Translating molecular medicine into clinical tools: doomed to fail by neglecting basic preanalytical principles
This commentary discusses a study on measurements of matrix metalloproteinase 9 (MMP-9) in serum of pseudoxanthoma elasticum patients recently published in Journal of Molecular Medicine. This study can be considered the typical "obstacle" to effective translational medicine as previously documented in JTM journal. Although serum has been frequently proven as inappropriate sample for determining numerous circulating MMPs, among them MMP-9, there are over and over again studies, as in this case, that measure MMP-9 in serum. Comparative measurements in serum and plasma samples demonstrated higher concentrations for MMP-9 in serum due to the additional release from leukocytes and platelets following the coagulation/fibrinolysis process. From this example it can be concluded that translating basic research discoveries into clinical tools needs a more intensive exchange between basic biomedical research and clinical scientists already in an early stage. Otherwise a lost of translation, as discussed in JTM journal, seems to be inevitable.
KeywordsClot Activator Translational Medicine Pseudoxanthoma Elasticum Effective Translation Blood Processing
Diekmann et al.  recently reported data in the Journal of Molecular Medicine on the increased serum concentrations of circulating matrix metalloproteinases 2 and 9 (MMP-2; MMP-9) in patients suffering from pseudoxanthoma elasticum. This genetic disorder, caused by mutations in the transporter gene ABCC6, is characterized by alterations in the extracellular matrix, especially in the skin, retina, and the vascular system. The authors reported that MMP-9 in serum was found both in male and female patients about 2.5-times higher than that in healthy controls, whereas MMP-2 was elevated only in female patients. On this basis, the authors hypothesized that the development of the symptoms of pseudoxanthoma elasticum could be attributed to the action of MMPs, since these enzymes are well known to be involved in the initial step of damage and/or the following remodelling, repairing processes of extracellular matrix . The authors concluded that the measurement of serum MMP-2 and MMP-9 could be applied for non-invasive monitoring of matrix-degradative processes in pseudoxanthoma elasticum. In this respect, the use of MMP-2 and MMP-9 as surrogate biomarkers suggested by Diekmann et al.  may be appreciated as a nice example of translational medicine, defined as "the transfer of new understandings of disease mechanisms gained in the laboratory into the development of new methods for diagnosis, therapy, and prevention and their first testing in humans"  or "effective translation of the new knowledge, mechanisms, and techniques generated by advances in basic science research into new approaches for prevention, diagnosis, and treatment of disease ....for improving health" .
The study of Diekmann et al.  deals with an interesting topic and shows the potential of basic science discovery to improve clinical medicine. However, a closer and accurate re-examination of this "bench-to-bedside" example manifests that Diekmann et al.  have neglected the opposite "bedside-to-bench" effort of translational medicine as second part of its "two-way road" principle . According to growing literature evidence demonstrating that blood sampling strongly influences the measurement and recovery of "true" circulating matrix metalloproteinases (MMPs) and their tissue inhibitors (TIMPs), we would like to draw attention on the preanalytical impact of blood collection/handling methods in order to limit technical pitfalls that may lead to misinterpretations. In particular, the authors did not consider that serum was demonstrated as inappropriate sample for measuring circulating MMP-9. Noteworthy, the misuse of serum as sample for determining circulating MMP-9 was frequently considered inadequate, both in clinical and biochemical/analytical journals [6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11]. It was additionally pointed out that technical details of sampling and handling procedures (like the time between venipuncture and centrifugation of blood samples as well as the use of different anticoagulants) must be taken into consideration with more attention and have to be reported due to their known crucial influence on the concentrations and activation/inhibition patterns of MMP-9 [12, 13]. Thus, the fundamental significance of blood processing as important preanalytical determinant of accurate measurements of really circulating MMPs in peripheral blood, especially for MMP-9, has been clearly overlooked by Diekmann et al. . It is a typical example that may be considered as of one of the significant "obstacles" to effective translational medicine contributing to the "lost of translation" as well documented in JTM journal .
Figure 1A shows that higher MMP-9 concentrations were found in serum in comparison with plasma samples. Moreover, the highest values of MMP-9 were observed in serum(+) samples obtained after kaolin-enhanced clotting. They were up-to 4 times higher compared with those in serum(-) samples collected without clot activator and about 15 times higher than those in citrate plasma. In contrast, the MMP-2 concentrations were influenced to a less extent by the blood collection procedures (Figure 1B); in fact, in citrate plasma, MMP-2 concentrations were about 10% lower than in the other three kinds of samples. For these reasons and according to literature, plasma sample (e.g., obtained with citrate as anticoagulant) has been suggested to be the sample of choice for measuring circulating MMP-9 [16, 17, 18].
These data underline that MMP-9 concentrations detected in serum do not correspond to the true concentrations of MMP-9 circulating in blood. In fact, it has been demonstrated that increased MMP-9 concentrations in serum, in comparison to plasma samples, arise from the secretion of MMP-9 linked to platelet and leukocyte degranulation during coagulation/fibrinolysis processes (epiphenomenon greatly enhanced by kaolin-granulate) [8, 13]. It is noteworthy to highlight that both mRNA and protein of ABCC6, causative of the pseudoxanthoma elasticum, have been identified in leukocytes, macrophages, and lymphocytes [19, 20], and that all these white blood cells abundantly contain MMP-9 [21, 22].
Preconditions for a reasonably feasible extrapolation from serum to plasma data would be based on strong correlations between serum and plasma values and equal ratios of serum to plasma values in controls and the diseased cohort (e.g., equal slopes in the regression equations between the two kinds of samples in controls and the diseased patients). Although correlations of MMP-9 and MMP-2 between serum and plasma samples exist in patients with gestational hypertension and periodontal disease  (but they are obviously unknown for pseudoxanthoma elasticum patients), comparative measurements in other patient groups  showed that the high unspecific "background" concentration of MMP-9 in serum obviously was not related to the true pathological process of interest, thus impairing the potential diagnostic performance of MMP-9 biochemical evaluation . Moreover, the use of serum collected under similar conditions both in healthy and diseased patients is surely not suited to circumvent that misleading procedure especially since the technical details of sampling procedures (e.g., the presence of clot activator in serum tube, the time among sample collection, centrifugation and assay ) were not clearly described by Diekman et al. . Furthermore, the potential difference in leukocyte counts and profiles between patients affected by pseudoxanthoma elasticum and healthy subjects may significantly affect the release from white blood cells and platelets during clotting and subsequent recovery in serum of MMP-9. These preanalytical pitfalls can be avoided by the use of more standardized conditions and the use of plasma samples [15, 16]. Thus, if this known "bedside" experience of clinical scientists concerning preanalytical issues of blood sampling as important part of a study design is disregarded, it cannot be expected that serum MMPs result in reliable surrogate biomarkers .
In conclusion, to ensure an effective translation between basic biomedical research and clinical practice, appropriate preanalytical procedures of sample collection and handling have to be laid down; this is particularly true when investigating the potential diagnostic power of a biomarker in clinical trials [25, 26]. This principle should be considered already in an early stage to transfer basic science discoveries into new clinical tools. In addition, molecular medicine journals should recognize and support with their publication policy that important, though neglected issue. In particular, studies on MMPs and their tissue inhibitors TIMPs in physio-pathological conditions should address these preanalytical effects to avoid pitfalls and misinterpretations due to crucial interfering factors of blood processing, not properly taken into consideration .
- 8.Mannello F, Tonti GA, Tanus-Santos JE, Gerlach RF: Silicate increases the release of MMP-9 forms in peripheral blood: why gelatin zymography differs significantly in citrate plasma and serum obtained with or without clot activators. Clin Chem. 2007, 53: 1981-1982. 10.1373/clinchem.2007.090548.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
- 9.Mannello F, Tonti GA, Canestrari F: The 'never-ending story' of the influence of blood specimen collection methods affecting the concentration, the zymographic profile and the usefulness of matrix metalloproteinases and their tissue inhibitors in multiple sclerosis diagnosis/prognosis: a landmark for limiting the misuse of serum samples. Mult Scler. 2007, 13: 687-690. 10.1177/1352458506072492.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
- 11.Mannello F: Serum or plasma samples? The "Cinderella" role of blood collection procedures: preanalytical methodological issues influence the release and activity of circulating matrix metalloproteinases and their tissue inhibitors, hampering diagnostic trueness and leading to misinterpretation. Arterioscler Thromb Vasc Biol. 2008, 28: 611-614. 10.1161/ATVBAHA.107.159608.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
- 13.Mannello F, Tonti GA: Gelatinase concentrations and zymographic profiles in human breast cancer: matrix metalloproteinases circulating in plasma are better markers for the subclassification and early prediction of cancer: the coagulation/fibrinolysis pathways alter the release, activation and recovery of different gelatinases in serum. Int J Cancer. 2007, 121: 216-218. 10.1002/ijc.22652.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
- 24.Wu CY, Wu MS, Chiang EP, Chen YJ, Chen CJ, Chi NH, Shih YT, Chen GH, Lin JT: Plasma matrix metalloproteinase-9 level is better than serum matrix metalloproteinase-9 level to predict gastric cancer evolution. Clin Cancer Res. 2007, 13: 2054-2060. 10.1158/1078-0432.CCR-06-2299.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.