Abstract
Hardy’s poetry, on the whole, has not had a very satisfactory critical press, which may immediately tell us something about the difficulty of determining the nature of the achievement in his enormous poetic oeuvre. At the outset, when Hardy first turned again to poetry after completing his career as a novelist (v. Intro., pp. xxxi–xxxiv), the reviewers resented his decision to take up another genre and were often fiercely critical of his work in it. The Saturday Review, on the publication of WP, infamously commented on ‘this curious and wearisome volume, these many slovenly, slipshod, uncouth verses, stilted in sentiment, poorly conceived and worse wrought’;1 rejected some of the ballads there as ‘the most amazing balderdash that ever found its way into a book of verse’ (42); and wondered why ‘the bulk of the volume was published at all — why he did not himself burn the verse’ (41). E.K. Chambers, also on WP, noted that Hardy’s ‘success in poetry is of a very narrow range’; and, in a view which has become a primary feature of Hardy’s critical reception and evaluation as a poet, limited his ‘success’ to a ‘small cluster of really remarkable poems’.2 On PPP, The Academy judged in 1901: ‘there is more of sheer poetry in his novels’; and The Athenaeum that Hardy ‘is wholly mistaking his vocation’ in switching from fiction to verse.3 Conversely, in the last quarter of this century, now that ‘the essential qualities of his genius’,4 so it seems, can be taken for granted and we know that his ‘voice’ is ‘capable of greatness’,5 Hardy’s poetry is the subject of long, painstaking critical monographs full of exegesis, appreciation and interpretation — which nevertheless still leave me, at least, unsure that I am any closer to an understanding of ‘the essential qualities of his genius’, of what constitutes his ‘unique poetic voice’.6
Preview
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
Notes
Unsigned review, The Saturday Review, 7 Jan. 1899, LXXXVII, 19, in Gibson and Johnson, eds, TH: Poems (1979), 1993, p. 41.
Review in The Athenaeum, 14 Jan. 1899, in Gibson and Johnson, eds, op. cit., pp. 45, 44.
Hynes (1984), ‘Introduction’, p. xxvi, and Hynes (1994), p. xviii.
Blackmur, ‘The Shorter Poems ot TH’ (1940), 1952
Brown, TH, Longman, 1954
Stewart, TH: A Critical Biography, Longman, 1971
quoted in Taylor, Hardy’s Poetry… (1981), 1989, p. xxiii
Macmillan Papermac edtn, 1992, ‘Preface’, pp. ix, v–vi.
In Charles P.C. Pettit, ed, New Perspectives on TH, 1994, pp. 58, 62–3, my emphasis.
This essay is a reworking of ch. 7 of Johnson’s earlier A Critical Introduction …, 1991.
Weidenfeld and Nicolson, 1981, ‘Introduction’, pp. 16, 10, 16.
Aurum Press, 1990, ‘Introduction’, p. 11.
Macmillan Papermac edtn, 1992, p. 17.
The others were: G.M. Young, Selected Poems of TH (1940)
W.E. Williams, TH: The Penguin Poets (1960)
P.N. Furbank, Selected Poems of TH (1964)
G. Grigson, A Choice of H’s Poetry (1969)
and Johnson’s own Poems by TH for the Folio Society (1979).
Johnson, A Critical Introduction …, 1979, p. 170
For fuller discussion of Georgianism, cf., e.g., James Reeves, ed, Georgian Poetry, The Penguin Poets, 1962, ‘Introduction’ (where Reeves remarks: ‘Undoubtedly Hardy was another father-figure to the Georgians’, p. xvi)
V. de Sola Pinto, Crisis in English Poetry, 1880–1940 (1951), Grey Arrow, 1963, ch. 5
C.K. Stead, The New Poetic (1964), Penguin, 1967, chs. 2, 3
Robert H. Ross, The Georgian Revolt, 1967
E.P. Thompson, ‘Outside the Whale’, in Thompson et al., eds, Out of Apathy, New Left Books, 1960, p. 153.
Johnson, e.g., in A Critical Introduction …, 1991, p. 181, while noting ‘a certain ambiguity about the subject of the poem’, states: ‘it is not quite clear whether Hardy is addressing Love or the woman he once loved’.
T. Paulin, The Poetry of Perception, 1975
Johnson, A Critical Introduction…, 1991
Editor information
Copyright information
© 1997 Macmillan Publishers Limited
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Widdowson, P. (1997). Recasting Hardy the Poet: A Critical Commentary. In: Widdowson, P. (eds) Thomas Hardy. Palgrave, London. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-349-25082-0_4
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-349-25082-0_4
Publisher Name: Palgrave, London
Print ISBN: 978-0-333-66534-3
Online ISBN: 978-1-349-25082-0
eBook Packages: Palgrave Literature & Performing Arts CollectionLiterature, Cultural and Media Studies (R0)