Abstract
Trade, it has been argued, is an ‘economic equivalent to war’. The French eighteenth-century philosopher Benjamin Constant once remarked that ‘war and commerce are but two different means of arriving at the same aim which is to possess what is desired. Trade is nothing but a homage paid to the strength of the possessor by him who aspires to the possession; it is an attempt to obtain by mutual agreement that which one does not hope any longer to obtain by violence. The idea of commerce would never occur to a man who would always be the strongest.’1 East-West economic relations have indeed at times come close to an ‘equivalent of war’.
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Preview
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
Notes
Hirschman, National Power (1980) note 1, pp. 14,15.
Strausz-Hupd and Possony, ‘Economics as a Weapon’, in Robert L. Pfaltzgraff, Jr. (ed.), Politics and the International System (1969) p. 265.
Kennan, Memoirs: 1925–1950 (1967) pp. 539, 540.
Baldwin, Economic Statecraft (1985) p. 36.
Committee on Foreign Relations, United States Senate, The Premises of East-West Commercial Relations (1983) p. 150.
Baldwin, Economic Statecraft (1985) p. 37.
Wu, Economic Warfare (1952) p. 6.
Baldwin, Economic Statecraft (1985) pp. 37, 38.
Acheson, Present at the Creation. My Years in the State Department (1969) p. 48.
Hanson, Western Economic Statecraft in East-West Relations. Embargoes, Sanctions, Linkage, Economic Warfare, and Détente (1988) p. 53.
Deibel and Gaddis (eds), Containing the Soviet Union (1987) p. 62.
Wolf, U.S. East-West Trade Policy (1973) p. xvii.
Kennedy, Great Powers (1987)
Pipes, Survival (1984) p. 269.
Root, ‘Trade Controls that Work’, in Foreign Policy (1984) p. 76.
Wolf, U.S. East-West Trade Policy (1973) p. 7.
Allen, Soviet Economic Warfare (1960) p. 3 (emphasis added).
Smith (ed.), The Politics of East-West Trade (1984) p. 1.
Eudin and Fisher (eds), Documentary Survey (1957) p. 94 (emphasis added).
Eudin and Fisher (eds), Documentary Survey (1957) p. 48.
Northedge and Wells (eds), Britain and Soviet Communism. The Impact of a Revolution (1982) p. 218.
Clabaugh and Allen (eds), East-West Trade. Its Strategic Implications. Analysis and Inventory of Congressional Documents. 1959–1963 (1964) p. 35.
Stent, Embargo to Ostpolitik (1981) p. 99.
Clabaugh and Allen (eds), East-West Trade (1964) p. 63.
U. Ra’anan and Ch. M. Perry (eds), Strategic Minerals and International Security (1985) pp. 6, 7.
Mastanduno, ‘Strategies of Economic Containment’ (1985) p. 507.
Sokoloff, The Economy of Détente. The Soviet Union and Western Capital (1987) p. 45.
Funigiello, American-Soviet Trade (1988) p. 85.
Clabaugh and Allen (eds), East-West Trade (1964) p. 64.
Stent, Embargo to Ostpolitik (1981) p. 93.
Gift, ‘Trading in a Treath System: The US-Soviet Case’, in Journal of Conflict Resolution (1969).
Brito, ‘On Belligerent Trade’, in American Economics (1966) p. 21.
Gift, ‘Trading in a Threat System: The US-Soviet Case’ (1969) p. 437.
Chapman (ed.), Forum on U.S.-Soviet Trade Relations (1987) p. 42.
Funigiello, American-Soviet Trade (1988) p. 39.
Mastanduno, ‘Trade as a Strategic Weapon’ (1988) p. 131.
Funigiello, American-Soviet Trade (1988) p. 53.
Funigiello, American-Soviet Trade (1988) p. 83.
Goldman, Détente and Dollars. Doing Business with the Soviets (1975) P. 64.
Hardt (with Stolzenbach and Kohn), The Cold War Economic Gap. the Increasing Threat to American Supremacy (1961) p. 37.
NATO. Directorate of Economic Affairs, East-West Technological Co-operation (1976) p. 26.
Klinghoffer, The Soviet Union & International Oil Politics (1977) p. 29.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Copyright information
© 1992 Peter van Ham
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
van Ham, P. (1992). Economic Warfare: Better Safe than Sorry. In: Western Doctrines on East-West Trade. Palgrave Macmillan, London. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-349-12610-1_11
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-349-12610-1_11
Publisher Name: Palgrave Macmillan, London
Print ISBN: 978-1-349-12612-5
Online ISBN: 978-1-349-12610-1
eBook Packages: Palgrave Economics & Finance CollectionEconomics and Finance (R0)