Hydraulic Fracturing in Canada: Regulation by Moratorium or Specialized Agencies in Landscapes of Aboriginal and Treaty Rights

  • Deborah CurranEmail author
Part of the Water Security in a New World book series (WSEC)


Over the past decade hydraulic fracturing activities have rapidly transformed the landscape in some regions of Canada, with both public and private sector drives to expand the oil and gas industry taking precedence over long term water stewardship. Within the Canadian federation, provincial governments have devolved responsibility for both water management and the regulation of unconventional oil and gas. Provinces tend to issue renewable short-term water licences for fracking activities under regulatory review processes that are separate from normal water licensing processes. This separation of regulatory function, the sheer volume of water use involved, and the scale of fracking has resulted in conflicts over water use and unregulated storage and use of water for the industry. In addition, Indigenous communities’ aboriginal and treaty rights to water-based activities, such as fishing, are threatened by the extent of fracking activity and lack of hydrological data. These same First Nations are advocating for region- and watershed-wide water strategies to create objectives for long-term land and water planning that address the impacts of fracking and establish collaborative management structures for decision-making.


Water Hydraulic fracturing Canada Law Regulation Aboriginal rights Indigenous law Indigenous governance 


  1. An Act to limit oil and gas activities, SQ 2011, c 13Google Scholar
  2. BC Ministry of Energy and Mines (2012) British Columbia’s natural gas strategy. Accessed 16 Dec 2017
  3. BC Oil and Gas Commission (2010) Compliance and enforcement activity report for 2010/2011. Accessed 17 Dec 2017
  4. BC Oil and Gas Commission (2014) 2013–2014 compliance and enforcement activity summary. Accessed 17 Dec 2017
  5. BC Oil and Gas Commission (2000) Information release. Accessed 17 Dec 2017
  6. BC Oil and Gas Commission (2010) Horn River Basin status report 2010. BC Oil and Gas Commission. Accessed 16 Dec 2017
  7. BC Oil and Gas Commission (2012) Compliance and enforcement activity summary. Accessed 17 Dec 2017
  8. BC Oil and Gas Commission (2013) Gas migration preliminary investigation report – December 2013. Accessed 18 Dec 2017
  9. BC Oil and Gas Commission (2014) Oil and gas land use in Northeast British Columbia. BC Oil and Gas Commission. Accessed 16 Dec 2017
  10. BC Oil and Gas Commission (2015) Compliance and enforcement summary 2015. Accessed 17 Dec 2017
  11. BC Oil and Gas Commission (n.d.) Area-based analysis (ABA). Accessed 17 Dec 2017
  12. Bill 106, An Act to implement the 2030 Energy Policy and to amend various legislative provisions, 1st Sess, 41th Leg, Quebec, 2016Google Scholar
  13. Blueberry River First Nation v. British Columbia (2015) Vancouver Registry S-151727 Notice of Civil Claim. Accessed 16 Dec 2017
  14. Borrows J (2002) Recovering Canada: the resurgence of indigenous law. University of Toronto Press, TorontoGoogle Scholar
  15. Borrows J (2019) Earth-bound: indigenous laws and environmental reconciliation. In: M Asch, J Borrows, J Tully (eds) Resurgence and reconciliation: indigenous-settler relations and earth teachings. University of Toronto Press, Toronto, pp 49–81Google Scholar
  16. Brandes O, Curran D (2017) Changing currents: a case study in the evolution of water law in Western Canada. In: Renzetti S, Dupont D (eds) Water policy and governance in Canada. Springer, New York, pp 45–67CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Brandes OM, Nowlan L (2009) Wading into uncertain waters: using markets to transfer water rights in Canada—possibilities and pitfalls. J Environ Law Pract 19(3):267–287Google Scholar
  18. Brandes OM, Carr-Wilson S, Curran D, Simms R (2015) Awash with opportunity: ensuring the sustainability of British Columbia’s new water law. POLIS Project on Ecological Governance, University of Victoria, Victoria, Canada. Accessed 10 Dec 2017
  19. Brend Y (2017) Collision between indigenous hunting and oil development rights set for legal showdown in B.C. court. CBC News June 10 2017. Accessed 16 Dec 2017
  20. Burrard Power Co. v. R. (1910), [1911] A.C. 87 (Canada P.C)Google Scholar
  21. Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives (2017) Public inquiry needed to properly investigate deep social and environmental harms of fracking, coalition says. Accessed 16 Dec 2017
  22. Caron-Beaudoin E, Valter N, Chevrier J, Ayotte P, Frohlich K, Verner M-A (2018) Gestational exposure to volatile organic compounds (VOCs) in Northeastern British Columbia, Canada: a pilot study. Environ Int 110:131–138. Scholar
  23. Carter AV, Eaton EM (2016) Subnational responses to fracking in Canada: explaining Saskatchewan’s “wild west” regulatory approach. Rev Policy Res 33(4):393–419CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Canadian Water Network (2015) Water and hydraulic fracturing: where knowledge can best support decisions in Canada waterloo. ON, Canadian Water Network.
  25. Christie G (2006) Developing case law: the future of consultation and accommodation. UBC Law Rev 39:139Google Scholar
  26. CIA (Central Intelligence Agency) (2015) The world Factbook. Country comparison: natural gas – production. Retrieved February 2013, from
  27. Citizens and the Queen Insurance Cos of Canada v Parsons 4 SCR 215Google Scholar
  28. Constitution Act, 1867 (U.K.), 30 & 31 Vict., c. 3, s. 91 and 92, reprinted in RSC 1985, App. II, No. 5Google Scholar
  29. Constitution Act, 1982, being Schedule B to the Canada Act 1982 (UK), 1982, c 11Google Scholar
  30. Council of Canadian Academies. 2009. The Sustainable Management of Groundwater in Canada – Expert Panel on Groundwater. Ottawa: Council of Canadian AcademiesGoogle Scholar
  31. Council of Canadian Academies (2014) Environmental impacts of shale gas extraction in Canada. Council of Canadian Academies, OttawaGoogle Scholar
  32. Curran D (2014) British Columbia’s water sustainability act – a new approach to adaptive management and no compensation regulation. The University of Calgary Faculty of Law Blog on Developments in Alberta Law. Accessed 17 Dec 2017
  33. Curran D (2015) Water law as watershed endeavour: federal inactivity as an opportunity for local initiative. J Environ Law Pract 28(1):53–88Google Scholar
  34. Curran D, Brandes OM (2012) When the water dries up: lessons from the failure of water entitlements in Canada, the US and Australia—Workshop Discussion Paper. University of Victoria, Canada.
  35. Curran D (2017a) Leaks in the system: environmental flows, aboriginal rights and the modernization imperative for water law in British Columbia. UBC Law Rev 50(2):233–291Google Scholar
  36. Curran D (2017b) ‘Legalizing’ the great bear rainforest agreements: colonial adaptations towards reconciliation and conservation. McGill Law J 62(3):813–860CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Delgamuukw v BC, [1997] 3 SCR 1010, [1997] SCJ No 108Google Scholar
  38. Environmental Assessment Act, S.B.C. 2002, c. 43Google Scholar
  39. Environmental Assessment Office (2017) In the matter of the environmental assessment Act S.B.C. 2002, c.43 (the act) and progress energy non-compliance with section 8.1 of the act – order under section 34(1). Accessed 16 Dec 2017
  40. Environmental Protection and Management Regulation. B.C. Reg. 200/2010Google Scholar
  41. Ernst v Alberta Energy Regulator 2017 SCC 1Google Scholar
  42. Fort Nelson First Nation v. Assistant Regional Water Manager (2015) BC EAB decision, 2012-WAT-013(c), 3 September 2015Google Scholar
  43. Fort Nelson First Nation (2017) Medzih action plan: Fort Nelson first boreal Caribou recovery plan. Accessed 15 Dec 2017
  44. Fort Nelson First Nation (n.d.) Liard and Horn River Basin water monitoring. Accessed 16 Dec 2017
  45. Friends of the Old Man River Society v Canada (Minister of Transport) [1992] 1 SCR 3Google Scholar
  46. Garvie KH, Lowe L, Shaw K (2014) Shale gas development in Fort Nelson first nation territory: potential regional impacts of the LNG boom. BC Stud 184:45–72Google Scholar
  47. Gastem, Inc. v Municipalite de Ristigouche-Partie-Sud-Est 28 fevrier 2018 Cour Superiere du Quebec No. 105-17-000384-132Google Scholar
  48. Government of Quebec (2009) An act to affirm the collective nature of water resources and provide for increased water resource protection, CQLR c C-6.2.
  49. Government of Quebec (2017) Île d’Anticosti – Le Gouvernement du Québec soustrait définitivement le territoire de l’île d’Anticosti à l’exploration pétrolière et gazière:
  50. Grassy Narrows First Nation v Ontario (Natural Resources) 2014 SCC 48Google Scholar
  51. Groundwater Protection Regulation. B.C. Reg. 39/2016Google Scholar
  52. Haida Nation v BC, 2004 SCC 73Google Scholar
  53. Hume M (2014) First nations’ LNG fight takes wing on an eagle’s feather. Globe and Mail, April 20 2014 online:
  54. Kassam A (2018) Tiny Canada town defeats oil firm in fight over drinking water. The Guardian, March 3 2018 online:
  55. Kennett SA (1991) Managing interjurisdictional waters in Canada: a constitutional analysis. Canadian Institute of Resources Law, CalgaryGoogle Scholar
  56. LaForme HHS, Truesdale C (2013) Section 25 of the charter; section 35 of the constitution act, 1982: aboriginal and treaty rights – 30 years of recognition and affirmation. Supreme Court Law Rev 2(687):62Google Scholar
  57. Lavoie J (2017) B.C. coughs up fracking report four years late and only after it was leaked to journalist. DeSmog Canada. Accessed 18 December 2017
  58. Mikisew Cree First Nation v Canada (Minister of Canadian Heritage) 2005 SCC 69Google Scholar
  59. Moore M-L, Castleden H, Shaw K (2015) Regional snapshot. Building capacity for building trust: key challenges for water governance in relation to hydraulic fracturing. Canadian Water Network, WaterlooGoogle Scholar
  60. Napoleon V (2015) Tsilhqot’in law of consent. UBC Law Rev 48:3 873–3 901Google Scholar
  61. Napoleon V, Friedland H (2016) An inside job: engaging with indigenous legal traditions through stories. McGill L J 61:4 725–4 754Google Scholar
  62. National Energy Board Act. R.S.C. (1985) C. N-7Google Scholar
  63. Natural Resources Transfer Agreements, Constitution Act, 1930, 20-21 Geo. V c 26 (uk), Schedule 2 s 1Google Scholar
  64. NEB (National Energy Board) (2009) Energy brief – understanding Canadian shale gas. National Energy Board, CalgaryGoogle Scholar
  65. NEB (National Energy Board) (2011) Canadian energy overview 2010. National Energy Board, CalgaryGoogle Scholar
  66. NEB (National Energy Board) (2013) Marketable natural gas production in Canada. Retrieved February 2013, from
  67. New Brunswick (2016) News release: moratorium on hydraulic fracturing to continue indefinitely. Accessed 17 Dec 2017
  68. Nova Scotia (n.d.) Hydraulic fracturing review. Accessed 17 Dec 2017
  69. Nowlan L (2005) Buried treasure: groundwater permitting and pricing in Canada. Walter and Duncan Gordon Foundation. Accessed 17 Dec 2017
  70. Nowlan L (2012) CPR for Canadian rivers – law to conserve, protect, and restore environmental flows in Canada. Environ Law Pract 23:203–252Google Scholar
  71. O’Shannassey J (2012) Fort Nelson first nation’s action: moving towards a water management plan. Presentation to keepers of the water IV conference. Accessed 16 Dec 2017
  72. Office of the Auditor General of British Columbia (2016) An audit of compliance and enforcement of the mining sector. Office of the Auditor General of British Columbia, VictoriaGoogle Scholar
  73. Oil and Gas Activities Act, SBC 2008, c 36Google Scholar
  74. Olive A, Delshad AB (2017) Fracking and framing: a comparative analysis of media coverage of hydraulic fracturing in Canadian and US newspapers. Environ Commun 11:784–799. Scholar
  75. Page J (2018) Small Quebec village, sued for trying to protect its drinking water, wins legal battle. February 28, 2018 CBC, online:
  76. Parfitt B 2017. A dam big problem: regulatory breakdown as fracking companies in BC’s northeast build dozens of unauthorized dams. Vancouver: Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives. Accessed 16 Dec 2017
  77. Percy DR (1988) The framework of water rights legislation in Canada. Canadian Institute of Resources Law, CalgaryGoogle Scholar
  78. Petroleum Natural Gas Act, RSBC 1996, c 361Google Scholar
  79. Pothukuchi K, Arrowsmith M, Lyon N (2017) Hydraulic fracturing: a review of implications for food systems planning.
  80. Progress Energy (2017) Letter from Jarred Anstett to Theresa Morris July 20 2017. Accessed 16 Dec 2017
  81. Prohibition Against Hydraulic Fracturing Regulation – Oil and Natural Gas Act. New Brunswick Regulation 2015–28Google Scholar
  82. Quebec Oil and Gas Association (2016) Quebec government gives the first authorization certificate for fracking in Quebec. Accessed 17 Dec 2017
  83. R v Van der Peet, [1996] 2 SCR 507, 137 DLR (4th) 289Google Scholar
  84. R. v Sparrow, [1990] 1 SCR 1075, 70 DLR (4th) 385Google Scholar
  85. Rankin M, Carpenter S, Burchmore P, Jones C (2000) Regulatory reform in the British Columbia petroleum industry: the oil and gas commission. Alta L Rev 38(1):143–169Google Scholar
  86. Reviewable Projects Regulation, B.C. Reg. 370/2002Google Scholar
  87. Ritchie K (2013) Issues associated with the implementation of the duty to consult and accommodate aboriginal peoples: threatening the goals of reconciliation and meaningful consultation. UBC Law Rev 43:397Google Scholar
  88. Rokosh CD, Lyster S, Anderson SDA, Beaton AP, Berhane H, Brazzoni T, Chen D, Cheng Y, Mack T, Pana C, Pawlowicz JG (2012) Summary of Alberta’s shale- and siltstone-hosted hydrocarbon resource potential. Alberta Energy Regulator, CalgaryGoogle Scholar
  89. Saunders OJ (1988) Interjurisdictional issues in Canadian water management. The Canadian Institute of Resources Law, CalgaryGoogle Scholar
  90. Shackelford N, Starzomski BM, Banning NC, Battaglia LL, Becker A, Bellingham PJ, Bestelmeyer B, Catford JA, Dwyer JM, Dynesius M, Gilmour J, Hallett LM, Hobbs RJ, Price J, Sasaki T, Tanner EVJ, Standish RJ, Institutionen för ekologi, miljö och geovetenskap, Umeå universitet, Teknisk-naturvetenskapliga fakulteten (2017) Isolation predicts compositional change after discrete disturbances in a global meta-study. Ecography 40:1256–1266. Scholar
  91. The Water Security Agency Act, SS 2005, C. W-8.1Google Scholar
  92. Tsilhqot’in Nation v. British Columbia, [2014] SCC 44Google Scholar
  93. Turner N, Berkes F, Stephenson J, Dick J (2013) Blundering intruders: extraneous impacts on two indigenous food systems. Hum Ecol 41:463–574. Scholar
  94. Vermette D (2011) Dizzying dialogue: Canadian courts and the continuing justification of the dispossession of aboriginal peoples. Windsor Yearb Access Justice 29(1):55CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  95. Water Sustainability Act, SBC 2014, c 15Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer International Publishing AG 2020

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.University of VictoriaVictoriaCanada

Personalised recommendations