Effect of the Different Phases of the Menstrual Cycle and Oral Contraceptives on Athletic Performance
- 147 Downloads
The female athlete, during her reproductive years, has a complex and ever-changing milieu of female steroid hormones, whether it is the endogenous variations in estradiol and progesterone of a regular menstrual cycle, or the exogenous synthetic hormones of the oral contraceptives. Both estrogens and progestins have individual, interactive and sometimes opposing physiological actions with potential implications for the exercising female.
In retrospective surveys on the menstrual cycle and performance, from 37 to 63% of athletes did not report any cycle ‘phase’ detriment, while 13 to 29% reported an improvement during menstruation. The best performances were generally in the immediate postmenstrual days, with the worse performances during the premenstrual interval and the first few days of menstrual flow. However, this type of study has an inherent built-in bias, and is further limited by the lack of substantiation of cycle phase.
Many of the women studied associated premenstrual symptoms, such as fluid retention, weight gain, mood changes, and dysmenorrhoea with performance decrement. Such factors have also been causally linked with an increase in traumatic musculoskeletal injuries during the premenstrual and menstrual period. Neuromuscular coordination, manual dexterity, judgement and reaction time for complex tests have been shown to be adversely affected in women with premenstrual syndrome or symptoms, but confounding variables may include nutrition status and blood sugar levels. In addition, not all women suffer to the same level with premenstrual symptoms.
Fluctuations in many physiological functions occur throughout the normal menstrual cycle. Results of early studies are difficult to interpret owing to the small numbers of women studied, wide range of fitness levels, and variability in the definitions of cycle phase. Nevertheless, investigators did not document any significant changes in measures of athletic performance as a function of timing of testing during the menstrual cycle. Swimmers have shown a premenstrual worsening of performance times, with improvement during the menstrual phase and on the eighth day of the cycle. An increase in perceived exertion was noted premenstrually and during the early menstrual stage with very intense exercise. In cross-country skiers, the best times were recorded in the postovulatory and postmenstrual phases, prompting the recommendation that training loads be selected according to cycle phase to achieve maximum benefit.
Investigations using estradiol and progesterone levels as a confirmatory index of ovulation have not generally found significant differences across the cycle in either maximal or submaximal exercise responses, although a slight decrease in aerobic capacity during the luteal phase has been reported. In contrast, an enhancement of endurance performance during the luteal phase, without any concomitant changes in cardiovascular variables has also been reported.
There is evidence to suggest a decrement in isometric strength and endurance, potentially related to an increase in deep muscle temperature during the luteal phase, however, little accurate information exists on the influence of menstrual cycle phase on strength.
Increased progesterone and estradiol levels during the luteal phase leads to a net fluid retention because of a complex interaction of the aldosterone/renin/angiotensin systems. Consequently, there are changes in serum electrolytes, osmolality, and minor variations in haemoglobin, but these have no measurable repercussions for performance. Cardiac output is increased, primarily through an increase in plasma volume and stroke volume.
Results of studies, with and without hormonal documentation, are inconsistent regarding heat stress responses during exercise. Similarly trained and acclimated men and women do not display any differences in thermoregulation. Sweat rate is not significantly affected by the alterations in steroid hormones during the menstrual cycle. Nevertheless, the higher core temperature during the luteal phase is postulated to increase cardiovascular strain (as evidenced by an increased heart rate) and level of perceived exertion during exercise. The temperature-induced increase in metabolic rate has also been associated with decreased exercise efficiency and increased mean oxygen consumption.
High progesterone levels during the luteal phase and pregnancy stimulate ventilation and the ventilatory responses to hypoxia and hypercapnia. Success in endurance sports has been correlated with blunted respiratory drives, therefore enhancement of this ventilatory responsiveness may be detrimental in athletes. Nonathletic women have been shown to have altered exercise performance, possibly because of a subjective sensation of dyspnoea, but no effects have been shown with elite female athletes. A synthetic progestin, medroxyprogesterone acetate, when administered to both men and women, causes similar respiratory changes without any corresponding performance decrement. Investigators have not been able to correlate actual progesterone levels with the alterations in ventilatory drives. Estradiol acts to potentiate the action of progesterone through its induction of progesterone receptors.
There is a gender difference in substrate metabolism during exercise. Estrogen and progesterone enhance muscle glycogen storage and uptake. Increased estradiol levels also promote lipolysis and lipid synthesis. A shift in metabolism towards free fatty acids leads to a decrease in glycogenolysis and gluconeogenesis. A greater urinary protein loss during the luteal phase reflects greater protein catabolism. Blood glucose levels vary during the menstrual cycle, but differences are affected by altering the pre-exercise nutritional status of the athletes. Other hormones, particularly catecholamines and growth hormone have also been shown to be important. Increased estradiol levels act to increase growth hormone, which in turn stimulates fat mobilisation.
Oral contraceptives are frequently administered to athletes for a variety of therapeutic reasons. The original formulations contained higher dosages of both estrogens and progestins. Surveys showed that half the women did not notice any difference in performance, and 8% even noted an improvement with higher dosages. Musculoskeletal injuries have been shown to be reduced in women taking oral contraceptives, possibly because of a reduction of dysmenorrhoea and premenstrual symptoms. Some cross-sectional studies have found an increase in oxygen consumption for a standardised workload in women taking oral contraceptives. A slight decrease in maximal aerobic capacity with a decrease in muscle mitochondrial citrate has been demonstrated, suggesting a potential cellular mechanism. Recent investigations have shown a slight decrease in maximum oxgen uptake (V̇O2max), without alterations in any of the cardiovascular variables.
Oral contraceptives appear to have little impact on strength indices, although there is limited evidence of a detrimental effect on isometric endurance. Since the androgenic actions of the progesterone component diminish with the newer preparations, there is likely no significant influence of the exogenous hormones.
Synthetic steroid hormones can influence vascular volume, ventilation and substrate metabolism. Combined oral contraceptives increase cardiac output more than progestin-only formulations implying that the estrogen effect dominates. An augmented stroke volume may potentially increase oxygen delivery to the tissues, and the reduction in menstrual blood loss may also be beneficial for performance. An increase in ventilation has been demonstrated with oral contraceptive use, but the studies which showed small alterations in performance, however, have not shown any of the respiratory changes.
Substrate metabolism is also influenced by oral contraceptives, with varying effects on glucose and insulin. Other hormones such as thyroxine, cortisol, catecholamines and growth hormone have a counterregulatory action. Progesterone acts to oppose insulin binding, through a decrease in insulin receptor numbers. The effects on growth hormone (GH), which is also a potent stimulator of lipolysis, depend on the relative concentrations of estradiol and progesterone, which increase and decrease GH levels, respectively. A net shift towards triglyceride use may be potentially advantageous during extended endurance exercise. Lower blood glucose levels and decreased carbohydrate utilisation found both at rest and during exercise may result from the glycogen-sparing actions of the hormones and may also reflect decreased hepatic production.
In general, the effects of oral contraceptives on athletic performance have diminished with the lower dosages of these medications. The overall advantages, including the noncontraceptive health benefits, probably outweigh any small observed differences. There is, however, a large degree of interindividual variability that must be considered in the clinical situation, both during the menstrual cycle and with administration of oral contraceptives.
KeywordsMenstrual Cycle Oral Contraceptive Luteal Phase Female Athlete Apply Physiology
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
- Allsen PE, Parsons P, Bryce GR. Effect of the menstrual cycle on maximum oxygen uptake. Physician and Sportsmedicine 5: 53–55, 1977Google Scholar
- Bale P, Nelson G. The effects of menstruation on performance of swimmers. Australian Journal of Science and Medicine in Sport March: 19–22, 1985Google Scholar
- Bemden DA, Boileau RA, Bahr JM, Nelson RA, Misner JE. Effects of oral contraceptives on hormonal and metabolic responses during exercise. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise 24: 434–441, 1992Google Scholar
- Bonen A, Keizer HA. Athletic menstrual cycle irregularity: endocrine response to exercise and training. Physician and Sportsmedicine 12: 78–94, 1984Google Scholar
- Brooks-Gunn J, Gargiulo JM, Warren MP. The effect of cycle phase on the adolescent swimmers. Physician and Sportsmedicine 14: 182–192, 1986Google Scholar
- Bunt JC. Metabolic actions of estradiol: significance for acute and chronic exercise response. Medicine and Science in Sport and Exercise 22: 286–290, 1990Google Scholar
- Canada. Fitness and Amateur Sport. Sport Canada Policy on Women in Sport. Ottawa. Fitness and Amateur Sport: Condition physique et sport amateur pp. 1–27, 1986Google Scholar
- Daggett A, Davies B, Boobis L. Physiological and biochemical responses to exercise following oral contraceptive use. Abstract. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise 15: 174, 1983Google Scholar
- De Bruyn-Prevost P, Masset C, Sturbois X. Physiological response from 18–25 years women to aerobic and anaerobic physical fitness tests at different periods during the menstrual cycle. Journal of Sports Medicine 24: 144–148, 1984Google Scholar
- Doolittle TL, Engebretsen J. Performance variations during the menstrual cycle. Journal of Sports Medicine 12: 54–58, 1972Google Scholar
- England SJ, Farhi LE. Fluctuations in alveolar CO2 and in base excess during the menstrual cycle. Respiratory Physiology 26: 157–161, 1976Google Scholar
- Erdelyi GJ. Gynecological survey of female athletes. Journal of Sports Medicine and Physical Fitness 2: 174–179, 1962Google Scholar
- Eston RG, Burke EJ. Effects of the menstrual cycle on selected responses to short constant-load exercise. Journal of Sports Sciences 2: 145–153, 1984Google Scholar
- Fomin SK, Pivovarova VI, Voronova VI. Changes in the special working capacity and mental stability of well-trained woman skiers at various phases of the biological cycle. Sports Training Medicine and Rehabilitation 1: 89–92, 1989Google Scholar
- Fox EL, Martin FL, Bartels RL. Metabolic and cardiorespiratory responses to exercise during the menstrual cycle in trained and untrained subjects. Abstract. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise 9: 70, 1977Google Scholar
- Gaebelein CJ, Senay, Jr LC. Vascular volume dynamics during ergometer exercise at different menstrual phases. European Journal of Applied Physiology 50: 1–11, 1982Google Scholar
- Gamberale F, Strindberg L, Wahlberg I. Female work capacity during the menstrual cycle: physiological and psychological reactions. Scandinavian Journal of Work Environment and Health 1: 120–127, 1975Google Scholar
- Garlick MA, Bernauer EM. Exercise during the menstrual cycle: variations in physiological baselines. Research Quarterly of the American Association for Health and Physical Education 39: 533–542, 1968Google Scholar
- Hackney AC, Curley CS, Nicklas BJ. Physiologic responses to sub-maximal exercise at the mid-follicular, ovulatory and mid-luteal phases of the menstrual cycle. Scandinavian Journal of Medicine and Science in Sport 1: 94–98, 1991Google Scholar
- Higgs SL, Robertson LA. Cyclic variations in perceived exertion and physical work capacity in females. Canadian Journal of Applied Sport Sciences 6: 191–196, 1981Google Scholar
- Horvath SM, Drinkwater BL. Thermoregulation and the menstrual cycle. Aviation Space Environmental Medicine 53: 790–794, 1982Google Scholar
- Ingman O. Menstruation in Finnish top-class sportswomen. In: Karvonen (Ed.) Sports Medicine, pp. 96–99, Finnish Association of Sports Medicine, Helsinki, 1953Google Scholar
- Jurkowski JEH, Jones NL, Walker WE, Younglai EV, Sutton JR. Ovarian hormonal responses to exercise. Journal of Applied Physiology: Respiratory, Environmental and Exercise Physiology 44: 109–114, 1978Google Scholar
- Keizer, HA, Van Schaik FW, DeBeer EL, Schiereck P, Van Heeswyk G. Exercise-induced changes in estradiol metabolism and their possible physiological meaning. Medicine and Sport Baseline 14: 125–140, 1981Google Scholar
- Kral J, Markalous K. The influence of menstruation on sport performance. In: Mollwitz, A. Proceedings of the 2nd International Congress on Sports Medicine, Thieme-Stratton, Leipzig, 1939Google Scholar
- Lamont LS. Lack of influence of the menstrual cycle on blood lactate. Physician and Sportsmedicine 14: 159–163, 1986Google Scholar
- Lamont LS, Lemon PWR, Brust BC. Menstrual cycle and exercise effects on protein catabolism. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise 192: 106–110, 1987Google Scholar
- Lebrun CM, McKenzie DC, Prior JC, Taunton JE. Effects of menstrual cycle phase on athletic performance. Submitted for publication, 1993aGoogle Scholar
- Lebrun CM, McKenzie DC, Prior JC, Taunton JE. Effects of a triphasic oral contraceptive on athletic performance. Submitted for publication, 1993bGoogle Scholar
- Martin BJ, Sparks KE, Zwillich CW, Weil JV. Low exercise ventilation in endurance athletes. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise 11: 181–185, 1979Google Scholar
- McNeill AW, Mozingo E. Changes in the metabolic cost of standardized work associated with the use of an oral contraceptive. Journal of Sports Medicine 21: 238–244, 1981Google Scholar
- Merions DR, Haskell WL, Vranizon KM, Phelps J, Woods PD, et al. Relationship of exercise, oral contraceptive use and body fat to concentrations of plasma lipids and lipoprotein cholesterol in young women. American Journal of Medicine 78: 913–919, 1985Google Scholar
- Petrofsky JS, Lind AR. The relationship of body fat content to deep muscle temperature and isometric endurance in man. Clinical Science 48:405–412, 1975Google Scholar
- Pivamik JM, Marichal CJ, Spillman T, Morrow Jr JR. Menstrual cycle phase affects temperature regulation during endurance exercise. Journal of Applied Physiology 72: 543–548, 1992Google Scholar
- Prange-Hansen A, Weeke J. Fasting serum growth hormone levels and growth hormone responses to exercise during normal menstrual cycles and cycles on oral contraceptives. SCandinavian Journal of Clinical Laboratory Investigation 34: 199–205, 1974Google Scholar
- Prior JC, Vigna YM. Absence of motimina: The clinical or self-diagnosis of anovulation. Society Menstrual Cycle Research. Ann Arbor, Michigan June (Abstract), JuneGoogle Scholar
- Prior JC, Vigna YM. Ovulation disturbances and exercise training. Clinics in Obstretics and Gynecology 34: 180–190, 1991Google Scholar
- Quadagno D, Faquin L, Lim G-N, Kuminka W, Moffatt R. The menstrual cycle: does it affect athletic performance? Physician and Sportsmedicine 19: 121–124, 1991Google Scholar
- Robertson LA, Higgs LS. Menstrual cycle variations in physical work capacity, post-exercuse blood lactate, and perceived exertion. Canadian Journal of Applied Sports Sciences 8: 220, 1983Google Scholar
- Selye H. The effect of adaption to various damaging agents on the female sex organs of the rat. Endocrinology 25: 615–624, 1939Google Scholar
- Shangold MM. Menstrual irregularity in athletes: basic principles, evaluation and treatment. Canadian Journal of Applied Sport Sciences 7: 68–73, 1982Google Scholar
- Shangold MM, Mirkin G (Eds). In: Women and exercise: physiology and sports medicine, pp. 140–141, FA Davis Co., Philadelphia, 1988Google Scholar
- Vellar OD. Changes in hemoglobin concentration and hematocrit during the menstrual cycle. Acta Obstetrica Gynecologica Scandinavia 53: 243–246, 1974Google Scholar
- Vollman RF. The menstrual cycle. In: Friedman (Ed.) Major problems in obstetrics and gynecology, Vol. 7, W.B. Saunders Co., Toronto, 1977Google Scholar