Comparable Worth for Public Employees: Implementing a New Wage Policy in Minnesota

  • Sara M. Evans
  • Barbara J. Nelson

Abstract

Minnesota is a state with a long history of social and economic policy innovation concerning women’s issues. In the governmental sphere Minnesota was among the first states to adopt Mothers’ Aid and, in the last decade, Minnesota led the nation in no-fault divorce reform and programmes for sexually abused children (Jacob, 1988). In the non-governmental sphere, women of the labour movement and the political left in Minneapolis were among the few who protested about the inadequacy of Aid to Dependent Children payments that were lower than work relief payments during the Depression (Faue, 1988). More recently, St Paul was the site of the first battered women’s shelter in the USA (Gelb, 1983).

Keywords

Depression Assure Expense Arena Boulder 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Council on the Economic Status of Women (1982) Pay Equity and Public Employment (St. Paul, MN).Google Scholar
  2. Eckstein, H. (1975) ‘Case Study and Theory in Political Science’, in F. I. Greenstein and N. W. Polsby (eds) Handbook of Political Science (Reading, Mass.: Addison-Wesley) pp. 79–138.Google Scholar
  3. Evans, S. and Nelson, B. (1988) ‘Mandating local change in Minnesota: State-required implementation of comparable worth by local jurisdictions’, in Ronnie Steinberg (ed.) Comparable Worth: A View From the States (Philadelphia, Pa: Temple University Press).Google Scholar
  4. Eyestone, R. (1977) ‘Confusion, Diffusion, and Innovation’, American Political Science Review, no 71, pp. 441–7.Google Scholar
  5. Faue, E. (1990) ‘Women, Family and Politics: Farm-Labor Women and Social Policy in the Great Depression’ in Patricia Gurin and Louise Tilly (eds) Women in Politics and Change (New York: Russell Sage Foundation).Google Scholar
  6. Freeman, J. (1975) The Politics of Women’s Liberation (New York: McKay).Google Scholar
  7. Gelb, J. (1983) ‘The Politics of Wife Abuse’, in Irene Diamond (ed.) Families, Politics and Public Policy (New York: Longman) pp. 250–62.Google Scholar
  8. George, A. L. (1979) ‘Case Studies and Theory Development: The Method of Structured, Focused Comparison’, in Paul Gorden Lauren (ed.) Diplomacy: New Approaches in History, Theory, and Policy (New York: Free Press) pp. 43–68.Google Scholar
  9. Gieske, M. L. (1984) ‘Minnesota in Midpassage: A Century of Transition in Political Culture’, in M. L. Gieske (ed.) Perspectives on Minnesota Government and Politics (Minneapolis, Minn.: Burgess Publishing Company) pp. 1–34.Google Scholar
  10. Gray, V. (1973), ‘Innovation in the States: A Diffusion Study’, American Political Science Review, no 67, pp. 1174–85.Google Scholar
  11. Jacob, H. (1990) ‘Women and Divorce Reform’, in Pat Gurin and Louise Tilly (eds) Women, Politics and Change (New York: Russell Sage Foundation).Google Scholar
  12. Johansen, E. (1984) Comparable Worth: The Myth and the Movement. (Boulder, Colo.: Westview Press).Google Scholar
  13. Mazmanian, D. A. and Sabatier, P. (1983) Implementation and Public Policy (Glenview, III.: Scott, Foresman).Google Scholar
  14. Minneapolis Star (1974) ‘state-job Sex Bias Suspected’, 15 October, 7C.Google Scholar
  15. Minneapolis Star (1977) ‘study Says State’s Job Policy Full of Sex Bias’, 23 March, 9A.Google Scholar
  16. Minneapolis Star and Tribune (1982) ‘Group says ‘Female’ Jobs Pay Less than ‘Male’Jobs’, 22 January, 1A.Google Scholar
  17. Minneapolis Star and Tribune (1982) ‘Quie Vetoes Bill Establishing Job Creation Conference’, 24 March, 6B.Google Scholar
  18. Minneapolis Star and Tribune (1983) ‘squabble in the Sisterhood’, 20 March, 2C.Google Scholar
  19. Minneapolis Star and Tribune (1983) ‘County Pays Women Less, Study Indicates’, 8 June, 12B.Google Scholar
  20. Minneapolis Star and Tribune (1983) ‘state Closing Gender Gap on Salaries’, 26 July, 1A.Google Scholar
  21. Minneapolis Star and Tribune (1983) ‘Legislation Requested to Equalize Public Wages’, 23 September, 17A.Google Scholar
  22. Minneapolis Star and Tribune (1984) ‘Civil Rights Panel to Study Major Program Changes’, 6 January, 3A.Google Scholar
  23. Minneapolis Star and Tribune (1984) ‘school Clerical Workers Fight Equal Pay Issue’, 22 February, 4B.Google Scholar
  24. Minneapolis Star and Tribune (1984) ‘Minnesota’s Comparable Worth Plan was the First in Nation, and ‘It Works’, 29 April, 1B.Google Scholar
  25. Minneapolis Star and Tribune (1984) ‘Comparable Worth Raises [rises] Concerns’, 31 July, 1B.Google Scholar
  26. Minneapolis Star and Tribune (1984) ‘Perpich Loses Spot on Group’s Board’, 1 August, 13A.Google Scholar
  27. Minneapolis Star and Tribune (1984) ‘Disagreement over Methods Stalls City’s Pay Equity Project’, 16 August, 20A.Google Scholar
  28. Minneapolis Star and Tribune (1984) ‘A Hennepin County Comparable-Worth Study’, 24 August, 8B.Google Scholar
  29. Minneapolis Star and Tribune (1984) “Comparable Worth” a Loony Idea, Says Rights Panel Chief, 17 November, 1A.Google Scholar
  30. Minneapolis Star and Tribune (1985) ‘Local Governments Tackle Issue of Comparable Worth’, 14 March, 1Y.Google Scholar
  31. Minneapolis Star and Tribune (1985) ‘Comparable-Worth Bill Passes’, 10 May, 20B.Google Scholar
  32. Minneapolis Star and Tribune (1985) ‘Durenberger Set To Introduce Comparable Worth Legislation’, 15 May, 10A.Google Scholar
  33. Minneapolis Star and Tribune (1985) ‘state’s Comparable Worth Law a Model’, 6 September, 1A.Google Scholar
  34. Minneapolis Star and Tribune (1986) ‘school District Approves Comparable Play Plan’, 30 April, 6B.Google Scholar
  35. Minneapolis Star and Tribune (1986) ‘County Study Finds Inequities in Women’s Pay’, 14 November, 7B.Google Scholar
  36. Minneapolis Tribune (1976) ‘state Panel on Women’s Pay is Backed’, 11 February, 6B.Google Scholar
  37. Minneapolis Tribune (1976) ‘study: Women Suffer Job Bias’, 8 November, 1B.Google Scholar
  38. Minneapolis Tribune (1977) ‘Economic Status of Women Profiled’, 17 April, 17E.Google Scholar
  39. Minneapolis Tribune (1979) ‘Women’s Council Strives to Continue Record of Success’, 5 February, 2B.Google Scholar
  40. Minneapolis Tribune (1979) ‘Women in Minnesota Still Lag in Pay’, 11 June, 10A.Google Scholar
  41. Minneapolis Tribune (1980) ‘Union, Feminist Leaders See Bias in Pay Differences’, 26 August, 1A.Google Scholar
  42. Minneapolis Tribune (1981), ‘230 Secretaries Strike in Area School District for Custodian Salaries’, 1 July, 6A.Google Scholar
  43. Minneapolis Tribune (1981) ‘some on Women’s Economic Council Object to Social Issues’, 19 November, 8D.Google Scholar
  44. Minnesota Department of Employee Relations (1986) Pay Equity in Minnesota Local Governments (St Paul, Minn. MDOER).Google Scholar
  45. Nelson, B. J. (1985a) ‘Comparable Worth: A Brief Review of History, Practice, and Theory’, Minnesota Law Review, no 69, pp. 1199–216.Google Scholar
  46. Nelson, B. J. (1985b) ‘Popular Misperceptions of Comparable Worth Policies and Their Political Consequences’, presented at the Western Political Science Association meetings, March.Google Scholar
  47. Nelson, B. J. (1984) Making an Issue of Child Abuse: Political Agenda Setting for Social Problems (Chicago: University of Chicago Press).Google Scholar
  48. Pressman, Jeffrey L. and Wildavsky, Aaron (1979), Implementation (Berkeley, Cal.: University of California Press) 2nd edn.Google Scholar
  49. St Paul Pioneer Press and Dispatch (1986) ‘Council OKs Comparable Worth Pact’, 17 October, 4C.Google Scholar
  50. Scott, Rick (1985) ‘Comments at the Conference, New Directions in Comparable Worth: Minnesota and the Nation’, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis.Google Scholar
  51. Shrewsbury, C. M. (1984) ‘Women in Minnesota Politics: A Preliminary Sketch’, in M. L. Gieske (ed.) Perspectives on Minnesota Government and the Politics (Minneapolis, Minn.: Burgess) pp. 44–52.Google Scholar
  52. Verba, S. (1967) ‘some Dilemmas in Comparative Research’, World Politics no 20, pp. 111–27.Google Scholar
  53. Walker, J. (1969) ‘The Diffusion of Innovations among the American States’, American Political Science Review, no 63, pp. 880–900.Google Scholar
  54. AFSCME v. State of Washington, 452 US, 161, 1981.Google Scholar
  55. Watkins, Bonnie (1986) Phone interview, 25 September.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Palgrave Macmillan, a division of Macmillan Publishers Limited 1992

Authors and Affiliations

  • Sara M. Evans
  • Barbara J. Nelson

There are no affiliations available

Personalised recommendations