Abstract
A Nobel Prize was awarded to Hans Spemann over 50 years ago (1935) for his discovery of the organizer effect in embryonic development. The citation did not mention induction. During the following year, when he published his book summarizing his work and thought, its title in German was Experimentelle Beiträge zu einer Theorie der Entwicklung (Experimental Contributions to a Theory of Development) (1). It was only in the English translation (1938) that the word induction was introduced into the title: Embryonic Development and Induction (2). But it was the concept of induction that was celebrated by the prize.
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Preview
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
Notes and References
Spemann, H., 1936, Experimentelle Beiträge zu einer Theorie der Entwickelung, Julius Springer, Berlin.
Spemann, H., 1938, Embryonic Development and Induction. Yale University Press, New Haven, CT.
Spemann, H., and Mangold, H., 1924, Ueber Induktion von Embryonalanlagen durch Implantation artfremder Organisatoren, Arch. mikr. Anat. Entwicklungsmech. 100:599–638. English transi. in Foundations of Experimental Embryology, 2nd ed., 1974 ( B. Willier and J. Oppenheimer, eds.), Hafner Press, New York, pp. 146–184.
Spemann, H., 1903, Entwicklungsphysiologische Studien am Tritonei III, Wilhelm Roux’ Arch. Entwicklungsmech. 16: 551–631.
Holtfreter, H., and Hamburger, V., 1955, Embryogeneses: Progressive differentiation. Amphibians, in: Analysis of Development (B. H. Willier, P. A. Weiss, and V. Hamburger, eds.), Saunders, Philadelphia, pp. 230–296. Quotation from p. 275. Emphasis by original authors.
Hertwig, O., 1893, Ueber den Wert der ersten Furchungszellen für die Organbildung des Embryo, Arch. mikr. Anat. 42: 662–806.
Endres, H., 1896, Ueber Anstich-und Schnurversuche an Eiern von Triton taeniatus, Jahresbericht Schles. Gesellsch. vaterländ. Cultur 73:27–34. The 73d Jahresbericht bears the publication date 1896; Endres’s paper was previously delivered orally at a session held in 1895.
Herlitzka, A., 1897, Sullo sviluppo di embrioni completi da blastomeri isolati di uova di Tritone, Wilhelm Roux Arch. Entwicklungsmech. 4: 624–658.
Spemann, H., 1901a, Entwicklungsphysiologische Studien am Tritonei I, Wilhelm Roux’ Arch. Entwicklungsmech. 12: 224–264.
Spemann, H., 1901b, Ueber Correlationen in der Entwicklung des Auges, Verhandl. Anat. Gesellsch., 15. Versamml., Bonn, 61–79.
Herbst, C., 1901a, Formative Reize in der tierischen Ontogenese, Ein Beitrag zum Verständnis der tierischen Embryonalentwicklung, Arthur Georgi, Leipzig.
Ibid., p. 66.
Spemann, 1901b, p. 79. “Shortly after I had demonstrated… that the formation of the lens is brought about [ausgelöst] by the eye cup, Herbst also [in 1901] expressed the same opinion independently of me.”
Printed sources of information about Herbst’s life are rare. His death was close to the time that World War II ended; therefore, the obituary notice that would normally have appeared in Naturwissenschaften was never published. A short, unsigned notice appeared in Sitzungsberichte der Hei del berger Akademie der Wissenschaften, Jahreshefte 1943/55, Heidelberg, 1959, pp. 41–42. Hans Querner prepared a short biographical summary for Neue deutsche Biographie, 1969, Duncker & Humblot, Berlin, 8:593. Information about his personality has been provided not only by the printed sources specified in the following notes, but also by private correspondence in letters from Viktor Hamburger, once a student of Herbst; from Hans Querner, who, like Herbst, was a professor in Heidelberg; and from Dr. Gottfried Zirnstein of Leipzig, who has access to Herbst’s letters to Driesch written between 1902 and 1924. One of Querner’s personal sources of information was Erich von Holst, who came to Heidelberg in 1946 and who was interested in Herbst; Querner had been von Holst’s assistant. Dr. Marion Kazemi provided photocopies of documents relating to Herbst as a member of the Kaiser Wilhelm Foundation and as a possible candidate for office in the Kaiser Wilhelm Institute in Berlin-Dahlem. I am grateful to them all.
Uschmann, G., 1959, Geschichte der Zoologie und der zoologischen Anstalten in Jena 1779–1919, Gustav Fischer, Jena, pp. 179–181.
Goldschmidt, R. B., 1956, Portraits from Memory. Recollections of a Zoologist, University of Washington Press, Seattle, p. 68.
Driesch, H., 1951 (posthumous), Lebenserinnerungen. Aufzeichnungen eines Forschers und Denkers in entscheidender Zeit, Ernst Reinhardt, Basel, p. 69.
Akten der Generalverwaltung der Kaiser-Wilhelm-Gesellschaft, No. 1557: “Professor C. Herbst 1.10.1914 bis 31.3.1915… 4500 M.” The exchange rates published in the New York Times on five Fridays in April 1915 (4/2; 4/9; 4/16; 4/23; 4/30) were used to convert German marks to American dollars.
Baltzer, F., 1967, Theodor Boveri. Life and Work of a Great Biologist 1862–1915 (D. Rudnick, transl.), University of California Press, Berkeley and Los Angeles, p. 20. The reference is to the English edition rather than to the German original because the latter did not specify the date of the letter; Rudnick, working with Baltzer in Switzerland, made some editorial improvements when she prepared the English translation.
Horder, T. J., and Weindling, P. J., 1986, Hans Spemann and the organiser, in: A History of Embryology (T. J. Horder, P. Weindling, and C. C. Wylie, eds.), Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, England, pp. 183–242. My text refers to data presented on p. 205 and in note 63 on p. 239.
Hamburger, V., letter to J.M.O. 2/17/87.
Spemann, H., letter to the President of the Kaiser Wilhelm Foundation, Berlin, April 13, 1918; photocopy provided by Dr. M. Kazemi.
Mangold, O., 1953, Hans Spemann, Ein Meister der Entwicklungsphysiologie, sein Leben und sein Werk, Wissenschaftliche Verlagsgesellschaft, Stuttgart, p. 40.
Goldschmidt, R., 1960, In and out of the Ivory Tower. The Autobiography of Richard B. Goldschmidt, University of Washington Press, Seattle, p. 188.
Aufzeichnung über die Sitzung des Kuratoriums des Kaiser-Wilhelm-Instituts für Biologie… den 13.März 1919… in der Akademie der Wissenschaften. Aus Akt II 11/3 p. 120c. “Von Herbst und Brauss sei zu sagen, dass sie den Zenith ihres Lebens überschritten hätten.”
Querner, H., letter to J. M. O., 2/25/85.
Hamburger, V., letter to J. M. O., 3/11/85.
Hamburger, V., 1988. The Heritage of Experimental Embryology. Hans Spemann and the Organizer. Oxford University Press, Oxford and New York, p. 15.
Hamburger, V., letter to J. M. O., 9/15/88. In 1988 Hamburger may have been thinking of restaurants in railroad stations as they had become by that year. I remember well that even in the 1940s the Savarin Restaurant in Pennsylvania Station was, if not the most elegant dining place in Manhattan, at least sufficiently pleasant to choose unapologetically as an agreeable meeting place for dinner with friends.
Goldschmidt, 1956, p. 70.
Zirnstein, G., letter to J. M. O., 3/21/89.
Zirnstein, G., postcard to J. M. O., 5/15/89.
Goldschmidt, 1956, p. 70. In 1971 The Mendel Newsletter described the Goldschmidt papers housed in the Bancroft Library at the University of California (Berkeley), stating that nine Herbst items (1907–1939) were included in the collection (p. 2). Photocopies of these, which I have seen, indicate that their content was exclusively scientific, not at all political. Perhaps Goldschmidt destroyed the later letters he received from Herbst. Goldschmidt had emigrated from Germany to the United States in 1936.
Hamburger, 1988, pp. 15–16.
Oppenheimer, J. M. 1981, Walter Landauer and developmental genetics, in: Levels of Genetic Control in Development ( S. Subtelny and U. K. Abbott, eds.), Alan R. Liss, New York, pp. 1–13.
Herbst, C., 1892, Experimentelle Untersuchungen über den Einfluss der veränderten chemischen Zusammensetzung des umgebenden Mediums auf die Entwicklung der Thiere. I. Theil. Versuche an Seeigeleiern, Zeit. wiss. Zool. 55: 446–528
Herbst, C., 1893, II. Weiteres über die morphologische Wirkung der Lithiumsälze und ihre theoretische Bedeutung, Mitt. d. zool. Station Neapel 11:136–220. The results of variations on these experiments were described in further publications in this series that appeared in 1896 and again in a new series published in 1901, 1902, and 1904. The references to these articles are very long and are omitted here as the specific content of the publications is not referred to in the text. The 1901 publication was a small monograph; this was Herbst’s Habilitationsschrift, a special presentation required in Germany for acceptance as a university faculty member: Herbst, C., 1901b, Ueber die zur Entwickelung der Seeigeleiern nothwendigen Stoffe, ihre Rolle und ihr Vertretbarkeit. II. Theil. Die Vertretbarkeit der nothwendigen Stoffe durch andere ähnlicher chemischer Natur, Wilhelm Engelmann, Leipzig.
Raikov, B. E., 1968, Karl Ernst von Baer 1792–1876. Sein Leben und sein Werk, Johann Ambrosius Barth, Leipzig, pp. 212–213.
Herbst, 1892, p. 446.
Herbst, C., 1941, Hans Driesch als experimentellen und theoretischen Biologe, Wilhelm Roux’ Arch. Entwicklungsmech. 141:111–153. Quotation from p. 145. The three short publications by Pouchet and Chabry referred to by Herbst all appeared in 1889, as follows: Pouchet, G. and Chabry L., Sur le développement des larves d’Oursin dans l’eau de mer privée de chaux, Compt. rend. Soc. biol. 41:17–20; De la production des larves monstrueuses d’Oursin, par privation de chaux, Compt. rend. Acad. sci. 108:196–198; L’eau de mer artificielle comme agent tératogénique, J. anat. physiol. 25: 298–307.
This passage is reprinted, with the permission of The Johns Hopkins University Press, from Oppenheimer, J. M., 1970. Some diverse backgrounds for Curt Herbst’s ideas about embryonic induction, Bull. Hist. Med. 44:241–250. The passage reprinted here is found on pp. 243,244–248. It concludes here with the sentence at the top of p. 73.
Herbst, C., 1900, Ueber das Auseinandergehen von Furchungs-und Gewebezellen in kalkfreien Medium, Wilhelm Roux’ Arch. Entwicklungsmech. 9:424–436. A recent article on sea urchin morphogenesis refers to Herbst (1900) when stating that hyaline layer (HL) can be dissolved in Cat+-free medium, and points out that “Herbst’s (1900) experiments and later observations indicate[d] that microvilli link the apical surfaces of the blastomeres with HL” (Adelson, D. L. and Humphreys, T., 1988, Sea urchin morphogenesis and cell-hyalin adhesion are perturbed by a monoclonal antibody specific for hyalin, Development 104:391–402; quotation from p. 392). It is correct that Herbst described the layer surrounding the blastomeres as hyalin (the same word in German) and as containing radiating fibers, and his drawings indicate clearly and indisputably that he saw delicate fibers that protruded into the layer; in his text (1900, p. 430) he said that here and there they could be seen to come and go. These observations antedated by decades, however, the use of the word “microvilli” to define cytoplasmic cell protrusions.
Herbst, C., 1893, II. Weiteres über die morphologische Wirkung der Lithiumsälze und ihre theoretische Bedeutung, Mitt. d. zool. Station Neapel. 11: 143.
Hamburger, 1988, p. 14.
Herbst, C., 1894, Ueber die Bedeutung der Reizphysiologie für die kausale Auffassung von Vorgängen in der tierishen Ontogenese. I, Biol. Centralbl. 14:657–666, 689–697, 727–744, 753777, 800–810; Herbst, C., 1895a, Ueber die Bedeutung der Reizphysiologie für die kausale Auffassung…, II, Biol. Centralbl. 15:721–745, 753–772, 792–805, 817–831, 849–855.
Herbst, 1894, p. 657.
Loeb, J., 1888, Die Orientierung der Thiere gegen das Licht (Thierischer Heliotropismus), Sitz.-berichte phys.-med. Gesellsch. Würzburg, 1888, p. 1–5, 1888; Die Orientierung der Thiere gegen die Schwerkraft der Erde (Thierischer Geotropismus), Sitz.-berichte phys.-med. Gesellsch. Würzburg., 1888, p. 5–10.
Herbst, 1894, pp. 690–756.
Hamburger, 1988, p. 18.
Herbst, 1941, p. 119.
Driesch, H., 1896, Die taktische Reizbarkeit von Mesenchymzellen von Echinus tuberculatus, Wilhelm Roux’ Arch. Entwicklungsmech. 3: 362–380.
Driesch, 1896, p. 1; Herbst, 1893, p. 199. Driesch liked to move things around; in an article published in 1893 (Zur Verlagerung der Blastomeren des Echidineies, Anat. Anzeiger 8:348–357) he described experiments in which he thought he shifted cells by compressing eggs between two glass plates; here he was moving cells for a different reason, and he subsequently recognized, according to Herbst in his obituary notice of Driesch (Wilhelm Roux’ Arch. Entwicklungsmech., 1941, 141:115), that it was not whole cells, but only their nuclei, that were displaced. For further detail see Oppenheimer, J. M., 1970, Hans Driesch and the theory and practice of embryonic transplantation, Bull. Hist. Med. 44: 241–250.
Herbst, 1895a, p. 792.
Ibid., p. 722.
Ibid., pp. 819, 821, 822, 830.
Ibid., p. 819.
Ibid., p. 820.
Herbst, 1894, pp. 664, 728.
Noll, F., 1892. Ueber heterogene Induktion. Versuch eines Beitrags zur Kenntnis der Reizerscheinung der Pflanzen. Wilhelm Engelmann, Leipzig.
Herbst, 1894, p. 729. Herbst acknowledged the comparison as borrowed from Pfeffer; he referred it to the latter’s 1893 Reizphysiologie der Pflanzen, but without giving chapter and verse.
Herbst, 1895a, pp. 723 (emphasis by Herbst), 804.
Ibid., p. 794.
Ibid., p. 797.
Herbst, 1901a, p. 41.
Holtfreter and Hamburger, 1955, p. 275.
Herbst, 1901a, p. 38.
Harrison, R. G., 1937, Embryology and its relations, Science 85:369–374. Quotation from p. 372.
Oppenheimer, J. M., 1970, Cells and organizers, Am. Zoologist 10: 75–88.
Hamburger, 1988, p. 14.
Herbst, 1895a, p. 820.
Adler, H., 1881, Ueber den Generationswechsel der Eichengallwespen, Zeit. wiss. Zool. 35: 151–246
Beijerinck, M. W., 1883, Beobachtungen über die ersten Entwicklungsphasen einiger Cnypidengallen, Verh. kon. Akad. Wetensch. Amsterdam 22: 1–198.
Herbst, 1892, pp. 511, 512.
Herbst, 1895a, pp. 721, 742–745, 753–754, 795–796, 799, 824–830, 849–850.
Herbst, 1901a, pp. 118–119.
Herbst, C., 1895b, Ueber die Regeneration von antenneähnlichen Organen an Stelle von Augen, I, Wilhelm Roux’ Arch. Entwicklungsmech. 2: 554–558
Herbst, C., 1896, II, Versuche an Sycionia sculpta, Vierteljahrschr. naturf. Gesellsch. Zürich. 41: 435–454
Herbst, C., 1900, III, Weitere Versuche mit total exstirpirter Augen; IV, Versuche mit theilweise abgeschnittenen Augen, Wilhelm Roux’ Arch. Entwicklungsmech. 9: 215–292
Herbst, C., 1902, Ueber die Regeneration…, Weitere Beweise für die Abhängigkeit der Qualität des Regenerates von den nervösen Centralorganen, Wilhelm Roux’ Arch. Entwicklungsmech. 13: 436–447
Herbst, C., 1910, VI, Die Bewegungsreaktion, welche durch Reizung der heteromorphen Antennulae ausgelöst werden, Wilhelm Roux’ Arch. Entwicklungsmech. 30: 1–14
Herbst, C., 1916, VII, Die Anatomie der Gehirnnerven und des Gehirns bei Krebsen mit Antennulis an Stelle von Augen, Wilhelm Roux’ Arch. Entwicklungsmech. 42: 407–489.
Loeb, J., 1891, Untersuchungen zur physiologische Morphologie der Tiere. I. Ueber Heteromorphose. Georg Hertz, Wurzburg, p. 1.
Bateson, W., 1894, Materials for the Study of Variation, Macmillan, London, pp. 150–151.
Herbst, 1895a, p. 797.
Herbst, 1895b.
Herbst, 1899.
Herbst, 1900.
Spengel, J. W., 1879. Die Eibildung, die Entwicklung und das Männchen der Bonellia, Mitt. d. Zool. Station Neapel. 1: 357–419.
Baltzer, E, 1928, Ueber metagame Geschlechtsbestimmung und ihre Beziehung zu einigen Problemen der Entwicklungsmechanik und Vererbung…, Verh. deutsch. Zool. Gesellsch. 32 Versamml., 273–325.
Herbst, C., 1928, Untersuchungen zur Bestimmung des Geschlechts. I. Sitz.-ber. d. Heidelberger Akad. Wiss., math.-wissensch. KI. [no vol. #]:1–19. The second article in the series appeared in the same periodical in 1929; numbers III—X appeared in Wilhelm Roux’ Arch. Entwicklungsmech. between 1932 and 1940.
Spemann, 1938, p. 220.
Herbst, C., 1943. Die Bedeutung der Salzversuche für die Frage nach der Wirkungsort der Gene, Wilhelm Roux’ Arch. Entwicklungmech. 142: 319–378.
Pfeffer, W., 1881. Pflanzenphysiologie. Ein Handbuch des Stoffwechsels und Kraftwechsels in der Pflanze, Wilhelm Engelmann, Leipzig.
Roux, W., (ed.), 1912. Terminologie der Entwicklungsmechanik der Tiere und Pflanzen, Wilhelm Engelmann, Leipzig, pp. 204–205.
Pfeffer, W., 1871 (1874), Studien über Symmetrie und specifische Wachtumsursachen, Arb. aus d. bot. Inst. Würzburg, Heft 1, 1871, S. 77–98. (This article is next to the last in Heft 1, which is dated 1871. The volume, which also includes later Hefte, is dated 1874.) The portions quoted are from pp. 90 and 93.
Herbst, 1894, p. 754.
His, W., 1878, Untersuchungen über die Bildung des Knochenfischembryo, Arch. Anat. Physiol., Anat. Abt.$11878 [no vol. #1: 180–221.
Weismann, A., 1894, Aeussere Einflüsse als Entwicklungsreize, Gustav Fischer, Jena.
Herbst, 1892, pp. 447–448.
Schmankewitsch, W., 1877, Zur Kenntniss des Einflusses der äusseren Lebensbedingungen auf die Organisation der Thiere, Zeit. wiss. Zool. 29: 429–494.
Roux, W., 1881, Der züchtende Kampf der Theile oder die “Theilauslese” im Organismus, Wilhelm Engelmann, Leipzig, p. 206.
Herbst, 1895a, p. 721.
Herbst, 1901a, p. 1.
Virchow, R., 1858, Reizung und Reizbarkeit, Arch. pathol. Anat. Physiol. klin. Med. 14:1–64. Quotation from pp. 30 and 39.
von Baer, K. E., 1828, Ueber Entwickelungsgeschichte der Thiere: Beobachtung und Reflexion. Bornträger, Königsberg, p. 155.
Billroth, T., 1890, Ueber die Einwirkungen lebender Pflanzen-und Thierzellen auf einander. Eine biologische Studie, Alfred Hölder, Vienna.
Ibid., p. 9.
Ibid., pp. 13–14.
Faraday, M., 1832, Experimental researches in electricity, Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc. London for1832, Part II, pp. 125–194. Quotation from p. 125.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 1991 Plenum Press, New York
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Oppenheimer, J.M. (1991). Curt Herbst’s Contributions to the Concept of Embryonic Induction. In: Gilbert, S.F. (eds) A Conceptual History of Modern Embryology. Developmental Biology, vol 7. Springer, Boston, MA. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4615-6823-0_4
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4615-6823-0_4
Publisher Name: Springer, Boston, MA
Print ISBN: 978-1-4615-6825-4
Online ISBN: 978-1-4615-6823-0
eBook Packages: Springer Book Archive