Advertisement

Responding to Health Emergencies: The Ethical and Legal Considerations for Militaries

  • Adam Kamradt-ScottEmail author
Chapter
Part of the International Library of Ethics, Law, and the New Medicine book series (LIME, volume 82)

Abstract

The twenty-first century has already witnessed a number of public health emergencies of international concern. Current indications suggest this trend is set to continue. Traditionally, health crises have resulted in a different set of actors responding to the event than if it is declared a humanitarian disaster, and vice versa. The 2014 Ebola outbreak in West Africa blurred these boundaries though, as the event proved to be both a public health crisis as well as a humanitarian disaster. In an unprecedented move, during the outbreak over 5000 foreign military personnel were deployed to assist civilian authorities contain the spread of the virus, build treatment facilities, train health workers, and provide medical care, while domestic military forces were engaged to enforce quarantine, provide protection, and in some instances, assist with burials. The involvement of military personnel in a health emergency has generated concern amongst some communities though that it is yet further evidence of the “militarisation” of humanitarian assistance, while some militaries have since indicated they would be prepared to assist in future health emergencies. This chapter examines the ethical and legal issues arising from the involvement of military personnel in health emergencies. Drawing on work undertaken on civil-military cooperation in humanitarian disaster contexts, the chapter considers the extent to which health crises are qualitatively different from other disasters and what this may mean for the involvement of military personnel and other actors. It explores questions around the types of activities military personnel can be expected to perform and whether these differ between foreign or domestic militaries, how militaries conduct themselves during health emergencies, as well as the limits of military assistance.

Keywords

Military assistance Ebola Militarisation Humanitarian assistance 

References

  1. Adams G, Murray S (2014) Mission creep: the militarisation of US foreign policy? Georgetown University Press, Washington, DCGoogle Scholar
  2. Anderson JN, Nevin RL (2016) Prohibiting direct medical care by US military personnel in foreign disaster relief: arguments from the Ebola disaster. Med Confl Surviv 32(1):14–20Google Scholar
  3. Ansorge JT, Barkawi T (2016) Military manuels. In: Salter MB (ed) Making things international 2: Catalysts and reactions. University of Minnesota Press, MinnesotaGoogle Scholar
  4. Asgary R, Junck E (2013) New trends of short-term humanitarian medical volunteerism: professional and ethical considerations. J Med Ethics 39(10):625–631Google Scholar
  5. Bailey M, Beaton K, Bowley D, Eardley W, Hunt P, Johnson S, Round J, Tarmey N, Williams A (2016) Bending the curve: force health protection during the insertion phase of the Ebola outbreak response. J R Army Med Corps 162(3):191–197Google Scholar
  6. Barberis D (2003) In search of an object: organicist sociology and the reality of society in fin-de-siecle Francw. Hist Hum Sci 16(3):51–72Google Scholar
  7. Barnett M (2011) Empire of humanity: a history of humanitarianism. Cornell University Press, IthacaGoogle Scholar
  8. Barnett M (2016) The humanitarian act: how humanitarian? Int Soc Sci J 65(215–216):13–24Google Scholar
  9. Benatar SR, Upshur R (2008) Dual loyalty of physicians in the military and in civilian life. Am J Public Health 98(12):2161–2167Google Scholar
  10. Bernard KW (2013) Health and national security: a contemporary collision of cultures. Biosecur Bioterror 11(2):157–162Google Scholar
  11. Boon KE (2016) The United Nations as good samaritan: immunity and responsibility. Chic J Int Law 16(2):341–385Google Scholar
  12. Bricknell MC, Gadd RDM (2007) Roles for international military medical services in stability operations (reconstruction and development). J R Army Med Corps 153(3):160–164Google Scholar
  13. Bricknell MC, Hodgetts T, Beaton K, McCourt A (2015) Operation GRITROCK: the defence medical services’ story and emerging lessons from supporting the UK response to the Ebola crisis. J R Army Med Corps 162(3):169–175Google Scholar
  14. Burkle FM (2013) Throwing the baby out with the bathwater: can the military’s role in global health crises be redeemed? Prehospital Disaster Med 28(3):197–199Google Scholar
  15. Butler D (2014) Ebola drug trials set to begin amid crisis. Nature 513(7516):13–14Google Scholar
  16. Byleveld PM, Kent M, McCall BJ (2005) Operation Sumatra Assist: post-tsunami environmental and public health response in Banda Aceh. ADF Health 6(October):48–53Google Scholar
  17. Calcagno D (2016) Killing Ebola: the militarisation of US aid to Liberia. J Afr Stud Dev 8(7):88–97Google Scholar
  18. Cassese A (1998) On the current trends towards criminal prosecution of breaches of international humanitarian law. Eur J Int Law 9(1):2–17Google Scholar
  19. Cassese A (2005) International law, 2nd edn. Oxford University Press, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  20. Chretien J-P (2011) US military global health engagement since 9/11: seeking stability through health. Glob Health Gov 4(2):1–12Google Scholar
  21. Cornyn DK (2008) The military, freedom of speech, and the internet: preserving operational security and service members’ right of free speech. Tex Law Rev 87:463–486Google Scholar
  22. Crack A (2016) Reversing the telescope: evaluating NGO peer regulation initiatives. J Int Dev 28(1):40–56Google Scholar
  23. Davies S, Rushton S (2016) Public health emergencies: a new peacekeeping mission? Insights from UNMIL’s role in the Liberia Ebola outbreak. Third World Q 37(3):419–435Google Scholar
  24. Diehl G, Bradstreet N, Monahan F (2016) The department of defense at the forefront of a global health emergency response: lessons learned from the Ebola outbreak. Health Secur 14(5):366–374Google Scholar
  25. Fauci A (2014) Ebola—underscoring the global disparities in health care resources. N Engl J Med 371(12):1084–1086Google Scholar
  26. Frangonikolopoulos C (2005) Non-governmental organisations and humanitarian action: the need for a viable change of praxis and ethos. Glob Soc 19(1):49–72Google Scholar
  27. Geale S (2012) The ethics of disaster management. Disaster Prev Manag 21(4):445–462Google Scholar
  28. Gordon S (2010) The United Kingdom’s stabilisation model and Afghanistan: the impact on humanitarian actors. Disasters 34(S3):S368–S387Google Scholar
  29. Gordon S (2014) The military physician and contested medical humanitarianism: a dueling identity? Soc Sci Med 120(November):421–429Google Scholar
  30. Gronke P, Feaver PD (2001) Uncertain confidence: civilian and military attitudes about civil-military relations. In: Feaver PD, Kohn RH (eds) Soldiers and civilians: the civil-military gap and American National Security. Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs, Cambridge, MAGoogle Scholar
  31. Heaslip G, Barber E (2014) Using the military in disaster relief: systemising challenges and opportunities. J Humanit Logist Supply Chain Manag 4(1):60–81Google Scholar
  32. IARAN (2017) The future of aid INGOs in 2030. In: Fraser L (ed) Institut de relations internationales et Stratégiques, ParisGoogle Scholar
  33. IASC (2011a) Civil-military coordination during humanitarian health action. In: Inter-agency Standing Committee Global Health Cluster. United Nations, GenevaGoogle Scholar
  34. IASC (2011b) Civil-military coordination during humanitarian health action. In: Inter-agency Standing Committee Global Health Cluster. United Nations, Geneva, p 9Google Scholar
  35. JCOA (2016) Operation united assistance: the DOD response to Ebola in West Africa. Joint and Coalition Operational Analysis, Virginia, p 26Google Scholar
  36. Kamradt-Scott A, Harman S, Wenham C, Smith Frank (2015) Saving lives: the civil-military response to the 2014 Ebola outbreak in West Africa. University of Sydney, SydneyGoogle Scholar
  37. Karadag O, Hakan K (2012) Ethical dilemmas in disaster medicine. Iran Red Crescent Med J 14(10):602–612Google Scholar
  38. Katz IT, Wright AA (2004) Collateral damage—médecins sans frontières leaves Afghanistan and Iraq. N Engl J Med 351(25):2571–2573Google Scholar
  39. Kinlaw K, Barrett D, Levine R (2009) Ethical guidelines in pandemic influenza: recommendations of the ethics subcommittee of the advisory committee of the director, centers for disease control and prevention. Disaster Med Public Health Prep 3(S2):S185–S192Google Scholar
  40. Krause M (2014) The good project: humanitarian relief NGOs and the fragmentation of reason. University of Chicago Press, ChicagoGoogle Scholar
  41. Lane C, Marston H, Fauci A (2016) Conducting clinical trials in outbreak settings: points to consider. Clin Trials 13(1):92–95Google Scholar
  42. Licina Derek (2012) The military sector’s role in global health: historical context and future direction. Glob Health Gov 6(1):1–30Google Scholar
  43. Lischer SK (2007) Military intervention and the humanitarian “force multiplier”. Glob Gov 13(1):99–118Google Scholar
  44. Liu Z, Liu Y, Liu X, Kang P, Xue C, Zhang L (2014) The lessons learned from disaster medical relief of Chinese military medical service. Int Rev Armed Forces Med Serv 87(4):33–41Google Scholar
  45. London L, Rubenstein LS, Baldwin-Ragaven L, Van Es A (2006) Dual loyalty among military health professionals: human rights and ethics in times of armed conflict. Camb Q Healthc Ethics 15(4):381–391Google Scholar
  46. Lu Y, Rong G, Yu SP, Sun Z, Duan X, Dong Z, Xia H, Zhan N, Jin C, Ji J, Duan Huijuan (2016) Chinese military medical teams in the Ebola outbreak of Sierra Leone. J R Army Med Corps 162(3):198–202Google Scholar
  47. Lugo K, Searing E (2014) The impact of situational factors on forum choice and criminal justice system development in Bangladesh. Emory Int Law Rev 29(2):327–378Google Scholar
  48. Lum T, Margesson R (2014) Typhoon Haiyan (Yolanda): US and international response to Philippines disaster. Curr Polit Econ South Southeast Cent Asia 23(2):209–246Google Scholar
  49. Madiwale A, Virk K (2011) Civil-military relations in natural disasters: a case study of the 2010 Pakistan floods. Int Rev Red Cross 93(884):1085–1105Google Scholar
  50. Margesson R (2013) International crises and disasters: US humanitarian assistance response mechanisms. Congressional Research Service, Washington, DCGoogle Scholar
  51. Marion D, Charlebois PB, Kao R (2016) The healthcare workers’ clinical skill set requirements for a uniformed international response to the Ebola virus disease outbreak in West Africa: the Canadian perspective. J R Army Med Corps 162(3):207–211Google Scholar
  52. Martins MS (1995) “War Crimes” during operations other than war: military doctrine and law fifty years after Nuremberg—and beyond. Mil Law Rev 149:145–187Google Scholar
  53. McInnes C, Rushton S (2014) Health for health’s sake, winning for God’s sake: US global health diplomacy and smart power in Iraq and Afghanistan. Rev Int Stud 40(5):835–857Google Scholar
  54. Meron T (1996) The continuing role of custom in the formation of international humanitarian law. Am J Int Law 90(2):238–249Google Scholar
  55. Miller LL (1999) From adversaries to allies: relief workers’ attitudes toward the US military. Qual Sociol 22(3):181–197Google Scholar
  56. Narli N (2000) Civil-military relations in Turkey. Turk Stud 1(1):107–127Google Scholar
  57. OCHA (2012) OCHA on message: humanitarian principles. United Nations, New York, p 1Google Scholar
  58. Olsthoorn P, Bollen M (2013) Civilian care in war: lessons from Afghanistan. In: Gross ML, Carrick D (eds) Military medical ethics for the 21st century. Ashgate, SurreyGoogle Scholar
  59. Ralph G (1944) American experience with military government. Am Hist Rev 49(4):630–643Google Scholar
  60. Rid A, Emanuel E (2014) Ethical considerations of experimental interventions in the Ebola outbreak. Lancet 384(9957):1896–1899Google Scholar
  61. Robson P, Lenze A, Dastoor N, Dickinson J, Rich C (2017) Setting the theater the army service component command way: a humanitarian response to the Ebola epidemic in Liberia. Army Lawyer 2017(2):18–43Google Scholar
  62. Sarigil Z (2009) Deconstructing the Turkish military’s popularity. Armed Forces Soc 35(4):709–727Google Scholar
  63. Sayburn A (2014) WHO gives go ahead for experimental treatments to be used in Ebola outbreak. BMJ 349:g5161Google Scholar
  64. Schmidt Ulf (2013) Accidents and experiments: Nazi chemical warfare research and medical ethics during the second World War. In: Gross ML, Carrick D (eds) Military medical ethics for the 21st century. Ashgate, SurreyGoogle Scholar
  65. Sesay JB (2015) Government to continue building RSLAF’s capacity to the highest level of professionalism-VP Foh. In: Shaw IS (ed) ExpoTimes, BristolGoogle Scholar
  66. Sidel V, Levy B (2003) Physician-soldier: a moral dilemma. In: Beam TE, Sparacino LR (eds) Military medical ethics, vol 1. TMM Publications, Washington, DC, p 312Google Scholar
  67. Smith T (2002) Moral hazard and humanitarian law: the international criminal court and the limits of legalism. Int Polit 39(2):175–192Google Scholar
  68. Tatham P, Rietjens S (2016) Integrated disaster relief logistics: a stepping stone towards viable civil-military networks? Disasters 40(1):7–25Google Scholar
  69. Tong J (2004) Questionable accountability: MSF and sphere in 2003. Disasters 28(2):176–189Google Scholar
  70. Trump DH (2002) Force health protection: 10 years of lessons learned by the department of defense. Mil Med 167(3):179–185Google Scholar
  71. UN (2006) Guidelines on the use of military and civil defence assets to support united nations humanitarian activities in complex emergencies. United Nations, Geneva, p 3Google Scholar
  72. UN (2007) Oslo guidelines: Guidelines on the use of foreign military and civil defence assets in disaster relief. United Nations, GenevaGoogle Scholar
  73. UN (2015) UN-CMCoord field handbook. United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs, GenevaGoogle Scholar
  74. Ungar M (2013) The rot within: security and corruption in Latin America. Soc Res: Int Q 80(4):1187–1212Google Scholar
  75. Venables E, Pellecchia U (2017) Introduction: engaging anthropology in an Ebola outbreak: case studies from West Africa. Anthropol Action 24(2):1–8Google Scholar
  76. Wilson RL (2009) Disasters and conflict zones around the world: the roles and relationships of the military and nongovernmental organisations. In: Gaist PA (ed) Igniting the power of community: the role of CBOs and NGOs in global public health. Springer, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  77. Winslow D (2002) Strange bedfellows: NGOs and the military in humanitarian crises. Int J Peace Stud 7(2):35–55Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Nature Switzerland AG 2020

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Centre for International Security StudiesUniversity of SydneySydneyAustralia

Personalised recommendations