Advertisement

Ernst Mach: Science and Buddhism. A Misunderstanding Under Globalization’s Signature

  • Ursula BaatzEmail author
Chapter
Part of the Vienna Circle Institute Yearbook book series (VCIY, volume 22)

Abstract

Ernst Mach was one of the most influential intellectuals in Vienna’s cultural life during the fin de siècle. His assumption of the self as a complex of transitory elements has influenced poets like Hoffmannsthal, Schnitzler and Musil. During these years, Buddhism, which shares some of the same assumptions, was discovered by Western intellectuals, among them also intellectuals who were critical of religion. At that time, Buddhism was hardly known and frequently misinterpreted. Nevertheless, the apparent parallels between Mach’s thought and Buddhism – especially in his “Analysis of Sensations” – has inspired contemporaries to bestow Mach the title “Buddha of Science”(Gomperz).

Today, the close connection of Buddhism and science is almost commonplace, especially in neuroscience. Sometimes science is used to substantiate Buddhist claims and at other times it is vice versa. The current trends of the relationship of science and Buddhism have a long history. Sinhalese and Japanese Buddhists as well as American freethinkers have featured the idea of Buddhism’s affinity to Science as early as in the nineteenth century. One of the most important intermediaries in this process was Paul Carus, Mach’s translator and editor in the US.

A closer look at Ernst Mach’s “Analysis of Sensation” could prove that the supposed relationship is a category mistake, even though there are in fact certain parallels and isomorphisms. The “Scientific Buddha” (Lopez) is the result of a complex process of the reception of Buddhism in Europe, the US and Asia. Western representations and interpretations of Buddhism were turned into anticolonial propaganda in the course of the struggle of Sri Lanka and Japan against Western colonial powers and their ally, Christianity. This modernized Buddhism was then re-exported to Europe and the US as its authentic version, where it was welcomed as a form of traditional wisdom. Thus, any attempts to equate or verify Buddhism with or by science is a naturalistic fallacy.

References

  1. Almond, Philip (1988), The British discovery of Buddhism, Cambridge, Cambridge University PressCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Arnold, Edwin (1995), Die Leuchte Asiens. Erzählungen eines indischen Buddhisten. Übers. von Konrad Wernicke, Arthur Pfungst 1887 Leipzig W. FriedrichGoogle Scholar
  3. Askew, Rie (2009) The critical reception of Lafcadio Hearn outside Japan, New Zealand Journal of Asian Studies11, 2 December 2009), 44–71Google Scholar
  4. Baatz, Ursula (1992), Ernst Mach – the Scientist as a Buddhist?” Ernst Mach – A Deeper Look. Documents and New Perspectives. Hrsg. John Blackmore, Springer Verlag, Dordrecht/ Boston/ London 183–199CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Baatz, Ursula (1996), Ernst Mach and the World of Sensations in: Vienna: The World of Yesterday, 1889–1914. Hrsg. Stephen Eric Bronner und F. Peter Wagner, Brill, Atlantic Highlands, N.J., 82–92.Google Scholar
  6. Berg, Maxine (2005), Luxury & Pleasure in Eighteenth Century Britain, Oxford: Oxford University PressGoogle Scholar
  7. Benedikt, Michael, Hg. (1995) Verdrängter Humanismus – verzögerte Aufklärung : Philosophie in Österreich von 1400 bis heute. 3. Bildung und Einbildung : vom verfehlten Bürgerlichen zum Liberalismus ; Philosophie in Österreich (1820 – 1880), Klausen-Leopoldsdorf : Verl. Leben – Kunst – Wiss.Google Scholar
  8. Blackmore, John (1972), Ernst Mach – his work, life and influence, Berkeley University of California PressGoogle Scholar
  9. Bolz, Matthias / Singer, Tania, Hg. (2013), Compassion. Bridging Practice and Science, eBook, Max Planck Society, MunichGoogle Scholar
  10. Boyce, Barry (2005), Two Sciences of the Mind, Lions’ Roar http://www.lionsroar.com/two-sciences-of-mind/
  11. Capra Fritjof (1977), Das Tao der Physik, München, O.W.Barth-VerlagGoogle Scholar
  12. Carus, Paul (1894), The Gospel of the Buddha, Chicago, Open Court Publications; German: Das Evangelium des Buddha, New York: Westermann 1895Google Scholar
  13. Crill, Rosemary (2004), Asia in Europe: Textiles for the West, in: Jackson/Jaffer Encounters 2004, 262–270Google Scholar
  14. Flaubert, Gustave (2014), Bouvard et Pécuchet A tragic-comic novel of bourgeoise life,Auckland, New Zealand: The Floating Press (ebook)Google Scholar
  15. Gilsinan, Kathy (2015), The Buddhist and the Neuroscientist, http://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2015/07/dalai-lama-neuroscience-compassion/397706/
  16. Gomperz, Heinrich (1953), Philosophical Studies, hg. von Robinson, Daniel Sommer, Boston: The Christopher Publishing HouseGoogle Scholar
  17. Haller, Rudolf/Stadler, Friedrich, Hg. (1988), Ernst Mach. Werk und Wirkung, Wien: Hölder-Pichler-TempskyGoogle Scholar
  18. Henderson, Harold (1993), Catalyst for controversy. Paul Carus of Open Court. Carbondale, Southern Illinois University PressGoogle Scholar
  19. Jackson, Anna/Jaffer,Amin (2004), Encounters. The Meeting of Asia and Europe 1500-1800l London, V&A PublicationsGoogle Scholar
  20. Kellner, Birgit (2016), „Neue Zugänge zur Philosophie des Buddhismus? Neurowissenschaftliche Forschung als Anfrage an die Buddhismuskunde’ Unpublished lecture Nov 18, 2016 at the University of Vienna, Departement of South Asian, Tibetan and Buddhist StudiesGoogle Scholar
  21. Kleine, Christoph (2011a), Kanonisierungsansätze im ostasiatischen Buddhismus. Von der Kanon-Bildung zur buddhistischen Bibel? In: Deeg, Max; Freiberg Oliver, Kleine Christoph (Hg.) (2011) Kanonisierung und Kanonbildung in der asiatischen Religionsgeschichte in: Sitzungsberichte der philosophisch-historischen Klasse, Band: 820, Beiträge zur Kultur- und Geistesgeschichte Asiens, Band: 72, Wien: VÖAW, S.259–319Google Scholar
  22. Kleine, Christoph (2011b), Der Buddhismus in Japan: Geschichte, Lehre, Praxis, Tübingen Mohr SiebeckGoogle Scholar
  23. Lampa, Ernst (1918), Ernst Mach, Prag, Verlag deutsche ArbeitGoogle Scholar
  24. Leinfellner, Werner, Physiologie und Psychologie – Ernst Machs „Analyse der Empfindungen“, in: Haller/Stadler (1988), a.a.O., 113–137Google Scholar
  25. Lopez, Donald S., ed. (1995), Curators of the Buddha. The study of Buddhism under colonialism, Chicago; University of Chicago PressGoogle Scholar
  26. Lopez, Donald S. (2008), Buddhism and Science. A Guide for the Perplexed,Google Scholar
  27. Lopez, Donald S. (2012), The Scientific Buddha. His short and happy life, New Haven:Yale University PressGoogle Scholar
  28. Mach, Ernst (1918), Die Analyse der Empfindungen und das Verhältnis des Psychischen zum Physischen, 7. Auflage, Jena:FischerGoogle Scholar
  29. Mach, Ernst (1920) Erkenntnis und Irrtum, Skizzen zur Psychologie der Forschung, 4.mit Anmerkungen versehene Auflage, Leipzig:BarthGoogle Scholar
  30. Moore, John Walter (1994), A life of Erwin Schrödinger, Cambridge, Cambridge University PressGoogle Scholar
  31. Purser, Ronald E., Forbes, David, Burke, Adam eds. (2016), Handbook of Mindfulness, New York:SpringerGoogle Scholar
  32. Sargent, William M. (2004), Asia in Europe: Chinese Paintings for the West, in Jackson/Jaffers 2004, 272–281Google Scholar
  33. Schopenhauer, Arthur (1859/1998), Die Welt als Wille und Vorstellung, hg. von Ludger Lütkehaus, München, Deutscher Taschenbuch VerlagGoogle Scholar
  34. Sharf, Robert (1995), The Zen of Japanese Nationalism, in: Lopez, Curators of the Buddha: The Study of Buddhism under Colonialism, 107–160.Google Scholar
  35. Singer, Tania/ Bolz, Matthias (2013) Mitgefühl in Alltag und Forschung http://www.compassion-training.org/?lang=de
  36. Steinkellner, Ernst, Zur Lehre vom Nicht-Selbst (anâtman) im frühen Buddhismus (2002), in: J. Figl, H.-D. Klein (Hg.), Der Begriff der Seele in der Religionswissenschaft, Würzburg, 171–186Google Scholar
  37. von Stuckrad, Kocku (2004), Was ist Esoterik? München:BeckGoogle Scholar
  38. Zotz, Volker (2000); Auf den glückseligen Inseln. Buddhismus in der deutschen Kultur, Berlin TheseusGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Nature Switzerland AG 2019

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Independent ScholarWienAustria

Personalised recommendations