Advertisement

The Embodiment of Otherness: Deconstructing Power Relations Between Staffing Agencies, Diverse Jobseekers, and Organizations in the Israeli Business Sector

  • Shani Kuna
  • Ronit Nadiv
Chapter

Abstract

Prior research has not examined staffing agencies’ (SAs) impact on the workforce diversity of their client organizations, where jobseekers are placed to work. Our exploratory qualitative study addresses this gap in the literature as well as critically examines the embodiment of diverse jobseekers as constructed by SAs. We conducted in-depth, semi-structured interviews with recruiters in SAs that serve the Israeli business sector. The findings suggest that practices utilized by a recruiting agency vis-à-vis their clients could promote workforce diversity, while in reality they often inhibit it. We illustrate the dual potential effect of SAs on the workforce diversity of their client organizations and critically analyze their function as intermediaries that construct the “otherness” of diverse jobseekers and exploit it in ways which might exacerbate their employment precariousness. Theoretical considerations and practical implications are discussed.

References

  1. Abu-Nimer, Mohammed, and Simona Sharoni. 2013. The Israeli-Palestinian conflict. In Understanding the contemporary Middle East, ed. Jillian Schwedler, 175–221. Boulder: Lynne Rienner Publishers Inc.Google Scholar
  2. Acker, Joan. 2006. Inequality regimes: Gender, class, and race in organizations. Gender & Society 20 (4): 441–464.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Ahmed, Sara. 2007a. The language of diversity. Ethnic and Racial Studies 30 (2): 235–256.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. ———. 2007b. A phenomenology of whiteness. Feminist Theory 8 (2): 149–168.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. ———. 2007c. You end up doing the document rather than doing the doing: Diversity, race equality and the politics of documentation. Ethnic and Racial Studies 30 (4): 590–609.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. ———. 2009. Embodying diversity: Problems and paradoxes for Black feminists. Race, Ethnicity and Education 12 (1): 41–52.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. AKT & HRD Survey. 2016. Annual Israeli recruitment benchmark survey. Retrieved from http://hrd.ravpage.co.il/SEKER-2016 (In Hebrew).
  8. Andrijasevic, R., and D. Sacchetto. 2017. ‘Disappearing workers’: Foxconn in Europe and the changing role of temporary work agencies. Work, Employment and Society 31 (1): 54–70.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Benach, J., A. Vives, M. Amable, C. Vanroelen, G. Tarafa, and C. Muntaner. 2014. Precarious employment: Understanding an emerging social determinant of health. Annual Review of Public Health 35: 229–235.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Bendl, R., A. Fleischmann, and C. Walenta. 2008. Diversity management discourse meets queer theory. Gender in Management: An International Journal 23 (6): 382–394.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Benjamin, Orly. 2011. Gender outcomes of labor market policy in Israel. Equality, Diversity and Inclusion: An International Journal 30 (5): 394–408.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. ———. 2016. Gendering Israel’s outsourcing: The erasure of employees’ caring skills, 63–90. Cham: Palgrave Macmillan.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Benjamin, Orly, and Rona Goclaw. 2005. Narrating the power of non-standard employment: The case of the Israeli public sector. Journal of Management Studies 42 (4): 737–759.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Benschop, Y., and H.E. Meihuizen. 2002. Keeping up gendered appearances: Representations of gender in financial annual reports. Accounting, Organizations and Society 27 (7): 611–636.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Block, C.J., and D.A. Noumair. 2017. Understanding diversity dynamics in systems: Social equality as an organization change issue. The Journal of Applied Behavioral Science 53 (2): 150–155.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Bonet, R., P. Cappelli, and M. Hamori. 2013. Labor market intermediaries and the new paradigm for human resources. The Academy of Management Annals 7 (1): 341–392.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Bosmans, K., W. Lewchuk, N. De Cuyper, S. Hardonk, K. Van Aerden, and C. Vanroelen. 2017. The experience of employment strain and activation among temporary agency workers in Canada. Society, Health & Vulnerability 8 (1): 1306914.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Cappelli, P., and J.R. Keller. 2013. Classifying work in the new economy. Academy of Management Review 38 (4): 575–596.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Chetrit, Sami Shalom. 2010. Intra-Jewish conflict in Israel: White Jews, Black Jews. New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
  20. Coe, N.M., K. Jones, and K. Ward. 2010. The business of temporary staffing: A developing research agenda. Geography Compass 4 (8): 1055–1068.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Creswell, J.W., and C.N. Poth. 2017. Qualitative inquiry and research design: Choosing among five approaches. 4th ed. Thousand Oaks: Sage.Google Scholar
  22. Daskalaki, Maria, and Marianna Fotaki. 2017. The neoliberal crisis: Alternative organizing and spaces of/for feminist solidarity. In Feminists and queer theorists debate the future of critical management studies (Dialogues in critical management studies, Volume 3) eds. Alison Pullen, Nancy Harding and Mary Phillips,129–153. Bingley: Emerald Publishing Limited. CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Davidov, G. 2004. Joint employer status in triangular employment relationships. British Journal of Industrial Relations 42 (4): 727–746.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Dobbin, F., D. Schrage, and A. Kalev. 2015. Rage against the iron cage: The varied effects of bureaucratic personnel reforms on diversity. American Sociological Review 80 (5): 1014–1044.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Duchêne, Alexandre, and Monica Heller, eds. 2012. Language in late capitalism: Pride and profit. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
  26. Elcioglu, E.F. 2010. Producing precarity: The temporary staffing agency in the labor market. Qualitative Sociology 33 (2): 117–136.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Ely, R.J., and D.A. Thomas. 2001. Cultural diversity at work: The effects of diversity perspectives on work group processes and outcomes. Administrative Science Quarterly 46 (2): 229–273.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Findlay, P., A. Kalleberg, and C. Warhurst. 2013. Understanding job quality. Human Relations 66 (4): 441–617.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Fotaki, Marianna, and Nancy Harding. 2017. Gender and the organization: Women at work in the 21st century. Abington: Routledge.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Gatrell, Caroline, Cary L. Cooper, and Ellen Ernst Kossek. 2017. Maternal bodies as taboo at work: New perspectives on the marginalizing of senior-level women in organizations. The Academy of Management Perspectives 31 (3): 239–252.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Håkansson, K., T. Isidorsson, and H. Kantelius. 2013. Stable flexibility: Long-term strategic use of temporary agency workers in Sweden. International Journal of Action Research 9 (3): 278–300.Google Scholar
  32. Hall, R. 2006. Temporary agency work and HRM in Australia: Cooperation, specialisation and satisfaction for the good of all? Personnel Review 35 (2): 158–174.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Hall, Alex, Jenny Hockey, and Victoria Robinson. 2007. Occupational cultures and the embodiment of masculinity: Hairdressing, estate agency and firefighting. Gender, Work and Organization 14 (6): 534–551.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  34. Hatton, E. 2014. Temporary weapons: Employers’ use of temps against organized labor. ILR Review 67 (1): 86–110.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Holvino, E. 2010. Intersections: The simultaneity of race, gender and class in organization studies. Gender, Work and Organization 17 (3): 248–277.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Hope, A. 2011. The body: A review and a theoretical perspective. In Handbook of gender, work and organization, ed. E.L. Jeanes, D. Knights, and P. Yancey Martin, 131–146. Chichester: Wiley.Google Scholar
  37. Houseman, S.N. 2001. Why employers use flexible staffing arrangements: Evidence from an establishment survey. ILR Review 55 (1): 149–170.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Janssens, M., and P. Zanoni. 2005. Many diversities for many services: Theorizing diversity (management) in service companies. Human Relations 58 (3): 311–340.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. Kalleberg, A.L. 2000. Nonstandard employment relations: Part-time, temporary and contract work. Annual Review of Sociology 26 (1): 341–365.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. ———. 2009. Precarious work, insecure workers: Employment relations in transition. American Sociological Review 74 (1): 1–22.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Kenny, K., and Emma Bell. 2011. Representing the successful managerial body. In Handbook of gender, work and organization, ed. E.L. Jeanes, D. Knights, and P. Yancey Martin, 163–176. Chichester: Wiley.Google Scholar
  42. Khazzoom, Aziza. 2003. The great chain of orientalism: Jewish identity, stigma management, and ethnic exclusion in Israel. American Sociological Review 68: 481–510.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. King, Judith, Noam Fischman, and Abraham Wolde-Tsadick. 2012. Twenty years later: A survey of Ethiopian immigrants who have lived in Israel for two decades or more. Jerusalem: Myers-JDC-Brookdale Institute (In Hebrew).Google Scholar
  44. King, D., S. Svensson, and Z. Wei. 2017. Not always a quick fix: The impact of employing temporary agency workers on retention in the Australian aged care workforce. Journal of Industrial Relations 59 (1): 85–103.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Kochan, T., K. Bezrukova, R. Ely, S. Jackson, A. Joshi, K. Jehn, J. Leonard, D. Levine, and D. Thomas. 2003. The effects of diversity on business performance: Report of the diversity research network. Human Resource Management 42 (1): 3–21.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Konrad, A.M., Y. Yang, and C.C. Maurer. 2016. Antecedents and outcomes of diversity and equality management systems: An integrated institutional agency and strategic human resource management approach. Human Resource Management 55 (1): 83–107.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. Locke, R.M., B.A. Rissing, and T. Pal. 2013. Complements or substitutes? Private codes, state regulation and the enforcement of labour standards in global supply chains. British Journal of Industrial Relations 51 (3): 519–552.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  48. McCall, L. 2005. The complexity of intersectionality. Signs 30: 1771–1800.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  49. McKay, S., and E. Markova. 2010. The operation and management of agency workers in conditions of vulnerability. Industrial Relations Journal 41 (5): 446–460.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. Meriläinen, S., J. Tienari, S. Katila, and Y. Benschop. 2009. Diversity management versus gender equality: The Finnish case. Canadian Journal of Administrative Sciences 26 (3): 230–243.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. Meriläinen, Susan, Janne Tienari, and Anu Valtonen. 2015. Headhunters and the ‘ideal’ executive body. Organization 22 (1): 3–22.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  52. Michel, Alexandra. 2011. Transcending socialization: A nine-year ethnography of the body’s role in organizational control and knowledge workers’ transformation. Administrative Science Quarterly 56 (3): 325–368.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. Mitlacher, L.W. 2007. The role of temporary agency work in different industrial relations systems—A comparison between Germany and the USA. British Journal of Industrial Relations 45 (3): 581–606.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  54. Mizrachi, Nissim, and Hanna Herzog. 2012. Participatory destigmatization strategies among Palestinian citizens, Ethiopian Jews and Mizrahi Jews in Israel. Ethnic and Racial Studies 35 (3): 418–435.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  55. Mundlak, Guy. 2017. Contradictions in Neoliberal reforms: The regulation of labor subcontracting. In Neoliberalism as a state project: Changing the political economy of Israel, ed. Asa Maron and Michael Shalev, 153–171. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  56. Nadiv, Ronit. 2005. Employment through labor force contractors in Israel, The state of Israel’s authority for labor force planning. Jerusalem: Ministry of Industry, Market and Employment. (In Hebrew)Google Scholar
  57. Nadiv, Ronit, Aviad Raz, and Shani Kuna. 2017. What a difference a role makes: Occupational and organizational characteristics related to HR strategic role among human resource managers. Employee Relations 39 (7): 1131–1147.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  58. Nagar-Ron, Sigal. 2014. Rethinking employment opportunities on the periphery: Employment opportunities of Mizrahi women in low status positions in a southern Israeli development town. Hagar: Studies in Culture, Polities and Identities 11 (2): 38–59 (In Hebrew).Google Scholar
  59. Nisim, Sarit, and Orly Benjamin. 2010. The speech of services procurement: The negotiated order of commodification and dehumanization of cleaning employees. Human Organization 69 (3): 221–232.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  60. Park, Joseph Sung-Yul. 2013. Metadiscursive regimes of diversity in a multinational corporation. Language in Society 42 (5): 557–577.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  61. Peck, J.A., and N. Theodore. 2002a. The temporary staffing industry: Growth imperatives and limits of contingency. Economic Geography 78: 463–493.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  62. ———. 2002b. Temped out? Industry rhetoric, labor regulation and economic restructuring in the temporary staffing business. Economic and Industrial Democracy 23: 143–175.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  63. ———. 2006. Flexible recession: The temporary staffing industry and mediated work in the United States. Cambridge Journal of Economics 31 (2): 1–22.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  64. Peck, J., N. Theodore, and K. Ward. 2005. Constructing markets for temporary labour: Employment liberalization and the internationalization of the staffing industry. Global Networks 5 (1): 3–26.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  65. Prasad, P., and A.J. Mills. 1997. From showcase to shadow. Understanding the dilemmas of managing workplace diversity. In Managing the organizational melting pot: Dilemmas of workplace diversity, ed. P. Prasad, A.J. Mills, M. Elmes, and A. Prasad, 3–27. Thousand Oaks: Sage.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  66. Pullen, Alison, and Ruth Simpson. 2009. Managing difference in feminized work: Men, otherness and social practice. Human Relations 62 (4): 561–587.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  67. Purser, G. 2006. Waiting for work: An ethnography of a day labor agency. Institute for the Study of Social Change.Google Scholar
  68. ———. 2012. Still doin’ time: Clamoring for work in the say labor industry. Journal of Labor and Society 15 (3): 397–415.Google Scholar
  69. Sharone, O. 2013a. Why do unemployed Americans blame themselves while Israelis blame the system? Social Forces 91 (4): 1429–1450.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  70. ———. 2013b. Flawed system/flawed self: Job searching and unemployment experiences. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  71. Shohat, Ella. 1999. The invention of the Mizrahim. Journal of Palestine Studies 29 (1): 5–20.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  72. Sliter, Y., and Judith King. 2014. Advancing workforce diversity in Israel. Jerusalem: JDC-Brookdale Institute In Hebrew.Google Scholar
  73. Smith, V., and E. Neuwirth. 2008. The good temp. Ithaca: ILR/Cornell University.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  74. Standing, Guy. 2016. The precariat: The new dangerous class. New York: Bloomsbury Publishing.Google Scholar
  75. Styhre, A. 2004. The (Re)embodied organization: Four perspectives on the body in organizations. Human Resource Development International 7 (1): 101–116.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  76. Swan, Elaine, and Steve Fox. 2010. Playing the game: Strategies of resistance and co-optation in diversity work. Gender, Work and Organization 17 (5): 567–589.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  77. Trethewey, Angela. 1999. Disciplined bodies: Women’s embodied identities at work. Organization Studies 20 (3): 423–450.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  78. van der Zee, K.I., and S. Otten. 2015. Organizational perspectives on diversity. In Towards inclusive organizations, ed. S. Otten, K.I. van der Zee, and M.B. Brewer, 29–48. London: Psychology Press/Taylor and Francis.Google Scholar
  79. Van Knippenberg, Daan, and Michaela C. Schippers. 2007. Work group diversity. Annual Review of Psychology 58: 515–541.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  80. Vosko, L. 2000. Temporary work: The gendered rise of a precarious employment relationship. Toronto: University of Toronto.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  81. Walby, S. 2009. Globalisation and inequalities: Complexity and contested modernities. London: Sage.Google Scholar
  82. Wasserman, Varda, and Michal Frenkel. 2015. Spatial work in between glass ceilings and glass walls: Gender-class intersectionality and organizational aesthetics. Organization Studies 36 (11): 1485–1505.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  83. Wilkin, C.L. 2013. I can’t get no job satisfaction: Meta-analysis comparing permanent and contingent workers. Journal of Organizational Behavior 34 (1): 47–64.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  84. Windscheid, L., L. Bowes-Sperry, D.L. Kidder, H.K. Cheung, M. Morner, and F. Lievens. 2016. Actions speak louder than words: Outsiders’ perceptions of diversity mixed messages. Journal of Applied Psychology 101 (9): 1329–1341.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  85. Zanoni, P., and M. Janssens. 2004. Deconstructing difference: The rhetoric of human resource managers’ diversity discourses. Organization Studies 25 (1): 55–74.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  86. ———. 2007. Minority employees engaging with (diversity) management: An analysis of control, agency, and micro-emancipation. Journal of Management Studies 44 (8): 1371–1397.Google Scholar
  87. Zanoni, P., M. Janssens, Y. Benschop, and S. Nkomo. 2010. Unpacking diversity, grasping inequality: Rethinking difference through critical perspectives. Organization 17 (1): 9–29.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© The Author(s) 2019

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Department of Human Resource Management StudiesSapir Academic CollegeSha’ar HanegevIsrael

Personalised recommendations