Advertisement

Capitalism, Socialism, and Justice: Reflections on Rawls’ Theory of Justice

  • Kai Nielsen

Abstract

Some key features of a Marxist critique of Rawls’ theory of justice are articulated and probed. Without challenging Rawls’ fundamental ideals of equal liberty and an equality of self-respect, it is argued that only in a socialist society could such ideals be reasonably approximated. Rawls’ own assumptions of what constitute realistic social expectations are in conflict with his own principles of justice. If society must be as Rawls pictures it, then his principles of justice can have not even approximate application.

Keywords

Income Inequality Social Theory Public Affair Capitalist Society Capitalist System 
These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Ackerman, Frank et al. (1972) ‘The extent of income inequality in the United States’, in The Capitalist System, Richard C. Edwards et al. (eds), pp. 207–18 (Englewood Cliffs, N.J.: Prentice-Hall).Google Scholar
  2. Althusser, Louis (1972) Politics and History, trans. B. Brewster (London: New Left Books).Google Scholar
  3. Arneson, John (1979) ‘Mill’s doubts about freedom under socialism’, Cartadian Journal of Philosophy, supplementary vol. 5: 231–49.Google Scholar
  4. Berberoglu, Berech (1976–1977) ‘The essence of inequality: A critical analysis of classical and contemporary theories of stratification and inequality’, Social Praxis 4: 1–2.Google Scholar
  5. Braverman, Harry (1974) Labor and Monopoly Capital: The Degradation of Work in the Twentieth Century (New York: Monthly Review Press).Google Scholar
  6. Chomsky, Noam (1977) ‘Trilateral’s RX for crisis’, Seven Days, 14 February.Google Scholar
  7. Crick, Bernard (1972) ‘Review of A Theory of Justice’, New Statesman, 5 May, 601–2.Google Scholar
  8. Dahrendorf, Rals (1968) Essays in the Theory of Society (Stanford: Stanford University Press).Google Scholar
  9. Duncan Graeme (1973) Marx and Mill (London: Cambridge University Press).Google Scholar
  10. Duncan Graeme and Gray, John (1979) ‘The Left against Mill’, Canadian Journal of Philosophy, supplementary vol. 5: 203–29.Google Scholar
  11. Dworkin, Ronald (1975) ‘The original position’, University of Chicago Law Review 40 (3).Google Scholar
  12. Edwards, Richard C. et al. (eds) (1972) The Capitalist System (Englewood Cliffs, N.J.: Prentice Hall, 1978; 2nd edn).Google Scholar
  13. Engels, Frederick (1966) Anti Dühring (New York: International Publishers).Google Scholar
  14. Flew, Antony (1976) ‘A theory of social justice’, in Contemporary British Philosophy, 4th series, H. D. Lewis (ed.), pp. 69–85 (London: George Allen and Unwin).Google Scholar
  15. —— (1978) ‘Equality or justice’, Midwest Studies in Philosophy 3: 176–94.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Friedman, Milton (1962) Capitalism and Freedom (New York).Google Scholar
  17. Hayek, Friedrich A. (1960) The Constitution of Liberty (Chicago: University of Chicago Press).Google Scholar
  18. Huntington, Samuel et al. (1975) The Governability of Democracies (New York).Google Scholar
  19. Kristol, Irving (1972) ‘About equality’, Commentary, November, 41–7.Google Scholar
  20. Levine, Andrew (1976) The Politics of Autonomy (Amherst: University of Massachusetts Press).Google Scholar
  21. Lichtman, Richard (1970) ‘The facade of equality in liberal democratic theory’, Socialist Revolution 1 (1): 85–126.Google Scholar
  22. Macpherson, C. B. (1978) See bibliography I.Google Scholar
  23. Marx, Karl (1938) Critique of the Gotha ProgrammeGoogle Scholar
  24. Neilsen, Kai (1978d) See bibliography I.Google Scholar
  25. Rawls, John (1971) A Theory of Justice (Cambridge, Mass: Harvard University Press)Google Scholar
  26. Sklar, Martin J. (1977) ‘Liberty and equality and socialism’, Socialist Revolution 7 (4).Google Scholar
  27. Stojanovic, Svetozar (1973) Between Ideals and Reality (New York: Oxford University Press).Google Scholar
  28. Taylor, Charles (1978) ‘Politics of the steady state’, New Universities Quarterly 32 (2): 157–84.Google Scholar
  29. Weisskopf, Thomas E. (1972) ‘Capitalism and inequality’, in The Capitalist System, Richard C. Edwards et al. (eds), pp. 125–33 (Englewood Cliffs, N.J.: Prentice-Hall).Google Scholar
  30. —— Work in America (1963) (Cambridge, Mass: MIT Press).Google Scholar

Bibliography: Radical Critiques Of Rawls: I Critics on the Left (Marxist, quasi-Marxist and semi-Marxist)*

  1. Carmichael, D. J. C. (n.d.) ‘The limits of individualism’. Unpublished ms.Google Scholar
  2. Clark, Barry (with Herbert Gintis) (1978) ‘Rawlsian justice and economic systems’, Philosophy and Public Affairs (4): 302–25.Google Scholar
  3. Crocker, David A. (1978) ‘Introduction’, The Occasional Review 8/9, 1–20.Google Scholar
  4. Crocker Lawrence (1977). Equality, solidarity and Rawls’s maximin. Philosophy and Public Affairs 6, 262–6.Google Scholar
  5. Daniels, Norman (1975a) ‘Equal liberty and unequal worth of liberty’, in Norman Daniels (ed.), Reading Rawls, pp. 253–81 (New York: Basic Books).Google Scholar
  6. —— (1975b) ‘Introduction’, Norman Daniels (ed.), Reading Rawls (New York: Basic Books Inc., 1975), pp. xi–xxxivGoogle Scholar
  7. —— (1978) ‘Merit and Meritocracy’, Philosophy and Public Affairs 7 (3): 206–23.Google Scholar
  8. —— (1979a) ‘Moral Theory and the plasticity of persons’ Monist 62 (3).Google Scholar
  9. —— (1979b) ‘Reflective Equilibrium and theory acceptance in ethics’, Journal of Philosophy 76 (5).Google Scholar
  10. —— (1980a) ‘Reflective equilibrium and Archimedean points’ Canadian Journal of Philosophy 10 (1): 83–104Google Scholar
  11. —— (1980b) ‘Some methods of ethics and linguistics’ Philosophical Studies 37, (1975): 21–36CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Doppelt, Gerald (1975) ‘Rawls a critique from the Left’ American Philosophical Association Meetings, Eastern Division (December).Google Scholar
  13. —— (forthcoming) The Scarcity of Self-Respect under Capitalism: A Critique of Rawlsian Justice from the Left.Google Scholar
  14. Esheté, Andreas (1974) ‘Contractarianism and the scope of justice’ Ethics 85 (1): 38–49.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Fisk, Milton (1975) ‘History and reason in Rawls’s moral theory’; in Reading Rawls, Norman Daniels (ed.), pp. 53–80 (New York: Basic Books).Google Scholar
  16. Gilbert, Alan (1978) ‘Equality and social theory in Rawls’s theory of justice’ The Occasional Review 8/9: 95–117.Google Scholar
  17. Gintis, Herbert (with Barry Clark) (1978) ‘Rawlsian justice and economic systems’ Philosophy and Public Affairs 7 (4): 302–25.Google Scholar
  18. Hedman, Carl (1980) ‘Rousseau on self-interest, compassion and moral progress’, in Jim MacAdam et al. (eds), Trent-Pousseau Papers (Ottawa: University of Ottawa Press).Google Scholar
  19. Levine, Andrew (1974) ‘Rawls’s Kantianism’, Social Theory and Practice 3 (1): 47–63.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. MacBride, William L. (1972) ‘Social theory sub specie aeternitatis: A new perspective’, Yale Law Journal 81 (5): 980–1003.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. —— (1973) ‘The concept of justice in Marx Engels and others’, Ethics 85 (3): 204–18.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. McDonald, Virginia (1977) ‘Rawlsian contractarianism: Liberal equality or inequality’, in Kai Nielsen and Roger Shiner (eds), New Essays on Contract Theory (Guelph, Ont.: Canadian Association for Publishing in Philosophy).Google Scholar
  23. Macpherson, C. B. (1973a) Democratic Theory, pp. 77–94 (Oxford: Clarendon Press).Google Scholar
  24. —— (1973b) ‘Rawls’s models of man and society’, Philosophy of the Social Sciences 3 (4): 341–7. —— (1978) ‘Class, classlessness and the critique of Rawls’, Political Theory 6 (2): 209–11.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Miller, Richard (1975) ‘Rawls and Marxism’, in Norman Daniels (ed.), Reading Rawls, pp. 206–29 (New York: Basic Books).Google Scholar
  26. Moore, Stanley (n.d.) ‘Rawls and the tradition: A socialist critique’. Unpublished ms.Google Scholar
  27. Nielsen, Kai (1972) ‘A note on rationality’, Journal of Critical Analysis 4: 16–19.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. —— (1973) ‘A critical notice of John Rawls’s A Theory of Justice’, Second Order 2 (2): 101–21.Google Scholar
  29. —— (1974) ‘For impurity in philosophy: Some programmatic dicta’. University of Toronto Quarterly 43 (2): 121–31.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. —— (1976) ‘On philosophic method’, International Philosophical Quarterly 16 (3): 349–68.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. —— (1977a) ‘The choice between perfectionism and Rawlsian contractarianism’, Interpretation 6: 132–9.Google Scholar
  32. —— (1977b) ‘Our considered judgements’, Ratio 19 (1): 39–46.Google Scholar
  33. —— (1977c) ‘The priority of liberty examined’, Indian Political Science Review 2: 48–59.Google Scholar
  34. —— (1977d) ‘Rawls and classist amoralism’, Mind 86: 341.Google Scholar
  35. —— (1977e) ‘Rawls’s defense of morality’, Personalist 59 (1): 93–100.Google Scholar
  36. —— (1978a) ‘Equality, justice and class’, Dialectica 32 (2): 126–33.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. —— (1978b) ‘Morality, marxism and the ideological functions of morality: A theory of justice as a test case’, The Occasional Review 8/9: 165–82.Google Scholar
  38. —— (1978c) ‘On moral expertise’, Midwestern Journal of Philosophy (Spring).Google Scholar
  39. —— (1978d) ‘On the very possibility of a classless society’, Political Theory 6 (2): 191–208.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. —— (1978e). ‘Rationality and the moral sentiments’, Philosophica 22 (2): 167–91.Google Scholar
  41. —— (1978f) ‘Class and justice’, in John Arthur and william H. Shaw (eds), Justice and Economic Distribution (Englewood Cliffs, N.J.: Prentice-Hall), pp. 225–45Google Scholar
  42. —— (1979a) ‘Radical egalitarian justice’, Social Theory and Practice 5 (2).Google Scholar
  43. —— (1979b) ‘Reason and sentiment’, in Theodore F. Geraets (ed.), Rationality To-Day (Ottawa: University of Ottawa Press), pp. 249–79.Google Scholar
  44. —— (1979c) ‘The role of radical philosophers in Canada’, Socialist Studies 1 (1): 1–14.Google Scholar
  45. —— (1980a) ‘Ideological mystification and Archimedean points’, Revue Internationale de philosophic 10.Google Scholar
  46. —— (1980b) ‘Morality and ideology: Some radical critiques of Rawls’, Graduate Faculty Philosophy Journal.Google Scholar
  47. —— (1980c) ‘Rawls and the Left: Some Left critiques of Rawls’ Principles of Justice’, Analyse & Kritik 1 (2): 74–97.Google Scholar
  48. Rapaport, Elizabeth (1977) ‘Classical liberalism and Rawlsian revisionism’, in Kai Nielsen and Roger Shiner (eds), New Essays on Contract Theory (Guelph Ont.: Canadian Association for Publishing in Philosophy).Google Scholar
  49. Schweickart, David (1975) ‘Should Rawls be a socialist?’, Social Theory and Practice 5 (1): 1–28CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. Shih, Yuan-Kang (1980) ‘The limits of contractarianism: Rawls’s moral methodology and ideological framework’, unpublished doctoral dissertation. University of Ottawa.Google Scholar
  51. Skillen, Anthony (1977) Ruling Illusions: Philosophy and the Social Order (Hassocks, Sussex: Harvester Press).Google Scholar
  52. Teitelman, Michael (1972) ‘The limits of individualism’, Journal of Philosophy 69: 545–56.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. —— (1978) ‘On the theory of the practice of the theory of justice’, Journal of Chinese Philosophy 5: 217–47.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  54. Wolff, Robert Paul (1977) Understanding Rawls (Princeton: Princeton University Press).Google Scholar

II Other Articles with a Left Bearing**

  1. Ake, Christopher (1975) ‘Justice as equality’, Philosophy and Public Affairs 5 (1): 69–89.Google Scholar
  2. Altham, J. E. J. (1973) ‘Rawls’s difference principle’, Philosophy 48: 75–8.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. —— (1975) ‘ Rawls and power’, Cambridge Review 96 (2225): 106–8.Google Scholar
  4. Amdur, R. (1977) ‘Rawls’s theory of justice — Domestic and international perspectives’, World Politics 29: 438–61.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Barber, Benjamin (1975) ‘Justifying justice’, in Norman Daniels (ed.), Reading Rawls, pp. 292–318 (New York: Basic Books).Google Scholar
  6. Barry, Brian (1973) ‘The Liberal Theory of Justice’ (Oxford: Clarendon Press).Google Scholar
  7. —— (1978) ‘Critical notice of Wolff: Understanding Rawls. Canadian Journal of Philosophy 8 (4): 753–83.Google Scholar
  8. Bedau, Hugo Adam (1978) ‘Social justice and social institutions’. Midwest Studies in Philosophy, 3: 159–75.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Cooper, Wesley (1977) ‘The perfectly just society’, Philosophy and phenomenological Research: 46–55.Google Scholar
  10. Copp, David (1974) ‘Justice and the difference principle’, Canadian Journal of Philosophy 4 (2).Google Scholar
  11. Dworkin, Gerald (1975) ‘Non-neutral principles’, in Norman Daniels (ed.), Reading Rawls, pp. 124–40 (New York: Basic Books).Google Scholar
  12. English, Jane (n.d.) ‘Ethics and science’, Proceedings of the XVIth World Congress of Philosophy.Google Scholar
  13. Fishkin, James (1975) ‘Justice and rationality’, American Political Science Review 69 (2): 615–29.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Gauthier, David (1974) ‘Justice and natural endowment: Toward a critique of Rawls’s ideological framework’, Social Theory and Practice 3 (1): 3–26.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. —— (1977) ‘The social contract as ideology’, Philosophy and Public Affairs 6 (2): 130–64.Google Scholar
  16. Gibson, Mary (1975) ‘Behind the veil of ignorance: A dim view’, unpublished doctoral dissertation, Princeton University.Google Scholar
  17. —— (1977) ‘Rationality’, Philosophy and Public Affairs 6 (3): 193–225.Google Scholar
  18. Goodin, Robert (1976) ‘Possessive individualism again’, Political Studies 24: 488–501.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Gray, John (1978) ‘On liberty, liberalism and essential contestability’. British Journal of Political Science 8 (4): 385–402.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Hampshire, Stuart (1972) ‘What is the just society’, New York Review of Books 18 (3) (February 24 ) 34–9.Google Scholar
  21. Harsanyi, John C. (1978) ‘Sneed on Rawls’s theory of social institutions’, Erkenntnis 13 (2): 225–30.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Hart, H. L. A. (1975) ‘Rawls on liberty and its priority’, in Norman Daniels (ed.), Reading Rawls, pp. 230–52 (New York: Basic Books).Google Scholar
  23. Honderich, Ted (1975) ‘The use of the basic proposition of a Theory of Justice’, Mind 84 (333): 63–78.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. La France, Guy (1978) ‘Les deux principes de la justice selon Rawls’. Dialectica 32 (C).Google Scholar
  25. —— (1979) ‘Une contrepartie à Marx: la théorie de la justice de Rawls’, Dialogue 18 (1): 14–25.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  26. Lessenoff, Michael (1974) ‘Barry on Rawls’s priority of liberty’, Philosophy and Public Affairs 4 (1): 101–14.Google Scholar
  27. Lukes, Steven (1977) ‘Essays in Social Theory’ pp. 154–76, 187–91 (London: Macmillan).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Meyer, Michel (1977) ‘Justice distributive et égalité, la pensée de John Rawls et son paradoxe fondamental’, L’Égalité 5, 260–76.Google Scholar
  29. —— (1979) ‘Un manuel de la raison pratique’, Le Monde (June 22).Google Scholar
  30. Miller, David (1977) ‘Democracy and social justice’, British Journal of Political Science 8: 1–19CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. —— (1976) ‘Social Justice (Oxford: Clarendon Press).Google Scholar
  32. —— (with Russell Keat) (1974) ‘Understanding justice’, Political Theory (1): 3–31.Google Scholar
  33. Nagel, Thomas (1975) ‘Rawls on justice’, in Norman Daniels (ed.), Reading Rawls, pp. 1–16 (New York: Basic Books).Google Scholar
  34. —— (1979) Moral Questions, pp. 106–27 (London: Cambridge University Press).Google Scholar
  35. Philips, Derek (1977) ‘The equality debate: What does justice require?’, Theory and Society 4: 247–72.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. —— (1979) Equality, Justice and Rectification: An Exploration in Normative Sociology (New York: Academic Press).Google Scholar
  37. Schwartz, Adiina (1973) ‘Moral neutrality and primary goods’, Ethics 83: 294–307.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. —— (1977) ‘A review of reading Rawls’, Philosophical Review 86: 238–41.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. Shue, Henry (1974) ‘The current fashions: Trickle-downs by Arrow and close-knits by Rawls’, Journal of Philosophy 71: 319–26.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. —— (1974–1975) ‘Liberty and self-respect’, Ethics 85: 195–203.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. —— (1975–1976) ‘Jutice, Rationality and desire’, Southern Journal of Philosophy 13.Google Scholar
  42. Simpson, Evan (1976) ‘Socialist justice’, Ethics 87: 1–17.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Snare, Frank (1975) ‘John Rawls and the methods of ethics’, Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 36: 100–12.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  44. —— (1977) ‘Dissolving the moral contract’, Philosophy (201): 301–12.Google Scholar
  45. Sneed, Joseph D. (1976) ‘John Rawls and the liberal theory of society’. Erkenntnis 10: 1–19.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. —— (1979) ‘Political institutions as means to economic justice: A Critique of Rawls’ Contractarianism’, Analyse & Kritik 1: 125–46.Google Scholar
  47. Taylor, Charles (1977) ‘On social justice’, Canadian Journal of Political and Social Theory 1.Google Scholar
  48. Williams, Bernard (1976) ‘The moral view of politics’ The Listener (June 3).Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Palgrave Macmillan, a division of Macmillan Publishers Limited 1991

Authors and Affiliations

  • Kai Nielsen

There are no affiliations available

Personalised recommendations