaya komissiya po prepodavaniu matematiki. Matematika na vystavke v Briussele [International Commission on Mathematics Instruction. Mathematics at the Exhibition in Brussels]. Vestnik opytnoi fiziki i elementarnoy matematiki 525: 227–234.Google Scholar
  75. Sintsov, Dmitry M. 1911a. Mezhdunarodnaya komissiya po prepodavaniu matematiki. Siezd v Milane 5-7 (18-20) sentiabria 1911 g. [ICMI. Congress in Milan, September 5-7 (18-20), 1911]. Vestnik opytnoi fiziki i elementarnoy matematiki 550: 267–282.Google Scholar
  76. Sintsov, Dmitry M. 1911b. Pis’mo professora matematiki Khar’kovskogo universiteta Predsedateliu Uchenogo Komiteta N.Ya. Soninu o rabote milanskogo s’ezda matematikov [Letter from a University of Kharkov mathematics professor to the chair of the Scientific Committee N.Ya. Sonin about the Work of the Congress of Mathematicians in Milan]. Russian State historical archive, f. 734, op. 5, d. 261.Google Scholar
  77. Sintsov, Dmitry M. (Ed.). 1911c. Sbornik program I instruktsii po prepodavaniiu matematiki v Zapadnoy Evrope [Collection of Curricula and Instructions on Teaching Mathematics in Western Europe]. Moscow: Tipografiya Sytina.Google Scholar
  78. Sintsov, Dmitry M. 1912a. V Mezhdunarodnyi matematicheskii s’ezd v Cambridge [The International Mathematical Congress in Cambridge]. Vestnik opytnoi fiziki i elementarnoy matematiki 569, 129–136.Google Scholar
  79. Sintsov (Sintsof), Dmitry M. 1912b. Le premier congrès des professeurs de Mathématiques en Russie. L’Enseignement Mathématique 14: 222–228.Google Scholar
  80. Sintsov, Dmitry M. 1913. Mezhdunarodnaya komissiya po prepodavaniyu matematiki [International commission on mathematics instruction]. In Trudy 1-go vserossiiskogo s’ezda uchiteley matematiki, volume 3, 1–19). St. Petersburg: Sever.Google Scholar
  81. Sintsov (Sintsof) Dmitry M. 1929. Russia. In Significant changes and trends in the teaching of mathematics throughout the world since 1910, edited by W.D.Reeve, 94–11. New York: Teachers College, Columbia University.Google Scholar
  82. Sonin, Nikolay Ya., Boris M. Koyalovich, Karl, V Vogt. 1909. Mezhdunarodnaya komissiya po prepodavaniiu matematiki. Predvaritel]nyi doklad. [Preliminary Report. International Commission on Mathematical Instruction]. Zhurnal Ministerstva narodnogo prosvescheniya 3, 34–47.Google Scholar
  83. Soveschanie o reforme sredney shkoly [Conference on Secondary School Reforms]. 1915. Pedagogicheskii sbornik 7: 49–58.Google Scholar
  84. Soveschaniya, proiskhodivshie v 1899 godu v Moskovskom uchebnom okruge po voprosam o sredney shkole. Vypusk 6. [Conferences Which Took Place in 1899 in the Moscow School District to Address Questions Pertaining to Secondary Schools]. 1899. Moscow.Google Scholar
  85. S.P. 1902. O programmakh matematiki [On Mathematics Curricula], Pedagogicheskii sbornik 2: 142–153.Google Scholar
  86. Stanislavskii, Konstantin S. 1929. Moya zhizn’ v iskusstve [My Life in Art]. Leningrad: Academia.Google Scholar
  87. Stenogramma soveschaniya uchiteley matematiki nachal’nykh shkol [Transcript of Elementary School Teachers’ Conference]. 1936. Central state archive of Saint Petersburg, f. 5039, op. 3, d. 140.Google Scholar
  88. Trudy vysochaishe utverzhdennoy komissii po voprosu ob uluchsheniyakh v sredney shkole [Proceedings of the Imperially Constituted Commission on the Question of Improvements in Secondary Schools]. 1900. St. Petersburg: Tipografiya S-Peterburgskoy tiur’my.Google Scholar
  89. Trudy komissii P.S. Vannovskogo po preobrazovaniiu sredney shkoly [Proceedings of the P. S. Vannovsky Commission on the Transformation of Secondary Schools]. 1901.St. Petersburg.Google Scholar
  90. Trudy 1-go vserossiiskogo s’ezda uchiteley matematiki [Proceedings of the First Russian National Congress of Teachers of Mathematics]. Volumes 1-3. 1913. St. Petersburg: Sever.Google Scholar
  91. Tsvetkov, Ivan. 1911. O pedagogike matematiki. Russkaya mysl’ 2: 14–22.Google Scholar
  92. Volkov, Alexander A. 1916. Proekt novykh program prepodavaniya matematiki v sredney shkole, sostavlennyi Komissiey pri Ministerstve narodnogo prosvescheniya vesnoy 1915 goda [Plan of New Programs for Teaching Mathematics in Secondary Schools, Written by the Commission of the Ministry of Education in Spring 1915]. Matematicheskoe obrazovanie 1-2: 24–40Google Scholar
  93. Vol’berg, Ovsey A. 1918. Matematika v trudovoy shkole [Mathematics in the school of labor]. Matematika v shkole 1(1–2): 9–18.Google Scholar
  94. Vol’berg, Ovsey A. 1919. Dva mirovozzreniya [Two Worldviews]. Narodnoe prosveschenie 11-12: 81–86.Google Scholar
  95. Ushakov N. 1914. Otchet o 2-m vserossiiskom s’ezde prepodavateley matematiki [Report on the Second Russian National Congress of Teachers of Mathematics]. Vestnik obrazovaniya i vospitaniya 4: 442–452Google Scholar
  96. Young, Jacob W.A. 1912. Kak prepodavat’ matematiku. Prepodavanie matematiki v sredney i nachal’noy shkole. V 2-kh vypuskakh. [How to Teach Mathematics. The Teaching of Mathematics in Secondary and Elementary Schools. In Two Installments]. St. Petersburg: Obschestvennaya pol’za.Google Scholar
  97. Zalgaller, Vladimir A. 2002. Vospominaniya ob A.D.Alexandrove i ego Leningradskom geometricheskom sdeminare (1945–1963) [Recollecting A.D]. In Akademik Alexander Danilovich Alexandrov. Vospominaniya. Publikatsii. Materialy, ed. by G.M. Idlis and O.A. Ladyzhenskaya 15–33. Moscow: Nauka.Google Scholar
  98. Zasedanie 29 aprelya 1909 goda [Meeting of April 29, 1909]. 1910. Soobscheniya Khar’kovskogo matematicheskogo obschestva XI (6): 298–299.Google Scholar
  99. Zavadskii, Norbert B. 1904. K voprosu o reforme prepodavaniya matematiki [On the Issue of Mathematics Education Reform]. St. Petersburg.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Nature Switzerland AG 2019

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Teachers College, Columbia UniversityNew York CityUSA

Personalised recommendations