Advertisement

Transparency in the Insurance Contract Law of the Western Balkans

  • Nikola Filipović
Chapter
  • 13 Downloads
Part of the AIDA Europe Research Series on Insurance Law and Regulation book series (ERSILR, volume 2)

Abstract

The concept and notion of transparency is relatively new in insurance (contract) law. The idea of transparency is penetrating Serbian law from the relevant EU regulations in this field, and most Serbian laws do not explicitly mention transparency as a concept. However, as transparency is understood as clarity and comprehensibility of the contract, a number of general provisions might apply to this end. Transparency and disclosure duties in particular have been analyzed extensively from comparative perspective. As potential candidates for membership in the EU, Serbia and Montenegro launched negotiation process, while Bosnia & Herzegovina signed Stabilization and Association Agreement, which is a first step in the process that entails harmonization with EU acquis. As such, the concept of transparency on the EU level will without doubt largely influence the development of the concept in the jurisdictions covered by the chapter. Additional problem might be that even on the EU level, especially in the EU secondary legislation, there are some inconsistencies in the use of the expression. Transparency is sometimes described as the goal to be achieved, while sometimes it is defined as a tool to achieve the goal, i.e., consumer protection. Until the countries embarked on the process of harmonization of law as part of the EU accession aspiration, there were no explicit pre-contractual information duties for the insurers in Insurance Law, and very limited duties of the insurer under Contract Law.

References

  1. Antić O (2008) Obligaciono Pravo, 2nd edn. Pravni fakultet Univerziteta u BeogradGoogle Scholar
  2. Antić O (2012) Moral (Etika) u Građanskom Pravu. In: Marković-Dijalović D (eds) Harmonizacija građanskog prava u regionu. Pravni Fakultet Univerziteta u Istočnom SarajevuGoogle Scholar
  3. Antonijević Z (1974) Privredno pravno, 5th edn. Savremena Administracija, BeogradGoogle Scholar
  4. Bartoš M, Antonijević Z, Jovanović V (1974) Menično i čekovno pravo. Privredni Pregled, BeogradGoogle Scholar
  5. Benjamin J (2010) Narratives of financial law. Oxf J Legal Stud 30(4):787–814CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Đurović M (2013) General prohibition of unfair business practices under Serbian law. In: Bourgoignie T, Jovanić T (eds) Strengthening consumer protection in Serbia. Pravni fakultet Univerzitet u Beogradu, BeogradGoogle Scholar
  7. Golubović B, Stojković L, Pavlović B (2015) Vodič za primenu zakona o osiguranju. DIS Public, BeogradGoogle Scholar
  8. Hesselink WM (1995) The new European private law – essays on the future of private law in Europe. Kluwer Law InternationalGoogle Scholar
  9. Jankovec I (1980) Ugovor o Osiguranju. In: Perović S, Stojanović D (eds) Komentar Zakona o Obligacionim odnosima. Pravni Fakultet u KragujevcuGoogle Scholar
  10. Karanikić M, Miklitz H-W, Reich N (2012) Modernising consumer law – the experience of the Western Balkan. NomosGoogle Scholar
  11. Mekšić Z (2010) Bosnia and Herzegovina legislative techniques. In: Civil law forum for South East Europe, Collection of studies and Analyses First Regional Conference, CavtatGoogle Scholar
  12. Nikolić D (2010) Influence of distinguished lawyers on the development of law in the European Union and Serbia. In: Private law reform in South East Europe, Liber Amicorum Christa Jessel-Holst. University of Belgrade, Faculty of Law, BelgradeGoogle Scholar
  13. Obradović L (2016) Swiss Franc Loans and the development of the EU’s current consumer protection framework. In: Hojnik J, Orešek N (eds) Strengthening the rule of law in the EU. MariborGoogle Scholar
  14. Petrović TN (2013) Investment based life insurance. Anali Pravnog Fakulteta u Beogradu, 1Google Scholar
  15. Petrović TN (2015) Zaštita potrošača usluga osiguranja. Pravni Fakultet Univerziteta u Beogradu, BeogradGoogle Scholar
  16. Petrović Z, Čolović V, Knežević D (2013) History of Insurance in Serbia, Montenegro and Yugoslavia until 1941. Dosije, BeogradGoogle Scholar
  17. Slavnić J (2012) Predlog tema za javnu raspravu o rešenjima koja nisu prihvaćena u prednacrtu Građanskog zakonika Republike Srbije u odnosu na ugovor o osiguranju. Eur Insur Law Rev, 1Google Scholar
  18. Slavnić J (2014a) New areas and rules of contract interpretation in favour of one contract party in the insurance contract – contribution to the consultation on insurance contract regulation in the Draft Civil Code of Serbia. In: Jovanović S, Marano P, Žarković N (eds) Modern insurance law current trends and issues. Udruženje za pravo osiguranja Srbije, BeogradGoogle Scholar
  19. Slavnić J (2014b) Transparentnost provizije brokera osiguranja u evropskom pravu. Pravni Život, 11Google Scholar
  20. Slavnić J (2016) Udruženje za pravo osiguranja Srbije je rodna kuća predloga rešenja kojima se reformiše ugovor o osiguranju u prednacrtu Građanskog zakonika Republike Srbije. Eur Insur Law Rev, 4Google Scholar
  21. Slavnić J, Filipović N (2015) Transparentno informisanje i savetovanje prema kupca osiguranja od strane posrednika osiguranja prema nacrtu Direktive o distribuciji osiguranja. In: Jovanović S, Slavnić J, Marano P (eds) Pravo osiguranja, uprava i transparentnost – osnove pravne sigurnosti. Udruženje za pravo osiguranja Srbije, Gesamtverband der Deutschen Versicherungswirtschaft e.V, BeogradGoogle Scholar
  22. Slavnić J, Jovanović S (2008) Obaveza davanja predugovornih informacija i informacija posle zaključenja ugovora o osiguranju potrošačima usluga osiguranja prema direktivama EU i zakonima država članica. Eur Insur Law Rev, 3Google Scholar
  23. Slijepčević D (2016) Primena valutne klauzule promenljive kamatne stope u ugovoru o kreditu. Report from the Conference of the Judges of the Commercial Courts in Serbia, ZlatiborGoogle Scholar
  24. Stojanović D (1980) Načelo Savesnosti i Poštenja. In: Perović S, Stojanović D (eds) Komentar Zakona o Obligacionim odnosima. Pravni Fakultet u KragujevcuGoogle Scholar
  25. Šulejić P (2005) Pravo Osiguranja, 5th edn. Pravni Fakultet Univerziteta u Beogradu, BeogradGoogle Scholar
  26. Tereszkiewicz P (2016) Neutral third-party counselling as nudge toward safer financial products? In: Mathias K, Avishalom T (eds) Nudging - possibilities, limitations and applications in European law and economics. SpringerGoogle Scholar
  27. Wandt M (2012) Transparency as general principle of insurance law. In: Wandt M, Unan S (eds) Transparency in insurance law. Sigorta Hukuku Türk Derneği, Deutscher Verein für Versicherungswissenschaft, IstambulGoogle Scholar
  28. Weatherill S (2013) EU consumer law and policy, 2nd edn. Elgar European LawGoogle Scholar

Legal Acts, Court Decisions and Other Official Documents

  1. Decision of Commercial Appellate Court in Belgrade, ПЖ 3826/15 from 26.05. 2016Google Scholar
  2. Decision of Commercial Court in Belgrade, ПЖ 2743/2016 from 01.12.2016Google Scholar
  3. Decision of the Appellate Court in Novi Sad, ГЖ 1781/16 from 01.09.2016Google Scholar
  4. Decision of the Commercial Appellate Court in Belgrade ПЖ 2237/2016 from 02.03.2017Google Scholar
  5. Decision of the Commercial Appellate Court in Belgrade ПЖ 924/15 from 26.05.2016Google Scholar
  6. Decision of the High Court of Bosnia and Herzegovina vs. BiH, Rev. 629/83, from 19.01.1984Google Scholar
  7. Decision of the Supreme Court of Serbia, РЕВ 1282/2015 from 05.10.2016Google Scholar
  8. Draft of the Civil Code of Serbia available at: http://www.mpravde.gov.rs/files/NACRT.pdf
  9. National Bank of Serbia, Insurance Supervision Department, Insurance Sector in Serbia Report for 2015 available at: http://www.nbs.rs/internet/english/60/60_6/insurance_IV_2015.pdf
  10. Opšta preporuka Ombudsman u Osiguranju, 06-603-4/10. From 31.12.2010. Available at http://www.azors.rs.ba/azors/lat/pod_akti/ombudsman/Peporuka_ugovaranje.pdf
  11. Smernica Narodne Banke Srbije broj 1- O dostupnosti podataka i informacija finansijskoj javnosti i o transparentnosti na tržištu osiguranja (Guideline number 1 of National Bank of Serbia - On availability of information to financial public and transparency on insurance market) available at: https://www.nbs.rs/internet/latinica/20/osg/smernica_1_transparentnost.pdf
  12. Zakon o društvima za osiguranje, Službeni Glasnik Republike Srpske 17/05, 01/06, 64/06, 74/10, 47/17 (Insurance Law of Republika Srpska)Google Scholar
  13. Zakon o obligacionim odnosima Crne Gore, Službeni List Crne Gore 47/2008 (Law on Obligations of Montenegro)Google Scholar
  14. Zakon o obligacionim odnosima Federacije Bosne i Hercegovine i Republike Srpske, (“Službeni list RBiH”, br. 2/92, 13/93 i 13/94) (“Službeni glasnik RS”, br. 17/93 i 3/96) (Law on Obligations of Federation of Bosnia & Herzegovina and Republika Srpska)Google Scholar
  15. Zakon o obligacionim odnosima Republike Srbije, Službeni list SCG 1/2003 (Law on Obligations of Serbia)Google Scholar
  16. Zakon o Osiguranju Federacije Bosne i Hercegovine, Službene novine Federacije BiH 23/17 (Insurance Law of Federation of Bosnia & Herzegovina)Google Scholar
  17. Zakon o Osiguranju Republike Crne Gore, Službeni list Republike Crne Gore, broj 78/2006 (Insurance Law of Montenegro)Google Scholar
  18. Zakon o Osiguranju Republike Srbije, Službeni Glasnik Republike Srbije 139/14 (Insurance Law of Serbia)Google Scholar
  19. Zakon o Zaštiti korisnika finansijskih usluga, Službeni Glasnik Republike Srbije 36/2011(Law on Protection of Consumers in Financial Services of Serbia)Google Scholar
  20. Zakon o Zaštiti korisnika finansijskih usluga, Službeni List Crne Gore 043/15 (Law on Protection of Consumers in Financial Services of Montenegro)Google Scholar
  21. Zakon o Zaštiti potrošača, Službeni Glasnik Bosne i Hercegovine 271/06 (Consumer Protection Law of Federation of Bosnia & Herzegovina)Google Scholar
  22. Zakon o Zaštiti potrošača, Službeni Glasnik Republike Srbije 62/2014 (Law on Consumer Protection of Serbia)Google Scholar
  23. Zakon o Zaštiti potrošača, Službeni List Crne Gore 002/14 (Law on Consumer Protection Monenegro)Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Nature Switzerland AG 2019

Authors and Affiliations

  • Nikola Filipović
    • 1
  1. 1.University of GrazGrazAustria

Personalised recommendations