Abstract
In 1941 the publisher Henry Luce hailed the dawn of the American Century and summoned the USA to reshape the world in its own image.1 There was no more dramatic representative of this imperial vision than Spruille Braden, who became US Ambassador to Argentina in April 1945. Braden believed that the future of Latin America depended upon the development of middle-class democracy linked with American goods and capital.2 In Buenos Aires he rapidly established himself as the champion of freedom, reviving civilian opposition to the military regime and pressing for elections. His campaign against Fascism in the shape of Colonel Juan Perón reopened the wartime rift with Argentina. It also revived the debate with Britain about the Argentine question. British officials looked on with horror as Braden brought the country to the brink of civil war with little consideration for British interests. As one diplomat complained, the US ambassador was taking risks with ‘the property of others, especially ours’.3 The Braden episode confirmed British prejudices about the immaturity of American policy. The problem for London, as it had been since 1942, was to reconcile the protection of British interests in Argentina with the maintenance of the wider Anglo-American relationship on which British security and economic stability ultimately depended.
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Preview
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
Notes and References
Arthur A. Ekirch, Jr., Ideologies and Utopias (Chicago: 1969) pp. 246–7.
John Morton Blum (ed) The Price of Vision. The Diary of Henry A. Wallace, 1942–1946 (Boston: 1973) pp. 610–12.
Hadow to Perowne, 25 August 1945, AS4475/12/2 F0371/44688.
David Green, The Containment of Latin America (Chicago: 1971) pp. 246–51; Bryce Wood, The Dismantling of the Good Neighbor Policy (Austin: 1985) pp. 76–92.
Green, pp. 251–2
Peter Collier and David Horowitz, The Rockefellers. An American Dynasty (New York: 1976) p. 236.
Ibid., pp. 236–40; Green, pp. 249–52.
Fortune, June 1945, p. 94.
C.A. MacDonald, ‘The Politics of Intervention: The United States and Argentina, 1941–1946’, Journal of Latin American Studies, November 1980, p. 384.
Ibid.
Ibid.
R.A. Humphreys, Latin America and the Second World War, 1942–1945 (London: 1982) pp. 196–7.
Spruille Braden, Diplomats and Demagogues (New Rochelle, N.Y.: 1971) p. 319.
Wood, pp. 94–5.
Braden, p. 320.
Ibid.
Green, pp. 216–22.
Sumner Welles, Where Are We Heading? (New York and London: 1946) p. 213.
Humphreys, p. 198.
Collier and Horowitz, p. 242.
Hadow to Perowne, 8 August 1945, A54232/12/2 F0371/44688; Hadow to Perowne, 30 March 1946, AS 1978/235/2 F0371/51811; Hadow to Perowne, 2 April 1946, AS2108/235/2 F0371/51812.
MacDonald, p. 386.
Braden, p. 316.
Braden to Bohan, 12 July 1944, Merwin L. Bohan Papers, Harry S. Truman Library, Independence, Missouri. Hereafter HSTL.
Braden to Secretary of State, 4 September 1945, Foreign Relations of the United States 1945, vol. 9, pp. 406–8. Hereafter FR.
Braden, p. 334; Kelly to Foreign Office, 9 July 1945, AS 3615/1561/2 F0371/44762.
Blum, p. 611.
Braden, p. 320.
Ibid., p. 323.
Kelly to Foreign Office, 7 July 1945, AS3557/12/2 F0371/44687.
‘Notes Made by Mr Collins of the United Press of the Press Conference Given by Ambassador Braden on September 18, 1945’, File 1730, George S. Messersmith Papers, University of Delaware.
Braden to Secretary of State, 11 July 1945, FR1945, vol. 9, pp. 391–3.
Braden to Secretary of State, 31 May 1945, Ibid., pp. 537–8.
Secretary of State to Reed, 12 April 1945, Ibid., p. 530.
Braden to State Department, 30 June 1945, PSF Telegrams BA-Perón, HSTL.
Braden, p. 322.
Memo by Lockwood, 23 June 1945, ARA Memoranda, Box 19
Green, p. 252
Kelly to Foreign Office, 27 July 1945, AS4193/12/2 F0371/4468.
‘Notes Made by Mr Collins of the United Press’, File 1730, Messersmith Papers.
Braden to Secretary of State, 5 July 1945, FR 1945, vol 9, p. 389
Braden to Secretary of State, 4 September 1945, Ibid, pp. 406–8
Ibid.
Hadow to Perowne, 13 June 1945, As3219/12/2 F0371/44687
Welles, p. 220
Ibid.
Blum, p. 465; Woods, p. 102
MacDonald, 386–7.
Braden, pp. 340–1.
Military Intelligence Report, 5 December 1945, RG 226, XL31023, USNA Braden, p. 341.
Hadow to Perowne, 8 August 1945, AS4232/72/2 F0371/44688
FO to Kelly, 28 September 1945, AS5021/159/2 F0371/44723
Kelly to FO, 2 July 1945, AS3471/12/2 F0371/44687
‘Notes Made by Mr Collins of the United Press’, File 1730, Messersmith Papers.
Hadow to Kelly, 26 October 1945, AS5647/12/2, FO371/44690.
Memo of Conversation, 11 August 1945, State Department Decimal File, 711.35/8-1145, USNA.
Hadow to Perowne, 13 June 1945, AS3219/12/2 F0371/44687; Hadow to Perowne, 20 July 1945, AS3849/159/2 F0371/44721.
Wood, pp. 98–9. Collier and Horowitz, pp. 242–3.
Braden, pp. 328–30, 331–4.
FO to Halifax, 13 August 1943, A7633/11/2 F0371/33515.
Minute by Perowne, 18 July 1943, A6670/4/2 FO371/33508.
Wood, pp. 43–75, Humphreys pp. 178–80.
Wood, pp. 80–5; Humphreys, 178–80.
Humphreys, pp. 197–8
R.S. Sayers, History of the Second World War: Financial Policy 1939–45 (London: 1956) pp. 445–6.
Kelly to FO, 18 May 1945, AS2661/159/2 F0371/44179.
Hadow to Perowne, 17 August 1945, AS4423/12/2 F0371/44688; Kelly to FO, 18 August 1945, AS4254/109/2 F0371/44671; Braden to Secretary of State, 20 September 1945, FR 1945, vol. 9, pp. 550–2.
Kelly to FO, 18 May 1945, AS2661/159/2 F0371/44179 Minute by Perowne, 19 June 1945, AS3235/12/2 F0371/44687.
Perowne to Kelly, 2 July 1945, AS3745/92/2 F0371/44172; Sir David Kelly, The Ruling Few (London: 1953) p. 314.
Robert A. Potash, The Army and Politics in Argentina, 1928–1945 (Stanford: 1969) pp. 259–60.
Minute by Perowne, 16 September 1945, AS4817/159/2 F0371/44722.
Minute by Butler, 8 August 1945, AS4301/12/2 F0371/44688.
Kelly to FO, 9 July 1945, AS3615/1561/2 F0371/44672; Kelly to FO, 27 June 1945, AS3354/12/2 F0371/44687; Minute by Hancock, 3 September 1945, AS4477/92/5 F0371/44713.
Hadow to Perowne, 13 June 1945, AS3219/12/2 F0371/44687.
Hadow to Perowne, 31 July 1945, AS4185/12/2 F0371/44688; Minute by Perowne, 2 July 1945, AS3471/12/2 F0371/44687.
Perowne to Meres, 4 May 1946, A2396/235/2 F0371/51813.
Wood, p. 103.
Braden, p. 339.
Acheson to Braden, 7 September 1945, FR 1945, vol 9, pp. 548–9; Winant to Secretary of State, 6 October 1945, Ibid., p. 552.
Braden, p. 339.
Balfour to Foreign Office, 25 August 1945, AS4409/12/2 F0371/44688; Minute by Perowne, 16 September 1945, AS4817/159/2 F0371/44722; Halifax to Foreign Office, 22 September 1945, AS4920/159/2 F0371/44723.
Foreign Office to Washington, 2 October 1945, AS4634/159/2 F0371/44723.
Hadow to Perowne, 30 August 1945, AS4594/12/2 F0371/44688. Hadow to Perowne, 28 September 1945, AS5110/12/2 F0371/44689; Braden, pp. 312–3.
Halifax to Foreign Office, 29 September 1945, AS5022/12/2 F0371/44689.
Minute by Perowne, 2 October 1945, AS4634/159/2 F0371/44723; Bevin to Halifax, 5 October 1945, AS5198/12/2 F0371/44689.
Bevin to Halifax, 9 October 1945, AS5263/12/2 F0371/44689.
Braden, p. 339.
Green, p. 253.
Wood, pp. 102–3; Braden, p. 341.
Potash, pp. 269–282; David Rock, Argentina, 1516–1982 (London: 1986) pp. 259–60.
Wood, p. 105.
Minute by Perowne, 8 August 1945, AS4029/92/2 F0371/44712.
Minute by Butler, 11 October 1945, AS5350/12/2 F0371/44689.
Minute by Perowne, 17 October 1945, AS5380/92/2 F0371/44714. Kelly, p. 309.
Minute by Perowne, 22 October 1945, AS5459/92/2 F0371/44714.
Department of State to the British Embassy, 15 November 1945, FR1945, vol. 9, pp. 555–7; Thorp to Paul, 29 December 1945, Ibid., pp. 558–9.
Braden, p. 356.
Humphreys, pp. 221–2.
Hadow to Perowne, 3 December 1945, AS6738/317/51 FO371/45019.
Cabot to Briggs, 17 November 1945, FR1945, Vol. 9, pp. 426–34; Cabot to Secretary of State, 9 January 1946, 835.00/1-946, USNA.
Cabot to Briggs, 17 November 1945, FR1945, vol. 9, pp. 426–34.
MacDonald, pp. 388–9.
Wood, pp. 112–3.
Minute by Perowne, 19 February 1946, AS961/235/2 FO371/51809.
Minute by Murray, 11 January 1946, AS270/126/2 FO371/51801.
R.J. Hammond, Food (London: 1962) p. 275; Kelly to Foreign Office, 23 August 1945, AS4348/159/2 F0371/44721. On discussion of railway deal see Minutes of Treasury Meeting, 11 November 1945, AS6069/109/2 F0371/446717.
Minute by Perowne, 9 December 1945, AS6334/12/2 FO371/44680. Roger Gravil, ‘Argentina’s Blue Book scandal of 1946’, Unpublished paper delivered at University of London, Institute of Latin American Studies, 17 January 1986. The Americans picked up a rumour about this. See Cabot to Secretary of State, 21 November 1945, FR1945, vol. 9, p. 434.
Minute by Perowne, 28 November 1945, AS6118/92/2 F0371/46715.
Kelly to Foreign Office, 15 November 1945, AS6267/12/2 FO371/44690. Minute by Perowne, 9 December 1945, AS6334/12/2 FO371/44680.
Wood, p. 112; Minute by Perowne, 19 February 1946, AS961/235/2 FO371/51809. Minute by Perowne, 15 February 1946, AS985/124/2 FO371/51801.
Foreign Office Minute, 15 February 1946, Ibid.
Minute by Perowne, 15 February 1946, AS986/235/2 FO371/51809. Minute by Perowne, 15 February 1946, AS985/124/2 FO371/51801.
Bevin to Winant, 19 February 1946, AS985/126/2 FO371/51801.
Halifax to Byrnes, 28 February 1946, 835.00/2-2846 USNA. Halifax to Perowne, 20 February 1946, AS1119/235/2 FO371/51809.
Callum A. MacDonald, ‘The US, The Cold War and Perón’, in Christopher Abel and Colin M. Lewis (eds) Latin America, Economic Imperialism and the State (London: 1985) pp. 405–7.
Braden, p. 341.
Collier and Horowitz, p. 236.
Braden, p. 333. Wood, p. 100.
Hadow to Perowne, 28 February 1946, AS1206/235/2 FO371/51809.
Hadow to Perowne, 12 March 1943, AS3015/11/2 F0371/33511; Shuckburgh to Perowne, 13 December 1944, AS193/12/2 F0371/44694.
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Copyright information
© 1989 Guido di Tella and D. Cameron Watt
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
MacDonald, C.A. (1989). The Braden Campaign and Anglo-American Relations in Argentina, 1945–6. In: di Tella, G., Watt, D.C. (eds) Argentina between the Great Powers, 1939–46. St Antony’s/Macmillan Series. Palgrave Macmillan, London. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-349-10977-7_7
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-349-10977-7_7
Publisher Name: Palgrave Macmillan, London
Print ISBN: 978-1-349-10979-1
Online ISBN: 978-1-349-10977-7
eBook Packages: Palgrave History CollectionHistory (R0)