Foster Care as a Problem and a Solution

  • Sarah A. Font
  • Elizabeth T. Gershoff
Part of the SpringerBriefs in Psychology book series (BRIEFSPSYCHOL)


This chapter first describes how foster care, intended as a temporary but necessary solution for children who cannot safely remain at home, is increasingly described as a problem in and of itself rather than as a solution to a difficult problem. Specifically, we identify and address the primary criticisms levied against the foster care system by scholars, media, and the public, namely that (1) foster care is overused as an intervention; (2) foster care is harmful to children; and (3) racial and class bias affect decisions about the removal of children. We describe the philosophical frameworks that inform perspectives about foster care and then examine and discuss the empirical evidence pertinent to these arguments. We conclude that, although there are numerous ways in which the quality of the current foster care system could be improved, an objective review of relevant research does not validate the most critical claims about foster care.


Foster care Removal Family preservation Disproportionality Decision making Trauma 


  1. Administration for Children and Families. (2018). Information memorandum (No. ACYF-CB-IM-18-02). Retrieved from
  2. Administration for Children and Families. (2019). Find a program or service. Retrieved October 10, 2019, from Title IV-E Prevention Services Clearinghouse website:
  3. Adoption Assistance and Child Welfare Act. (1980). Pub. L. No. H.R. 3434, P.L. 96–272.Google Scholar
  4. Al, C. M. W., Stams, G. J. J. M., Bek, M. S., Damen, E. M., Asscher, J. J., & van der Laan, P. H. (2012). A meta-analysis of intensive family preservation programs: Placement prevention and improvement of family functioning. Children and Youth Services Review, 34(8), 1472–1479. Scholar
  5. Annie E. Casey Foundation. (2013). The kinship diversion debate: Policy and practice implications for children, families and child welfare agencies. Retrieved from
  6. Atewologun, D., Cornish, T., & Tresh, F. (2018). Unconscious bias training: An assessment of the evidence for effectiveness. Retrieved from Equality and Human Rights Commission website:
  7. Averdijk, M., Ribeaud, D., & Eisner, M. (2018). The long-term effects of out-of-home placement in late adolescence: A propensity score matching analysis among Swiss youths. Longitudinal and Life Course Studies, 9(1), 30–57. Scholar
  8. Bacon, H., & Richardson, S. (2001). Attachment theory and child abuse: An overview of the literature for practitioners. Child Abuse Review, 10(6), 377–397. Scholar
  9. Baer, J. C., & Martinez, C. D. (2006). Child maltreatment and insecure attachment: A meta-analysis. Journal of Reproductive and Infant Psychology, 24(3), 187–197. Scholar
  10. Bald, A., Chyn, E., Hastings, J. S., & Machelett, M. (2019). The causal impact of removing children from abusive and neglectful homes. National Bureau of Economic Research.Google Scholar
  11. Baldwin, H., Biehal, N., Cusworth, L., Wade, J., Allgar, V., & Vostanis, P. (2019). Disentangling the effect of out-of-home care on child mental health. Child Abuse & Neglect, 88, 189–200. Scholar
  12. Berger, L. M., Bruch, S. K., Johnson, E. I., James, S., & Rubin, D. (2009). Estimating the “impact” of out-of-home placement on child well-being: Approaching the problem of selection bias. Child Development, 80(6), 1856–1876. Scholar
  13. Berger, L. M., Cancian, M., Han, E., Noyes, J., & Rios-Salas, V. (2015). Children’s academic achievement and foster care. Pediatrics, 135(1), 109–116. Scholar
  14. Bernard, K., Butzin-Dozier, Z., Rittenhouse, J., & Dozier, M. (2010). Cortisol production patterns in young children living with birth parents vs children placed in foster care following involvement of child protective services. Archives of Pediatrics & Adolescent Medicine, 164(5), 438–443. Scholar
  15. Berrick, J. D., Young, C., D’Andrade, A. C., & Frame, L. (2008). Reasonable efforts? Implementation of the reunification exception provisions of ASFA. Child Welfare, 87(3), 163–184.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  16. Bipartisan Budget Act. (2018). Pub. L. No. 115–123, § Title VII: Family First Prevention Services Act.Google Scholar
  17. Bogolub, E. B. (2006). The impact of recruitment-generated bias on qualitative research interviews with foster children. Families in Society, 87(1), 140–143. Scholar
  18. Brook, J., & McDonald, T. (2009). The impact of parental substance abuse on the stability of family reunifications from foster care. Children and Youth Services Review, 31(2), 193–198. Scholar
  19. Brosschot, J. F., Verkuil, B., & Thayer, J. F. (2016). The default response to uncertainty and the importance of perceived safety in anxiety and stress: An evolution-theoretical perspective. Fearing the Unknown, 41, 22–34. Scholar
  20. Carlson, V., Cicchetti, D., Barnett, D., & Braunwald, K. (1989). Disorganized/disoriented attachment relationships in maltreated infants. Developmental Psychology, 25(4), 525.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Casanueva, C., Tueller, S., Dolan, M., Testa, M., Smith, K., & Day, O. (2015). Examining predictors of re-reports and recurrence of child maltreatment using two national data sources. Children and Youth Services Review, 48, 1–13. Scholar
  22. Chapman, M. V., Wall, A., & Barth, R. P. (2004). Children’s voices: The perceptions of children in foster care. American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 74(3), 293. Scholar
  23. Chenot, D. (2011). The vicious cycle: Recurrent interactions among the media, politicians, the public, and child welfare services organizations. Journal of Public Child Welfare, 5(2–3), 167–184. Scholar
  24. Child Trends. (2018, December 13). Racial and ethnic composition of the child population. Retrieved June 18, 2019, from Child Trends website:
  25. Child Welfare Information Gateway. (2012). Reasonable efforts to preserve or reunify families and achieve permanency for children. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Administration for Children and Families, Administration on Children, Youth, and Families, Children’s Bureau.Google Scholar
  26. Child Welfare Information Gateway. (2014). In-home services in child welfare (p. 13). Retrieved from U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Administration for Children and Families, Administration on Children, Youth and Families, Children’s Bureau website:
  27. Conn, A.-M., Szilagyi, M. A., Jee, S. H., Blumkin, A. K., & Szilagyi, P. G. (2015). Mental health outcomes among child welfare investigated children: In-home versus out-of-home care. Children and Youth Services Review, 57, 106–111. Scholar
  28. Connell, C. M., Bergeron, N., Katz, K. H., Saunders, L., & Tebes, J. K. (2007). Re-referral to child protective services: The influence of child, family, and case characteristics on risk status. Child Abuse & Neglect, 31(5), 573–588. Scholar
  29. Connell, C. M., Vanderploeg, J. J., Katz, K. H., Caron, C., Saunders, L., & Tebes, J. K. (2009). Maltreatment following reunification: Predictors of subsequent child protective services contact after children return home. Child Abuse & Neglect, 33(4), 218–228. Scholar
  30. Cummings, K. (2016). The impact of foster care on depression: An examination of placement type and mental health service utilization among children and adolescents. New York: City University of New York.Google Scholar
  31. Davidson-Arad, B., Englechin-Segal, D., & Wozner, Y. (2003). Short-term follow-up of children at risk: Comparison of the quality of life of children removed from home and children remaining at home. Child Abuse & Neglect, 27(7), 733–750. Scholar
  32. Debowska, A., Willmott, D., Boduszek, D., & Jones, A. D. (2017). What do we know about child abuse and neglect patterns of co-occurrence? A systematic review of profiling studies and recommendations for future research. Child Abuse & Neglect, 70, 100–111. Scholar
  33. Dewan, S. (2018, November 2). Family separation: It’s a problem for U.S. citizens, too. The New York Times. Retrieved from
  34. Dolan, M., Casanueva, C., Smith, K., Day, O., & Dowd, K. (2014). Child abuse and neglect re-reports: Combining and comparing data from two national sources. Children and Youth Services Review, 47, 323–333. Scholar
  35. Dolan, M., Smith, K., Casanueva, C., & Ringeisen, H. (2011). NSCAW II baseline report: Introduction to NSCAW II final report (OPRE Report 2011-27a). Washington, DC: Office of Planning, Research and Evaluation, Administration for Children and Families, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.Google Scholar
  36. Doyle, J. J., Jr. (2007). Child protection and child outcomes: Measuring the effects of foster care. American Economic Review, 97(5), 1583–1610. Scholar
  37. Doyle, J. J., Jr. (2008). Child protection and adult crime: Using investigator assignment to estimate causal effects of foster care. Journal of Political Economy, 116(4), 746–770. Scholar
  38. Dozier, M., Lindhiem, O., Lewis, E., Bick, J., Bernard, K., & Peloso, E. (2009). Effects of a foster parent training program on young children’s attachment behaviors: Preliminary evidence from a randomized clinical trial. Child and Adolescent Social Work Journal, 26, 321–332. Scholar
  39. Drake, B., & Jonson-Reid, M. (2011). NIS interpretations: Race and the national incidence studies of child abuse and neglect. Children and Youth Services Review, 33(1), 16–20. Scholar
  40. Drake, B., & Zuravin, S. (1998). Bias in child maltreatment reporting: Revisiting the myth of classlessness. American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 68(2), 295–304. Scholar
  41. Dunn, D. M., Culhane, S. E., & Taussig, H. N. (2010). Children’s appraisals of their experiences in out-of-home care. Children and Youth Services Review, 32(10), 1324–1330. Scholar
  42. Eamon, M. K., & Kopels, S. (2004). ‘For reasons of poverty’: Court challenges to child welfare practices and mandated programs. Children and Youth Services Review, 26(9), 821–836. Scholar
  43. Ehrenfreund, M. (2015). The bipartisan plan to save foster care. The Washington Post. Retrieved from
  44. Fein, E. (1991). Issues in foster family care: Where do we stand? American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 61(4), 578–583. Scholar
  45. Fernandez, E. (2007). Unravelling emotional, behavioural and educational outcomes in a longitudinal study of children in foster-care. British Journal of Social Work, 38(7), 1283–1301. Scholar
  46. Fluke, J. D. (2009). Allegory of the cave: On the theme of substantiation. Child Maltreatment, 14(1), 69–72. Scholar
  47. Fluke, J. D., Shusterman, G. R., Hollinshead, D. M., & Yuan, Y.-Y. T. (2008). Longitudinal analysis of repeated child abuse reporting and victimization: Multistate analysis of associated factors. Child Maltreatment, 13(1), 76–88. Scholar
  48. Folman, R. D. (1998). “I was tooken”: How children experience removal from their parents preliminary to placement into foster care. Adoption Quarterly, 2(2), 7–35. Scholar
  49. Font, S. A., Cancian, M., & Berger, L. M. (2019). Prevalence and risk factors for early motherhood among low-income, maltreated, and foster youth. Demography, 56, 261–284. Scholar
  50. Font, S. A., & Maguire-Jack, K. (2019). The organizational context of substantiation in child protective services cases. Journal of Interpersonal Violence. Advance online publication.
  51. Franck Meyer, A. (2019). The human need for belonging: Moving from harm to healing. Plenary Session presented at the 2019 National Conference on Child Abuse and Neglect. Retrieved from
  52. Goemans, A., van Geel, M., & Vedder, P. (2015). Over three decades of longitudinal research on the development of foster children: A meta-analysis. Child Abuse & Neglect, 42, 121–134. Scholar
  53. Goldsmith, D. F., Oppenheim, D., & Wanlass, J. (2004). Separation and reunification: Using attachment theory and research to inform decisions affecting the placements of children in foster care. Juvenile and Family Court Journal, 55(2), 1–13. Scholar
  54. Goldstein, J., Freud, A., Solnit, A. J., & Goldstein, S. (1986). In the best interests of the child. New York: The Free Press.Google Scholar
  55. Graham, J. C., Stepura, K., Baumann, D. J., & Kern, H. (2010). Predicting child fatalities among less-severe CPS investigations. Children and Youth Services Review, 32(2), 274–280. Scholar
  56. Gross, M. (2019). Temporary stays and persistent gains: The causal effects of foster care. Unpublished manuscript, Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan.Google Scholar
  57. Heimpel, D. (2018, April 12). Inside game: How foster care was changed forever. The American Prospect. Retrieved from
  58. Hélie, S., & Bouchard, C. (2010). Recurrent reporting of child maltreatment: State of knowledge and avenues for research. Children and Youth Services Review, 32(3), 416–422. Scholar
  59. Hildyard, K. L., & Wolfe, D. A. (2002). Child neglect: Developmental issues and outcomes. Child Abuse & Neglect, 26(6–7), 679–695. Scholar
  60. Horwitz, S. M., Balestracci, K. M., & Simms, M. D. (2001). Foster care placement improves children’s functioning. Archives of Pediatrics & Adolescent Medicine, 155(11), 1255–1260. Scholar
  61. Horwitz, S. M., Hurlburt, M. S., Cohen, S. D., Zhang, J., & Landsverk, J. (2011). Predictors of placement for children who initially remained in their homes after an investigation for abuse or neglect. Child Abuse & Neglect, 35(3), 188–198. Scholar
  62. Hughes, R. C., & Rycusa, J. S. (2006). Issues in risk assessment in child protective services. Journal of Public Child Welfare, 1(1), 85–116. Scholar
  63. Hussey, J. M., Marshall, J. M., English, D. J., Knight, E. D., Lau, A. S., Dubowitz, H., & Kotch, J. B. (2005). Defining maltreatment according to substantiation: Distinction without a difference? Child Abuse & Neglect, 29(5), 479–492. Scholar
  64. Jagannathan, R., & Camasso, M. J. (2017). Social outrage and organizational behavior: A national study of child protective service decisions. Children and Youth Services Review, 77, 153–163. Scholar
  65. James, B. (1994). Handbook for treatment of attachment-trauma problems in children. New York: Simon and Schuster.Google Scholar
  66. Johnson, P. R., Yoken, C., & Voss, R. (1995). Family foster care placement: The child’s perspective. Child Welfare, 74(5), 959–968.Google Scholar
  67. Jonson-Reid, M. (2003). Foster care and future risk of maltreatment. Children and Youth Services Review, 25(4), 271–294. Scholar
  68. Jonson-Reid, M., Chung, S., Way, I., & Jolley, J. (2010). Understanding service use and victim patterns associated with re-reports of alleged maltreatment perpetrators. Children and Youth Services Review, 32(6), 790–797. Scholar
  69. Jonson-Reid, M., Drake, B., & Kohl, P. L. (2009). Is the overrepresentation of the poor in child welfare caseloads due to bias or need? Children and Youth Services Review, 31, 422–427. Scholar
  70. Jonson-Reid, M., Drake, B., Kohl, P., Guo, S., Brown, D., McBride, T., … Lewis, E. (2017). What do we really know about usual care child protective services? Children and Youth Services Review, 82, 222–229. Scholar
  71. Kim, H., & Drake, B. (2019). Cumulative prevalence of onset and recurrence of child maltreatment reports. Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, 58, 1175–1183. Scholar
  72. Kimberlin, S. E., Anthony, E. K., & Austin, M. J. (2009). Re-entering foster care: Trends, evidence, and implications. Children and Youth Services Review, 31(4), 471–481. Scholar
  73. Klevens, J., & Leeb, R. T. (2010). Child maltreatment fatalities in children under 5: Findings from the National Violence Death Reporting System. Child Abuse & Neglect, 34(4), 262–266. Scholar
  74. Lee, B. R., & Cosgrove, J. A. (2018). The role of care coordination and out-of-home placement in youth dental and vision care visits. International Journal of Social Welfare, 27(4), 388–396. Scholar
  75. Lindquist, M. J., & Santavirta, T. (2014). Does placing children in foster care increase their adult criminality? Labour Economics, 31, 72–83. Scholar
  76. Lindsey, D. (1991). Factors affecting the foster care placement decision: An analysis of national survey data. American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 61(2), 272–281. Scholar
  77. Lindsey, D. (1994). Family preservation and child protection: Striking a balance. Special Double Issue Family Preservation and Child Protection: Striking a Balance, 16(5), 279–294. Scholar
  78. Lindsey, D., Martin, S., & Doh, J. (2002). The failure of intensive casework services to reduce foster care placements: An examination of family preservation studies. Children and Youth Services Review, 24(9), 743–775. Scholar
  79. Lipien, L., & Forthofer, M. S. (2004). An event history analysis of recurrent child maltreatment reports in Florida. Child Abuse & Neglect, 28(9), 947–966. Scholar
  80. Maclean, M. J., Taylor, C. L., & O’Donnell, M. (2018). Out-of-home care and the educational achievement, attendance, and suspensions of maltreated children: A propensity-matched study. The Journal of Pediatrics, 198, 287–293. Scholar
  81. Maguire-Jack, K., Font, S. A., & Dillard, R. (2020). Child protective services decision-making: The role of children’s race and county factors. American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 90(1), 48–62. Scholar
  82. Malm, K., & Allen, T. (2016). A qualitative research study of kinship diversion practices. Washington, DC: Child Trends.Google Scholar
  83. Mann, J. (1990). Fostering common sense. The Washington Post (1974-Current File), D3.Google Scholar
  84. Mitchell, M. B., & Kuczynski, L. (2010). Does anyone know what is going on? Examining children’s lived experience of the transition into foster care. Children and Youth Services Review, 32(3), 437–444. Scholar
  85. Mitchell, M. B., Kuczynski, L., Tubbs, C. Y., & Ross, C. (2010). We care about care: Advice by children in care for children in care, foster parents and child welfare workers about the transition into foster care. Child & Family Social Work, 15(2), 176–185. Scholar
  86. Norman, R. E., Byambaa, M., De, R., Butchart, A., Scott, J., & Vos, T. (2012). The long-term health consequences of child physical abuse, emotional abuse, and neglect: A systematic review and meta-analysis. PLoS Medicine, 9(11), e1001349. Scholar
  87. Palusci, V. J., & Covington, T. M. (2014). Child maltreatment deaths in the US national child death review case reporting system. Child Abuse & Neglect, 38(1), 25–36. Scholar
  88. Pelton, L. H. (1978). Child abuse and neglect: The myth of classlessness. American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 48(4), 608–617. Scholar
  89. Pelton, L. H. (2015). The continuing role of material factors in child maltreatment and placement. Child Abuse & Neglect, 41, 30–39. Scholar
  90. Pew Research Center. (2013, September 4). At grandmother’s house we stay. Retrieved May 30, 2019, from
  91. Pryce, J., Lee, W., Crowe, E., Park, D., McCarthy, M., & Owens, G. (2019). A case study in public child welfare: County-level practices that address racial disparity in foster care placement. Journal of Public Child Welfare, 13(1), 35–59. Scholar
  92. Putnam-Hornstein, E., Simon, J. D., Eastman, A. L., & Magruder, J. (2015). Risk of re-reporting among infants who remain at home following alleged maltreatment. Child Maltreatment, 20(2), 92–103. Scholar
  93. Raz, M., & Sankaran, V. (2019). Opposing family separation policies for the welfare of children. American Journal of Public Health, 109(11), 1529–1530. Scholar
  94. Roberts, D. E. (2012). Prison, foster care, and the systemic punishment of black mothers. UCLA Law Review, 59, 1474–1501.Google Scholar
  95. Roberts, K. (2019). Foster care and child welfare (Dissertation, Clemson University). Retrieved from
  96. Rolock, N. (2011). Trends in Illinois’ child welfare system: A 25 year retrospective, 1985 to 2010. Retrieved from University of Illinois at Chicago, Jane Addams College of Social Work, Child Welfare Research Collaborative website:
  97. Sankaran, V. (2017). Timely permanency or unnecessary removal? Tips for advocates for children who spend less than 30 days in foster care. Retrieved from American Bar Association website:
  98. Sedlak, A. J., McPherson, K., & Das, B. (2010). Supplementary analyses of race differences in child maltreatment rates in the NIS-4.
  99. Sedlak, A. J., Mettenburg, J., Basena, M., Peta, I., McPherson, K., Greene, A., & Li, S. (2010). Fourth national incidence study of child abuse and neglect (NIS-4). Washington, DC: US Department of Health and Human Services.Google Scholar
  100. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. (2019). Child maltreatment 2017 (p. 261). Washington, DC: Author, Administration for Children and Families, Administration on Children, Youth and Families, Children’s Bureau.Google Scholar
  101. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Administration for Children and Families. (2018). State requirements for electing Title IV-E prevention and family services and programs (No. ACYF-CB-PI-18-09). Retrieved from
  102. Wexler, R. (2019, May 23). Little AJ Freund’s horrific death is not an argument for tearing up more families. Chicago Sun-Times. Retrieved from
  103. Whiting, J. B., & Lee, R. E. (2003). Voices from the system: A qualitative study of foster children’s stories. Family Relations, 52(3), 288–295. Scholar
  104. Wildeman, C., & Emanuel, N. (2014). Cumulative risks of foster care placement by age 18 for US children, 2000–2011. PLoS One, 9(3), e92785. Scholar
  105. Wilson, L., & Conroy, J. (2001). Satisfaction of children in out-of-home care. In K. Barbell & L. M. Wright (Eds.), Family foster care in the next century (pp. 53–67). New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Publishers.Google Scholar
  106. Zajac, L., Raby, K. L., & Dozier, M. (2019). Receptive vocabulary development of children placed in foster care and children who remained with birth parents after involvement with child protective services. Child Maltreatment, 24(1), 107–112. Scholar

Copyright information

© The Author(s), under exclusive license to Springer Nature Switzerland AG 2020

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Department of Sociology and CriminologyPennsylvania State UniversityUniversity ParkUSA
  2. 2.Department of Human Development and Family SciencesUniversity of Texas at AustinAustinUSA

Personalised recommendations