Of the contentious debates that deconstruction has touched off, the one concerning its relation to hermeneutics has drawn special attention. As Pöggeler has noted, one can already create a small library from the pertinent writings about this subject (Pöggeler, 1994, p. 481). In any event, what distinguishes the debate is a seemingly uncompromising confrontation with no end in sight. Derrida’s critique of hermeneutics’ postulation of a master sense, a sole and true meaning of texts, has triggered the verdict by hermeneutic philosophers, including Gadamer, that deconstruction celebrates the end of the philosophies of meaning in a Nietzschean feast of, and free play on, words. However, it is worth remarking that Derrida only rarely, and merely in passing, takes on the various positions in the institutionalized discipline of hermeneutics. Certainly, at times, Derrida’s statements about hermeneutics read like a critique of Ricoeur’s hermeneutic philosophy. But, except for Derrida’s response to Gadamer’s intervention during their meeting in Paris in 1981, references to Gadamer’s philosophical hermeneutics are absent from his examination of hermeneutics. Still, what about the occasional presence of the name of Schleiermacher in Derrida’s writings? Does it not at least suggest a concerted and focused debate with the historical forms of the art of interpretation, and the hermeneutic tradition?
KeywordsHermeneutic Phenomenology Hermeneutic Tradition Institutionalize Discipline Phenomenology Affect Master Sense
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
- Derrida, Jacques (1979), Spurs: Nietzsche’s Styles/Éperons: Les styles de Nietzsche (Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press). (Page numbers in the text refer to this edition. All translations from this work are mine–RG.)Google Scholar
- Gadamer, Hans-Georg (1989), ‘Destruction and Deconstruction’, Dialogue and Deconstruction: The Gadamer–Derrida Encounter, ed. D. P. Michelfelder and R. E. Palmer (Albany, NY: SUNY Press), pp. 102–13.Google Scholar
- Gadamer, Hans-Georg (1993), Gesammelte Werke, vol. 2: Hermeneutik II. Wahrheit und Methode. Ergänzungen Register (Tübingen: J. C. B. Mohr).Google Scholar
- Greisch, Jean (1996), ‘Déconstruction et/ou Herméneutique’, La théologie en post-modernité, Lieux Théologiques, vol. 29, ed. P. Gisel and P. Evrard (Geneva: Labor et Fides), pp. 353–86.Google Scholar
- Grondin, Jean (1994), Introduction to Philosophical Hermeneutics, trans. J. Weinsheimer (New Haven, CT: Yale University Press).Google Scholar
- Nietzsche, Friedrich (1974), The Gay Science, trans. Walter Kaufmann (New York: Vintage).Google Scholar
- Pöggeler, Otto (1994), ‘Hermeneutik und Dekonstruktion’, Schritte zu einer hermeneutischen Philosophie (Munich: Karl Alber), pp. 479–98.Google Scholar