Advertisement

Community Consultations: Local Responses to Large-Scale Mining in Latin America

  • Mariana Walter
  • Leire Urkidi

Abstract

This chapter studies the emergence and spread of community consultations in large-scale metal mining projects in Latin America. These consultations are different from the free, prior and informed consent (FPIC)-related consultations, or consulta previa, that are fostered by national governments. From Tambogrande (Peru) in June 2002 to Mataquescuintla (Guatemala) in November 2012, 68 consultations/referenda have been conducted in Peru, Argentina, Guatemala, Colombia and Peru. In all cases the result has been a large opposition to mining projects. This process is occurring in a context of growing pressures to extract mineral ores in Latin America and an increasing number of related socioenvironmental conflicts (see Chapter 2). The particularity of these consultations is that these are not commissioned by national governments as part of official procedures to consult communities but instead are promoted by environmental justice movements (EJMs), usually with the support of local governments.

Keywords

Mining Activity Social Movement Environmental Justice Environmental Governance Mining Project 
These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.

References

  1. Arnstein, S.R. (1969) “A Ladder of Citizen Participation”, JAIP 35(4): 216–224.Google Scholar
  2. Bebbington, A. (2012a) “Social Conflict and Emergent Institutions. Hypotheses from Piura, Peru”, in A. Bebbington (ed.), Extractive Industries, Social Conflict and Economic Development: Evidence from South America (London: Routledge), 67–88.Google Scholar
  3. Bebbington, A. (2012b) “Underground Political Ecologies: The Second Annual Lecture of the Cultural and Political Ecology Specialty Group of the Association of American Geographers”, Geoforum 43: 1152–1162.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Bebbington, A., Connarty, M., Coxshall, W., O’Shaughnessy, H. and Williams, M. (2007) Mining and Development in Peru. With Special Reference to the Rio Blanco Project (Piura: Peru Support Group).Google Scholar
  5. Bebbington, A., Humphreys Bebbington, D. and Bury, J. (2011) “Federating and Defending Water, Territory and Extraction in the Andes”, in R. Boelens, D. Getches and A. Guevara Gil (eds), Out of the Mainstream: The Politics of Water Rights and Identity in the Andes (London: Earthscan), 307–327.Google Scholar
  6. Bickerstaff, K. and Agyeman, J. (2009) “Assembling Justice Spaces: The Scalar Networking of Environmental Justice in North-East England”, Antipode 41(4): 781–806.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Bridge, G. (2004) “Mapping the Bonanza: Geographies of Mining Investment in an Era of Neo-Liberal Reform”, Professional Geographer 56(3): 406–421.Google Scholar
  8. Bullard, R. (1990) Dumping in Dixie: Race, Class, and Environmental Quality (Boulder, CO: Westview Press).Google Scholar
  9. Bulkeley, H. (2005) “Reconfiguring Environmental Governance: Towards a Politics of Scale and Networks”, Political Geography 24: 875–902.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Cabellos, E. and Boyd, S. (2007) Tambogrande: Mangos, Muerte, Minería, Documentary, Guarango Association, Peru.Google Scholar
  11. CAOI (Coordinadora Andina de Organizaciones Indígenas) (2009) Seis Distritos de la Provincia Arequipeña de Islay se pronunciaron a través del Voto, http://elecochasqui.wordpress.com/actualidad/setiembre-2009/caoi-seis-distritos-de-la-provincia-arequipena-de-islay-se-pronunciaron-a-traves-del-voto-rechazo-al-proyecto-minero-tia-maria-alcanza-el-97/, date accessed 10 January 2013.
  12. Carruthers, D. (ed.) (2008) Environmental Justice in Latin America: Problems, Promise, and Practice (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press).Google Scholar
  13. Castagnino, V. (2006) Metal Mining and Human Rights in Guatemala: The Marlin Mine in San Marcos (Guatemala: Peace Brigades International).Google Scholar
  14. CENSAT (2009) Colombia: No a la Minería en Territorio Indígena, http://censat.org/component/content/article/314, date accessed 10 January 2013.
  15. CISDE-ALAI (2009) América Latina: Riqueza Privada, Pobreza Pública (CISDE-ALAI).Google Scholar
  16. Chaparro Avila, E. (2002) Actualización de la Compilación de Leyes Mineras de Catorce Países de América Latina y el Caribe, UUNN División de Recursos Naturales e Infraestructura ECLAC http://www.eclac.org/publicaciones/xml/6/ 10756/LCL1739-P-E.pdf, date accessed 10 January 2013.
  17. Cleaver, F. (2001) “Institutional Bricolage, Conflict and Cooperation in Usangu, Tanzania”, IDS Bulletin 32(4): 26–35.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Cleaver, F. (2002) “Reinventing Institutions: Bricolage and the Social Embeddedness of Natural Resource Management”, The European Journal of Development Research 14(2): 11–30.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Cleaver, F. (2012) Development Through Bricolage: Rethinking Institutions for Natural Resource Management (London: Routledge).Google Scholar
  20. Cleaver, F., Franks, T., Maganga, F. and Hall, K. (2013) Beyond Negotiation?: Real Governance, Hybrid Institutions and Pastoralism in the Usangu Plains, Tanzania, Working paper 61 (London: King’s College).Google Scholar
  21. Cobain, I. (2009) “British Mining Company Faces Damages Claims Alter Allegations of Torture in Peru”, The Guardian, 18 October 2009.Google Scholar
  22. Comité por la Defensa del Agua y el Páramo de Santurbán (2012) Queja Presentada ante la Oficina del Ombudsman y Asesor en Materia de Observancia, http://www.aida-americas.org/es/release/queja-interpuesta-contra-el-financi amiento-de-mina-de-oro-en-fragiles-humedales-colombianos, date accessed 10 August 2013.
  23. Colao, D. and Claps, L.M. (2005) Comunicación, Recursos Naturales y Comunidad en el Caso Esquel, Graduate Thesis (Buenos Aires: Universidad de Buenos Aires).Google Scholar
  24. Cole, L.W. and Foster, S.R. (2001) From the Ground Up: Environmental Racism and the Rise of the Environmental Justice Movement (New York: University Press London).Google Scholar
  25. De Echave, J., Diez, A., Huber, L., Revesz, B., Lanata, X.R. and Tanaka, M. (2009) Minería y Conflicto Social (Lima: Instituto de Estudios Peruanos).Google Scholar
  26. Delmas, M.A. and Young O.R. (eds) (2009) Governance for the Environment (New York: Cambridge University Press).Google Scholar
  27. Diez Hurtado, A. (2007) “Ronderos y Alcaldes en el Conflicto Minero de Río Blanco en Piura, Perú”, in J. Bengoa (ed.), Territorios Rurales. Movimientos Sociales y Desarrollo Territorial Rural en América latina (Santiago de Chile: RIMISP).Google Scholar
  28. Duthie, K. (2012) Local Votes and Mining in the Americas (Mining Watch Canada).Google Scholar
  29. Ejolt (2013) A Letter from Piedras, Tolima, Colombia: Local Referendum Against Anto Gold Ashanti, Environmental Justice Organizations, Liabilities and Trade Project, http://www.ejolt.org/2013/09/a-letter-from-colombia/, date accessed 10 October 2013.
  30. Fedepaz (2013) Kañaris, Última Comunidad de Habla Quechua en la Costa Peruana, realiza Consulta Comunal, Fundación Ecuménica para el desarrollo y la Paz, http://www.fedepaz.org/index.php?option=com_content&task=view& id=194&Itemid=18, date accessed 20 August 2013.
  31. Ford, L.H. (2003) “Challenging Global Environmental Governance: Social Movement Agency and Global Civil Society”, Global Environmental Politics 3: 120–134.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Fulmer, A. (2011) “La Consulta a los Pueblos Indígenas y su Evolución como Herramienta de Negociación Política en América Latina. Los Casos de Perú y Guatemala”, Apuntes 68: 37–62.Google Scholar
  33. Greenspan, E. (2013) Peru backslides on Indigenous Rights, Oxfam America, http://politicsofpoverty.oxfamamerica.org/2013/05/08/peru-backslides-on-indigenous-rights/, date accessed 10 October 2013.
  34. Gutiérrez Zeballos, P.J. (2011) “Las Razones de Lucha por el Valle del Tambo”, in Cooperacción/Red Muqui/Frente Ambito de Defensa del Valle de Tambo/ Municipalidad Distrital de Dean Valdivia, Valle de Tambo-Islay. Territorio, Agua y Derechos Locales en Riesgo con la Minería a Tajo Abierto.Google Scholar
  35. Haarstad, H. and Floysand, A. (2007) “Globalization and the Power of Rescaled Narratives: A Case of Opposition to Mining in Tambogrande, Peru”, Political Geography 26(3): 289–308.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Harvey, D. (1996) Justice, Nature and the Geography of Difference (Cambridge, MA: Blackwell).Google Scholar
  37. Holden, W. and Jacobson, D. (2008) “Civil Society Opposition to Nonferrous Metals Mining in Guatemala”, Voluntas 19: 325–350.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Jahncke Benavente, J. and Meza, R. (2010) Derecho a la Participación y a la Consulta Previa en Latinoamerica (Lima: Fedepaz Muqui Miserer CIDSE).Google Scholar
  39. Kurtz, H. (2003) “Scale Frames and Counter Scale Frames: Constructing the Social Grievance of Environmental Injustice”, Political Geography 22: 887–916.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Leitner, H., Seppard, E. and Sziarto, K.M. (2008) “The Spatialities of Contentious Politics”, Transactions Institute of British Geographers 33: 157–172.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Marquez, N. (2009) “Más del 90% de Pobladores de Cocachacra se pronunció en contra de la Instalación Extractiva y de la Utilización de Aguas Subterráneas”, La Jornada de Arequipa Journal, http://www.jornaldearequipa.com/Tambo.htm, date accessed 10 August 2013.
  42. McGee, B. (2008) An International Observer’s Account of a Local Vote in Río Blanco Peru, Environmental Defender Law Center, http://www.edlc.org/ resources/local-votes/observers-account/, date accessed 20 January 2013.
  43. McGee, B. (2009) “The Community Referendum: Participatory Democracy and the Right to Free, Prior and Informed Consent to Development”, Berkeley Journal of International Law 27(2): 570.Google Scholar
  44. Mérida, A.C. and Krenmayr, W. (2010) Sistematización de Experiencias 2008– 2009: Tejiendo entre los Pueblos la Defensa del Territorio (Guatemala: Asamblea Departamental por la Defensa de los Recursos Naturales Renovables y no Renovables de Huehuetenango).Google Scholar
  45. Movice (2012) Pueblos Indígenas y la Protección del Territorio. Cartografía de Impulsos y Restricciones de Movimiento en el Territorio, http://www.conlospiesporlatierra.net/?p=1543, date accessed 10 August 2013.
  46. Municipal Code (2002) “Decree 12–2002: Municipal Code Congress of the Republic of Guatemala”.Google Scholar
  47. Municipality of Kañaris (2012) Datos Económicos y Sociales, http://www.munikanaris.gob.pe/DatosDistrito.php, date accessed 20 August 2013.
  48. Muradian, R., Martinez-Alier, J. and Correa, H. (2003) “International Capital Versus Local Population: The Environmental Conflict of the Tambogrande Mining Project, Peru”, Society and Natural Resources 16: 775–792.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  49. National Electoral Office (2002) Resolución RJ N◦098–2002-J/ONPE, http://www.web.onpe.gob.pe/modResoluciones/descargas/RJN098–2002-J.pdf, date accessed 2 March 2002.
  50. Nisgua (2011) Comunidades rechazan Iniciativa por Normar las Consultas Comunitarias, http://nisgua.blogspot.com.es/2011/03/comunidades-rechazan-iniciativa-por.html, date accessed 3 January 2014.
  51. OCMAL (2011) Cuando tiemblan los Derechos: Extractivismo y Criminalización en América Latina (Quito: OCMAL-Acción Ecológica).Google Scholar
  52. Ostrom, E. (1990) Governing the Commons: The Evolution of Institutions for Collective Action (New York: Cambridge University Press).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. OXFAM (2007) Río Blanco: History of a Mismatch in Peru, Oxfam America, http://www.oxfamamerica.org/articles/rio-blanco-history-of-a-mismatch-in-peru/?searchterm=majaz, date accessed 10 January 2013.
  54. OXFAM (2009) Oxfam calls for an Investigation of Alleged Torture of 28 in Peru, http://www.oxfamamerica.org/articles/oxfam-calls-for-an-investigation-of-alleged-torture-of-28-in-peru, date accessed 19 January 2013.
  55. Paterson, M., Humphreys, D. and Pettiford, L. (2003) “Conceptualizing Global Environmental Governance: From Interstate Regimes to Counter-Hegemonic Struggles”, Global Environmental Politics 3: 1–10.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  56. Perez Guartambel, C. (2012) Agua u Oro. Kimsakocha la Resistencia por el Agua (Cuenca: Universidad Estatal de Cuenca).Google Scholar
  57. Portugal Mendoza, C. (2005) “Gobernanza en el Acceso a la Actividad Minera a los Recursos Naturales Locales: El Caso Tambogrande”, Grupo de Investigaciones Económicas.Google Scholar
  58. Radio Uno (2008) Este Viernes remitirán Resultados de Consulta en Candarave al Ejecutivo y al Legislativo, http://www.radiouno.pe/noticias/3963/upt_banner. swf, date accessed 10 August 2013.
  59. Rasch, E.D. (2012) “Transformations in Citizenship: Local Resistance against Mining Projects in Huehuetenango (Guatemala)”, Journal of Developing Societies 28(2): 159–184.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  60. Red Muqui (2009) “La Consulta Vecinal: Un Mecanismo de Democracia Directa para los Pueblos”, in America Latina: Riqueza Privada, Pobreza Pública (Lima: CIDSE-ALAI).Google Scholar
  61. Red Muqui (2011) “Valle de Tambo-Islay. Territorio, Agua y Derechos Locales en Riesgo con la Minería a Tajo Abierto”, Red Cooperacción, Frente de Defensa del Valle de Tambo, Municipalidad Distrital de Dean Valdivia Muqui.Google Scholar
  62. Revenga, A. (2005) Sipakapa NO se vende. Sipakapa qal k’o pirk’ey xik, Documentary. Caracol Producciones.Google Scholar
  63. SEGEPLAN (2002) Propuesta de Política para el Desarrollo Rural (Guatemala: Secre-taría General de Planificación y Programación de la Presidencia SEGEPLAN).Google Scholar
  64. Servindi (2012) Perú: En Consulta Communal el 95% de Votantes de Kañaris rechazó Proyecto Minero Cañariaco, guamina.blogspot.com.es/2012/10/peru-en-consulta-comunal-el-95-de.html, date accessed 10 January 2013.
  65. Schlosberg, D. (2007) Defining Environmental Justice: Theories, Movements, and Nature (New York: Oxford University Press).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  66. Smith, N. (1996) “Spaces of Vulnerability: The Space of Flows and the Politics of Scale”, Critique of Anthropology 16: 63–77.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  67. Subies Grau, T., Beltrán, M.J., Mérida, J.M., Moreno, M., Salas, I., Sánchez Corominas, A., Soler, M. and Parea, M. (2005) “El Éxito de Tambogrande”, Ecología política 30: 95–116.Google Scholar
  68. Suryanata, K. and Umemoto, K. (2005) “Beyond Environmental Impact: Articulating the ‘Intangibles’ in a Resource Conflict”, Geoforum 36: 750–760.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  69. Svampa, M. and Antonelli, A. (eds) (2009) Minería Transnacional, Narrativas del Desarrollo y Resistencias Sociales (Buenos Aires: Biblos).Google Scholar
  70. Trentavizi, B. and Cahuec, E. (2012) “Las Consultas Comunitarias de ‘Buena Fe’ y las Prácticas Ancestrales Comunitarias Indígenas en Guatemala”, Centro de Investigaciones Regionales de Mesoamérica – Oficina del Alto Comisionado para los Derechos Humanos de las Naciones Unidas.Google Scholar
  71. UNOPS/PNUMA (2011) Revisión “ad hoc” del Estudio de Impacto Ambiental, Proyecto Tía María, Informe de Observaciones y Requerimiento de Información Complementaria, http://xa.yimg.com/kq/groups/2122051/1296039927/name/ Revisi%C3%B3n+del+Estudio+de+Impacto+Ambiental+del+Proyecto+ T%C3%ADa+Mar%C3%ADa.pdf, date accessed 10 January 2013.
  72. Urkidi, L. (2011) “The Defence of Community in the Anti-Mining Movement of Guatemala”, Journal of Agrarian Change 11(4): 556–580.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  73. Urkidi, L. and Walter, M. (2011) “Concepts of Environmental Justice in Anti-Gold Mining Movements in Latin-America”, Geoforum 42: 683–695.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  74. Van de Sandt, J. (2009) Mining Conflicts and Indigenous Peoples in Guatemala (The Hague: Cordaid – University of Amsterdam).Google Scholar
  75. Walter, M. and Martinez-Alier, J. (2010) “How to Be Heard When Nobody Wants to Listen: The Esquel Mining Conflict”, Canadian Journal of Development Studies 30(1–2): 281–303.Google Scholar
  76. Xiloj, L. and Porras, G. (2008) Diagnóstico sobre el Derecho a la Consulta que tienen los Pueblos Indígenas y sus Consecuencias Jurídicas y Políticas a Partir del Caso de la Explotación Minera en el Departamento de San Marcos (Guatemala: Fundación Rigoberta Menchú).Google Scholar
  77. Yappert, S. (2009) “Pedimos que pongan Freno a estos Proyectos de Muerte”, Rio Negro Newspaper 5/5/2009.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Mariana Walter and Leire Urkidi 2016

Authors and Affiliations

  • Mariana Walter
  • Leire Urkidi

There are no affiliations available

Personalised recommendations