Abstract
The stories that were probably most often chatted about in streets were those related to debt, specifically those cases that were sent to court.
Each community has, therefore, a weapon for the enforcement of its rights: reciprocity .
Malinowski (1926: 23)
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution.
Buying options
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Learn about institutional subscriptionsNotes
- 1.
Disputes solved by the National Court between 1948–1995 in Li Village.
File number
Type
Year
Plaintiff (name and village)
Defendant (name and village)
Cause
Solution
1948-32
Civil case
1948
Ren Huimin, Liu Xingkui; Zhao County
Li Xinduo, Wang Jingxi; Li Village
Debt
1949-1
Civil case
1949
Song Shuzhi; Li Village
Shi Mingtai; Dongzhuang Village
Debt
1949-116
Civil case
1949
Song Shuzhi; Li Village
Zhao Quanfu, Shi Jingfu; Dongzhuang Village
Articles ownership
1949-157
Civil case
1949
Jia Sijun; Xiaohaozhuang Village
Li Xiaowu; Li Village
Divorce
1949-269
Civil case
1949
Daughter of Li Erdan; Li Village
Wang Xiaoju; Xiezhuang Village
Divorce
Mediation
1949-307
Civil case
1949
Li Bing; Li Village
Jia Shengxi; Chang Xin
Divorce
1950-37
Criminal case
1950
Li Shunfa; Li Village
Steal
1950-52
Criminal case
1950
Li Lansuo; Li Village
Confirmed thief
Three-year imprisonment
1950-52
Criminal case
1950
Li Heizi; Li Village
Confirmed thief
Three-year imprisonment
1951-89
Criminal case
1951
Zhang Hujiao; Li Village
A17 counterrevolutionary murder
Fifteen-year imprisonment
1951-150
Criminal case
1951
Li Qiufu; Li Village
Landlord counterattack
Three-and-half-year imprisonment
1951-198
Criminal case
1951
Li Lankui; Li Village
Counterrevolutionary
Four-year imprisonment
1951-212
Criminal case
1951
Wang Huanshu; Li Village
Murder
Death penalty
1954-180
Civil case
1954
Li Sumei; Li Village
Bai Xiaochen; Gezi
Divorce
1954-375
Civil case
1954
Zhang Liannv; Guangzong Lizhi Village
Li Wuchen; Li Village
Divorce
1954-452
Civil case
1954
Feng Jinghuai; Li Village
Geng Xinju; Xiaoyou
Divorce
Divorce decree
1954-488
Civil case
1954
Li Huansheng; Xianmenlou
Li Wentai; Li Village
Divorce
1955-151
Civil case
1955
Li Meihua; Li Village
Yao Shengqiao; Yaojiazhuang Village
Divorce
1955-291
Civil case
1955
Wang Zhizhang; Li Village
Geng Dani; Xiaoyou
Divorce
1955-307
Civil case
1955
Li Jinggai; Caozhuang Village
Li Erchen; Li Village
Divorce
1955-322
Civil case
1955
Li Jilin; Li Village
Zhao Qinhua; Li Village
Divorce
1955-457
Civil case
1955
Li Shenghua; Li Village
Ren Genkui; Xiezhuang Village
Divorce
1955-97
Criminal case
1955
Li Fengkui; Li Village
E02 stealing
Nine-year imprisonment
1956-109
Criminal case
1956
Li Laobian; Li Village
Counterrevolutionary
Three-year imprisonment
1956-81
Civil case
1956
Su Meixiu; Li Village
Li Baogen; Li Village
Divorce
1957-18
Civil case
1957
Li Xiulian; Li Village
Zhang Qingwen; Fanzhuang Village
Divorce
1957-22
Civil case
1957
Ling Chunrui; Da’an Village
Li Yinxiang; Li Village
Divorce
Reconciliation
1957-35
Civil case
1957
Sun Sheng; Li Village
Li Daqing, Li Hunong; Li Village
Debt
1958-24
Criminal case
1958
Wang Shuangsheng; Li Village
G07 Offenses against marriage
One-and-half-
year imprisonment
1960-48
Criminal case
1960
Li Tonghuai; Li Village
D06 rape young female
Ten-year imprisonment
1964-19
Criminal case
1964
Li Changzao; Li Village
G03 violation of the PLA man’s marriage
One-year imprisonment
1965-194
Criminal case
1965
Li Lansuo; Li Village
Stealing
Eight-year imprisonment
Shi Xiaoqun; Li Village
Stealing
Four-year imprisonment
1965-200
Criminal case
1965
Li Lansuo
Stealing
Eight-year imprisonment
1966-62
Civil case
1966
Li Meiqiao; Li Village
Li Zhensuo; Fanzhuang Village
Divorce
Reconciliation
1966-224
Civil case
1966
Zheng Zhongyi; Li Village
Li Shuqiao; Li Village
Divorce
1966-83
Civil case
1966
Li Fengju; Qiandama Village
Feng Duchen; Li Village
Divorce
1966-104
Civil case
1966
Li Xinque; Li Village
Duan Rongjiang; Da’an Village
Divorce
1966-113
Civil case
1966
Liu Zhengfang; Tianzhuang Village
Li Qingfang; Li Village
Divorce
1968-11
Civil case
1968
Li Genxi; Li Village
Feng Jinglu; Li Village
Divorce
Lawsuit withdrawal
1969-55
Civil case
1969
Li Qingxian; Li Village
Gao Suhuan; Gao Village
Divorce
1969-27
Civil case
1969
Gu Shuhua; Handan
Li Kaiyin; Li Village
Divorce
1970-6
Civil case
1970
Li Qingchuan; Li Village
Li Lingqiao; Li Village
Divorce
1973-26
Civil case
1973
Fan Genxu; Fanzhuang Village
Li Chunsu; Li Village
Divorce
Mediation
1973-48
Civil case
1973
Li Ruike; Li Village
An Yuejiu; Anjiazhuang Village
Divorce
Reconciliation
1973-67
Civil case
1973
Li Shuzhong; Li Village
Cheng Zhongbao; Dadongping Village
Divorce
Judgment
1973-110
Civil case
1973
Shi Qinrui; Dongzhuang Village
Li Qingchuan; Li Village
Divorce
Mediation
1979-14
Criminal case
1979
Li Binsuo; Li Village
Murder
Death penalty; three-year probation
1980-31
Criminal case
1980
Li Jianmin; Li Village
Traffic accident
Two-year imprisonment, three-year probation
1983-6
Administrative economy
1983
Seventh Group; Li Village
Eighth Grouo; Gedatou Village
Arrearage
Mediation
1983-33
Civil case
1983
Song Yueping; Anjiazhuang Village
Li Jianjun; Li Village
Divorce
Mediation
1984-80
Civil case
1984
Ren Jidun; Xiezhuang Village
Li Yinrui; Li Village
Divorce
Mediation
1984-98
Civil case
1984
Li Haishuan; Li Village
Wang Junxiao; Anjiazhuang Village
Arrearage
Mediation
1984-183
Civil case
1984
Gao Wenzeng; Dasizhuang Village
Li Rongsu; Li Village
Divorce
Mediation
1985-170
Civil case
1985
Li Guangsheng; Li Village
Li Meisheng; Li Village
Arrearage
Mediation
1986-51
Administrative economy
1986
Li Village Committee
County-Town-Village Business Administration
Loan
Mediation
1986-156
Civil case
1986
Li Guangjin; Li Village
Li Erjun; Li Village
Arrearage
Mediation
1986-159
Civil case
1986
Li Jianguo; Li Village
Liu Guojun; Caozhuang Village
Arrearage
Mediation
1987-5
Civil case
1987
An Xi Road; Xinzhai Store Cement Plant
Li Zengshui; Li Village
Compensation
1987-26
Criminal case
1987
Li Shuanping; Li Village
Harm
Lawsuit withdrawal
1987-69
Civil case
1987
Wang Yingshan, Li Zengmin; Li Village
Han Village; Sujiatin Village Committee
Debt
1988-34
Administrative economy
1988
Li suoyin; Li Village
Li Dongliang, Wu Qingzhen, Li Lihui, Li Guofen, Yao Huandong; Gedatou Village
1988-40
Administrative economy
1988
Packaging Decoration Plant of City Shi
Li Qingshuang; Li Village
Arrearage
Lawsuit withdrawal
1988-63
Civil case
1988
Cao Tongfang; Li Village
Zhang Zhihui; Xiezhuang Village
Divorce
Mediation
1988-239
Civil case
1988
Li Shuzi; Li Village
Li Qingke; Li Village
Homestead
Judge
1988-325
Civil case
1988
Li Jianguo; Li Village
Geng Sujun; Xiaoyou
Arrearage
Mediation
1988-338
Civil case
1988
Cao Congjun; Li Village
Zhang Shucheng; Shahe River Store
Divorce
Mediation
1988-364
Civil case
1988
Li Haishuan; Li Village
Geng Sujun; Xiaoyou, Zhang Guobin; Changxinying
Arrearage
Mediation
1988-383
Civil case
1988
Shi Xiaoqun; Li Village
Li Jianmin, Li Jjishuan; Li Village
Homestead dispute
Mediation
1989-53
Civil case
1989
Li Shuwei; Li Village
Zheng Zhongsheng; Dahaozhuang
Arrearage
Mediation
1989-112
Civil case
1989
Wang Tongxi, Cao Hongrui; Li Village
Wang Jibin; Li Village
Maintenance dispute
Mediation
1989-157
Civil case
1989
Zhao Qingzhen; Li Village
Yan Qunyang; Mazhuang Village
Arrearage
Mediation
1989-187
Civil case
1989
Li Zhongyuan; Dasizhuang Village
Li Ronggui; Li Village
Arrearage
Mediation
1989-211
Civil case
1989
Li Zhongqi; Dasizhuang Village
Li Yonggui; Li Village
Arrearage
Mediation
1989-232
Civil case
1989
Zhao Qingzhen; Li Village
Lu Shuanzhen; Dahaozhuang Village
Arrearage
Mediation
1989-333
Civil case
1989
Li Dongmin; Li Village
Liu Chunyang; Yaojiazhuang Village
Arrearage
Judgment
1989-345
Civil case
1989
Zhao Qingzhen; Li Village
Zheng Subin; Dahaozhuang Village
Debt
Mediation
1989-385
Civil case
1989
Li Ruishen; Li Village
Yao Guangyan; Yaojiazhuang Village
Arrearage
Mediation
1989-522
Civil case
1989
Li Ruishen; Li Village
Li Sanhuan; Yaojiazhuang Village
Arrearage
Mediation
1989-529
Civil case
1989
Li Ruishen; Li Village
Li Shizhen; Gedatou Village
Arrearage
Mediation
1989-565
Civil case
1989
Zhao Qingzhen; Li Village
Zheng Zhongliang; Dahaozhuang Village
Arrearage
Mediation
1989-650
Civil case
1989
Li Qingke; Li Village
Li Village Committee , (Li Shuzi; Li Village)
Homestead dispute
Judgment
1989-694
Civil case
1989
Li Ruishen; Li Village
Li Shiying; Gedatou Village
Arrearage
Mediation
1989-712
Civil case
1989
Li Zhencai; Li Village
Fan Village People’s Government
Refuse administrative penalty
Lawsuit withdrawal
1989-720
Civil case
1989
Tian Jingmei; Li Village
Li Junjiang, Li Junhai; Li Village
Support
Mediation
1989-722
Civil case
1989
Li Meisheng; Li Village
Li Zengshou; Li Village
Arrearage
Mediation
1989-727
Civil case
1989
Li Shenghuai; Li Village
Fan Village People’s Government
Refuse administrative penalty
Lawsuit withdrawal
1989-732
Civil case
1989
Shi Xiaoqun; Li Village
Li Shiying; Gedatou Village
Arrearage
Mediation
1990-41
Administrative economy
1990
Packaging Decoration Plant of Boxiang County
Li Ruishen; Li Village
Arrearage dispute
Judgment
1990-49
Administrative economy
1990
Li Wenjie;
Li Village
Printery Retail Salesroom of Zhao County
Arrearage
Mediation
1990-54
Criminal case
1990
Li Jinyan; Li Village
Harm
Lawsuit withdrawal
1990-323
Civil case
1990
Clip Packaging Materials Plant of City Shi
Li Shuquan; Li Village
Arrearage
Mediation
1990-349
Civil case
1990
An Jingke; Anjiazhuang Village
Li Zhenfang; Li Village
Arrearage
Lawsuit withdrawal
1990-372
Civil case
1990
Zheng Guoping;
Dahaozhuang Village
Li Minshe; Li Village
Divorce
Mediation
1990-409
Civil case
1990
Qinghua Carton Plant of Xingtang County
Li Jianguo; Li Village
Overdue obligations to suppliers
Mediation
1990-421
Civil case
1990
Yin Qingle; Li Village
Li Zhidong, Li Heizi, Li Ruibin, Wang Chunzhen, Xu Bingchen; Li Village
Economic dispute
1990-485
Civil case
1990
Shi Ruisu; Dongzhuang Village
Feng Jingbin; Li Village
Divorce
Mediation
1991-162
Civil case
1991
Li Village
Zhang Shengzu; Li Village
Inheritance
Lawsuit withdrawal
1991-34
Criminal case
1991
Li Mengji; Li Village
Mild harm
Lawsuit withdrawal
1991-260
Civil case
1991
Packaging Production Plant of Boxiang County
Li Jichen, Li Ruixing; Li Village
Arrearage
Lawsuit withdrawal
1991-343
Civil case
1991
Feng Jingjun; Li Village
Tian Shenghui; Ying’enpu Village
Arrearage
Mediation
1991-426
Civil case
1991
Packaging Printing Plant of Zhao County
Packaging Plant of Li Village
Arrearage
Judgment
1991-488
Civil case
1991
Shi Xiaoqun; Li Village
Li Qingshan; Gedatou Village
Arrearage
Judgment
1991-501
Civil case
1991
Guo Xianghui, Meng Zhenkui; Yanghu North Gate
Li Jianguo;
Li Village
Arrearage
Mediation
1991-503
Civil case
1991
Li Shuanping; Li Village
Yao Shengguo; Yaojiazhuang Village
Divorce
Judgment
1991-511
Civil case
1991
Shi City Yongchang industrial corporation carton plant
Li Ruitian; Li Village
Arrearage
Judgment
1992-38
Civil case
1992
Li Ruilin; Li Village
Li Xingwei; Gedatou Village, Li Dongwei; Li Village
Business dispute
Judgment
1992-55
Criminal case
1992
Li Weiqiang; Li Village
Intentional injury
Three-year prisonment
1992-62
Administrative economy
1992
Carton Plant of Li Village
Zheng Yingjun, Zheng Wensheng; Dahaozhuang Village
Direct purchase contract
Judgment
1992-79
Civil case
1992
Zhang Siba; Northeast Ying Village
Li Zhenguo; Li Village, Ren Jichen; Xiezhuang
Arrearage
Judgment
1992-90
Civil case
1992
Yin Qingle; Li Village
Qi Mengzhen; Li Village
Illegal detention
Lawsuit withdrawal
1992-96
Civil case
1992
Wang Guangjun; Anbaishe Village
Zheng Guangzhi; Li Village
Arrearage
Lawsuit withdrawal
1992-186
Civil case
1992
Wang Juezhen; Li Village
Jia Qingyi; Gaojiazhuang Village
Divorce
Judgment
1992-219
Civil case
1992
Li Qinghua, Wang Jingzhu; Li Village
Li Guoyan; Li Village, Anxi Road, Anwang Village
Arrearage
Judgment
1993-143
Civil case
1993
An Xianjun; Anjiazhuang Village
Feng Yuerui; Li Village
Relieve concubinage
1994-9
Civil case
1994
Li Tuilin; Li Village
Huang Xiuqing; Xibailu Gaocheng Town
Divorce
Judgment
1994-13
Administrative economy
1994
Zhao Zongqiao; Xianqian Village
Li Xianbin; Li Village
Loan
Mediation
1994-33
Administrative economy
1994
Li Huisuo; Li Village
Zhang Genhui; Changxin Village
Arrearage
Mediation
1994-436
Civil case
1994
Li Pinghai; Li Village
Fruit Stop of Zhao County in Li Village (third party: Xia Chunqing, Beijing Fédération Aéronautique)
Arrearage
1994-447
Civil case
1994
Li Yanjun; Li Village
Zhao Jiancai; Zhangjiazhuang Village
Relieve concubinage
Mediation
1994-513
Civil case
1994
Li Qunsuo; Li Village
Li Jingshun; Li Village
Default pear money
Lawsuit withdrawal
1995-4
Administrative economy
1995
Carton Plant of Li Village
Ling Guanghui; Liu Erbeng; Da’an Village
Arrearage
Lawsuit withdrawal
1995-39
Civil case
1995
Water Conservancy Bureau of Zhao County
An Tongxu; Li Village
Arrearage
Mediation
1995-41
Civil case
1995
Water Conservancy Bureau of Zhao County
Li Yimin; Li Village
Arrearage
Mediation
1995-42
Civil case
1995
Water Conservancy Bureau of Zhao County
Li Shuanzhu; Li Village
Arrearage
Mediation
1995-54
Civil case
1995
Water Conservancy Bureau of Zhao County
Li Zengxu; Li Village
Arrearage
Mediation
1995-382
Civil case
1995
Wang Guanghua; Xiaowangzhuang in Zaozhuang, Shandong Province
Li Yurui; Li Village
Illegal detention
Lawsuit withdrawal
- 2.
From the archive of Ba County of Sichuan in Qing Dynasty, in law suits of land selling and debt presented to the court, complainants’ logic read between the lines was hoping the county officer to be a mediator to recover the “giving-paying back ” reciprocal relationship. Take a farmland selling and buying case as an example, “in the 13th year of Qianlong period, Yi bought the farmland of Wang. Several years later, Yi was in debt, he sold his property to Tian Taihua in the 38th year of Qianlong period at the price of 960,000 copper coins. At that time, Yi received 790,000 copper coins, with the left 170,000 copper coins unpaid. Besides Yi’s original contract, Yi asked Zhang Mingyang to write another one. Tian (the borrower) didn’t pay back the rest money. Since Tian was rich and powerful, Yi had no way but to ask the officer for help.” (Sichuan Provincial Archives 1991: 17).
- 3.
It is common in rural areas to exchange gifts like money or agricultural products for country’s authority resources. A recent study on popular Chinese ballads conducted by Li Qingshan showed another type of exchange: the “exchanging things for things” reciprocal relationship, which means “both sides own some rights which control resources that the other side needed”. To realize one’s goal, each side should meet the other side’s request. Namely, two parties are both the requesting side and the requested side. If they want to realize their own goal, they have to help the other side reach his. This is the commonly said “exchanging things for other things that the reciprocal relationship is convenient for both” (Li 1996: 313). This reciprocal relationship is common in urban area instead of rural area, because farmers do not have any state power. It is more often for rural residents to exchange their economic resources for taking advantage of the state power.
- 4.
Since this dispute involved 14 families’ interests, these families sued the defendant jointly. Thus, every family shared the cost evenly. The cost was recorded by Li Shuhai and other two people and each cost was recorded in detail. Information of the table is from this account book.
- 5.
Demographers always express the reciprocity in revenue in the term of “making both ends meet”. He Bingdi’s study on the population development from Ming Dynasty to 1950s showed a law that the efficiency of a government could be indirectly reflected from whether breaking the principle of “making both ends meet”. The ruling class generally calculated expenses at the beginning of state-founding, hereby setting the nationwide tax amount and assuring nation surplus. Once the tax amount was set, it could not be changed (He 1989: 118). Reasons for the increase in tax resulted from the fact that the government had intensified state-building or hadn’t implemented strong supervision on corruption. He Bingdi’s comparison of tax system between the government of late Qing Dynasty and that of Republic China may be inspiring. He asserted that “if the tax burden of farmers was heavy in the late Qing Dynasty, their situation would be worse in the early Republic of China. Even if the financial system of late Qing Dynasty had decayed, it was still based on the traditional tax amount and the principle of ‘making both ends meet’. In the republican period, warlords were unscrupulous and were totally shameless blackmailers. They added taxes and levied at will and often collected land taxes in advance. Until the end of 1920s and the beginning of 1930s, the financial reformation of the National Government had seldom improved farmers’ life, although it did make some progress technically” (He 1989: 214).
- 6.
Selected from an interview with a Li villager on Novermber 14th, 1997.
- 7.
In Chinese Gentry, Urban-rural Relationship, Fei Xiaotong clearly pointed out the urban-rural relationship that before 1949: Gentries who lived inside urban areas extracted land interests from farmers, but they didn’t return necessary products that farmers needed. Their actions caused damage to rural villagers, thus leading to many social problems (1953: 91–107). This condition can be still reflected by the present urban-rural relationship. However, it is the administrative system that has extracted farmers’ interests, instead of gentries who acted between the national authority and civil society. Such revenue system aims only at realizing economic goal, forgetting to return the basic interests to farmers. It may cause social problems.
- 8.
Potlatch of Kwakiutl people was first described by the American anthropologist Franz Boas, and then explained by Benedict, which was generally regarded by subsequent anthropologists as a kind of economic redistribution system. This ceremony distinctly existed among Indians in American northwest coast, especially in groups like Tlingit, Salish and Kwakiutl. According to Chinooks dialect, potlatch can be understood as “give-away”. In that ceremony, local leaders gave away their properties in a seemingly wasteful way. Every family would hold this kind of potlatch . Before the potlatch , they needed to spare no efforts to collect food and valuable articles, such as fish, fur and so on, and gave these materials to local leaders. In potlatch , leaders usually took more articles than their competitors so as to give away their possessions. The more gifts they gave away, the higher status they obtained. Anthropologist Kottak explained this process like: “A village enjoying an especially good year had a surplus of subsistence items, which it could trade for more durable wealth items …. Wealth, in turn, by being distributed, could be converted into prestige …. The long-term adaptive value of intercommunity feasting becomes clear when we consider what happened when a formerly prosperous village had a run of bad luck.” (Kottak 1944: 177).
References
Ash, R. F. (1996). The peasant and the state. In B. Hook (Ed.), The individual and the state in China (pp. 70–103). Oxford: Clarendon Press.
Barry, B. (1995). Justice as impartiality. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
Barton, R. F. (1919). Ifugao law. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Chu, A. (1998). New judicial work and jail work witnessed in Ha’erbin. Collected works of Chu Anping (Part 2) (pp. 298–309). Shanghai: Orient Publishing Center (Original in Chinese).
Duara, P. (1988). Culture, power, and the state: Rural North China, 1900–1942. Stanford: Stanford University Press.
Fei, X. (“Fei Xiaotong” and “Fei Hsiao-Tung” refer to the same person.). (1946). Inland Villages. Shanghai: Shenghuo Publishing House (Original in Chinese).
Fei, H.-T. (1953) China’s gentry: Essays on rural-urban relations (Rev. & ed., Margaret Park Redfield). Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.
Fei, X. (1992). Discussion on township development. Ningxia: Ningxia People’s Publishing House.
Firth, R. (1929). Primitive economics of the New Zealand Maori. London: George Routledge & Sons Ltd.
He, B. (1989). China population studies from 1368 to 1953 (Ge Jianxiong Trans.). Shanghai: Shanghai Ancient Books Publishing House.
Hebei Province Zhao County Chorography Compilation Committee. (1993). Zhao County chorography. Beijing: City Press (Original in Chinese).
Investigation Group of “Wuxi and Baoding” of Institute of Economics, Chinese Academy of Social Sciences. (1999). Chinese village economy: Investigation report of 22 villages in Wuxi and Baoding (1987–1998). Beijing: China Financial and Economic Publishing House (Original in Chinese).
Kottak, C. P. (1994). Anthropology: The exploration of human diversity. New York: McGraw-Hill Inc.
Li, Q. (1996). New theory of Chinese people—Study of popular feelings from Chinese proverb. Beijing: China Social Sciences Publishing House (Original in Chinese).
Liang, Z. (1996a). Customary law in Qing Dynasty: Society and the state. Beijing: China University of Political Science and Law Press (Original in Chinese).
Liang, Z. (1996b). Customary law, society and the state. Reading (9), 45–55 (Original in Chinese).
Malinowski, B. (1926). Crime and custom in savage society. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul Ltd.
Mauss, M. (1990). The gift: The form and reason for exchange in archaic societies (W. D. Halls, Trans.). London: Routledge.
Pound, R. (1942). Social control through law. New Haven: Yale University Press.
Pye, L. W. (1996). The state and the individual: An overview interpretation. In B. Hook (Ed.), The individual and the state in China (pp. 16–42). Oxford: Clarendon Press.
Scott, J. C. (1976). The moral economy of the peasant. New Haven: Yale University Press.
Scott, J. C. (1990). Domination and the arts of resistance. New Haven: Yale University Press.
Sichuan Provincial Archives. (1991). Archives of Baxian County in Qing dynasty: Volume of Qianlong Empire. Beijing: Archives Press (Original in Chinese).
Yunxiang, Y. (1996). The flow of gifts: Reciprocity and social networks in a Chinese village. Stanford: Stanford University Press.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 2019 Foreign Language Teaching and Research Publishing Co., Ltd and Springer-Verlag GmbH Germany, part of Springer Nature
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Zhao, X. (2019). Reciprocity and Power. In: Power and Justice. China Academic Library. Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-662-53834-0_5
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-662-53834-0_5
Published:
Publisher Name: Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg
Print ISBN: 978-3-662-53832-6
Online ISBN: 978-3-662-53834-0
eBook Packages: Social SciencesSocial Sciences (R0)