Advertisement

Arsonists and the Psychiatrist

  • M. Faulk

Abstract

Esquirol in 1835 in his Text Book of Mental Disorder showed that arson could be due to mental illness. He had borrowed his case histories from Dr Marc’s essay of 1833. The descriptions indicate that although firesetting might be due to jealousy or revenge as well as attempts by criminals to cover other offences, there were certainly cases which were associated with hallucinations and delusions, dementia, subnormality and epilepsy. At that time a diagnosis of monomania was in fashion. This diagnosis was made where the patient demonstrated an abnormal preoccupation and thus the term ‘pyromania’ for recurrent arsonists came about. Several threads about the psychopathology of firesetting run through the literature. Some workers believe that ‘pyromania’ was a real illness characterised by the presence of an irresistible impulse. This clearly would have, and indeed did have in Germany, substantial legal consequences in terms of responsibility and insanity of the offender. Antagonists of this view held there was no such entity as ‘pyromania’ and generally insisted that a motive could always be found. The development of this argument, which seems to have persisted into the second half of the nineteenth century, was described in detail by Lewis and Yarnell (1951).

Keywords

Current Theme Special Hospital Restriction Order Prison Sentence Sexual Difficulty 
These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Esquirol, J. E. D. (1965). Mental Maladies. Treatise on Insanity, Hafner, LondonGoogle Scholar
  2. Fry, J. F. and Le Couteur, B. (1966). Arson. Medico-Legal J., XXXIV, 108–121Google Scholar
  3. Hurley, W. and Monahan, T. M. (1969). Arson: the criminal and the crime. Br. J. Grimm.,n 9, 4–21Google Scholar
  4. Lewis, N. D. C. and Yarnell, H. (1951). Pathological firesetting. Nervous and Mental Disease Monographs, No. 82. New YorkGoogle Scholar
  5. Marc, M. (1833). Considérations medico-légales sur la monomanie et particulièrement sur la monomanie incendiare. Annls Hygs. publ. Méd. lég., 10, 367–484Google Scholar
  6. McKerracher, D. W. and Dacre, A. J. I. (1966). A study of arsonists in a special security hospital. Br. J. Psychiat., 112, 1151–1154CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Osiander, F. B. (1813). Ueber den Selbstmord, seine Uraschen Arten, medicinischgerichtliche Untersuchung und die Mittel gegen denselben. Eine Schrift sowohl für Politei-und Justiz-Beamte, als für gerichtliche Aerzte und Wundärzte für Psychologen und Volkslehrer, XII, HannoverGoogle Scholar
  8. Schmid, Hans (1914). Zur Psychologie der Brandstifter. Psychologische Abhandlungen, Bd. 1, 80–179Google Scholar
  9. Scott, D. F. (1974). Fire and Fire-Raisers. Duckworth, LondonGoogle Scholar
  10. Scott, P. D. S. (1977). Assessing dangerousness in criminals. Br. J. Psychiat., 131, 127–142CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Soothill, K. L. and Pope, P. J. (1973). Arson. A twenty year cohort study. Med., Sci. Law, 13, 127–138Google Scholar
  12. Stekel, Wilhelm (1924). Pyromania, Vol. II, Peculiarities of Behaviour. BoniLiverwright Co., pp. 124–232Google Scholar
  13. Tennent, T. G., McQuaid, A., Loughnane, T. and Hands, A. J. (1971). Female arsonists. Br. J. Psychiat., 119, 497–502CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Topp, D. O. (1973). Fire as a symbol and as a weapon of death. Med., Sci. Law, 13, 79–86Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Raghu N. Gaind and Barbara L. Hudson 1979

Authors and Affiliations

  • M. Faulk

There are no affiliations available

Personalised recommendations