On Measuring the Social Opportunity Cost of Public Funds
The literature on project evaluation abounds with competing recommendations as to what rate of interest should be used to discount to a single point in time the estimated costs and benefits of public-sector projects. Official policy in the United States, as established in the Green Book1 and in Senate Resolutions, is to base public-sector investment decisions on interest rates prevailing or expected to prevail in the market for government bonds. An alternative, proposed by such authors as Hirshleifer, DeHaven and Milliman, Strotz, and Stockfisch, is to discount benefits and costs at the estimated marginal productivity of capital in the private sector of the economy. A third group, to which Marglin and Sen belong, asserts that market interest rates give an exaggerated picture of the rate of ‘social time preference’, and suggests that that rate be chosen which represents the consensus of the policy-makers (or of the society as a whole) concerning what the social time preference rate really is or should be. I shall defer discussion of social time preference rates, thus arbitrarily defined, to a later point, and shall instead assume that the ‘social rate of time preference’ refers to an appropriately weighted average of the different marginal rates of time preference applicable to the individuals who compose the society.
KeywordsInterest Rate Capital Market Time Preference Marginal Productivity Project Evaluation
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
- Hirshleifer, Jack, DeHaven, James C., and Milliman, Jerome W. Water Supply: Economics, Technology, and Policy. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1960.Google Scholar
- Marglin, Stephen A. ‘The Social Rate of Discount and the Optimal Rate of Saving.’ Quarterly Journal of Economics (February 1963).Google Scholar
- Marglin, Stephen A. Approaches to Dynamic Investment Planning.Google Scholar
- Marglin, Stephen A. ‘The Opportunity Costs of Public Investment.’ Quarterly Journal of Economics (May 1963).Google Scholar
- Sen, A. K. ‘On Optimizing the Rate of Saving.’ Economic Journal (September 1961).Google Scholar
- Stockfisch, J. A. ‘The Social Rate of Discount: Some Issues in the Theories of Cost and Public Finance’ (mimeographed 1968 ).Google Scholar
- Stockfisch, J. A. ‘The Interest Rate Applicable to Government Investment Projects.’Google Scholar
- Strotz, Robert H. ‘The Social Rate of Time Discount’ (mimeographed, 1964 ).Google Scholar
- U.S. Interagency Committee on Water Resources, Proposed Practices for Economic Analysis of River Basin Projects, 1950.Google Scholar