Abstract
The separatist adventure of Franz Josef Heinz was part of a general Rhenish crisis which for years spawned vehement propaganda. French nationalists railed against the threat of German aggression and claimed the essential Frenchness of the western bank of the Rhine, while their German counterparts proclaimed that the border of Germany was in danger from immoral French influence.1 The separatists received a particularly bad press, being portrayed as a lumpenproletariat of treasonous revolver-toting bandits.2 These images were potent and they poisoned political debate in the Rhineland through the 1920s and beyond. However, behind the rhetoric separatism had real causes. These included the French search for security to the east, but also the chaotic economic and political circumstances of the Rhineland.
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Preview
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
Notes and References
E.g. M. Barrès, Les grands problèmes de Rhin (Paris, 1930)
P. Tirard, La France sur le Rhin (Paris, 1930)
J. Dorten, La Tragédie Rhénane (Paris, 1945)
H. Stegemann, Der Kampf um den Rhein: Das Stromgebiet des Rheins im Rahmen der grossen Politik und im Wandel der Kriegsgeschichte (Berlin and Leipzig, 1924)
R. Oberhauser, Kampf der Westmark: Frankreich, Separatismus und Abwehrbewegung 1918–24 (Neustadt a.d.H., 1934), and Der Kampf urn die Rheinpfalz (Leipzig, 1932); Dokumentensammlung zur Geschichte des pfälzischen Separatismus (Heidelberg, 1924), hereafter DGPS; PFB. Cf. K. Nelson, ‘The Black Horror on the Rhine’, JMH (1970), 606–27; S. Marks, ‘Black Watch on the Rhine: A Study in Propaganda, Prejudice and Prurience’, ESR (1983), 297–334.
For a vivid image see ‘A typical group of “Revolver Republican” troops’ in G. Gedye, The Revolver Republic: France’s Bid for the Rhine (London, 1930), between pp. 192 and 193.
The best account based on French documentation is McDougall, France’s Rhineland Diplomacy. Other treatments include: K. Erdmann, Adenauer in der Rheinlandpolitik nach dem Ersten Weltkrieg (Stuttgart, 1966); E. Bischof, Rheinischer Separatismus 1918–24: H.A. Dortens Rheinstaatbestrebungen (Bern, 1969); Zimmermann, Frankreichs Ruhrpolitik; K. Jones,’ stresemann, the Ruhr Crisis, and Rhenish Separatism: A Case Study of Westpolitik’, ESR (1977), 311–40; Nadler, ‘The Rhenish Separatist Movements’; K. Reimer, Rheinlandfrage und Rheinlandbewegung (1918–1933): Ein Beitrag zur Geschichte der regionalistischen Bestrebungen in Deutschland (Frankfurt a.M., 1979). At the time of writing, G. Gräber and M. Spindler, Revolver-Republik am Rhein: Die pfälzischen Separatisten von 1923/24 und ihre Feinde. Eine deutsche Geschichte had not yet appeared.
McDougall, France’s Rhineland Diplomacy, pp. 70–2; Gedye, The Revolver Republic, pp. 34–50; Nadler, ‘The Rhenish Separatist Movements’, p. 128.
Cf. McDougall, France’s Rhineland Diplomacy, pp. 89–213; Nadler, ‘The Rhenish Separatist Movements’, pp. 151–2; ‘Die “Pénétration économique” in der Pfalz’, Europäische Staats-und Wirtschaftszeitung 7/9 (1922); Erdmann, Adenauer in der Rheinlandpolitik.
These are charted in McDougall, France’s Rhineland Diplomacy.
J.-P. Bois, ‘L’Opinion Catholique Rhénane devant le Separatisme en 1923’, Revue d’Histoire Moderne et Contemporaine 21 (1974), 221–51; Ursachen und Folgen, v, Document 1116.
Cf. Nadler, ‘The Rhenish Separatist Movements’, p. 54, 326–9, 460; McDougall, France’s Rhineland Diplomacy, p. 50; Reimer, Rheinlandfrage, pp. 91 ff.; K. Nelson, Victors Divided: America and the Allies in Germany 1918–23 (Berkeley, Los Angeles, London, 1975), pp. 110–11. See most recently D. Hennig, Johannes Hoffmann: Sozialdemokrat und Bayerischer Ministerpräsident: Biographie (Munich, London, New York and Princeton, 1990) pp. 471–95.
Cf. Nadler, ‘The Rhenish Separatist Movements’, pp. 288–9, 349–53.
McDougall, France’s Rhineland Diplomacy, pp. 65–6, 71; D. Schlegel, ‘Vor 50 Jahren: Der Separatismus in der Pfalz nach dem Ersten Weltkrieg’, Mitteilungen des historischen Vereins der Pfalz 71 (1974), pp. 223–6; PFB, 9, 20 March 1919.
PFB, 22 February, 31 March, 21 April 1919.
PFB, 17 May, 21 May–2 June 1919; BAK R43I/1840, pp. 32–4: report by Gebhart, 3 June 1919; Schlegel, ‘Vor 50 Jahren: Separatismus in der Pfalz’, pp. 225–8, 236–7.
McDougall, France’s Rhineland Diplomacy, p. 86; PFB, 6 February, 10 June 1919; BAK R43I/1840, pp. 32–4: Gebhart; pp. 66–72: Centralstelle für pfälzische Angelegenheiten, n.d.
Pénétration économique’, pp. 44–9; BAK R431/1840, pp. 139–42: ‘Aus der Pfalz’, Frankfurt a.M., 10 Aug. 1921; H. Wilkens-Weyland, Kein Recht auf Autonomie (Wahlstedt, 1973), pp. 10–11; Gedye, The Revolver Republic, pp. 64–6.
W. Schineller, Die Regierungspräsidenten der Pfalz (Speyer, 1980), pp. 61–72; PFB, 1 November 1923; BAK R43I/1840, pp. 210–11: report, 23 December 1923; BHStAM MA/107 987: notes on meetings in Ministry for External Affairs with Peasants’ League and Free Peasant leaders, 1 February 1924. See Appendix 3.
BHStAM MA/107 668, 107 987–8; BAK R43I/1840.
BAK R43I/1840, pp. 150–4: report by Staehler, 15 April 1923; PFB, passim.
BHStAM MInn/71 713: Speyerer Bildersturm; PFB, 31 August — 10 September 1921.
PFB, 2 November 1923.
Hamm, Freie Bauernschaft, pp. 2–7.
PFB, 8 August, 8 September 1923.
Documents on British Foreign Policy 1919–1939 (hereafter DBFP) 1st Series, xxi (London, 1978): 384: Grahame to Curzon, 1 Oct. 1923; McDougall, France’s Rhineland Diplomacy, pp. 280–6, 299–304.
DBFP, xxi, document 410: Lieut.-Col. Ryan to Curzon, 25 October. 1923; McDougall, France’s Rhineland Diplomacy, pp. 304–8.
Hennig, Johannes Hoffmann, pp. 479 ff.
Akten der Reichskanzlei: Kabinett Stresemann, ed. Erdmann and Vogt (Boppard, 1978), ii, document 171: report of telephone call from Zapf, 24 October 1923; 179: meeting with representatives of occupied territories, Hagen, 25 October 1923, pp. 804–6; 180: Bavarian ambassador Preger, 25 October 1923; 181: report of telephone call from Zapf and Knoch, 25 October 1923; PFB, 23–6 October 1923; Ursachen und Folgen, v, documents 1124(a)–(b).
PFB, 24 October 1923.
BHStAM MA/107 987: report by Heckmann, 23 March 1920; BA Landau to Palatine government, 8 February 1921; report from Landstuhl, n.d.; BHStAM MA/107 988: BA Zweibrücken, 16 June 1922.
Revol, Le Syndicalisme paysan; O. Jung in Pfälzische Rundschau, 11 February 1931.
BHStAM MA/107 987: Peasants’ League resolution, 11 December 1921; Wappes to Lerchenfeld, 4 February 1922.
BHStAM MA/107 987: Minister of Agriculture to Reich Minister of Interior, 4 July 1923.
In H. Rössler (ed.), Die Folgen von Versailles 1919–24 (Göttingen, 1969), pp. 134–5, Ritter is quoted as saying that the late Ludwig Zimmermann had found numerous archival proofs of finance for Heinz directed through André François-Poncet.
Hamm, Freie Bauernschaft, p. 49.
Hamm, Freie Bauernschaft, p. 39.
Hamm, Freie Bauernschaft, pp. 40–1, 93; Jung in Pfälzische Rundschau, 13 February 1931.
Hamm, Freie Bauernschaft, pp. 41–6; PFB, 26 October 1923; BHStAM MInn/73 729: report of meeting.
Hamm, Freie Bauernschaft, pp. 48–9.
PFB, 5 November 1923; Ursachen und Folgen, v, documents 1124(c)–(d).
PFB, 5 November 1923 ff. See Appendix 3.
PFB, 5 November 1923.
BAK R431/1840: Braun von Stumm to Wiehl, 23 November 1923; M. Springer, Loslösungsbestrebungen am Rhein 1918–24 (Berlin, 1924), p. 125.
PFB, 15 December 1923; BAK R43I/1840, pp. 195–8: Braun von Stumm, 11 December 1923; Gedye, The Revolver Republic, p. 220; Hamm interview, 1978; Hamm, Freie Bauernschaft, pp. 70, 100.
Hamm, Freie Bauernschaft, p. 23.
BHStAM MA/107 668: Antz to Wappes, 11, 13 November 1923; BAK R43I/1840: Braun von Stumm, 23 November, 11 December 1923.
Hamm, Freie Bauernschaft, pp. 50–1; BAK R43I/1840, p. 181: Braun von Stumm to Wiehl, 23 November 1923.
McDougall, France’s Rhineland Diplomacy, p. 332; PFB, 29 November, 4 December 1923.
BAK R43I/1841, p. 285: Braun von Stumm, 15 July 1924.
LAS R12/25: decree against black marketeering, 10 December 1923; decree on special profiteering tribunals, 30 December 1923; autonomous government to BA Kirchheimbolanden, 14 November 1923; Nickles (Rhenish Republic, Kaiserslautern), 6 December 1923; Speierer Zeitung, 11 December 1923.
BAK R43I/1840, p. 193: proposal for the securing of a currency of stable value, n.d.
McDougall, France’s Rhineland Diplomacy, p. 332.
BAK R43I/1840, pp. 195–8: Braun von Stumm to Reich Chancellery, 11 December 1923; pp. 228–30: unsigned report, Munich, 4 Jan. 1924.
Hamm, Freie Bauernschaft, p. 35; Jung in Pfälzische Rundschau, 8–24 February 1931.
Hamm, Freie Bauernschaft, p. 12.
Hamm, Freie Bauernschaft, p. 52.
Hamm, Freie Bauernschaft, pp. 49–50, 56–9; Jung in Pfälzische Rundschau, 15 February 1931; FB, 15 January 1924, 11 March 1925: ‘Brief von Philipp Gass 4., Rockenhausen, an die Oeffentlichkeit’; DGPS, pp. 24, 28.
Hamm, Freie Bauernschaft, pp. 52–6; Jung in Pfälzische Rundschau, 15 February 1931.
Cf. J. King, Foch versus Clemenceau: France and German Dismemberment 1918–19 (Cambridge, Mass., 1960), pp. 38–9; Jung in Pfälzische Rundschau, 13 February 1931; PFB, 20 November 1923
O. Bischoff, K. Heinz and A. Rapp (eds.), Das Grosse Pfalzbuch (5th ed., Neustadt a.d.W., 1976), p. 574.
Hamm, Freie Bauernschaft, pp. 59–63; DGPS, pp. 24, 28; FB, 14 December 1923; BHStAM MA/107 987–8; MA/108 379: Landwirt Rudolf Hamm, n.d.; MA/102 156: HMB, 5 June 1926; MA/107 668: Antz to Jolas, 27 March 1931; report of Heim/Förster trial, 24–8 November 1931; BSA 9, 1924; Hamm interview, 1978.
Hamm, Freie Bauernschaft, p. 46.
Hamm, Freie Bauernschaft, pp. 64–8; DGPS, p. 3.
Hamm, Freie Bauernschaft, p. 68; Jung in Pfälzische Rundschau, 15 February 1931.
DBFP, 1st series, xxvi (1985): 313: Kilmarnock to Curzon, 2 January 1924; 315: Curzon to Crewe, 4 January 1924; 319: Kilmarnock to Curzon, 5 January 1924; 322: Curzon to Phipps, 9 January 1924.
This account is based on several sources, which contain some irresoluble contradictions on points of detail: Gedye, The Revolver Republic; BHStAM MA/107 668: Antz to Wappes, 11, 13 November 1923; Antz to Jolas, 27 March 1931; Hausmann to Jolas, 10 April 1931; and three unattributed eyewitness reports of the murder; J. Röhl (ed.), From Bismarck to Hitler (Harlow, 1970), pp. 119–20: ‘The Assassination at Speyer 1924’ (by G. Muthmann or ‘Fritz’, as ed. Ernst von Salomon).
BHStAM MA/107 668: Antz to Wappes, 11, 13 November 1923; Antz to Jolas, 27 March 1931.
BHStAM MA/107 668: Antz to Jolas, 27 March 1931.
BHStAM MA/107 668: Antz to Jolas, 27 March 1931; Hausmann to Jolas, 10 April 1931.
BHStAM MA/107 668: report by unnamed eyewitness (1) to Palatine Head Office, 12 January 1924; Antz to Jolas, 27 March 1931; Gedye, The Revolver Republic, pp. 222, 230. ‘Weiss’ also appears as ‘Weis’.
Röhl, From Bismarck to Hitler, pp. 119–20; BHStAM MA/107 668: eyewitness (1); Gedye, The Revolver Republic, p. 230.
Gedye, The Revolver Republic, pp. 221–2.
BHStAM MA/107 668: eyewitness (1); report by unnamed eyewitness (2) to Palatine Head Office, n.d.; Röhl, From Bismarck to Hitler, p. 120; Gedye, The Revolver Republic, pp. 222–3. The number of assassins is variously given as between three and five. ‘Fritz’ claims that ‘Weiss’ fumbled with his gun (contrast Gedye) and that Heinz got up after the first shot and was killed by a second shot in the back (contrast Gedye and eyewitness (1)).
Gedye, The Revolver Republic, pp. 223–5; BHStAM MA/107 668: eyewitnesses (1) and (2).
Gedye, The Revolver Republic, pp. 224–5; Röhl, From Bismarck to Hitler, p. 120.
Gedye, The Revolver Republic, pp. 226–9; BHStAM MA/107 668: unnamed eyewitness (3) to Palatine Head Office, n.d. The wording of Schmitz’s pleas varies slightly in the two versions.
BHStAM MA/107 668: Antz to Jolas, 27 March 1931.
BAK R43I/1840: autonomous government to Reich Chancellery, 16 January 1924; FB, 25 January 1924; PFB, 12 January 1924.
BAK R43I/1840, pp. 257–8: Braun von Stumm to Reich Chancellery and Foreign Office, 17 January 1924; p. 241: Der Separatist 2, January 1924.
PFB, 22 January 1924; Der Separatist 2, January 1924.
Autonome Pfalz, 26 January 1924.
PFB, 10 January 1924; Hamm interview, 1978.
PFB, 10–11 January 1924; DBFP, 1st series, xxvi (1985): 327: Curzon to Crewe, 13 January 1924.
Hamm interview, 1978.
PFB, 13 January 1924; Hamm, Frefe Bauernschaft, pp. 71–2.
DBFP, 1st series, xxi (1978): 513: Kilmarnock to Curzon, 27 December 1923; xxvi (1985): 336: Curzon to Crewe, 19 January 1924; 348: MacDonald to Crewe, 2 February 1924; 327: Curzon to Crewe, 13 January 1924.
Hamm, Freie Bauernschaft, pp. 70, 73–5; Hamm interview, 1978.
DBFP, 1st series, xxvi (1985): 334: Kilmarnock to Curzon, 19 January 1924.
DBFP, 1st series, xxvi (1985): 346: Crewe to MacDonald, 30 January 1924; 349: MacDonald to Phipps, 4 February 1924; 350: Phipps to MacDonald, 5 February 1924; 352: Kilmarnock to MacDonald, 7 February 1924; 353: MacDonald to Kilmarnock, 8 February 1924.
DBFP, 1st series, xxvi (1985): 359: Kilmarnock to MacDonald, 13 February 1924; PFB, 31 January–12 February 1924; Gedye, The Revolver Republic, pp. 237–8.
DBFP, 1st series, xxvi (1985): 360, 363: Kilmarnock to MacDonald, 13, 15 February 1924; PFB, 15 February 1924.
PFB, 13 February–17 March 1924; Hamm interview, 1978.
BHStAM MA/107 668: Jolas, 15 April 1931.
BHStAM MA/107 668: report of Heim/Förster trial, 24–8 November 1931; MNN, 27 March 1923.
Cf. BAK R43I/1840, p. 286: Haniel, Reich representative in Bavaria, to Reich Chancellery, 4 February 1924.
Pfälzische Post, 2 April 1931; Hamm, Freie Bauernschaft, p. 34.
Landauer Anzeiger, 22 April 1931; Rheinpfälzer, 23 April 1931; Pfälzische Rundschau, 23 April 1931; Pfälzische Post, 23 April 1931; Hamm interview, 1978.
Frankenthaler Tageblatt, 14 February 1931; Rheinpfälzer, 23 April 1931; Pfälzische Rundschau, 24 April 1931; BHStAM MA/107 668: report of Heim/Förster trial, 24–8 November 1931.
Hamm, Freie Bauernschaft, pp. 34–7; Jung in Pfälzische Rundschau, 13 February 1931.
MNN, 23 November 1930: E. Jung, ‘Die Erschiessung des Heinz-Orbis in Speyer’; Rheinpfälzer, 6 December 1930: Eberlein; BHStAM MA/107 668: Eberlein to Jolas, 9 December 1930; Betz to Jolas, 17 December 1930.
BHStAM MA/107 668: Antz to Jolas, 27 March 1931.
BAK R43I/1841, pp. 133–4: Braun von Stumm to Reich Chancellery, 26 April 1924.
Die Ergebnisse der Reichstagswahlen vom 4. Mai und 7. Dezember 1924 in der Pfalz unter besonderer Berücksichtigung der Ergebnisse in Ludwigshafen am Rhein, ed. O. Stabel (Ludwigshafen, 1925).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Copyright information
© 1993 Jonathan Osmond
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Osmond, J. (1993). The Free Peasantry and Separatism. In: Rural Protest in the Weimar Republic. St Antony’s. Palgrave Macmillan, London. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-349-11568-6_6
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-349-11568-6_6
Publisher Name: Palgrave Macmillan, London
Print ISBN: 978-0-333-52448-0
Online ISBN: 978-1-349-11568-6
eBook Packages: Palgrave History CollectionHistory (R0)