Advertisement

The European Union’s Development Policy: A Balancing Act between ‘A More Comprehensive Approach’ and Creeping Securitization

  • Mark Furness
  • Stefan Gänzle
Part of the Rethinking International Development Series book series (RID)

Abstract

More than a decade after the release of the European Security Strategy (ESS) in 2003, its affirmation that development and security policy should work together is still one of its most discussed features. The vision of a more comprehensive — if not integrated — approach to security and development was underwritten by substantial changes to the EU’s external relations bureaucracy following the 2009 Lisbon Treaty. This ambition raises several important questions regarding the potential ‘securitization’ of EU development policy and foreign aid. Have security concerns had a growing influence on EU development policy and aid allocation? Do key concepts that have become prominent since the ESS was launched, such as ‘fragile states’ and ‘comprehensive approach’, reflect how European policymakers perceive the new reality of global development? Are resources that are supposed to support socioeconomic development being diverted for other purposes? This chapter addresses these questions by discussing the evolution of EU policies and aid practices at the interface of security and development since the turn of the 21st century. We are interested in how the EU manages tensions between security and development objectives, whether this can properly be understood as ‘securitization’ in the critical sense, or whether we should see it as a positive trend towards greater coherence.

Keywords

Security Policy European Council African Union Lisbon Treaty Fragile State 
These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Anderson, Stephanie and John Williams (2011) ‘The Securitization of Development Policy or the Developmentalization of Security Policy? Legitimacy, Public Opinion, and the EU External Action Service (EAS)’, Paper Presented at the 2011 European Union Studies Association Conference, Boston, 3–5 March.Google Scholar
  2. Banim, Guy (2008) ‘EU Responses to Fragile States’, in Stefani Weiss, Hans-Joachim Spanger, and Wim van Meurs (eds.), Diplomacy, Development and Defence, pp. 303–57. Gutersloh: Bertelsmann.Google Scholar
  3. Bello, Oladiran (2012) ‘The EU’s Approach to Fragility in Guinea Bissau: Between Ambition and Coherence’, FRIDE Policy Brief, 113.Google Scholar
  4. Biava, Allessia, Margriet Dren, and Graeme Herd (2011) ‘Characterizing the European Union’s Strategic Culture: An Analytical Framework’, Journal of Common Market Studies, 49.6: 1227–48.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Carbone, Maurizio (2010) ‘The European Union, Good Governance and Aid Coordination’, Third World Quarterly, 31.1: 13–29.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Del Biondo, Karen, Stefan Oltsch, and Jan Orbie (2012) ‘Security and Development in EU External Relations’, in Sven Biscop and Richard Whitman (eds.), Routledge Handbook of European Security, pp. 126–41. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
  7. Del Sarto, Rafaella and Tobias Schumacher (2005) ‘From EMP to ENP: What’s at Stake with the European Neighbourhood Policy towards the Southern Mediterranean?’, European Foreign Affairs Review, 10.1: 17–38.Google Scholar
  8. EC/HR/VP (2011b) ‘Joint Communication to the European Parliament, the Council, the European Economic and Social Committee and the Committee of the Regions: A New Response to a Changing Neighbourhood’, Brussels 25.3.2011, COM (2011) 303.Google Scholar
  9. EC/HR/VP (2013) ‘Joint Communication to the European Parliament and the Council: The EU’s Comprehensive Approach to External Conflict and Crises’, Brussels, 11. 12.2013 JOIN (2013) 30 Final.Google Scholar
  10. EC/HR/VP (2015) ‘Joint Consultation Paper: Towards a New Neighbourhood Policy’, Brussels 4.3.2015 JOIN (2015) 6 Final.Google Scholar
  11. European Commission (2005) Policy Coherence for Development: Accelerating Progress towards Attaining the Millennium Development Goals, COM/2005/0134 final, Brussels: European Commission.Google Scholar
  12. European Commission (2011) Increasing the Impact of EU Development Policy: An Agenda for Change. Brussels: European Commission.Google Scholar
  13. European Commission and High Representative of the European Union for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy (EC/HR/VP) (2011a) ‘Joint Communication: Partnership for Democracy and Shared Prosperity with the Southern Mediterranean’, Brussels 8.3.2011, COM (2011) 200 Final.Google Scholar
  14. European Council (2001) Presidency Conclusions. Brussels: Goteborg European Council.Google Scholar
  15. European Council (2003a) A Secure Europe in a Better World–European Security Strategy. Brussels: European Council.Google Scholar
  16. European Council (2003b) EU Strategy against Proliferation of Weapons of Mass Destruction. Brussels: European Council.Google Scholar
  17. European Council (2008) Report on the Implementation of the European Security Strategy. Brussels: European Council.Google Scholar
  18. European Council (2011) A Strategic Framework for the Horn of Africa. Brussels: European Council.Google Scholar
  19. European Council (2012) EU Strategic Framework and Action Plan on Human Rights and Democracy. Luxembourg: European Council.Google Scholar
  20. EU Council Political and Security Committee (2012) Non-paper on Further Developing the Comprehensive Approach. Brussels: European Council.Google Scholar
  21. EEAS (2011) Strategy for Security and Development in the Sahel. Brussels: European External Action Service.Google Scholar
  22. European Union (2006) ‘The European Consensus on Development. Joint Statement by the Council and the Representatives of the Governments of the Member States Meeting within the Council, the European Parliament and the Commission on European Union Development Policy: The European Consensus’, Official Journal of the European Union, 2006 C 46/01: 1–19.Google Scholar
  23. Faust, Jorg and Dirk Messner (2004) ‘Europe’s New Security Strategy: Challenges for Development Policy’, DIE Discussion Paper 3. Bonn: German Development Institute.Google Scholar
  24. Frisch, Dieter (2008) The European Union’s Development Policy: A Personal View of 50 Years of International Cooperation, ECDPM Policy Management Report, No. 15. Maastricht: ECDPM.Google Scholar
  25. Furness, Mark (2011) ‘Sustaining EU Financing for Security and Development: The Difficult Case of the African Peace Facility’, DIE Briefing Paper 7. Bonn: German Development Institute.Google Scholar
  26. Furness, Mark (2013) ‘Who Controls the European External Action Service? Agent Autonomy in EU External Policy’, European Foreign Affairs Review, 18.1: 103–26.Google Scholar
  27. Furness, Mark and Gorm Rye Olsen (2016) ‘Europeanization and the EU’s Comprehensive Approach to Crisis Management in Africa’, European Politics and Society, 17(1): doi 10.1080/23745118.2015.1075779.Google Scholar
  28. Gänzle, Stefan (2009) Coping with the Security-Development Nexus: The European Community’s Instrument for Stability-Rationale and Potential, DIE Study 47. Bonn: German Development Institute.Google Scholar
  29. Garrasi, Donata (2010) Funding Peacebuilding and Recovery: A Comparative Review of System-Wide Multi-Donor Trust Funds and Other Funding Instruments for Peacebuilding and Post-Conflict Recovery. London: Department for International Development.Google Scholar
  30. Gaub, Florence, Olivier de France, and Daniel Fiott (2014) EUISS Yearbook of European Security 2014. Paris: European Union Institute for Security Studies.Google Scholar
  31. Gourlay, Catriona (2009) EU-UN Cooperation in Peacebuilding: Partners in Practice? Geneva: UNIDIR.Google Scholar
  32. Grimm, Sven (2009) ‘The Reorganisation of EU Foreign Relations: What Role for Development Policies within the European Institutional Setup?’, DIE Briefing Paper 11. Bonn: German Development Institute.Google Scholar
  33. Hadfield, Amelia (2007) ‘Janus Advances? An Analysis of EC Development Policy and the 2005 Amended Cotonou Partnership Agreement’, European Foreign Affairs Review, 12.1:39–66.Google Scholar
  34. Hadfield, Amelia and Richard Youngs (2008) ‘Development, Security and Energy: Improving Coherence’, EDC2020 Policy Brief 2, http://www.edc2020.eu/index.php?id=44, accessed 14 June 2013.Google Scholar
  35. Hayes, Ben and Tony Bunyan (2003) ‘Migration, Development and the EU Security Agenda’, in Europe in the World: Essays on EU Foreign, Security and Development Policies, pp. 71–80. London: BOND.Google Scholar
  36. Helly, Damian (2010) ‘Lessons from EUFOR Tchad/RCA’, EUISS Seminar Reports 18 March.Google Scholar
  37. Hoffmeister, Frank (2008) ‘Inter-Pillar Coherence in the European Union’s Civilian Crisis Management’, in Steven Blockmans (ed.), The European Union and Crisis Management. Policy and Legal Aspects, pp. 157–80. Amsterdam: Asser Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Holland, Martin and Mathew Doidge (2012) Development Policy of the European Union. Houndsmills: Palgrave Macmillan.Google Scholar
  39. Hout, Wil (2010) ‘Between Development and Security: The European Union, Governance and Fragile States’, Third World Quarterly, 31.1: 141–57.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Howorth, Jolyon (2001) ‘European Defence and the Changing Politics of the European Union: Hanging Together or Hanging Separately?’, Journal of Common Market Studies, 39.4: 765–89.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Huysmans, Jeff (2006) The Politics of Insecurity: Fear, Migration and Asylum in the EU. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
  42. Joffé, George (2008) ‘Whither Sarkozy’s Mediterranean Union?’. New York: Carnegie Endowment of International Peace.Google Scholar
  43. Johannsen, Janina (2011) The EU’s Comprehensive Approach to Crisis Management: Premises, Ambitions, Limits. Baden-Baden: Nomos.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  44. Kausch, Kristina and Richard Youngs (2009) ‘The End of the Euro-Mediterranean Vision’, International Affairs, 85.5: 963–75.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Keukeleire Stephan and Kolja Raube (2013) ‘The Security-Development Nexus and Securitization in the EU’s Policies towards Developing Countries’, Cambridge Review of International Affairs, 26.3: 556–72.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. MacFarlane, Neil and Menon, Anand (2015) ‘The EU and Ukraine’, Survival 56.3: 95–101.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. Maxwell, Simon (2011) ‘Why the EU’s Aid Effort should Escape the Budgetary Axe’, Europe’s World, 18: 96–99.Google Scholar
  48. Neal, Andrew (2009) ‘Securitization and Risk at the EU Border: The Origins of FRONTEX’, Journal of Common Market Studies, 47.2: 333–56.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  49. Olsen, Gorm Rye (2009) ‘The EU and Military Conflict Management in Africa: For the Good of Africa or Europe?’ International Peacekeeping, 16.2: 245–60.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. Orbie, Jan (2008) ‘A Civilian Power in the World? Instruments and Objectives in European Union External Policies’, in Jan Orbie (ed.), Europe’s Global Role: External Policies of the European Union, pp. 1–33. Aldershot: Ashgate.Google Scholar
  51. Orbie, Jan and Karen Del Biondo (2015) ‘The European Union’s “Comprehensive Approach” in Chad: Securitisation and/or Compartmentalisation?’, Global Society, 29. 2: 243–59.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  52. Peter, Marina and Emmanuel LoWilla (2008) ‘Too Big, Too Many, Too Much: Policies and Instruments of the European Union in “Post-peace Agreement” Areas: A Coherent Contribution to Stability, Security and Development? The Case of Southern Sudan’, Study Commissioned by the Association of World Council of Churches Related Development Organisations in Europe (APRODEV), May.Google Scholar
  53. Phillips, Leigh (2010) ‘Development NGOs Issue Legal Warning over New EU Foreign Service’, EU Observer, 27 April, www.euobserver.com/foreign/29953, accessed 14 June 2013.Google Scholar
  54. Piebalgs, Andris (2010) ‘Upcoming Challenges for the EU Development Policy’, Speech to the Committee of Development, European Parliament, Speech/10/288, Brussels, 2 June 2010, http://europa.eu/rapid/press-release_SPEECH-10–288_en.htm?locale=en, accessed on July 31, 2015.Google Scholar
  55. Renard, Thomas and Sven Biscop (2010) ‘A Need for Strategy in a Multipolar World: Recommendations to the EU after Lisbon’, Egmont Security Policy Brief 5.Google Scholar
  56. Schlag, Gabi (2012) ‘Into the “Heart of Darkness” — EU’s Civilising Mission in the DR Congo’, Journal of International Relations and Development, 15.5: 321–44.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  57. Seibert, Bjorn (2010) ‘Hoping for the Best Is Not Always Enough’, European Voice, 11 March, www.europeanvoice.com/article/imported/hoping-for-thebest-is-not-always-enough/67373.aspx, accessed 14 June 2013.Google Scholar
  58. Smith, Michael E. (2013) ‘The European External Action Service and the Security-Development Nexus: Organizing for Effectiveness or Incoherence?’, Journal of European Public Policy, 20.9: 1299–315.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. Smith, Michael (2013) ‘Foreign Policy and Development in the Post-Lisbon European Union’, Cambridge Review of International Affairs, 26.3: 519–35.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  60. Toje, Asle (2011) ‘The European Union as a Small Power’, Journal of Common Market Studies, 49.1: 43–60.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  61. Vegro, Romina (2010) ‘Is the EU’s Development Policy Under Threat?’, Guardian, 17 December, www.guardian.co.uk/global-development/poverty-matters/2010/dec/17/eu-europe-development-foreign-policy, accessed 14 June 2013.Google Scholar
  62. Youngs, Richard (2008) ‘Fusing Security and Development: Just Another Euro-Platitude’, Journal ofEuropean Integration, 30.3: 419–37.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  63. Youngs, Richard (2011) ‘European Foreign Policy and the Economic Crisis: What Impact and How to Respond?’, FRIDE Working Paper 111. Madrid: FRIDE.Google Scholar
  64. Zwolski, Kamil (2012) ‘The EU and a Holistic Security Approach after Lisbon: Competing Norms and the Power of the Dominant Discourse’, Journal of European Public Policy, 19.7: 988–1005.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Mark Furness and Stefan Gänzle 2016

Authors and Affiliations

  • Mark Furness
  • Stefan Gänzle

There are no affiliations available

Personalised recommendations