A case of recurrent depressive disorder presenting with Alice in Wonderland syndrome: psychopathology and pre- and post-treatment FDG-PET findings
- 855 Downloads
Alice in Wonderland syndrome (AIWS) is a rare neuropsychiatric syndrome that typically manifests in distortion of extrapersonal visual image, altered perception of one’s body image, and a disturbed sense of the passage of distance and time. Several conditions have been reported to contribute to AIWS, although its biological basis is still unknown. Here, we present the first case demonstrating a clear concurrence of recurrent depressive disorder and AIWS. The clinical manifestations and pre- and post-treatment fluorodeoxyglucose positron-emission tomographic (FDG-PET) images provide insights into the psychopathological and biological basis of AIWS.
We describe a 63-year-old Japanese male who developed two distinct episodes of major depression concurrent with AIWS. In addition to typical AIWS perceptual symptoms, he complained of losing the ability to intuitively grasp the seriousness of news and the value of money, which implies disturbance of high-order cognition related to estimating magnitude and worth. Both depression and AIWS remitted after treatment in each episode. Pre-treatment FDG-PET images showed significant hypometabolism in the frontal cortex and hypermetabolism in the occipital and parietal cortex. Post-treatment images showed improvement of these abnormalities.
The clinical co-occurrence of depressive episodes and presentation of AIWS can be interpreted to mean that they have certain functional disturbances in common. In view of incapacity, indifference, devitalization, altered perception of one’s body image, and disturbed sense of time and space, the features of AIWS analogous to those of psychotic depression imply a common psychopathological basis. These high-order brain dysfunctions are possibly associated with the metabolic abnormalities in visual and parietotemporal association cortices that we observed on the pre- and post-treatment FDG-PET images in this case, while the hypometabolism in the frontal cortex is probably associated with depressive symptoms.
KeywordsAlice in Wonderland syndrome Recurrent depressive disorder Psychotic depression Fluorodeoxyglucose positron emission tomography High-order brain function Case report
Alice in Wonderland syndrome
Beck Depression Inventory-II
Fluorodeoxyglucose positron emission tomography
Mini-Mental State Examination
Magnetic resonance imaging
Subtraction ictal SPECT coregistered to MRI
Single photon emission computed tomography
Alice in Wonderland syndrome (AIWS) is a rare neuropsychiatric syndrome, which Todd  named after the character created by Lewis Carroll. Collective manifestations of AIWS include distortion of extrapersonal visual image (micropsia, macropsia, metamorphopsia, teleopsia, and pelopsia), altered perception of one’s body image, and a disturbed sense of the passage of distance and time .
Many conditions have been reported to contribute to AIWS, and Lanska et al.  indicates that viral infection and migraine are the two most commonly identified causes, occurring preferentially in young individuals. To the best of our knowledge, only two reports to date have associated AIWS with a depressive disorder [3, 4], neither of which clearly showed the concurrent nature of major depressive episodes and AIWS.
Evidence from a number of studies using fluorodeoxyglucose positron emission tomography (FDG-PET) indicates that specific cortical regions, primarily in the frontal cortex, are related to mood disorders. However, the results from imaging studies have not yielded a clear story, and many conflict with each other [5, 6, 7]. One of the more consistent findings with regard to depression, is that hypometabolism in the frontal cortex is characteristic in patients with depressive episodes, and can be partially reversed by successful treatment. In contrast, the biological basis of AIWS is even less clear, although a few studies have made attempts studying it using functional brain imaging [8, 9, 10, 11].
Here, we present a case of an older patient whose recurrent depressive episodes and AIWS emerged and remitted simultaneously with successful treatment with antidepressants, antipsychotics, and electroconvulsive therapy (ECT). This is the first report showing the concurrent and recurrent nature of, depressive episodes and AIWS, and the strong association between the two. The clinical manifestations and pre- and post-treatment FDG-PET images provide insights into the psychopathological and biological basis of AIWS.
Here, we report the case of a 63-year-old Japanese man with no medical or psychiatric history, except for type-2 diabetes mellitus and essential hypertension. He had no previous history of psychotropic drug use, including antidepressants and antipsychotics. Additionally, he had no developmental abnormalities or neurodevelopmental disorders. He held a steady job from college graduation until retirement age, and his wife described his premorbid personality as dependable, sociable, and patient. He had no family history of psychiatric disorders, migraine, or epilepsy.
One year before his first admission to an inpatient psychiatric unit, he started experiencing mild depressive moods and fatigue that did not disrupt his day-to-day functioning. Two months before the first hospital admission, he began complaining about typical AIWS symptoms, including micropsia, altered perception of his body image, and a disturbed sense of the passage of distance and time. All sorts of objects in his environment, such as buildings and cars, looked extremely small to him. He gave up driving because cars looked so small that he lost his sense of speed and distance in relation to the cars around him. Nearby objects also looked very small, with the single exception of pill strips that he had difficulty opening. Moreover, even though he knew it was not possible, he felt as if he could ‘step over’ long distances in a flash, such as the 50 km from his suburban town to the center of Tokyo. Additionally, he felt that days passed extremely quickly, as if in a single moment. He also sometimes felt his body was slightly enlarged or shrunken compared with normal. These AIWS symptoms persisted all day long during the depressive episodes.
In addition to the typical AIWS symptoms described above, he also complained of disturbances in high-order cognition. For instance, he said, “I cannot sense how important the news is. For example, when I see news about a serial murder on television, I can understand intellectually how sad it is, but I cannot realize it emotionally”. Similarly, he said, “I cannot appreciate the value of money. Even if there were a ¥10,000 bill in front of me, I wouldn’t care about it because I can’t realize how much value it would have”. Although his bowel movements and urination were normal, he complained of a decreased urge to defecate and urinate.
The depressed mood, loss of interest and pleasure, psychomotor retardation, fatigue, and reduced concentration gradually worsened. He was referred to a neurologist. Organic causes were ruled out as follows: his blood-sugar level and blood pressure were well controlled with insulin injections and oral medications; he was a non-drinker, had no history of head trauma, and took no medications associated with adverse reactions that could mimic depression, such as beta-blockers and cimetidine. Neurological examinations and laboratory tests including endocrine evaluations and an HIV test, electroencephalography, and brain magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) detected no abnormalities. He was then referred to a psychiatrist. After confirming that he was not experiencing a manic episode, was not using illicit drugs, and had not experienced any recent stressful life events, he was diagnosed as having a severe depressive episode with AIWS. His condition worsened to the degree that he could not continue working despite taking paroxetine, and he was hospitalized for the first time.
At this first admission, he was bed-ridden all day because of severe depressive symptoms. Administration of amitriptyline (75 mg/day) and perphenazine (6 mg/day) induced gradual improvement of depressive and AIWS symptoms. He was discharged on day 47 after he had remitted almost completely from the depressive episode, with the exception of easily becoming fatigued and waking at night. At that time, he was also completely remitted from AIWS. His day-to-day functioning returned to normal, and his work and life continued as they had before the episode began.
Three years after discharge, he relapsed into another major depressive episode, again simultaneously presenting with AIWS. The symptoms worsened despite the use of amitriptyline (50 mg/day) and aripiprazole (6 mg/day) in the outpatient clinic. The Visual Perception Test for Agnosia detected nothing abnormal. His thoughts became stunted and he became very inactive, lying in bed all day. He continuously refused inpatient treatment because he delusionally believed he was too poor. Upon the strong recommendation from his family, 8 months after this recurrence, he was admitted to the hospital with recurrent severe depressive symptoms and AIWS at the age of 67 years.
At this second admission, he was alert and oriented, but had prolonged speech latency and spoke in a slow and quiet manner without making eye contact. His face was unshaven and he did not smile. Dementia was ruled out as a plausible cause of his symptoms for the following reasons: 1) his Mini-Mental State Examination (MMSE) score was 28/30 during this depressive episode, 2) he made a complete recovery from the observed reduction in concentration and processing speed after treatment of the first episode, 3) he exhibited no other signs of recognizable cognitive decline such as impaired executive function, learning, memory, language, or social recognition, and 4) he did not exhibit any typical symptoms of common dementia subtypes, such as amnesia, fluctuating cognition, visual hallucinations, extrapyramidal symptoms, or behavioral symptoms. Evidence of depressive symptoms and AIWS was comparable between the first and second episodes. He scored 30/63 on the Beck Depression Inventory-II (BDI-II), indicating severe depression. An ophthalmologist confirmed no eye/visual abnormalities with the exception of bilateral cataracts. Pre-therapy FDG-PET was performed as described below. After 2 weeks of maprotiline (75 mg/day) had no effect, twice-weekly ECT, duloxetine (60 mg/day) and mirtazapine (45 mg/day) were administered. He remitted completely from AIWS and almost completely from the depressive episode after 12 ECT sessions, except for a mild reduction in concentration. He scored 12/63 on the BDI-II, which also indicated significant recovery from depression. He was discharged after 75 days, just after post-therapeutic FDG-PET was performed.
FDG-PET acquisition, visual inspection, and statistical analysis
We obtained the pre- and post-treatment FDG-PET images of the brain during the second admission. The patient was kept at rest in supine posture with a blinder in a quiet and dim room from 10 min before each PET examination until the end of the scan. Scans were recorded with a PET scanner (Advance NXi; GE Medical Systems, Milwaukee, WI, USA) 45 min after the injection of 296 MBq FDG.
Synchronicity of depressive episodes and AIWS
In this case study, we described an older patient presenting with two distinct major depressive episodes, both of which occurred simultaneously with episodes of AIWS. Both sets of symptoms remitted completely after standard treatment for psychotic depression (i.e., an antidepressant plus an antipsychotic, or ECT), and we excluded the potential influence of dementia and other organic causes. This is the first report that clearly shows a link between recurrent depressive disorder and AIWS. The clinical co-occurrence of depressive episodes and AIWS can be interpreted as arising from common functional disturbances. Below we elaborate on the relationship between AIWS and severe depression from the viewpoints of psychopathology and of neuroimaging.
AIWS presenting in the course of psychotic depression
Lanska et al. reported that a variety of conditions contribute to AIWS, including infection, migraine, toxic encephalopathy, major depression, epileptic seizures, medications, and stroke . However, to date, only two case reports have shown an association between depressive episodes and AIWS [3, 4]. Mizuno et al. reported a 54-year-old man who exhibited depressive symptoms with AIWS (metamorphopsia, disturbed sense of passage of time, and distortion of body image). In that case, AIWS disappeared 2 days after admission despite no improvement in depressive symptoms . Bui et al. reported a 74-year-old man who showed severe depressive symptoms with persecutory and somatic delusions (his stools being contaminated) and AIWS (he thought his hands and feet were shorter than usual), all of which remitted completely with ECT . Importantly, both cases presented with psychotic depression during the clinical course. In Mizuno et al., the patient developed a delusion of culpability and in Bui et al., the patient developed persecutory and somatic delusions. Our patient also transiently developed delusions (he believed he was poor) during the depressive episode. The clinical presentation of these three cases indicates an association between AIWS and psychotic depression in particular.
Psychopathological similarities between AIWS and psychotic depression
Patients with psychotic depression tend to regard themselves as being useless, or consider everything meaningless. They also claim to lose a grasp on proper emotions and visceral sensations. Stanghellini et al. extensively reviewed the psychopathology of depression and described the qualitative features of experience in patients with psychotic depression to include incapacity, indifference, timelessness, and bodily devitalization . Failure to sense the significance or magnitude of external facts or objects, such as the difficulty with news and money seen in our patient, can be viewed as being part of the incapacity or indifference categories. Being unable to estimate or sense one’s own urge to urinate or make bowel movements can also be explained by indifference or devitalization. According to Stanghellini et al. constriction of time and body experiences, as well as shrinking and extension of space, occur in major depression. Perceptual alterations in space, time, and body seem to be notably analogous to that of AIWS. Thus, we argue that comorbidity of AIWS and psychotic depression in our case was not by chance, but occurred because of a common underlying brain dysfunction.
Interpretation of FDG-PET results
The frontal cortex hypometabolism in our case was probably related to the depressive symptoms (Fig. 1). Hosokawa et al. reported that euthymic patients exhibited fewer areas with significantly low metabolism than did depressed patients in the cross-sectional study . In our case, the decreased metabolism of bilateral frontal cortex and anterior cingulate cortex during the second depressive episode improved after treatment, although these alterations were not statistically significant. These results are consistent with many studies demonstrating that metabolism in the frontal cortex decreases in patients with depressive episodes and can be partially reversed by treatment [5, 6].
The significant metabolic abnormalities and alterations in the posterior half of the cerebral cortex are the main characteristics of our case (Figs. 1, 2). These regions include the primary visual cortex, precuneus, posterior cingulate, and temporal, parietal, and extrastriate cortices. The abnormalities in these association cortices possibly correspond to positive symptoms in our case, such as delusions of poverty or experiencing alterations in space, time, and body, which are not simply perceptual, but also include high-order cognitive disturbances. The parieto-occipital hypermetabolism in our case might also be associated with a common underlying abnormality that occurs in both psychotic depression and AIWS, although this should be explored in future studies.
We present the first case demonstrating a clear relationship between recurrent depressive disorder and AIWS. The co-occurrence and similarities in clinical manifestations between AIWS and psychotic depression imply a common psychopathological basis. The metabolic abnormalities seen in high-order brain regions on FDG-PET images suggest a biological basis of AIWS and psychotic symptoms of depression. Careful analysis of psychiatric symptoms comparing with metabolic changes using FDG-PET provides new insights into higher-order involvements, not only primary visual perception, in AIWS and psychotic depression.
The authors are grateful to the patient and his family for their help and support in writing this case report. The authors thank Dr. Kiyoto Kasai for his general support. The authors also wish to express their deepest gratitude to Dr. Atsushi Iwata, Dr. Toshihiro Hayashi, Dr. Toji Miyagawa, and Dr. Kazuyuki Sugishita (Memory clinic of Tokyo University Hospital) for their support.
Availability of data materials
The data sets supporting the results of this article are included within the article.
TY, TO, and SK were responsible for the clinical decisions outlined in this report. TY, MT, and SK drafted the manuscript. TO conceived the report and helped to draft the manuscript. MT performed the FDG-PET analysis. TM supported with the FDG-PET analysis. SK was critically involved in the theoretical discussion and writing the manuscript. All authors contributed to the literature review and manuscript preparation and approved the final manuscript.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Consent for publication
Written informed consent for the publication of the case report was obtained from the patient.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
Approval by the University of Tokyo Hospital ethics committee was obtained (3349-(4)).
Open AccessThis article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated.