Some Philosophical Questions about Telepathy and Clairvoyance

Abstract

The founder of Psychical Research, though he has not yet received the honour due to him, seems to have been King Croesus of Lydia, who reigned from 560 to 546 B.C. He carried out an interesting experiment, recorded in detail by Herodotus,¹ to test the clairvoyant powers of a number of oracles. He sent embassies to seven oracles, six Greek and one Egyptian. They all started on the same day. On the hundredth day each embassy was instructed to ask its oracle, ‘What is King Croesus, the son of Alyattes, now doing?’ The answer was to be written down and brought back. The oracle of Delphi replied as follows, in hexameters, as its custom was: ‘I know the number of the sands and the measures of the sea. I understand the dumb, and I hear him who does not speak.’ Then it went on: ‘There comes to my mind the smell of a strong-shelled tortoise, which is being cooked along with lamb’s flesh in a brazen vessel; brass is spread beneath it, and with brass it is covered.’ As a matter of fact, this answer was perfectly correct. Herodotus tells us that ‘having considered what would be the most difficult thing to discover and to imagine’, Croesus ‘cut up a tortoise and a lamb, and himself boiled them together in a brazen pot’. What happened afterwards illustrates the difficulties of this sort of investigation, difficulties which still perplex us to this day.

A paper read to the Jowett Society on 15 May 1940, reprinted in Philosophy, 15 (60) (October 1940), pp. 363–85.