Monitoring Lung Volumes During Mechanical Ventilation
- 3.8k Downloads
Respiratory inductive plethysmography (RIP) is a non-invasive method of measuring change in lung volume which is well-established as a monitor of tidal ventilation and thus respiratory patterns in sleep medicine. As RIP is leak independent, can measure end-expiratory lung volume as well as tidal volume and is applicable to both the ventilated and spontaneously breathing patient, there has been a recent interest in its use as a bedside tool in the intensive care unit.
KeywordsElectrical Impedance Tomography Conventional Mechanical Ventilation Respiratory Inductive Plethysmography Electrical Impedance Tomography Data Continuous Distend Pressure
The theoretical basis and technique of RIP
The measurement of tidal volume and changes in end-expiratory lung volume during mechanical ventilation using RIP, including the limitations of these measurements
The potential applications for RIP in neonatal and paediatric intensive care, including during high-frequency ventilation and newborn resuscitation
This chapter will not discuss the use of RIP within the field of sleep medicine.
14.1 Respiratory Inductive Plethysmography
Respiratory inductive plethysmography (RIP) is a non-invasive method of measuring change in lung volume which is well-established as a monitor of tidal ventilation and thus respiratory patterns in sleep medicine. As RIP is leak independent, can measure end-expiratory lung volume as well as tidal volume and is applicable to both the ventilated and spontaneously breathing patient, there has been recent interest in its use as a bedside tool in the intensive care unit.
188.8.131.52 Theoretical Considerations
RIP determines change in lung volume by measuring the changes in both chest and abdominal volume displacements during tidal ventilation. In 1967, Konno and Mead, using the principle that there is a relationship between linear motion and volume displacement, showed that the chest wall operates with 2° of freedom and has two moving parts, the rib cage and the abdomen (Konno and Mead 1967). Additionally, in terms of motion of their surfaces, there is functional separation between the abdomen and the rib cage during breathing. By utilising this unitary behaviour of the two compartments, change in total thoracic volume1 can be determined from measurement of the volume displacement in each separate compartment. During ventilation, the lung will contribute to the majority of any thoracic volume change.
The true practical advantage of Konno and Mead’s observation can be realised by considering the fact that a volume change will result in a change in cross-sectional area within each compartment.
Early RIP devices operated solely in AC-coupled output mode. This was adequate for assessing respiratory rate, tidal volume and synchrony of respiration, but the baseline signal was too unstable to assess end-expiratory lung volume (EELV) (Morel et al. 1983). Modern RIP devices allow both an AC- and DC-coupled output. In DC-coupled output, the RIP signal is sufficiently stable to allow reliable measurement of changes in EELV (Morel et al. 1983; Valta et al. 1992a), with good agreement with EELV values obtained by whole-body plethysmography (Carry et al. 1997) and super-syringe (Albaiceta et al. 2003).
Changes in lung volume recorded by RIP are initially output as voltage changes. The RIP voltage change can be calibrated using a number of methods (Bar-Yishay et al. 2003). The two most common are the qualitative diagnostic calibration (QDC) algorithm (Sackner et al. 1989) and the least mean squares technique (Konno and Mead 1967; Strömberg et al. 1993). The least mean squares technique requires knowledge of a known volume change during the calibration phase, which is not always possible during paediatric and neonatal ventilation. For this reason, the QDC algorithm is the method most commonly used in ICU environments.
The QDC measures the voltage changes during a series of breaths at the start of the RIP recording, generally over 5 min. QDC allows derivation of the proportionality constant, k, in Eq. 14.2. The relative contribution of each compartment to the overall voltage change is estimated by selecting a series of breaths of similar tidal volume. This is achieved by excluding all breaths greater than one standard deviation (SD) of the mean ΔR ch and ΔR ab value. The constant k is then estimated as SD(R ch)/SD(R ab) (Sackner et al. 1989). QDC has been shown to generate acceptable agreement with pneumotachograph measurement of tidal volume in term newborn infants (Adams 1996) and piglet models of surfactant-deficient lung disease (Markhorst et al. 2006). The reliability of RIP calibration is best when measurements are immediately preceded by calibration and tend to deteriorate with time. RIP calibration accuracy decreases with severity of lung disease. In vitro, the phase deviation in the transducer outputs, and thus the stability of the proportionality factor, increases in a linear fashion at frequencies above 10 Hz (Boynton et al. 1989). The accuracy of this process is also directly related to the number of breaths analysed (Brown et al. 1998).
An advantage of the QDC method is that it can still be applied when absolute volume changes are not known. In these circumstances, changes in relative volume can be expressed as a ratio to the tidal volume during the QDC period. This is useful during non-invasive ventilation (Courtney et al. 2001) and high-frequency ventilation (Markhorst et al. 2006; Habib et al. 2002; Weber et al. 2000; Markhorst and van Genderingen 2004; Copnell et al. 2009; Hoellering et al. 2008; Tingay et al. 2006, 2007a). After QDC, a modern RIP device has been found to have a mean relative measurement bias of −2.0 (SD 9 %) during short periods of high-frequency ventilation (HFV) in a piglet model of paediatric lung disease (Markhorst et al. 2006; Markhorst and van Genderingen 2004). This error is less than common commercially available pneumotachographs (Scalfaro et al. 2001; Roske et al. 1998). This study also demonstrated that a k factor of 1.0 was reasonable for most paediatric lung disease states, overcoming some of the difficulties associated with QDC during high-rate, low tidal volume ventilation.
184.108.40.206 Clinical Applications
220.127.116.11.1 Assessment of EELV
The capacity of DC-coupled output RIP to achieve a stable baseline signal offers the potential to reliably measure change in EELV during mechanical ventilation, particularly high-frequency and non-invasive ventilation. Most modern ventilators include continuous airway flow monitoring, allowing RIP to be calibrated easily and frequently during conventional forms of mechanical ventilation.
18.104.22.168.1.1 Conventional Mechanical Ventilation
22.214.171.124.1.2 High-Frequency Ventilation
RIP has found a place in measurement of lung volume during high-frequency ventilation (HFV), in large part due to the difficulties in assessing volumetric change with other devices. The non-laminar gas flow during HFV makes pneumotachographic measurement of tidal volume difficult and measurement of EELV impossible (Gerstmann et al. 1990). RIP measures volume change directly within the thoracic cavity and is unaffected by flow characteristics. RIP thus has the potential to measure both tidal volume and EELV during HFV.
Calibrated RIP has been used to measure changes in lung volume during endotracheal tube suction in a small population of infants receiving HFV (Tingay et al. 2007a). This was achieved by calibrating the RIP voltage change against tidal volume at the airway opening in a series of tidal inflations during conventional ventilation. This technique requires transient discontinuation of HFV and, possibly, disconnection from mechanical ventilation. It is reasonable to conclude that this method of calibration would be accurate for short periods during HFV. Whether the calibration factors remain accurate over longer periods is questionable, especially in states of severe, or changing, lung disease (Tingay et al. 2007b).
Even when uncalibrated, RIP still has clinical potential to measure relative changes in lung volume during HFV and avoids the limitations of calibration (Markhorst et al. 2006). On the bench-top, uncalibrated RIP accurately measures relative change in EELV during HFV between frequencies of 7 and 15 Hz (Brazelton et al. 1999a), with a stable signal for up to 4 h in a thermally constant environment (Brazelton et al. 1999b). Signal stability beyond 3 h has not been confirmed in human studies (Tingay et al. 2006).
Uncalibrated RIP has been shown to be a reliable method of assessing relative change in EELV during HFV in animal models of neonatal lung disease, agreeing with changes in lung volume measured using whole-body plethysmography (Weber et al. 2000), super-syringe-derived pressure-volume relationships (Brazelton et al. 2001; Gothberg et al. 2001) and single-slice chest computed tomography (Authors’ unpublished data).
The first reported use of RIP to record changes in EELV during HFV was by Saari et al. (1984) in which dynamic hyperinflation was demonstrated in seven adult patients receiving high-frequency ventilation. More recently, RIP has been used to describe the relationship between applied P aw and thoracic volume during HFV in animal models of surfactant-deficient lung disease. Identification of lung overdistension during sequential increases in P aw was possible in the healthy and surfactant-depleted piglet lung using RIP-derived static compliance (Weber et al. 2000). In both lung models, the relationship between applied P aw and compliance fitted a second-order sigmoidal model of the pressure-volume relationship (Venegas et al. 1998), with the P aw resulting in overdistension translating to the upper inflection point of the sigmoid curve, suggesting that RIP could be used to describe the inflation limb of the pressure-volume relationship (Weber et al. 2000). The same group has also shown that RIP-derived time constants of the lung can be used to identify the point of optimal ventilation during sequential P aw increases (Habib et al. 2002).
Increasingly, strategies which aim to apply HFV at the lowest possible P aw that maintains lung volume after a recruitment manoeuvre are being advocated (Rimensberger et al. 1999a, b, 2000a, b; van Kaam and Rimensberger 2007; De Jaegere et al. 2006; van Kaam et al. 2003, 2004a, b; Lachmann 1992; Vazquez de Anda et al. 1999, 2000; Froese 1997). Mapping the volumetric response to recruitment is difficult at the bedside, and clinicians are limited to resorting to indirect indicators of lung volume, such as oxygenation. In a piglet model of paediatric acute respiratory distress syndrome (Brazelton et al. 2001) and term and preterm lambs (Gothberg et al. 2001), RIP has been used to demonstrate lung volume recruitment, hysteresis and subsequent optimal P aw on the deflation limb of the pressure-volume relationship of the lung. In both these studies, critical points within the pressure-volume relationship, including total lung capacity, were identifiable. RIP can also demonstrate improvement in the hysteresis of the lung after administration of exogenous surfactant (Gothberg et al. 2001).
126.96.36.199.1.3 Non-invasive Ventilation
188.8.131.52.2 Assessment of Tidal Volume and Breathing Patterns
184.108.40.206.2.1 Conventional Mechanical Ventilation
Due to the availability, relative ease and reliability of pneumotachographic assessment of tidal volume at the airway opening, there are very few reports of assessment of tidal volume using RIP during conventional mechanical ventilation. RIP has been used to identify improved tidal volume, thoraco-abdominal synchrony and chest wall displacement after transition to proportional assist ventilation from CPAP (Musante et al. 2001).
RIP has been shown to be a reliable alternative to pneumotachography in driving ventilator synchronisation during conventional mechanical ventilation in animal models of the normal and diseased paediatric lung (Schulze et al. 2001). The accuracy of the RIP bands was depended on a reliable calibration of the contribution of each band to the summated signal. This accuracy diminished significantly after body movement, limiting the use of the summated signal for prolonged mechanical ventilation periods in ICU. Schulze et al. have proposed that the use of the abdominal band alone would overcome these difficulties and offer the advantage of being a leak- and dead-space-free method of determining spontaneous respiratory effort (Schulze et al. 2001).
Pneumotachography will be unreliable during states of rapid compliance change or respiratory asynchrony, such as endotracheal tube suction (Copnell et al. 2009; Hoellering et al. 2008) and surfactant administration. During these situations, RIP is likely to be a better indicator of tidal volume change in the thorax.
220.127.116.11.2.2 High-Frequency Ventilation
Assessment of V T during HFV is problematic. Pneumotachographic measures at the airway opening provide an accurate trend of HFV V T in vitro (Scalfaro et al. 2001), but do not correspond with the volumetric changes measurable at the chest wall. The accuracy of pneumotachography during HFV in humans has not been confirmed (Zimova-Herknerova and Plavka 2006); thus, it should be considered at best a proxy for tidal changes more distally in the tracheobronchial tree. In contrast, RIP is a direct measure of chest wall movement during HFV and likely to be a better representative of tidal volume. In an animal model of paediatric acute lung injury, RIP tidal amplitudes could be accurately measured and altered accordingly with changing PEEP and compliance (Markhorst et al. 2005, 2006). RIP tidal amplitude could then be used to identify overdistension during HFV. A similar relationship between volume state of the lung and RIP-derived V T has been found in human infants receiving HFV (Fig. 14.5) (Tingay 2013). In this study, the RIP-derived V T response approximated that of V T measured by pneumotachograph (Tingay 2008).
18.104.22.168.2.3 Non-invasive Ventilation
The early descriptions of RIP in infants related to tidal patterns in spontaneously ventilated subjects (Strömberg et al. 1993; Duffty et al. 1981; Dolfin et al. 1982; Stefano et al. 1986). Compared to pneumotachography, RIP shows good agreement as a measure of V T during CPAP and spontaneous ventilation in preterm infants (Bar-Yishay et al. 2003; Brown et al. 1998). Unlike face mask pneumotachography, RIP offers the ability to monitor tidal ventilation without significant disruption and can determine the synchrony of ventilation using the phase angle between the chest and abdominal tidal signals, sometimes expressed as a laboured breathing index (LBI). RIP has been used to demonstrate the effect of alterations in continuous distending pressure on tidal breathing patterns in preterm infants receiving CPAP. A higher pressure (maximum 8 cm H2O) resulted in a better V T and thoraco-abdominal synchrony and lower LBI, suggesting less work of breathing (Elgellab et al. 2001). Courtney and co-workers also demonstrated an association between increased respiratory rate and greater phase angle with CPAP delivered via nasal cannulae compared with short binasal prongs (Courtney et al. 2001). These small studies suggest that RIP may be useful as a monitoring device during CPAP.
The most important limitation of RIP is the inability to determine the residual volume of the lung and absolute volume change. Furthermore, change in inductance measured by RIP is linearly related to total thoracic volume rather than gas volume per se. We have noted that RIP detects blood volume change within the chest during intravenous administration of fluid boluses (Authors unpublished data).
Early RIP systems were also susceptible to significant thermal drift, limiting the capacity to accurately monitor ΔEELV (Bhatia et al. 2010). Some modern RIP devices require up to 60 mins to achieve signal stability in a stable ambient temperature (Tingay 2008; Bhatia et al. 2010), but thereafter, signal stability is excellent and, in many cases, better than pneumotachographs (Markhorst et al. 2006; Brazelton et al. 2001; Tingay 2008). Drift appears to be less of an issue in newer RIP systems (Bhatia et al. 2010). The disease state of the lung may also affect the drift of the RIP signal. RIP was found to be unreliable during mechanical ventilation in adults with severe obstructive pulmonary disease (Neumann et al. 1998; Werchowski et al. 1990).
Strict adherence to a standardised method of transducer placement is required to reduce intersubject variability (Landon 2002). The chest and abdomen are most likely to operate with 1° of freedom when transducers are placed at the level of the nipples and at, or just above, the umbilicus (Konno and Mead 1967; Tingay et al. 2006; Brooks et al. 1997; Weese-Mayer et al. 2000). Most reports of RIP during paediatric critical care have equally weighted the chest and abdominal contributions. There is some evidence to support this assumption in paediatric acute lung injury (Markhorst et al. 2006), although it should be noted that this assumption is not universally true and may significantly alter measurement error (Poole et al. 2000).
The greatest hindrance for RIP is the lack of commercially available products specifically for intensive care use. Until RIP devices that measure changes in EELV and V T are integrated into modern monitoring systems, the potential for RIP is limited to a research tool.
22.214.171.124 Future Directions
Essentials to Remember
RIP is a non-invasive method of measuring absolute or relative changes in thoracic volume.
RIP is an accurate method of measuring breathing patterns and tidal volume, without the limitations associated with measurements at the airway opening.
More recently, RIP has shown promise as a reliable method of determining ΔEELV in the mechanically ventilated patient.
At present, RIP remains an important tool for respiratory research at the bedside in ICU.
In the future, with development of commercially available RIP units that overcome some of the inherent limitations present in current systems, RIP has the potential to be a valuable monitoring tool in paediatric and neonatal intensive care.
The plethora of information on the heterogeneity of lung disease, the response to recruitment and the distribution of aeration that has been gained by computed tomography
The value of other imaging techniques, including magnetic resonance imaging and positron emission tomography, in the study of the diseased lung
The limitations of these imaging techniques in ventilated infants and children
14.2 Lung Imaging Methods
14.2.1 Computed Tomography
The purpose of this section is to detail the advances in understanding of the diseased lung and its response to ventilation that have been made with the assistance of computed tomography. The use of CT imaging as a diagnostic tool in the ventilated infant and child is not discussed.
126.96.36.199 What Have We Learned from Computed Tomography of the Lung?
Information derived from computed tomography of the diseased lung
Inhomogeneity of lung expansion even with a relatively diffuse disease on plain X-ray
Effect of superimposed pressure on the dependent regions of the diseased lung
Presence of aeration “compartments” – non-aerated, poorly aerated, normally aerated and hyperinflated – in the diseased lung
Changes in lung aeration and recruitment (reduction in non-aerated lung) during ventilatory manoeuvres
Estimation of the potential for recruitment
Coincidence of recruitment and hyperinflation during tidal ventilation
Several descriptions of the morphological pattern of CT densities exist in ventilated patients with ARDS. The densities have been classed as diffuse, lobar or patchy (Puybasset et al. 2000), with the diffuse pattern being associated with a greater response to recruitment (Constantin et al. 2010). The pattern of lung densities has also been recognised to differ based on whether the lung disease is pulmonary or non-pulmonary in origin (Pelosi et al. 2003). In the latter case, the major impairment of compliance involves the chest wall, including the diaphragm, which may be subjected to significant limitation of movement in cases of abdominal sepsis or trauma (Pelosi et al. 2003). Not surprisingly, supra-diaphragmatic lung regions are most prone to atelectasis when there is diaphragmatic splinting of this type. Examples in childhood are a preterm infant with necrotising enterocolitis or a child with acute pancreatitis, but again no systematic CT imaging studies have been performed.
188.8.131.52 Measurements of CT Densities
184.108.40.206 Limitations of CT Scanning
CT scanning has not been used in ventilated neonatal and paediatric subjects solely for the purpose of evaluating lung aeration and recruitment potential. This is chiefly because of concerns regarding radiation exposure (Mayo et al. 2003), although, with the advent of low-dose thin-section CT, the radiation dose may be 5–10 % of that with conventional CT imaging. Other limitations are lack of availability of CT scanning time and the difficulties and risks of transfer of ventilated neonatal and paediatric subjects to the CT scanning suite. For these reasons, it is unlikely that CT imaging will become widely used as a tool for evaluating regional lung inflation in this group. As discussed elsewhere in this text, there is potential for electrical impedance tomography to give similar information at the bedside of a ventilated subject, and experience with this form of imaging is growing (Frerichs et al. 2001a).
14.2.2 Magnetic Resonance Imaging
The use of magnetic resonance (MR) imaging of the lung parenchyma is essentially limited to quantification of lung water content and its spatial distribution, using proton density-weighted images. Given the relative lack of fat and other hydrogen-bound complexes in the lung, there is a direct relationship between proton density and lung water content. Studies in experimental animals (Schmidt et al. 1986; Viard et al. 2008), as well as human adults (Mayo et al. 1995) and preterm infants (Adams et al. 2002), have confirmed that MR imaging can quantify the water content of the lung and indicate its distribution. A measurable increase in water content has been demonstrated in animals with experimental pulmonary oedema (Schmidt et al. 1986). Gravity-related maldistribution of lung water, with higher water content in the dependent regions, has been observed on MR imaging (Adams et al. 2002). Clearance of lung liquid after birth has been measured in preterm lambs using the technique (Viard et al. 2008).
Another application of MR imaging, not previously used in ventilated infants or children, is the use of hyperpolarised helium (3He) as a means both of tracking distribution of ventilation (Rudolph et al. 2009) and, intriguingly, of measuring intrapulmonary oxygen concentration (Eberle et al. 1999). Access to high-grade 3He gas and the gas delivery device required to control its administration are limiting factors to the wider application of this technique.
The limited availability of MR facilities, along with the need for non-ferrous ventilators and monitoring equipment, means that MR imaging is unlikely to become more widely used in the future for evaluation of either lung water content or ventilation distribution in neonatal and paediatric subjects on ventilatory support.
14.2.3 Positron Emission Tomography
Positron emission tomography (PET) is a three-dimensional functional imaging technique often combined with CT, which is based around detection of gamma radiation from a positron-emitting radionuclide. In the clinical setting, PET scanning is used quite extensively for diagnostic imaging of suspected pulmonary malignancy. In the research laboratory, PET techniques have been applied in experimental animals for the estimation of regional lung perfusion and water content (Schuster and Howard 1994; Richard et al. 2002) and for the evaluation of pulmonary inflammation and ventilator-induced lung injury (Kirpalani et al. 1997; Monkman et al. 2004; Costa et al. 2010). These latter studies used 18fluorodeoxyglucose, a tracer that is taken up into neutrophils and thus preferentially localises in areas of inflammation, including in the lung parenchyma. In newborn piglets, a clear increase in tracer uptake by the lung has been noted after injurious ventilation compared to controls with normal lungs (Kirpalani et al. 1997). Increased tracer uptake was seen in ventilated sheep with endotoxaemia to be localised to regions that were both aerated and perfused (Costa et al. 2010), suggesting that factors beyond gas distribution alone contribute to regional neutrophilic inflammation during lung injury with associated endotoxaemia.
A single investigative group has examined the possibility that PET scanning could discern differences in lung inflammation in preterm infants with and without exposure to inflammation prenatally (Andersen et al. 2003). No clear differences in 18FDG uptake were observed in preterm infants with a history of maternal chorioamnionitis compared with those with no antenatal inflammation. Several infants with no apparent systemic inflammatory response had very high tracer uptake in the lung on PET scanning (Andersen et al. 2003). This study did not point to a potential role for PET scanning in the investigation of lung inflammation in the ventilated preterm infant, and no further studies have been forthcoming.
Essentials to Remember
CT imaging of the diseased lung has revealed the heterogeneity of parenchymal densities, related both to random distributional effects and to gravity-related compressive forces acting on dependent regions.
CT imaging in ventilated adults with acute respiratory distress syndrome can map the distribution of opening pressures and quantify the potential for recruitment in response to sustained airway pressure.
MR imaging and PET scanning have contributed to the understanding of lung water content and distribution of aeration, but are not currently used in the clinical setting for these applications.
The limited availability of these imaging techniques, coupled with technical difficulties peculiar to each, precludes a recommendation for their use in the management of ventilated infants and children with lung disease.
14.3 Bedside Lung Imaging Methods (Electrical Impedance Tomography)
To understand the measuring principle of EIT
To learn how EIT is able to track changes in regional lung volumes and tidal volume distribution as well as to determine regional dynamic phenomena in lung ventilation
To identify the potential benefit of functional EIT lung imaging in monitoring of ventilated neonatal and paediatric patients
To identify the present limitations and drawbacks of EIT
The use of established radiological imaging methods in respiratory monitoring of mechanically ventilated infants is limited especially because of the imposed radiation load or the necessity of patient transport to the examination site. Ventilated patients would benefit from new monitoring approaches providing instantaneous assessment of regional lung function at the bedside and enabling more rapid adjustment of ventilator settings. The non-invasive and radiation-free method of electrical impedance tomography (EIT) has recently been proposed as a possible future monitoring tool in this indication. EIT allows the assessment of regional lung ventilation and of changes in regional lung volumes based on the measurement of electrical properties of the lung tissue. EIT has no known hazards and can be applied at the bedside. However, EIT has not been used routinely in a clinical setting, thus, its usefulness still has to be proved. Several small clinical studies in neonatal and paediatric patients indicate the potential of EIT monitoring. To establish the method as a routine medical examination tool, further development of the EIT hardware and software is necessary. Definition of the most adequate EIT examination procedures providing measures suitable for clinical decision-making and optimising the ventilator therapy is the other prerequisite.
220.127.116.11 Electrical Bioimpedance
The idea of imaging the human body by electrical current is not new. It is based on the fact that the tissue electrical properties are not uniform and vary among different organs (Geddes and Baker 1967). Biological tissues can conduct electrical current; however, their opposition to the transmission of current is not the same.
Medical examination techniques based on the measurement of electrical bioimpedance
Main information retrieved
The first attempts to produce electrical bioimpedance images of the body originate already from the late 1970s of the last century. They aimed at generating anterior to posterior chest images, similar to chest radiography (Henderson and Webster 1978). The first EIT system producing cross-sectional, i.e. tomographic images of the human body was developed by David C. Barber and Brian H. Brown in the early 1980s of the last century (Barber and Brown 1984).
18.104.22.168 EIT Setup
Most of the currently used EIT systems use an array of 16 electrodes. This number of electrodes is a good compromise securing sufficient image resolution and equidistant placement of electrodes without the risk of undesirable accidental electrode contact. Eight- and thirty-two-electrode EIT systems have also been developed; however, the loss in spatial resolution or the necessity of placing a large number of electrodes on the chest makes these systems less adequate.
22.214.171.124 EIT Data Acquisition
During an EIT examination, minute alternating electrical currents are injected into the body. These currents have an amplitude of only a few mA and a frequency in the range of approximately 10 kHz–1 MHz. The currents are applied between adjacent pairs of electrodes in most of the EIT systems. The current-carrying electrode pairs are cyclically activated, and the current injection rotates around the body. During each application of electrical current, the resulting potential differences are measured between all other passive electrode pairs. The voltage distribution developed on the surface of the chest is determined by the internal distribution of electrical resistances within the chest and its shape. Also in the case of voltage measurement, adjacent electrodes are preferentially used. With the described 16-electrode arrangement and pattern of rotating current application and voltage measurement, a total of 208 voltage values are acquired during each scan cycle. The maximum EIT scan rate is rather high. With up to 50–60 scans/s, it is much higher than in other, classical radiological tomographic methods, like computed tomography or magnetic resonance imaging.
126.96.36.199 EIT Image Reconstruction
The set of electrical voltages acquired at the chest surface as a result of electrical current application during each scan cycle is used to calculate the distribution of electrical impedance within the thorax. The calculated impedance values are then converted to a two-dimensional, cross-sectional EIT scan in an either grey or colour scale. This process of generation of impedance distribution images from the measured potential differences and known excitation currents is called image reconstruction (Barber 1990; Morucci and Marsili 1996).
The generation of EIT scans is not easy. This is first of all related to the fact that the human body is a three-dimensional object. Electrical currents applied through the electrodes at the boundary of the chest are not confined to the two-dimensional transverse plane, defined by the electrode array. The currents also flow into more distant regions, and their pathways are not known. This means that EIT scans always reflect not only the impedance distribution in the studied plane but are also affected by tissues lying outside of the measurement plane, although with lower sensitivity. Another point is that the currents tend to penetrate less into the deeper chest regions. Therefore, the spatial resolution also tends to be poorer in the centre than at the chest periphery.
In general, there exist three major ways how EIT scans can be generated (Boone et al. 1997). The first approach aims at depicting the distribution of absolute values of electrical impedance within the chest. Although such images have already been obtained in vivo, their quality was rather poor. This is mainly because these images are very sensitive to EIT data collection errors and require the knowledge of the shape of the body. The same limitations also apply to the second approach, which tries to differentiate the tissues based on their varying response to electrical currents of different frequencies. The most frequently used approach is the third one, in which changes or differences in electrical impedance are determined and converted to EIT scans. The advantages of this approach are that errors tend to cancel and the uncertainties about the body shape do not affect the image quality. The calculated impedance changes are often normalised by relating them to a reference state of impedance. This is, for instance, done when the so-called weighted backprojection (Barber 1990) is used, which has been the most often used method of EIT image reconstruction in in vivo EIT imaging so far. All EIT scans shown in the figures in this chapter have been generated using this type of image reconstruction.
The weighted backprojection algorithm is a rather old approach to image reconstruction known to be associated with several assumptions which are not met during measurements in humans. Nevertheless, it has been successfully applied in multiple clinical studies. Several other EIT image reconstruction algorithms have been developed over the past 20 years; however, their performance has mostly been tested only under in vitro conditions. EIT image reconstruction is one of the most active fields in EIT research. Only recently, an initiative of a large and representative group of experts has been formed to develop a unified reconstruction algorithm for lung EIT imaging which should secure the highest possible and uniform spatial resolution, accuracy and sensitivity (Adler et al. 2009).
14.3.3 Image Interpretation and Qualitative Analysis
Such series of individual EIT scans can be displayed directly online during the data acquisition or offline after the completion of the examination. Thanks to the high EIT scan rates, they result in a video sequence of the instantaneous distributions of electrical impedance in the chest. Such videos are dominated by the large impedance changes associated with the variation in regional lung volume; the much smaller changes in the cardiac region are often also discernible. The even smaller cyclic EIT signal variation caused by lung perfusion is usually masked by the large impedance changes during ventilation. Thus, lung perfusion only becomes visible in such video sequences when the lung air content does not change, e.g. during apnoea. The series of individual EIT scans are usually considered only the first step in further evaluation.
EIT can track rapid regional changes in electrical impedance in the chest cross-section resulting from the physiological processes like ventilation, heart action or lung perfusion. Figure 14.17 illustrates this capability of EIT by showing the regional tracings of EIT data in three image pixels. These tracings reveal the typical ventilation-related variation of the EIT signal as well as the heart beat synchronous variation detectable especially in the heart region. The excellent time resolution of EIT with high scan rates allows even more frequent events to be tracked, like the very small and rapid air volume oscillations during high-frequency oscillation ventilation.
14.3.4 Tracking Lung Volumes and Tidal Volume Distribution
188.8.131.52 Changes in Regional Lung Volumes
The ability of EIT to track regional lung volume changes has been validated by several established imaging modalities (computed tomography, positron emission tomography, single-photon emission computed tomography, ventilation scintigraphy) (Frerichs et al. 2002; Hinz et al. 2003b; Kunst et al. 1998; Richard et al. 2009; Serrano et al. 2002; Victorino et al. 2004; Wrigge et al. 2008) and other medical methods (spirometry, inert gas washout) (Hahn et al. 1995; Harris et al. 1987; Hinz et al. 2003a).
An increase in the lung air content leading to a rise in lung volume is accompanied by an increase in electrical impedance. Electrical impedance falls when lung volume decreases. These typical impedance changes occur regularly during the respiratory cycle both during spontaneous breathing or mechanical ventilation. In ventilated patients, additional lung volume changes may result from altered ventilator settings.
Changes in positive end-expiratory pressure (PEEP) influence the aeration of the lungs and, consequently, the impedance level, on which the cyclic ventilation-related variation of the EIT signal is superimposed (Erlandsson et al. 2006; Frerichs et al. 1999a, 2003a; Meier et al. 2008). The changes in aeration may be spatially inhomogeneous, and it is the advantage of EIT that it can track these aeration changes on a regional level. For instance, an increase in regional electrical impedance in the dependent lung regions after an increase in PEEP may indicate alveolar recruitment. Merely a small increase in impedance in the nondependent regions with a pronounced effect in other regions may hint at possible local overdistension.
184.108.40.206 Tidal Volume Distribution
During tidal spontaneous or artificial ventilation, the highest values of electrical impedance occur at end-inspiration, the lowest at end-expiration. The differences between the regional peak and trough values of the EIT signal are representative of regional tidal volumes. If these regional differences between the maximum and minimum impedance values are calculated from one or more respiratory cycles in each image pixel, they may be converted in another type of a functional EIT scan showing the distribution of tidal volume in the chest cross-section.
The distribution of tidal volume is influenced by the type of ventilation (spontaneous vs. mechanical), body position and gravity and by the local mechanical properties of the lung tissue which may be nonhomogeneously altered by lung pathology. Figure 14.19 shows how the tidal volume distribution may vary even within a very short time interval. In the course of this EIT examination, which was already referred to in the above text, the studied infant was ventilated in an assisted mode of ventilation. Ventilation was accomplished by ventilator-induced breaths in combination with spontaneous breathing activity. The functional EIT scans of tidal volume distribution generated from this phase of the EIT examination show that the regional tidal volumes were smaller during the spontaneous than ventilator-induced breaths; nevertheless, their spatial distribution was similar. An interesting phenomenon is revealed when the distribution of the ventilator-induced tidal volumes is compared between this phase and the phase when the infant ceased to breathe spontaneously. A more pronounced distribution of the tidal volume to the nondependent anterior regions was found in the latter phase indicating that a spatial redistribution of tidal volume had occurred when the mechanical breaths were applied at a lower end-expiratory lung volume.
220.127.116.11 Combination of Functional EIT Information
It was explained in the above text that functional EIT scans of various types can be generated from the same EIT examination by application of various evaluation steps and procedures. Figure 14.19 provided an example in which functional EIT scans showing the tidal volume distribution and regional lung volume changes relative to the lowest end-expiratory volume were obtained from the same EIT data by different analysis. The interpretation of multiple functional EIT scans may offer a deeper insight into the regional lung function. Even more detailed understanding could be obtained if functional EIT information is extracted from examinations performed during predefined manoeuvres, for instance, during a PEEP trial (Frerichs et al. 2003a; Meier et al. 2008).
The high scan rates achievable during EIT examinations allow an assessment of rapid dynamic phenomena in the regional lung function. Therefore, not only the above-mentioned regional lung volume changes and tidal volumes can be measured but also the dynamics of regional lung filling and emptying described (Frerichs et al. 2001b). For instance, progressive filling of lung regions characterised by an increasing rate of impedance change may occur during tidal lung recruitment or degressive filling with a decreasing rate of impedance change may arise from overinflation (Hinz et al. 2007). A regional time delay in an increase in impedance during lung inflation (Wrigge et al. 2008) may be a sign of airway collapse with delayed opening of the affected lung units. Regional tracings of the EIT signal registered after a stepwise change in airway pressure may be used to calculate the distribution of regional time constants.
Since many of the physiological processes in the lungs like ventilation and cardiac action, which contribute to the time variation of the EIT signal, are of cyclic origin, they can be separated by using frequency filtering procedures (Dunlop et al. 2006; Frerichs et al. 2001a, 2009). Independent analysis of these processes is then possible. For instance, the functional EIT scans of tidal volume distribution during ventilator-induced and spontaneous breaths during assisted ventilation shown in Fig. 14.19 could easily be generated because the ventilator and spontaneous breathing rates were not equal.
Thus, a variety of information on different aspects of regional lung function can be obtained from EIT examinations (Bodenstein et al. 2009; Brown 2003; Costa et al. 2009; Frerichs 2000). There exist two ways how this information can be used in clinical decision-making: (1) It can be visualised in form of functional EIT scans. This way of presentation is suitable if rapid information on the spatial distribution of a chosen relevant lung function measure is needed. (2) Alternatively, the relevant EIT lung function measure can be calculated in meaningful pulmonary regions of interest (Pulletz et al. 2008; Victorino et al. 2004; Zhao et al. 2009) and used in its numeric form, for instance, to follow regional changes in lung function over time. EIT data are then acquired during a longer monitoring interval or as a series of short but repetitive examinations. This approach may be applied, for example, to establish if a recruitment manoeuvre or a change in ventilator settings opened an atelectatic region with a non-transient effect on regional tidal volume.
14.3.5 Clinical Experience
Clinical experience with EIT use for lung imaging in neonatal and paediatric patients is scarce. Until 2009, less than 20 EIT studies have been conducted in this patient group, mostly in rather small numbers of patients. The number of experimental and clinical studies in adults is much higher. Many of these studies possess a high degree of relevance for EIT application in the neonatal/paediatric field.
EIT studies in neonates and infants have mostly been motivated by two goals. The first one was to utilise the full non-invasiveness and lack of radiation of this new examination method to study such phenomena in the lung function which were previously not accessible to other established medical modalities or not ethically justified. EIT enabled regional analysis of lung function in preterm infants or neonates. Even lung healthy babies could be examined by EIT during undisturbed spontaneous breathing. Since very little is known about the regional lung function in patients of this age group, EIT was able to provide valuable information on the ventilation distribution under a variety of conditions. For instance, the significant effects of body and head position and the influence of the respiratory pattern (e.g. respiratory rate, sighs) on the spatial distribution of ventilation were established (Frerichs et al. 2003b; Heinrich et al. 2006). Furthermore, the differences in regional ventilation between preterm and term neonates could be addressed (Riedel et al. 2009). The specific features of the neonatal ventilation distribution pattern have been studied and compared with adults (Dunlop et al. 2006; Schibler et al. 2009; Smallwood et al. 1999). A few studies have been performed in neonates with the aim of determining the effect of maturational changes on the lung electrical properties, showing that increased alveolisation is associated with higher electrical impedance of the lung tissue (Brown et al. 2002a, b).
The other studies were motivated by the awareness of the potential of EIT in monitoring ventilated infants. EIT was applied to determine the effects of changed ventilator settings or therapeutic procedures (surfactant administration, suctioning) on regional lung function. These studies were performed in neonatal and paediatric intensive care units and provided the first evidence that useful feedback information can be generated by EIT at the bedside. The studied infant patients were followed by EIT during spontaneous breathing and different modes of mechanical ventilation (e.g. non-invasive and invasive ventilation in fully controlled conventional and high-frequency oscillation modes or assisted ventilation). It has been demonstrated that the immediate effects of changing PEEP, peak inspiratory pressure, inspiration-to-expiration time ratio and fraction of inspired O2 on the spatial distribution of ventilation were discernible (Frerichs et al. 2001a). Long-term monitoring of several days duration was also successfully accomplished to study regional lung ventilation in a critically ill neonate before and after cardiac surgery (Frerichs et al. 1999b). It has also been shown that rapid, regionally heterogeneous derecruitment induced by suctioning can be detected by EIT in children suffering from ARDS (Wolf et al. 2007). Finally, regional end-expiratory lung volumes were determined by EIT in ventilated infants with respiratory failure due to a respiratory syncytial virus infection (Kneyber et al. 2009).
14.3.6 Limitations and Drawbacks
Pros and cons of EIT lung imaging
Non-invasiveness, no exposure to radiation, no known hazard
Poor spatial resolution
Necessity of surface electrodes or electrode bands
Small size, portability, bedside application
Hardware and software not yet optimised for clinical routine
Generation of tomographic images of a new biological quality
Procedures and quantitative parameters for clinical decision-making not yet defined
Good temporal resolution (i.e. high scan rate)
Large clinical studies lacking
Continuous examination (i.e. monitoring)
With a clear lack of other alternative medical modalities suitable for monitoring regional lung function in ventilated infants at the bedside EIT possesses many intriguing characteristics: It allows continuous measurement of regional lung volumes and tidal volume distribution as well as the assessment of other regional measures characterising the dynamics of lung behaviour during mechanical but also spontaneous breathing. To obtain this kind of information, no radiation exposure is necessary; there exist no known hazards. After the application of EIT electrodes on the chest, continuous EIT scanning can easily be performed and interrupted any time.
The disadvantages of EIT comprise first of all the relatively low spatial resolution of EIT scans. Although continuous technological development and use of more advanced image reconstruction procedures can be expected to improve the EIT image quality, image resolutions as known in conventional chest radiography, computed tomography and magnetic resonance imaging will never be possible (Seagar et al. 1987). However, it has to be pointed out that EIT is not intended to be recommended as a sole imaging method. A meaningful combination of patient examinations using conventional imaging modalities, providing excellent anatomical information, and EIT, providing functional information, should be aspired. The conventional methods will make intermittent information on lung morphology available; EIT will offer continuous monitoring of lung function.
The essential drawback of EIT at present is that it has hardly been applied in large clinical trials. The final proof of clinical relevance and efficacy is still lacking. Many of the intriguing data obtained by this method in ventilated neonates and infants were merely small observational studies, in part, simple case reports. This means that EIT must be applied in larger groups of patients with clearly defined goals and outcome measures. One of the most important objectives should be the definition of appropriate procedures for standardised EIT examination of patients. Such procedures should provide relevant EIT measures suitable for clinical decision-making and optimisation of ventilator therapy. Since EIT has the perspective of becoming a broadly used monitoring tool at the bedside, it will be operated by the medical personnel and not only by a few specialists, as is the case today. Therefore, factors like practicability of application and user friendliness of EIT data acquisition and evaluation will also play an important role in the clinical implementation of this technology.
EIT has the potential of becoming a bedside monitoring tool for monitoring regional lung function in ventilated neonatal and paediatric patients. This perspective is based on (1) the clinical need for improved patient monitoring, (2) several positive characteristics of this technology which are superior to other existing imaging modalities and (3) promising findings of hitherto existing EIT studies. The present interest in EIT is mainly driven by the increasing knowledge of possible detrimental effects of mechanical ventilation. If EIT monitoring succeeds to be established in a clinical setting, then it may provide online feedback on regional lung function and its changes in response to modified ventilator settings and other therapeutic procedures. This may facilitate individually optimised mechanical ventilation and minimise the incidence of ventilator-induced lung injury.
Essentials to Remember
EIT is a non-invasive, radiation-free bedside medical imaging modality.
EIT generates cross-sectional images of distribution of electrical bioimpedance within the chest.
EIT allows functional lung imaging, thanks to very high scan rates.
Functional EIT is able to determine changes in regional lung volumes and tidal volume distribution as well as regional dynamic phenomena in lung ventilation.
Ventilated patients may benefit from future EIT monitoring since an immediate feedback on regional lung function may facilitate rapid adjustment of ventilator settings.
Total thoracic volume is the combined volume of gas, blood and tissue within the thoracic cavity.
- Adams JA (1996) Respiratory inductive plethysmography. In: Stocks J, Sly PD, Tepper RS, Morgan WJ (eds) Infant respiratory function testing, 1st edn. Wiley-Liss, New YorkGoogle Scholar
- Adler A, Arnold JH, Bayford R, Borsic A, Brown B, Dixon P, Faes TJ, Frerichs I, Gagnon H, Garber Y, Grychtol B, Hahn G, Lionheart WR, Malik A, Patterson RP, Stocks J, Tizzard A, Weiler N, Wolf GK (2009) GREIT: a unified approach to 2D linear EIT reconstruction of lung images. Physiol Meas 30:S35–S55PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Barber D, Brown B (1984) Applied potential tomography. J Phys E Sci Instrum 17:723–733Google Scholar
- Bhatia R, Owen LS, Davis PG, Tingay DG (2010) Stability of end-expiratory lung volume signal in three different respiratory inductive plethysmographs. J Paediatr Child Health 46 (Suppl 1):8 [abstract]Google Scholar
- Brazelton TB, Watson KF, Thompson JE, Arnold JH (1999a) Bench validation of respiratory inductive plethysmography in determining the end-expiratory lung volume during high frequency ventilation. Pediatr Res 45:37A [abstract]Google Scholar
- Brazelton TB, Watson KF, Thompson JE, Arnold JH (1999b) Respiratory inductive plethysmography is stable during high frequency ventilation. Pediatr Res 45:38A [abstract]Google Scholar
- Constantin JM, Futier E, Cherprenet al, Chanques G, Guerin R, Cayot-Constantin S, Jabaudon M, Perbet S, Chartier C, Jung B, Guelon D, Jaber S, Bazin JE (2010) A recruitment maneuver increases oxygenation after intubation of hypoxemic intensive care unit patients: a randomized controlled study. Crit Care 14:R76Google Scholar
- Eberle B, Weiler N, Markstaller K, Kauczor H, Deninger A, Ebert M, Grossmann T, Heil W, Lauer LO, Roberts TP, Schreiber WG, Surkau R, Dick WF, Otten EW, Thelen M (1999) Analysis of intrapulmonary O(2) concentration by MR imaging of inhaled hyperpolarized helium-3. J Appl Physiol 87:2043–2052PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Landon C (2002) Respiratory monitoring: advantages of inductive plethysmography over impedance pneumography.1–7. http://www.aastweb.org/resources/focusgroups/2003respiratorymonitoring.pdf
- Puybasset L, Gusman P, Muller JC, Cluzel P, Coriat P, Rouby JJ (2000) Regional distribution of gas and tissue in acute respiratory distress syndrome. III. Consequences for the effects of positive end-expiratory pressure. CT Scan ARDS Study Group. Adult Respiratory Distress Syndrome. Intensive Care Med 26:1215–1227PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Rimensberger PC, Pache JC, McKerlie C, Frndova H, Cox PN (2000a) Lung recruitment and lung volume maintenance: a strategy for improving oxygenation and preventing lung injury during both conventional mechanical ventilation and high-frequency oscillation. Intensive Care Med 26:745–755PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Tabachnik E, Muller N, Toye B, Levison H (1981) Measurement of ventilation in children using the respiratory inductive plethysmograph. J Pediatr 99:899Google Scholar
- Tingay DG, Mills JF, Pellicano A, Morley CJ, Dargaville PA (2005) Time to stabilise lung volume after changing mean airway pressure during high frequency oscillatory ventilation (HFOV). Pediatr Res 57(Suppl):A2044 [abstract]Google Scholar
- Vazquez de Anda GF, Hartog A, Verbrugge SJ, Gommers D, Lachmann B (1999) The open lung concept: pressure-controlled ventilation is as effective as high-frequency oscillatory ventilation in improving gas exchange and lung mechanics in surfactant-deficient animals. Intensive Care Med 25:990–996PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Vazquez de Anda GF, Gommers D, Verbrugge SJ, De Jaegere A, Lachmann B (2000) Mechanical ventilation with high positive end-expiratory pressure and small driving pressure amplitude is as effective as high-frequency oscillatory ventilation to preserve the function of exogenous surfactant in lung-lavaged rats. Crit Care Med 28:2921–2925PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Weese-Mayer DE, Corwin MJ, Peuker MR, DiFiore JM, Hufford DR, Tinsley LR, Neuman MR, Martin RJ, Brooks LJ, Davidson Ward SL, Lister G, Willinger M, The CHIME Study Group (2000) Comparison of apnea identified by respiratory inductance plethysmography with that detected by end-tidal CO2 or thermistor. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 162:471–480PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Wrigge H, Zinserling J, Muders T, Varelmann D, Gunther U, von der Groeben C, Magnusson A, Hedenstierna G, Putensen C (2008) Electrical impedance tomography compared with thoracic computed tomography during a slow inflation maneuver in experimental models of lung injury. Crit Care Med 36:903–909PubMedGoogle Scholar