A Challenge Let Drop: Soviet Foreign Policy, the Cominform and the Italian Communist Party, 1947–8

  • Silvio Pons

Abstract

Criticism of the Italian and French Communist Parties constituted one of the crucial moments in the founding of Cominform in September 1947. Since Eugenio Reale — one of the members of the Italian delegation at the Szklarska Poręba Conference — revealed these criticisms,1 historians have pondered their significance. They have been seen as a consequence of the ‘two camps’ theory in international politics, and of an attempt to induce the Communist Parties to close ranks with the USSR.2 The archive material to which we now have access allows us to shed light on areas which were obscure until recently. The limits of the documentation available should also be made clear, however: in particular, this sheds no light on the decision-making process in the Soviet leadership which led to the founding of the Cominform. Nonetheless, we are now able to trace more clearly the framework which Soviet leaders gave to the Szklarska Poręba Conference, the positions taken up by representatives of other parties during Conference debates, the reactions of the Italian Communist Party (PCI) to the criticisms, and also developments in relations between the Italian Party and Moscow in the following months. We have enough new evidence to clarify — and sometimes to modify — the interpretations which have been proposed until now. In this chapter I intend to show that although the criticism of the Western Parties had wider consequences for all the other Parties belonging to the Cominform, these were only to a limited extent the corollary of any major reorientation in Soviet foreign policy.

Keywords

Europe Peri Arena Tempo Defend 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Notes

  1. 1.
    E. Reale, Nascita del Cominform (Milan: 1958).Google Scholar
  2. 2.
    Cf. P. Spriano, I comunisti europei e Stalin (Turin: 1983) pp. 287–90;Google Scholar
  3. A. Guerra, Gli anni del Cominform (Milan: 1977) pp. 153–6.Google Scholar
  4. 8.
    Cf. A. Di Biagio, ‘The Establishment of the Cominform’, in G. Procacci (ed.), G. Adibekov, A. Di Biagio, L. Gibianskii, F. Gori, S. Pons (coeds), The Cominform. Minutes of the Three Conferences 1947/1948/ 1949, Fondazione Feltrinelli, Annali, XXX (Milan: 1994) p. 23.Google Scholar
  5. 16.
    Cf. E. Kardelj, Memorie degli anni di ferro (Rome: 1980) pp. 111–12;Google Scholar
  6. M. Djilas, Rise and Fall (London: 1985) p. 135.Google Scholar
  7. 26.
    I.V. Stalin, Sochineniia (Works), XVI (3) (Stanford: 1967) pp. 76–9.Google Scholar
  8. Cf. S. Pons, ‘L’Unione Sovietica nella politica estera di Togliatti’, Studi Storici, 33 (1992) 435–56.Google Scholar
  9. 27.
    Cf. M.M. Narinskii, ‘Sovetskaia vneshniaia politika i proiskhozhdenie kholodnoi voiny’, in Sovetskaia Vneshniaia Politika v Retrospektive (Moscow: 1993) p. 122.Google Scholar
  10. Cf. A. Ulam’s assessment, Titoism and the Cominform (Cambridge, Mass.: 1952) p. 85.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. 30.
    Cf. L.Ia. Gibianskii, ‘Kak voznik Kominform. Po novym arkhivnym materialam’, Novaia i noveishaia istoriia, 4 (1993) 143.Google Scholar
  12. 36.
    Cf. M.P. Leffiler, A Preponderance of Power: National Security, the Truman Administration and the Cold War (Stanford: 1992) pp. 159–64.Google Scholar
  13. 39.
    See R. Martinelli, M.L. Righi (eds), La politica del partito comunista italiano nel periodo costituente. I verbali della direzione tra il V e il VI Congresso, 1946–1948, Fondazione Istituto Gramsci, Annali, II (Rome: 1992) pp. 498, 500.Google Scholar
  14. 40.
    Cf.: S. Galante, L’autonomia possibile. Il PCI del dopoguerra tra politica estera e politica interna (Florence: 1991) pp. 107, 130–1;Google Scholar
  15. A. Agosti, ‘Longo e il Cominform’, in Luigi Longo. La politica e Vazione (Rome: 1992) pp. 69–87.Google Scholar
  16. 46.
    Cf. A. Agosti, ‘Il partito comunista italiano e la svolta del 1947’, Studi Storici, 31 (1990) 72 ff.Google Scholar
  17. 64.
    For the conversation between Malenkov and Nenni at the end of November 1947, see P. Nenni, Tempo di guerra fredda. Diari 1943–1956 (Milan: 1981) p. 400.Google Scholar
  18. 82.
    Cf. N.V. Novikov, Vospominaniia diplomata. Zapiski 1938–1947 (Moscow: 1989) pp. 352–3.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Palgrave Macmillan, a division of Macmillan Publishers Limited 1996

Authors and Affiliations

  • Silvio Pons

There are no affiliations available

Personalised recommendations