Abstract
The Genitive of Negation (Gen Neg) in Russian involves alternation of Genitive with Nominative or Accusative under conditions which have been debated for many decades. What gives the construction its name is that Gen Neg occurs only under sentential negation; other allegedly crucial factors include topic–focus structure, unaccusativity, perspectival structure, the lexical semantics of the verb, and the referential status of the NP. Here we focus on Subject Gen Neg sentences, which on our account (following Babby and many Russian scholars) are normally Existential sentences. We address the problem raised by certain Gen Neg sentences with the copula byt’ and referential subjects which appear to be negations of Locative rather than Existential sentences. We review why Babby exempted some sentences with byt’ from his analysis, and present challenges raised by the two present tense forms of the verb. These problems lead to a re-examination of the distinction between Existential and Locative sentences, and of the distinction between sentential and constituent negation. We identify three distinct approaches to these issues, exploring their strengths and weaknesses. We do not argue conclusively for one approach but identify open questions which we believe need answers before the issues can be resolved.
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Preview
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
References
Abbott, Barbara. 1993. A pragmatic account of the definiteness effect in existential sentences. Journal of Pragmatics 19: 39–55.
Abbott, Barbara. 1997. Definiteness and existentials. Language 73: 103–108.
Apresjan, Jurij D. 1985. Syntaksičeskie priznaki leksem [Syntactic features of lexemes]. Russian Linguistics 9: 289–317.
Apresjan, Jurij D. 1986. Deiksis v grammatike i leksike i naivnaja model’ mira [Deixis in grammar and lexicon and the naïve model of the world]. Semiotika i Informatika 28: 5–33.
Apresjan, Jurij D. 1995. Izbrannye Trudy, Vol II: Integral’noe Opisanie Jazyka i Sistemnaja Leksikografia [Integrated Description of Language and Systematic Lexicography]. Moscow: Škola “Jazyki Russkoj Kultury”.
Arutjunova, Nina D. 1976. Predloženie i ego smysl [ The Sentence and its Meaning]. Moscow: Nauka.
Arutjunova, Nina D. 1997. Bytijnye predloženija [ Existential Sentences]. Enciklopedija “Russkij jazyk”. Moscow: Bol’šaja Rossijskaja Enciklopedija, 57–59.
Arutjunova, Nina D. and E.N. Širjaev. 1983. Russkoe predloženie. Bytijnyj tip (struktura i značenie). [The Russian Sentence. The Existential Type (Structure and Meaning)]. Moscow: Russkij jazyk.
Babby, Leonard. 1980. Existential Sentences and Negation in Russian. Ann Arbor, Michigan: Karoma Publishers.
Babby, Leonard. ms. 2000. The genitive of negation and unaccusativity. Ms., Princeton University.
Babby, Leonard H. 2001. The genitive of negation: a unified analysis. In Annual Workshop on Formal Approaches to Slavic Linguistics: The Bloomington Meeting 2000 (FASL 9), eds. Steven Franks, Tracy Holloway King and Michael Yadroff, 39–55. Ann Arbor: Michigan Slavic Publications.
Babyonyshev, Maria A. 1996. Structural Connections in Syntax and Processing: Studies in Russian and Japanese. Ph.D. dissertation, MIT. Distributed by MIT Working Papers in Linguistics, Cambridge, MA.
Bailyn, John F. 1997. Genitive of negation is obligatory. In Annual Workshop on Formal Approaches to Slavic Linguistics: The Cornell Meeting 1995 [ = FASL 4], eds. Wayles Browne, Ewa Dornsich, Natasha Kondrashova, and Draga Zec., 84–114. Ann Arbor, Michigan: Michigan Slavic Publications.
Bolinger, Dwight. 1977. Meaning and Form. London and New York: Longman.
Borschev, Vladimir and Barbara H. Partee. 1998a. Formal and Lexical Semantics and the Genitive in Negated Existential Sentences in Russian. In Formal Approaches to Slavic Linguistics: The Connecticut Meeting 1997, eds. Željko Bosković, Steven Franks and William Snyder, 75–96. Ann Arbor: Michigan Slavic Publications.
Borschev, Vladimir and Barbara H. Partee. 1998b. Bytijnye predloženija i otricanie v russkom jazyke: semantika i kommunikativnaja struktura. [Existential sentences and negation in Russian: semantics and communicative structure]. In Dialogue ’98: Computational Linguistics and Its Applications, ed. A.S. Narin’yani, 173–182. Kazan: Xéter.
Borschev, Vladimir and Barbara H. Partee. 2002a. The Russian genitive of negation in existential sentences: the role of Theme–Rheme structure reconsidered. In Travaux du Cercle Linguistique de Prague (nouvelle série, Vol. 4), eds. Eva Hajičová, Petr Sgall, Jiří Hana and Tomáš Hoskovec, 185–250. Amsterdam: John Benjamins Pub. Co.
Borschev, Vladimir and Barbara H. Partee. 2002b. The Russian genitive of negation: Theme–rheme structure or perspective structure? Journal of Slavic Linguistics 10: 105–144.
Borschev, Vladimir, and Barbara H. Partee. 2002c. O semantike bytijnyx predloženij (On the semantics of existential sentences). Semiotika i Informatika, 37 (Moscow: VINITI), 59–77.
Borschev, Vladimir, Paducheva, Elena V., Partee, Barbara H., Testelets, Yakov G., and Yanovich, Igor. 2006. Sentential and constituent negation in Russian BE-sentences revisited. In Formal Approaches to Slavic Linguistics: The Princeton Meeting 2005 (FASL 14), eds. James Lavine, Steven L. Franks, Mila Tasseva-Kurktchieva and Hana Filip, 50–65. Ann Arbor: Michigan Slavic Publications.
Bresnan, J. and Kanerva, Jonni M. 1989. Locative Inversion in Chicheŵa: A Case Study of Factorization in Grammar. Linguistic Inquiry 20: 1–50.
Brown, Sue. 1999. The Syntax of Negation in Russian: A Minimalist Approach. Stanford: CSLI Publications.
Chvany, Catherine V. 1975. On the Syntax of BE-Sentences in Russian. Cambridge, MA: Slavica.
Comorovski, Ileana. 1995. On quantifier strength and partitive noun phrases. In Quantification in Natural Languages, eds. Emmon Bach, Eloise Jelinek, Angelika Kratzer and Barbara H. Partee, 145–177. Dordrecht: Kluwer.
Déchaine, Rose-Marie. 1995. On be. In Linguistics in the Netherlands 1995, eds. M. den Dikken and K. Hengeveld, 73–88. Amsterdam/Philadelphia: John Benjamins Publishing Company.
Hajičová, Eva. 1973. Negation and Topic vs. Comment. Philologia Pragensia 16: 81–93.
Hajičová, Eva. 1974. Meaning, presupposition and allegation. Philologia Pragensia 17:18–25.
Hajičová, Eva. 1984. On presupposition and allegation. In Contributions to Functional Syntax, Semantics and Language Comprehension, ed. Petr Sgall, 99–122. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Harves, Stephanie 2002a. Unaccusative Syntax in Russian. Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, Princeton University.
Harves, Stephanie A. 2002b. Genitive of negation and the existential paradox. Journal of Slavic Linguistics 10: 185–212.
Horn, Laurence R. 1989. A Natural History of Negation. University of Chicago Press.
Ickovič, V.A. 1974. Očerki sintaksičeskoj normy [Remarks on the syntactic norm]. In Sintaksis i norma. ed., G.A. Zolotova, 43–106. Moscow: Nauka.
Jackendoff, Ray. 1972. Semantic Interpretation in Generative Grammar. Cambridge: MIT Press.
Jackendoff, Ray. 1990. Semantic Structures. Cambridge: MIT Press.
Kondrashova, Natalia. 1996. The Syntax of Existential Quantification. Ph.D. dissertation, University of Wisconsin, Madison.
Kovtunova, I.I. 1976. Sovremennyj russkij jazyk: porjadok slov i aktual’noe členenie predloženija [Modern Russian: word order and the communicative structure of a sentence]. Moscow: Russkij jazyk.
Kuroda, S.-Y. 1972. The categorical and the thetic judgment (evidence from Japanese). Foundations of Language 2: 153–185.
Mel’čuk, Igor A. 1982. Lexical functions in lexicographic description. In BLS 8: Proceedings of the Eighth Annual Meeting of the Berkeley Linguistics Society, 427–443. Berkeley, CA: Berkeley Linguistics Society.
Mel’čuk, I.A., and Iordanskaja, L.N. 1995. Glaza Mashi golubye vs Glaza u Mashi golubye: Choosing between two Russian constructions in the domain of body parts. In Russkij jazyk v modeli “Smysl <==> tekst” (The Russian Language in the “Meaning <==> Text” Model), ed. I.A. Mel’čuk, 135–167. Moscow and Vienna: Jazyki Russkoj Kul’tury.
Moro, Andrea. 1997. The Raising of Predicates: Predicative Noun Phrases and the Theory of Clause Structure: Cambridge Studies in Linguistics; 80. Cambridge; New York: Cambridge University Press.
Paducheva, E.V. 1974. O semantike sintaksisa: materialyktransformacionnoj grammatike russkogo jazyka [On the Semantics of Syntax: Materials toward the Transformational Grammar of Russian]. Moscow: Nauka.
Paducheva, E.V. 1992. O semantičeskom podxode k sintaksisu i genitivnom sub”ekte glagola BYT’ [On the semantic approach to syntax and the genitive subject of the verb BYT’ ‘BE’]. Russian Linguistics 16: 53–63.
Paducheva, E.V. 1994. From Puškin to Nabokov: narrator in the position of observer. Russian Literature 36: 353–370.
Paducheva, E.V. 1997. Roditel’nyj sub”ekta v otricatel’nom predloženii: sintaksis ili semantika? [Genitive of Subject in a negated sentence: syntax or semantics?]. Voprosy Jazykoznanija 2: 101–116.
Paducheva, E.V. 2000. Definiteness effect: the case of Russian. In Reference and anaphoric relations, ed. Klaus von Heusinger, 133–146. Dordrecht: Kluwer.
Paducheva, E.V. 2002. Diateza i diatetičeskij sdvig (‘Diathesis and diathesis shift’). Russian Linguistics 26: 179–215.
Paducheva, E.V. 2004. Dinamičeskie modeli v semantike leksiki [Dynamic models in lexical semantics]. Moscow: Jazyki slavjanskoj kultury.
Paducheva, E.V. 2006. Roditel’nyj otricanija i problema edinstva dejktičeskogo centra vyskazyvanija. (Genitive of negation and the problem of the unity of the deictic center of the utterance). Izvestija RAN, Serija Literatury i Jazyka 4: 3–10.
Partee, Barbara H. 1977. John is easy to please. In Linguistic Structures Processing, ed. A. Zampolli, 281–312. Amsterdam: North-Holland.
Partee, Barbara H. 2000. Topics under negation: But the answer never came. In Prosodie – Struktur – Interpretation. Linguistiche ArbeitsBerichte, eds. Johannes Dölling and Thomas Pechmann, 74, 43–57. Leipzig: University of Leipzig.
Partee, Barbara H. and Vladimir Borschev. 2002. Genitive of negation and scope of negation in Russian existential sentences. In Annual Workshop on Formal Approaches to Slavic Linguistics: The Second Ann Arbor Meeting 2001 (FASL 10), ed. Jindrich Toman, 181–200. Ann Arbor: Michigan Slavic Publications.
Partee, Barbara H. and Vladimir Borschev. 2004. The semantics of Russian Genitive of Negation: The nature and role of Perspectival Structure. In Proceedings of Semantics and Linguistic Theory (SALT) 14, eds. Kazuha Watanabe and Robert B. Young, 212–234. Ithaca, NY: CLC Publications.
Partee, Barbara H., and Vladimir Borschev. 2006. Information structure, perspectival structure, diathesis alternation, and the Russian Genitive of Negation. In Proceedings of Ninth Symposium on Logic and Language (LoLa 9), Beseny\H{o}telek, Hungary, August 24–26, 2006, eds. Beáta Gyuris, László Kálmán, Chris Piñón and Károly Varasdi, 120–129. Budapest: Research Institute for Linguistics, Hungarian Academy of Sciences, Theoretical Linguistics Programme, Eötvös Loránd University.
Peregrin, Jaroslav. 1996. Topic and focus in a formal framework. In Discourse and Meaning: Papers in Honor of Eva Hajičová, eds. B.H. Partee and P. Sgall, 235–254. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Pereltsvaig, Asya. 1997. The genitive of negation and aspect in Russian. Ms., The Hebrew University of Jerusalem/McGill University, Montreal.
Perlmutter, D. 1978. Impersonal passive and the unaccusative hypothesis. In Proceedings of the fourth annual meeting of the Berkeley Linguistics Society, eds. J. Jaeger et al. , University of California at Berkeley, 159–189.
Perlmutter, David and John Moore. 2002. Language-internal explanation: the distribution of Russian impersonals. Language 78: 619–650.
Pesetsky, David. 1982. Paths and Categories. Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation. Cambridge: MIT.
Peškovskij, Alexandr M. 1938. Russkij sintaksis v naučnom osveščenii [Russian syntax in a scientific light]. 6th edition. Moscow: Gosučpedgiz.
Seliverstova, Ol’ga N. 1990. Kontrastivnaja Sintaksicheskaja Semantika (Contrastive Syntactic Semantics). Moscow: Nauka.
Sgall, Petr, Eva Hajičová, and Jarmila Panevová. 1986. The Meaning of the Sentence in Its Semantic and Pragmatic Aspects. Dordrecht: Reidel and Prague: Academia.
Šatunovskij, I.B. 2000. Predloženija naličija vs. bytijnye i lokativnye predloženija v russkom jazyke (Presence-sentences vs. existential and locative sentences in Russian). In Logičeskij Analiz Jazyka: Jazyki Prostranstv (Logical Analysis of Language: Languages of Space), eds. N.D. Arutjunova and I.B. Levontina, 189–197. Moscow: Jazyki Russkoj Kultury.
Steube, Anita, and Andreas Späth. 1999. Determination in German and Russian. In Travaux du Cercle Linguistique de Prague (nouvelle série), Vol. 3, eds. E. Hajičová et al., 145–164. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Švedova, N. Ju. ed. 1980. Russkaja grammatika. Akademija nauk SSSR, Institut russkogo jazyka. Moscow: Nauka.
Ward, Gregory and Betty Birner. 1995. Definiteness and the English existential. Language 71: 722–742.
Yanko, T.E. 2000. Bytovanie i obladanie: konstrukcii s glaglom byt’ (Being and possession: constructions with the verb byt’ ‘be’). In Logičeskij Analiz Jazyka: Jazyki Prostranstv (Logical Analysis of Language: Languages of Space), eds. N.D. Arutjunova and I.B. Levontina, 198–211. Moscow: Jazyki Russkoj Kultury.
Yokoyama, Olga T. 1986. Discourse and Word order. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 2008 Springer Science+Business Media B.V
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Partee, B.H., Borschev, V. (2008). Existential Sentences, BE, and the Genitive of Negation in Russian. In: Comorovski, I., von Heusinger, K. (eds) Existence: Semantics and Syntax. Studies in Linguistics and Philosophy, vol 84. Springer, Dordrecht. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4020-6197-4_6
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4020-6197-4_6
Publisher Name: Springer, Dordrecht
Print ISBN: 978-1-4020-6198-1
Online ISBN: 978-1-4020-6197-4
eBook Packages: Humanities, Social Sciences and LawSocial Sciences (R0)