Advertisement

Battleground of the Revolutionaries: the Republic and Civil War in Spain, 1931–39

  • Tim Rees
Part of the Themes in Focus book series (TIF)

Abstract

To say that revolution was in everyone’s mind in Spain during the 1930s would be an exaggeration, but it would not be a too gross or unpardonable one. Perhaps no other place or time in Europe during the twentieth century — including Russia in 1917 — has witnessed the flourishing of such a number of movements proclaiming such a variety of openly revolutionary ideologies. The most recognised of the revolutionary episodes of the time took place during the Civil War of 1936–39 in the Republican zone, with George Orwell’s discovery of Barcelona as a city in the midst of Anarchist revolutionary turmoil the best-known account of it.1 However, it was not just the war that allowed revolution to flourish nor was anarchism the only example. In fact, the bitterly polemical nature of political conflict during the 1930s as a whole, which was at its most intense during the Civil War, encouraged the expression of political aims in revolutionary terms. Revolutionary movements initially grew in importance with the establishment of the democratic Second Republic in 1931 and encompassed a wide spectrum of ideas — including radical liberalism, socialism, communism and fascism, as well as anarchism. This breadth itself precluded the development of a classical revolutionary situation, conceived in terms of two opposing blocs representing the status quo and a revolutionary alternative. Instead, these multiple notions of a revolutionary future were often at odds with one another during the Republic and openly clashed during the Civil War, with each version seeking to subdue all others. In this way Spain in the 1930s became a battleground of virtually all the European ideologies that could be labelled as ‘revolutionary’ during the twentieth century.

Keywords

Trade Union Liberal Democracy Socialist Party Republican Government Popular Front 
These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Notes and References

  1. 1.
    G. Orwell, Homage to Catalonia (London, 1938).Google Scholar
  2. 2.
    Perhaps the closest attempt to do this is S. Payne, The Spanish Revolution (New York, 1970), though revolution is identified wholly with the political left.Google Scholar
  3. See also J. Tusell, Los intelectuales y la República (Madrid, 1990);Google Scholar
  4. A. Garosci, Los intelectuales y la guerra de España (Madrid, 1981)Google Scholar
  5. P. Preston, ‘War of Words: the Spanish Civil War and the Historians’, in P. Preston (ed.), Revolution and War in Spain, 1931–1939 (London, 1984).Google Scholar
  6. 3.
    On republicanism see N. Townson (ed.), El republicanismo en España (1830–1977) (Madrid, 1994)Google Scholar
  7. S. Ben-Ami, The Origins of the Second Republic in Spain (Oxford, 1978), chap. 1.Google Scholar
  8. 4.
    Useful overviews include E. Ucelay Da Cal, ‘The Nationalisms of the Periphery: Culture and Politics in the Construction of National Identity’, in H. Graham and J. Labanyi (eds), Spanish Cultural Studies: an Introduction (Oxford, 1995);Google Scholar
  9. D. Conversi, The Basques, the Catalans and Spain: Alternative Routes to Nationalist Mobilization (London, 1997);Google Scholar
  10. A. Balcells, Catalan Nationalism (London, 1996) esp. chap. 8CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. S. Payne, Basque Nationalism (Reno, Nevada, 1975), esp. chap. 4.Google Scholar
  12. 5.
    P. Heywood, Marxism and the Failure of Organised Socialism in Spain, 1879–1936 (Cambridge, 1990);CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. R. Gillespie, The Spanish Socialist Party: a History of Factionalism (Oxford, 1989);Google Scholar
  14. S. Juliá, Los socialistas en la política española, 1879–1982 (Madrid, 1997).Google Scholar
  15. J. C. Gibaja Velázquez, Indalecio Prieto y el socialismo español (Madrid, 1995);Google Scholar
  16. E. Cornide Fervant, Indalecio Prieto: socialista a fuera del liberal (Sada A Coruña, 1995);Google Scholar
  17. J. Aróstegui, Francisco Largo Caballero: la última etapa de un líder obrero (Madrid, 1990);Google Scholar
  18. Unión General de Trabajadores, Francisco Largo Caballero, 1869–1946 (Madrid, 1996).Google Scholar
  19. 7.
    M. Aragón, ‘Manuel Azaña y su ideal de la República’, in V. A. Serrano and J. M. San Luciano (eds), Azaña (Madrid, 1980), pp. 225–52;Google Scholar
  20. M. Contreras, El PSOE en la II República: organización y ideología (Madrid, 1981), pp. 209–18.Google Scholar
  21. 8.
    For further examples see S. Juliá, Manuel Azaña: una biografía política (Madrid, 1990), pp. 55–137.Google Scholar
  22. 10.
    S. Ben-Ami, ‘The Crisis of the Dynastic Elite in the Transition from Monarchy to Republic, 1929–1931’, in F. Lannon and P. Preston (eds), Elites and Power in Twentieth Century Spain (Oxford, 1990).Google Scholar
  23. 11.
    J. Tusell et al., Las Constituyentes de 1931: unas elecciones de transición (Madrid, 1982).Google Scholar
  24. 13.
    The fortunes of this reforming project are a central theme of the literature on the Second Republic. Contrasting interpretations can be found in S. Payne, Spain’s First Democracy. The Second Republic, 1931–1936 (Madison, Wis., 1993), esp. pp. 81–124;Google Scholar
  25. 14.
    O. Ruiz Manjón, El Partido Republicano Radical (1908–1936) (Madrid, 1976)Google Scholar
  26. for background J. Alvarez Junco, El emperador del paralelo. Lerroux y la demogogia populista (Madrid, 1990).Google Scholar
  27. 16.
    J. R. Montero, La CEDA: el catolicismo social y político en la II República, 2 vols (Madrid, 1977);Google Scholar
  28. M. Vincent, Catholicism in the Second Spanish Republic: Religion and Politics in Salamanca, 1930–36 (Oxford, 1996), esp. chap. 9CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. L. M. Moreno Fernández, Acción Popular Murciana (Murcia, 1987).Google Scholar
  30. 18.
    M. Blinkhorn, ‘Spain’, in S. Salter and J. Stevenson (eds), The Working Class and Politics in Europe and America, 1929–1945 (London, 1990);Google Scholar
  31. G. Meaker, The Revolutionary Left in Spain, 1914–1923 (Stanford, Calif., 1974);Google Scholar
  32. B. Martin, The Agony of Modernization: Labor and Industrialization in Spain (Ithaca, 1990).Google Scholar
  33. J. Casanova, De la calle al frente. El anarcosindicalismo en España (1931–39) (Barcelona, 1997);Google Scholar
  34. A. Elorza, La utopía anarquista bajo la segunda República española (Madrid, 1973);Google Scholar
  35. J. Alvarez Junco, Ideología y política del anarquismo español, 1880–1910 (Madrid, 1988);Google Scholar
  36. M. Bookchin, The Spanish Anarchists: the Heroic Years, 1868–1936 (New York, 1977)Google Scholar
  37. R. Gómez Casas, Anarchist Organisation: the History of the FAI (Montreal, 1986).Google Scholar
  38. 20.
    R. Cruz, El Partido Comunista de España en la segunda República (Madrid, 1987);Google Scholar
  39. V. Alba, The Communist Party in Spain (New Brunswick, NJ, 1983);Google Scholar
  40. P. Pages, Historia del Partido Comunista de España (Barcelona, 1978);Google Scholar
  41. A. Elorza, ‘In the Shadow of God: the Formation of the Comintern’s Spanish Policy’, in M. Narinsky and J. Rojahn (eds), Centre and Periphery: the History of the Comintern in the Light of New Documents (Amsterdam, 1996)Google Scholar
  42. 21.
    See A. Durgan, BOC 1930–1936: El Bloque Obrero y Campesino (Barcelona, 1996)Google Scholar
  43. V. Alba and S. Schwartz, Spanish Marxism Versus Soviet Communism: a History of the POUM (New Brunswick, NJ, 1988)Google Scholar
  44. Y. Riottot, Joaquín Maurín: de l’anarcho-syndical- isme au communisme (1919–1936) (Paris, 1997).Google Scholar
  45. 22.
    In addition to works cited above see J. Mintz, The Anarchists of Casas Viejas (Chicago, 1982);Google Scholar
  46. A. Barrio Alonso, Anarquismo y anarcosindicalismo en Asturias (1890–1936) (Madrid, 1988), pp. 313–422;Google Scholar
  47. C. Ealham, ‘Anarchism and Illegality in Barcelona, 1931–1937’, Contemporary European History, 4, 2 (1995), pp. 133–52;CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  48. G. Kelsey, Anarchosyndicalism, Libertarian Communism and the State: the CNT in Zaragoza and Aragón, 1930–1937 (Amsterdam, 1992Google Scholar
  49. S. Juliá, Madrid, 1931–1934: de la fiesta popular a la lucha de clases (Madrid, 1984), pp. 147–265.Google Scholar
  50. 23.
    Luis Araquistáin, ‘Tres años de la República’, Leviatán no. 1 (March 1934).Google Scholar
  51. 24.
    On the growth of discontent see G. A. Collier, Socialists of Rural Andalusia. Unacknowledged Revolutionaries of the Second Republic (Stanford, Calif., 1987), pp. 88–130;Google Scholar
  52. A. Shubert, The Road to Revolution in Spain. The Coal Miners of Asturias, 1860–1934 (Chicago, 1987), pp. 141–62;Google Scholar
  53. P. Biglino, El socialismo español y la cuestión agraria, 1890–1936 (Madrid, 1986), pp. 383–441.Google Scholar
  54. 25.
    On attempts at unity see V. Alba, La Alianza Obrera (Madrid, 1978);Google Scholar
  55. S. Juliá, Orígenes del Frente Popular en España (1934–1936) (Madrid, 1979), pp. 12–26.Google Scholar
  56. P. Preston, ‘The Creation of the Popular Front in Spain’, in H. Graham and P. Preston (eds), The Popular Front in Europe (London, 1987)Google Scholar
  57. J. Tusell, Las elecciones del Frente Popular, 2 vols (Madrid, 1971).Google Scholar
  58. 28.
    R. Viñas, La formación de las Juventudes Socialistas Unificadas (1934–1936) (Madrid, 1978);Google Scholar
  59. H. Graham, Socialism and War. The Spanish Socialist Party in Power and Crisis, 1936–1939 (Cambridge, 1991), pp. 15–52;CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  60. S. Juliá, La izquierda del PSOE (1935–1936) (Madrid, 1977) and Heywood, Marxism, pp. 171–9.Google Scholar
  61. 29.
    J. Gil Pecharromán, Conservadores subversivos: la derecha autoritaria alfonsina (1913–1936) (Madrid, 1994);Google Scholar
  62. R. Morodo, Los origenes ideológicos del franquismo: Acción Española (Madrid, 1985);Google Scholar
  63. P. C. Gonález Cuevas, Acción Española: teología política y nacionalismo autoritario en España (1913–1936) (Madrid, 1998);Google Scholar
  64. M. Blinkhorn, Carlism and Crisis in Spain, 1931–1939 (Cambridge, 1975).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  65. 30.
    On the right as a whole see M. Blinkhorn, ‘Conservatism, Traditionalism and Fascism in Spain, 1898–1937’, in M. Blinkhorn (ed.), Fascists and Conservatives (London, 1990).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  66. 31.
    S. Ellwood, Prietas las filas. Historia de Falange Española, 1933–1983 (Barcelona, 1984);Google Scholar
  67. S. Payne, Falange: a History of Spanish Fascism (Stanford, Calif., 1962);Google Scholar
  68. J. Jiménez Campo, El fascismo en la crisis de la II República (Madrid, 1979);Google Scholar
  69. P. Preston, ‘The Myths of José Antonio Primo de Rivera’, in R. A. Stradling et al. (eds), Conflict and Coexistence (Cardiff, 1996);Google Scholar
  70. J. Gil Pecharromán, José Antonio Primo de Rivera: retrato de un visionario (Madrid, 1996);Google Scholar
  71. J. L. Mínguez Goyanes, Onésimo Redondo, 1905–1936: precursor sindicalista (Madrid, 1990).Google Scholar
  72. 35.
    H. Thomas (ed.), José Antonio Primo de Rivera. Selected Writings (London, 1972), pp. 132–7.Google Scholar
  73. 40.
    The bibliography on the war is vast and unrepeatable here. For good recent introductions and bibliographies see P. Preston, A Concise History of the Spanish Civil War, 2nd edn (London, 1996);Google Scholar
  74. G. Esenwein and A. Shubert, Spain at War. The Spanish Civil War in Context, 1931–1939 (London, 1995)Google Scholar
  75. M. Tuñón de Lara et al., La guerra civil española: 50 años después (Madrid, 1985).Google Scholar
  76. 41.
    J. Aróstegui, ‘Manuel Azaña y la guerra civil como tragedia’, in A. Alted et al. (eds), Manuel Azaña: pensamiento y acción (Madrid, 1996);Google Scholar
  77. 42.
    H. Graham, ‘Spain, 1936. Resistance and Revolution: the Flaws in the Front’, in T. Kirk and T. McElligott (eds), Opposing Fascism: Community, Authority and Resistance in Europe (Cambridge, 1999).Google Scholar
  78. 43.
    W. Bernecker, Colectividades y revolución social. El anarquismo en la guerra civil española, 1936–1939 (Barcelona, 1982);Google Scholar
  79. A. Castells, Les collec-tivitzaciones a Barcelona (1936–1939) (Barcelona, 1993);Google Scholar
  80. M. Seidman, Workers against Work. Labor in Paris and Barcelona during the Popular Fronts (Berkeley, Calif., 1991);Google Scholar
  81. J. Casanova, Anarquismo y revolución en la sociedad rural aragonesa, 1936–1938 (Madrid, 1985);Google Scholar
  82. M. A. Ackelsberg, Free Women of Spain. Anarchism and the Struggle for the Emancipation of Women (Bloomington, Ill., 1992);Google Scholar
  83. L. Garrido González, Colectividades agrarias en Andalucía: Jaén (1931–1939) (Madrid, 1979);Google Scholar
  84. N. Rodrigo González, Las colectividades agrarias en Castilla-La Mancha (Toledo, 1985).Google Scholar
  85. R. Tostorff, Die POUM im Spanischen Burgerkrieg (Frankfurt, 1987) and Alba and Schwartz, Spanish Marxism, pp. 111–71.Google Scholar
  86. 44.
    A. Montero Montero, Historia de la persecución religiosa en España, 1936–1939 (Madrid, 1961) is the most reliable account of the religious persecution.Google Scholar
  87. See also J. M. Sánchez, The Spanish Civil War as a Religious Tragedy (Notre Dame, 1987).Google Scholar
  88. 45.
    T. Rees, ‘The Highpoint of Comintern Influence? The Communist Party and the Civil War in Spain’, in T. Rees and A. Thorpe (eds), International Communism and the Communist International, 1919–1943 (Manchester, 1998), p. 153;Google Scholar
  89. 48.
    See also E. H. Carr, The Comintern and the Spanish Civil War (London, 1984);CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  90. 49.
    J. Casanova, ‘Social History and Spanish Anarchists during the Civil War’, International Review of Social History, 37, 3 (1992–3), pp. 398–404.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  91. 50.
    See, for instance, the official history: D. Ibárruri et al. Guerra y revolución en España, 1936–1939, 4 vols (Moscow, 1966–77).Google Scholar
  92. 54.
    See A. Castells Duran, El proceso estatizador en la experiencia colectivista catalana (1936–1939) (Madrid, 1996).Google Scholar
  93. 55.
    F. Borkenau, ‘State and Revolution in the Paris Commune, the Russian Revolution and the Spanish Civil War’, Sociological Review, xxxix (1937), pp. 41–75.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  94. 57.
    See also A. Elorza, ‘Storia di un manifesto: Ercoli e la definizione del Frente Populare in Spagna’, Studi Storici, 36 (1995), pp. 353–62.Google Scholar
  95. 58.
    For an overview of conditions in the Nationalist zone see J. Grugel and T. Rees, Franco’s Spain (London, 1987), chap. 1 and Blinkhorn, Carlism, pp. 256–8.Google Scholar
  96. 59.
    S. Ellwood, ‘Falange Española, 1933–39: from Fascism to Francoism’, in M. Blinkhorn (ed.), Spain in Conflict, 1931–1939 (London, 1986) and Prietas, esp. pp. 78–82;Google Scholar
  97. R. Chueca, El fascismo en los comienzos del régimen de Franco (Madrid, 1983).Google Scholar
  98. 60.
    This was best represented in the notion of a ‘Crusade’ against the Republic: H. Southworth, El mito de la Cruzada de Franco (Paris, 1963).Google Scholar
  99. 61.
    P. Preston, Franco (London, 1993), pp. 144–83.Google Scholar
  100. M. García Venero, Historia de la Unificación. Falange y Requeté en 1937 (Madrid, 1970);Google Scholar
  101. 64.
    M. Aparicio, El sindicalismo vertical y la formación del Estado franquista (Barcelona, 1980)Google Scholar
  102. A. de Miguel, Sociología del franquismo (Barcelona, 1975).Google Scholar
  103. 65.
    J. Tusell, Franco en la Guerra Civil (Madrid, 1992), pp. 223–37;Google Scholar
  104. S. Payne, The Franco Regime (Madison, 1987), pp. 180–2.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Tim Rees 2001

Authors and Affiliations

  • Tim Rees

There are no affiliations available

Personalised recommendations