Abstract
Whereas for almost 100 years radical mastectomy was virtually unchallenged and accepted as standard therapy for clinically curable female breast cancer, there presently exists great controversy and actual confusion regarding the management of that disease. Women with breast cancers may have surgical procedures ranging from extended radical mastectomy with internal mammary node dissection to “lumpectomy,” depending entirely upon the belief of the surgeon. Unfortunately, more often than not the decision regarding which operation to employ has been based upon information obtained from poorly carried out retrospective analyses of heterogeneous groups of case records (the comparison of data which are worthless because they were acquired from divergent series of patients); peer pressure; emotionalism; and an outmoded concept of tumor biology. It is the latter which this reviewer considers the most significant factor responsible for the present period of clinical uncertainty.
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Preview
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
References
R. Virchow, Cellular Pathology, J.B. Lippincott, Philadelphia (1863).
W.S. Halsted, The results of radical operations for the cure of carcinoma of the breast, Ann. Surg. 46, 1–19 (1907).
B. Fisher, N. Slack, D.L. Katrych, and N. Wolmark, Ten year follow-up of breast cancer patients in a cooperative clinical trial evaluating surgical adjuvant chemotherapy, Surg. Gynecol. Obstet. 140, 528–534 (1975).
H.E. Skipper, Combination Therapy, Booklet 13, Southern Research Institute, Birmingham, Alabama (December, 1974), p. 1.
I. Hellstrom, K.E. Hellstrom, and H.O. Sjogren, Serum mediated inhibition of cellular immunity to methylcholanthrene-induced murine sarcomas, Cell. Immunol. 1, 18–30 (1970).
G.H. Heppner, In vitro studies on cell-mediated immunity following surgery in mice sensitized to syngeneic mammary tumors, Int. J. Cancer 9, 119–125 (1972).
B. Fisher, Unpublished information.
G.A. Currie and C. Basham, Serum mediated inhibition of the immunological reactions of the patient to his own tumour. A possible role for circulating antigen, Br. Cancer 26, 427–438(1972).
S.M. Watkins, The effects of surgery on lymphocyte transformation in patients with cancer, Clin. Exp. Immunol. 14, 69–76 (1973).
L.E. Hughes and W.D. McKay, Suppression of the tubercular response in malignant disease, Br. Med. J. 2, 1346–1348 (1965).
L. Israel, J. Mugica, and P. Chahinian, Prognosis of early bronchogenic carcinoma. Survival curves of 451 patients after resection of lung cancer in relation to the results of the preoperative tuberculin skin test, Biomedicine 19, 68–72 (1973).
Y.H. Pilch and R.S. Riggins, Antibodies to spontaneous and MC-induced tumors in inbred mice, Cancer Res. 26, 871–875 (1966).
J.B. Graham and R.M. Graham, Antibodies elicited by cancer in patients, Cancer 8, 409–416 (1955).
J.L. Odili and G. Taylor, Transience of immune responses to tumor antigens in man, Br. Med. J. 4, 584–586 (1971).
P.R. Riddle, Disturbed immune reactions following surgery, Br. Surg. 54, 882–886 (1967).
S.K. Park, J.I. Brody, H.A. Wallace, and W.S. Blakemore, Immunosuppressive effect of surgery, Lancet 1, 53–55 (1971).
E. Frindel, E.P. Malaise, E. Alpen, and M. Tubiana, Kinetics of cell proliferation of an experimental tumor, Cancer Res. 27, 1122–1131 (1967).
A.K. Laird, Dynamics of tumor growth, Br. Cancer 18, 490–502 (1964).
J.A. McCredie, W.R. Inch, J. Druuv, and T.A. Watson, The rate of tumor growth in animals, Growth 29, 331–347 (1965).
W.D. DeWys, Studies correlating the growth rate of a tumor and its metastases and providing evidence for tumor related systemic growth retarding factors, Cancer Res. 32, 374–379(1972).
F.M. Schabel, Jr., The use of tumor growth kinetics in planning “curative” chemotherapy of advanced solid tumors, Cancer Res. 29, 2384–2389 (1969).
F.M. Schabel, Jr., Concepts for systemic treatment of micrometastases, Cancer 35, 15–24 (1975).
L. Simpson-Herren, A.H. Sanford, and J.P. Holmquist, Cell population kinetics of transplanted and metastatic Lewis lung carcinoma, Cell Tissue Kinet. 7, 349–362 (1974).
B. Fisher and E.R. Fisher, Role of the lymphatic system in dissemination of tumor, in: Lymph and the Lymphatic System (H.S. Mayerson, ed.), pp. 324–347, Charles C. Thomas, New York (1968).
B. Fisher and E.R. Fisher, Transmigration of lymph nodes by tumor cells, Science 152, 1397–1398 (1966).
B. Fisher and E.R. Fisher, The barrier function of the lymph node to tumor cells and erythrocytes. I. Normal nodes, Cancer 20, 1907–1914 (1967).
B. Fisher and E.R. Fisher, The barrier function of the lymph node to tumor cells and erythrocytes. II. Effect of x-ray, inflammation, sensitization and tumor growth, Cancer 20, 1914–1919 (1967).
B. Fisher and E.R. Fisher, Interrelationship of hematogenous and lymphatic tumor cell dissemination, Surg. Gynecol. Obstet. 122, 791–798 (1966).
B. Fisher, E.A. Saffer, and E.R. Fisher, Studies concerning the regional lymph node in cancer. III. Response of regional lymph node cells from breast and colon cancer patients to PHA stimulation, Cancer 30, 1202–1215 (1972).
G.L. Cheatle and M. Cutler, Tumours of the Breast—Their Pathology Symptoms and Diagnosis and Treatment, J.B. Lippincott, Philadelphia (1931).
F.W. Foote and F.W. Stewart, Comparative studies of cancerous versus noncancerous breasts, Ann. Surg. 121, 5–53 (1945).
H.S. Gallager and J.E. Martin, The study of mammary carcinoma by mammography and whole organ sectioning, Cancer 23, 855–878 (1969).
G.W. Nicholson, Carcinoma of breast, Br. J. Surg. 8, 527–528 (1921).
G.M. Bosner, Microscopical study of evolution of mouse mammary cancer—Effect of milk factor and comparison with human disease, J. Pathol. Bacteriol. 57, 413–422 (1945).
R.A. Willis, Pathology of Tumours, 2nd Edition, Butterworths, London (1953).
J. A. Urban, Bilaterality of cancer of the breast. Biopsy of the opposite breast, Cancer 20, 1867–1870 (1967).
J.A. Urban, Biopsy of the “normal” breast in treating breast cancer, Surg. Clin. North Am. 49, 291–301(1969).
N.H. Slack, E.J. Bross, T. Nemoto, and B. Fisher, Experience with bilateral primary carcinoma of the breast in a cooperative study, Surg. Gynecol. Obstet. 136, 433–440 (1973).
W.M. Kramer and B.F. Rush, Mammary duct proliferation in the elderly—A histopathologic study, Cancer 31, 130–137 (1973).
F.M. Burnet, Immunological aspects of malignant disease, Lancet 1, 1171–1174 (1967).
CD. Haagensen and A.P. Stout, Carcinoma of the breast. I. Results of treatment, Ann. Surg. 116, 801–815(1942).
CD. Haagensen and A.P. Stout, Carcinoma of the breast. II. Criteria of operability, Ann. Surg. 118, 859–870 and 1032–1051 (1943).
CD. Haagensen and A.P. Stout, Carcinoma of the breast. III. Results of treatment, 1935–1942. Ann. Surg. 134, 151–172 (1951).
B. Fisher, R.G. Ravdin, R.K. Ausman, N.H. Slack, G.E. Moore, R.J. Noer, and Cooperating Investigators, Surgical adjuvant chemotherapy in cancer of the breast: Results of a decade of cooperative investigation, Ann. Surg. 168, 337–356 (1968).
B. Fisher, G.E. Moore, R.G. Ravdin, R.K. Ausman, N.H. Slack, R.J. Noer, and Cooperating Investigators, in: Breast Cancer: Early and Late (Thirteenth Annual Clinical Conference on Cancer, 1968, at The University of Texas M.D. Anderson Hospital and Tumor Institute), pp. 135–153, Year Book Medical Publishers, Inc., Chicago (1970).
B. Fisher, N.H. Slack, I.D.J. Bross, and Cooperating Investigators, Cancer of the breast: Size of neoplasm and prognosis, Cancer 24, 1071–1080 (1969).
R.T. Turner-Warwick, The lymphatics of the breast, Br. Surg. 46, 574–582 (1959).
R.S. Handley, The early spread of breast carcinoma and its bearing on operative treatment, Br. Surg. 51, 206–208 (1964).
E. Dahl-Iversen, Recherches sur le métastases microscopiques des ganglions lym-phatiques parasternaux dans le cancer du sein, J. Int. Chir. 11, 492 (1951).
M. Andreassen and E. Dahl-Iversen, Recherches sur le metastases microscopiques des ganglions lymphatiques sus-clavicularis dous de cancer du sein, J. Int. Chir. 9, 27 (1949).
M. Andreassen, E. Dahl-Iversen, and B. Sorensen, Glandular metastases in carcinoma of the breast: Results of a more radical operation, Lancet 1, 176–182 (1954).
E. Caceres, An evaluation of radical mastectomy and extended radical mastectomy for cancer of the breast, Surg. Gynecol. Obstet. 125, 337–341 (1967).
M. Margottini and P. Bucalossi, El metastasi lymphoghiandolari mammario interne nel cancro della mammella, Boll. Oncol. 23, 79 (1949).
M. Margottini, G. Jacobelli, and M. Cau, The end results of enlarged radical mastectomy, Acta Unio Int. Contra Cancrum 19, 1555–1559 (1963).
J.A. Urban, Discussion on radical mastectomy in breast cancer with supraclavicular and/or internal mammary node dissection, Proc. Natl. Cancer Conf. 2, 243–246 (1952).
J.A. Urban, Radical mastecotmy with en bloc in-continuity resection of internal mammary lymph node chain, Surg. Clin. North Am. 36, 1065–1082 (1956).
J.A. Urban, Clinical experience and results of excision of the internal mammary lymph node chain in primary operable breast cancer, Cancer 12, 14–22 (1959).
J.A. Urban, Extended radical mastectomy for breast cancer, Am. J. Surg. 106, 399–404 (1963).
J.A. Urban, What is the rationale for an extended radical procedure in early cases? J. Am. Med. Assoc. 199, 742–743 (1967).
J.A. Urban, Primary operable breast cancer. Current status of treatment, Rocky Mount. Med.]. 65, 39–46 (1968).
E.D. Sugarbaker, Extended radical mastectomy. Its superiority in the treatment of breast cancer, J. Am. Med. Assoc. 187, 96–99 (1964).
U. Veronesi and L. Zingo, Extended mastectomy for cancer of the breast, Cancer 20, 677–680 (1967).
J. Lacour, The place of the Halsted operation in treatment of breast cancer, Int. Surg. 47, 282–287(1967).
E. Dahl-Iversen and T. Tobiassen, Radical mastectomy with parasternal and supraclavicular dissection for mammary carcinoma, Ann. Surg. 157, 170–175 (1963).
S. Kaae and H. Johansen, Breast cancer. A comparison of the results of simple mastectomy with postoperative roentgen irradiation by the McWhirter method with those of extended radical mastectomy, Acta Radiol. Suppl. 188, 155–161 (1959).
M. Andreassen, E. Dahl-Iversen, and B. Sorensen, Extended exeresis of regional lymph nodes at operation for carcinoma of breast and result of 5-year follow-up of first 98 cases with removal of axillary as well as supraclavicular glands, Acta Chir. Scand. 107, 206–213(1954).
A. Abrao and F. Genril, Mastectomia radical ampliada com esvaziamento ganglionar supraclavicular, axillar a da codlia mammaris interna em monobloco, Rev. Paul. Med. 46, 217–226 (1955).
E. A. Gould, Prognosis of carcinoma involving the medial half of the breast, Am. Surg. 30, 9–11 (1964).
W.L. Donegan, An experience with extended radical mastectomy for mammary carcinoma, Mo. Med. 65, 109–112 (1968).
T.H. Ackland, Extended mastectomy, Med. J. Aust. i, 715–720 (1969).
P. Bucalossi and V. Veronesi, Long-term results of radical mastectomy with removal of internal mammary chain, Acta Unio Int. Contra Cancrum 15, 1052–1055 (1959).
H.C. Chin, T.T. Chang, T.Y. Wang, P.C. Cheng, Y.Y. Li, and T.T. Huang, A comparison of results of radical mastectomy and that combined with resection of internal mammary lymph node chains, Acta Unio Int. Contra Cancrum 19, 1572–1574 (1963).
S.A. Kholdin, Extended radical operations for mammary cancer, Prog. Clin. Cancer 1, 438–149 (1965).
O.F. Noel, Extended operation for carcinoma of breast—surgical techniques, Surgery 38, 423–431(1955).
A. Prudente, L’amputation inter-scapulo-mammo-thoracique, J. Chir. 65, 729–746 (1949).
H.J. Gray, Relation of the lymphatic vessels to the spread of cancer, Br. J. Surg. 26, 462–495 (1939).
. D.H. Patey and W.H. Dyson, The prognosis of carcinoma of the breast in relation to the type of operation performed, Br.J. Cancer 2, 7–13 (1948).
R.S. Handley, The technic and results of conservative radical mastectomy (Patey’s operation), Prog. Clin. Cancer 1, 462–470 (1965).
R. McWhirter, The value of simple mastectomy and radiotherapy in the treatment of cancer of the breast, Br. J. Radiol. 21, 599–610 (1948).
R. McWhirter, Discussion: The treatment of cancer of the breast, abridged, Proc. R. Soc. Med. 41, 122–129 (1948).
R. McWhirter, Treatment of cancer of the breast by simple mastectomy and roentgenotherapy, Arch. Surg. 59, 830–842 (1949).
R. McWhirter, The principles of treatment by radiotherapy in breast cancer, Br. J. Cancer 4, 368–371(1950).
R. McWhirter, Simple mastectomy and radiotherapy in the treatment of breast cancer, Br. J. Radiol. 28, 128–139 (1955).
R. McWhirter, Should more radical treatment be attempted in breast cancer? Caldwell lecture, 1963, Am. J. Roentgenol. 92, 3–13 (1964).
J.G. Williams, R.S. Murley, and M.P. Curwen, Carcinoma of the female breast: Conservative radical surgery, Br. Med. J. 2, 787–796 (1953).
L. Den Besten and S.E. Ziffren, Simple and radical mastectomy: A comparison of survival, Arch. Surg. 90, 755–759 (1965).
J.E. Devitt and W.G. Beattie, Rational treatment of carcinoma of the breast? Ann. Surg. 160, 71–80 (1964).
S. Kaae and H. Johansen, Breast cancer. Five-year results: Two random series of simple mastectomy with postoperative irradiation versus extended radical mastectomy, Am. J. Roentgenol. 87, 82–88 (1962).
S. Kaae and H. Johansen, Simple mastectomy plus postoperative irradiation by the method of McWhirter for mammary carcinoma, Prog. Clin. Cancer 1, 453–454 (1965).
G. Crile, Jr., Results of simple mastectomy without irradiation in the treatment of operative stage I cancer of the breast, Ann. Surg. 168, 330–336 (1968).
S. Mustakallio, Treatment of breast cancer by tumor extirpation and roentgen therapy instead of radical operation, J. Рас. Radiol. 6, 23–26 (1954).
S. Mustakallio, Conservative treatment of breast carcinoma—review of 25 years follow-up, Clin. Radiol. 23, 110–116 (1972).
A. Porritt, Early carcinoma of the breast, Br.J. Surg. 51, 214–216 (1964).
V.M. Peters, Wedge resection and irradiation, an effective treatment in early breast cancer, J. Am. Med. Assoc. 200, 134–135 (1967).
G. Crile, Jr., Treatment of breast cancer by local excision, Am. J. Surg. 109, 400–403 (1965).
G. Crile, Jr. and S. О. Hoerr, Results of treatment of carcinoma of the breast by local excision, Surg. Gynecol Obstet. 132, 780–782 (1971).
G. Crile, Jr., The case for local excision of breast cancer in selected cases, Lancet 1, 549–554 (1972).
H. Atkins, J.L. Hayward, D.L. Klugman, and A.B. Wayte, Treatment of breast cancer: A report after ten years of a clinical trial. Br. Med. J. 20, 423–429 (1972).
F.C. Nance, D.H. DeLoach, R.A. Welsh, and W.F. Becker, Pageťs disease of the breast, Ann. Surg. 171, 864–874 (1970).
W.P. Maier, G.P. Rosemond, E.L. Harasym, T.I. Al Saleem, E.M. Tassoni, and S.S. Shor, Pageťs disease in the female breast, Surg. Gynecol. Obstet. 128, 1253–1263 (1969).
F.W. Foote, Jr. and F.W. Stewart, Lobular carcinoma in situ: Rare form of mammary cancer, Am. J. Pathol. 17, 491–495 (1941).
N.E. Warner, Lobular carcinoma of the breast, Cancer 23, 840–846 (1969).
W. Newman, Lobular carcinoma of the female breast: Report of 73 cases, Ann. Surg. 164, 305–314 (1966).
R.V.P. Hutter and F.W. Foote, Jr., Lobular carcinoma in situ. Long term follow-up, Cancer 24, 1081–1085 (1969).
J.H. Farrow, Clinical considerations and treatment of in situ lobular breast cancer, Am. J. Roentgenol. 102, 652–656 (1968).
J.R. Benfield, M. Jacobson, and N.E. Warner, In situ lobular carcinoma of the breast, Arch. Surg. (Chicago) 91, 130–135 (1965).
J.W. Berg and G.F. Robbins, 20 year follow-ups of breast cancer, Acta Unio Int. Contra Cancrum 19, 1575–1577 (1963).
W. Newman, In situ lobular carcinoma of the breast: Report of 26 women with 32 cancers, Ann. Surg. 157, 591–599 (1963).
R.E. Snyder, Mammography and lobular carcinoma in si tu, Surg. Gynecol. Obstet. 122, 255–260 (1966).
H.P. Leis, Jr., W.L. Mersheimer, M.M. Black, and A. de Chabon, The second breast, N.Y. State J. Med. 65, 2460–2468 (1965).
R.W. McDivitt, R.V.P. Hutter, F.W. Foote, Jr., and F.W. Stewart, In situ lobular carcinoma. A prospective follow-up study indicating cumulative patient risks, J. Am. Med. Assoc. 201, 82–86 (1967).
F.W. Foote, Jr. and F.W. Stewart, A histologic classification of carcinoma of the breast, Surgery 19, 74–99 (1946).
F.W. Stewart, Tumors of the breast, in: Atlas of Tumor Pathology, Section DC, Fascicle 34, Armed Forces Institute of Pathology, Washington, D.C. (1950), pp. 7–13, 43–52.
F.R. Benfield, A.G. Fingerhut, and N.E. Warner, Lobular carcinoma of the breast— 1969. A therapeutic proposal, Arch. Surg. (Chicago) 99, 129–131 (1969).
E.F. Lewison and G.G. Finney, Jr., Lobular carcinoma in situ of the breast, Surg. Gynecol Obstet. 126, 1280–1286 (1968).
A.R. Kilgore, The incidence of cancer in the second breast, J. Am. Med. Assoc. 77, 454–457 (1921).
W.T. Fitts, Jr. and L.T. Patterson, The spread of mammary cancer, Surg. Clin. North Am. 35, 1539–1551 (1955).
E.F. Lewison, The management of the contralateral breast, Hosp. Pract. 5, 101–106 (1970).
G.T. Pack, Bilateral mastectomy, Surgery 29, 929–931 (1951).
G.F. Robbins and J.W. Berg, Bilateral primary breast cancers. A prospective clinicopathological study, Cancer 17, 1501–1527 (1964).
T.B. Hubbard, Jr., Nonsimultaneous bilateral carcinoma of the breast, Surgery 34, 706–723 (1953).
A.R. Kilgore, H.G. Bell, and R.E. Ahlquist, Jr., Cancer in the second breast, Am.J. Surg. 92, 156–161 (1956).
P. Mustacchi, A Pandolfi, and P. Bucalossi, Bilateral mammary cancer in Italian women, J. Natl. Cancer Inst. 19, 1035–1042 (1957).
E.C. White, G.H. Fletcher, and R.L. Clark, Surgical experience with preoperative irradiation for carcinoma of the breast, Ann. Surg. 155, 948–956 (1962).
E.H. Grubbe, X-Ray Treatment, Its Origin, Birth, and Early History, Bruce Publishing Company, St. Paul (1949).
V.P. Collins, Changing concepts of breast cancer and radiotherapy, Proc. Natl. Cancer. Conf. 4, 239–250(1960).
R. Paterson and M. H. Russell, Clinical trials in malignant disease, Part III. Evaluation of postoperative radiotherapy, J. Fac. Radiol. 10, 175–180 (1959).
B. Fisher, N.H. Slack, P.J. Cavanaugh, B. Gardner, R.G. Ravdin, and Cooperating Investigators, Postoperative radiotherapy in the treatment of breast cancer: Results of the NSABP clinical trial, Ann. Surg. 172, 711–732 (1970).
B. Fisher, P. Carbone, S. G. Economou, R. Frelick, A. Glass, H. Lerner, C. Redmond, M. Zelen, D.L. Katrych, N. Wolmark, P. Band, E. R. Fisher, and Other Cooperating Investigabors, L-Phenylalanine mustard (1-PAM) in the management of primary breast cancer: A report of early findings, N. Engl.J. Med. 292, 117–122 (1975).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 1977 Springer Science+Business Media New York
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Fisher, B. (1977). Surgery of Primary Breast Cancer. In: McGuire, W.L. (eds) Current Approaches to Therapy. Springer, Boston, MA. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4757-0480-8_1
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4757-0480-8_1
Publisher Name: Springer, Boston, MA
Print ISBN: 978-1-4757-0482-2
Online ISBN: 978-1-4757-0480-8
eBook Packages: Springer Book Archive