© 2013

Transformations in Research, Higher Education and the Academic Market

The Breakdown of Scientific Thought

  • Sharon Rider
  • Ylva Hasselberg
  • Alexandra Waluszewski

Part of the Higher Education Dynamics book series (HEDY, volume 39)

Table of contents

  1. Front Matter
    Pages i-vi
  2. Ylva Hasselberg, Sharon Rider, Alexandra Waluszewski
    Pages 1-18
  3. Politics and Policy

  4. Economic Models

  5. Research and Scholarship

    1. Front Matter
      Pages 123-123
    2. Ylva Hasselberg
      Pages 137-144
  6. Higher Education

    1. Front Matter
      Pages 155-155
    2. Michael Gustavsson
      Pages 157-170
    3. Daniel Ankarloo, Torbjörn Friberg
      Pages 187-200
    4. Ylva Hasselberg, Sharon Rider, Alexandra Waluszewski
      Pages 201-214
  7. Back Matter
    Pages 215-221

About this book


This volume tackles head-on the controversy regarding the tensions between the principles underlying Academe on the one hand, and the free market on the other. Its outspoken thesis posits that seemingly irresistible institutional pressures are betraying a core principle of the Enlightenment: that the free pursuit of knowledge is of the highest value in its own right. As ‘market principles’ are forced on universities, inducing a neoteric culture of ‘managerialism’, many worry that the very characteristics that made European higher education in particular such a success are being eroded and replaced by ideological opportunism and economic expediency.
Richly interdisciplinary, the anthology explores a wealth of issues such as the phenomenon of bibliometrics (linking an institution’s success to the volume and visibility of publications produced). Many argue that the use of such indicators to measure scientific value is inimical to the time-consuming complexities of genuine truth-seeking. A number of the greatest discoveries and innovations in the history of science, such as Newton’s laws of mechanics or the Mendelian laws of inheritance, might never have seen the light of day if today’s system of determining and defining the form and content of science had dominated. With analytical perspectives from political science, economics, philosophy and media studies, the collection interrogates, for example, the doctrine of graduate employability that exerts such a powerful influence on course type and structure, especially on technical and professional training. In contrast, the liberal arts must choose between adaptation to the dictates of employability strategies or wither away as enrollments dwindle and resources evaporate. Research projects and aims have also become an area of controversy, with many governments now assessing the value of proposals in terms of assumed commercial benefits. The contributors argue that these changes, as well as ‘reforms’ in the managerial and administrative structures in tertiary education, constitute a radical break with the previous ontology of science and scholarship: a change in its very character, and not merely its form. It shows that the ‘scientific thinking’ students, researchers, and scholars are encouraged to adopt is undergoing a rapid shift in conceptual content, with significant consequences not only for science, but also for the society of which it is a part.


Academic norms Allocation of resources for teaching and research Application of market principles on academic norms Assessment and control of science Assessment of scholarly value Assessment of scientific value Commercialisation of scientific research Commercialisation of teaching Flourishing of science Free market of ideas Privatisation of knowledge Self-understanding of science and scholarship Training in scientific thinking Trends in higher education policy Trends in research policy University as a means for economic growth

Editors and affiliations

  • Sharon Rider
    • 1
  • Ylva Hasselberg
    • 2
  • Alexandra Waluszewski
    • 3
  1. 1., Dept. of PhilosophyUppsala UniversityUppsalaSweden
  2. 2., Department of Economic HistoryUppsala UniversityUppsalaSweden
  3. 3., Department of Economic HistoryUppsala UniversityUppsalaSweden

Bibliographic information

Industry Sectors
Finance, Business & Banking