Ebola virus infection inversely correlates with the overall expression levels of promyelocytic leukaemia (PML) protein in cultured cells
Ebola virus causes severe, often fatal hemorrhagic fever in humans. The mechanism of escape from cellular anti-viral mechanisms is not yet fully understood. The promyelocytic leukaemia (PML) associated nuclear body is part of the interferon inducible cellular defense system. Several RNA viruses have been found to interfere with the anti-viral function of the PML body. The possible interaction between Ebola virus and the PML bodies has not yet been explored.
We found that two cell lines, Vero E6 and MCF7, support virus production at high and low levels respectively. The expression of viral proteins was visualized and quantified using high resolution immunofluorescence microscopy. Ebola encoded NP and VP35 accumulated in cytoplasmic inclusion bodies whereas VP40 was mainly membrane associated but it was also present diffusely in the cytoplasm as well as in the euchromatic areas of the nucleus. The anti-VP40 antibody also allowed the detection of extracellular virions. Interferon-alpha treatment decreased the production of all three viral proteins and delayed the development of cytopathic effects in both cell lines. Virus infection and interferon-alpha treatment induced high levels of PML protein expression in MCF7 but much less in Vero E6 cells. No disruption of PML bodies, a common phenomenon induced by a variety of different viruses, was observed.
We have established a simple fixation and immunofluorescence staining procedure that allows specific co-detection and precise sub-cellular localization of the PML nuclear bodies and the Ebola virus encoded proteins NP, VP35 and VP40 in formaldehyde treated cells. Interferon-alpha treatment delays virus production in vitro. Intact PML bodies may play an anti-viral role in Ebola infected cells.
KeywordsMarburg Virus Infection VP40
Ebola virus belongs to the family of negative strand RNA viruses (Mononegavirales) and together with the Marburg virus are the two known species of the Filoviridae family . Electron microscopy of Ebola virions produced in cell culture have shown them to be pleomorphic, appearing as either 6-shaped, circular or as long filamentous (and sometimes branched) forms with a length up to 14,000 nm and a uniform diameter of 80 nm . The 19 kb single-stranded RNA genome encodes seven viral proteins: the membrane associated (matrix) proteins VP24 and VP40, the viral glycoproteins, GP (that forms the 10 nm long peplomers) and sGP (non-structural secreted form), the characteristic helical ribonucleocapsid that consists of the nucleoprotein (NP), VP30, VP35 and the L-protein that forms a RNA-dependent RNA polymerase .
Infection of humans and non-human primates by the Ebola virus often leads to severe disease, characterized by systemic hemorrhage, with mortality rates from around 50% up to nearly 90% . The underlying pathogenic mechanism of the hemorrhagic fever is poorly understood. A major reason for the limited amount of information regarding these types of viruses is that the handling of these agents requires a biological safety level 4 (BSL4) containment laboratory.
The reason for the severe tissue damage and organ failure is still somewhat obscure. Both direct cytolysis by the virus and indirect pathology induced by immune-mediated responses have been suggested to play a role [4, 5]. Several studies have suggested that the viral GP (the presumed attachment protein) is one of the major pathogenic factors [6, 7].
It is not yet clear how the virus evades cellular anti-viral responses. Certain studies have indicated that a strong inflammatory response early in infection may be beneficial for the survival of the infected individual . In a murine model system it was shown that the type I interferon (IFN) response plays a key role in the resistance of normal mice to sub-cutaneously inoculated mouse-adapted Ebola Zaire (EBO-Z) virus . Successful filovirus therapy has been suggested to require active participation of the type I IFN response . Emerging data suggests VP35 to function as a type I IFN antagonist .
Specific viral proteins are likely to contribute to the different aspects of the pathology. An important aspect for understanding the function of the different viral proteins is to characterize their precise sub-cellular localization and behaviour during the different phases of viral life cycle. High resolution localization of filovirus antigens is hampered by the difficulties associated with handling of BSL4 agents. Complex, computer supported imaging systems are not regular accessories of high containment level laboratories. To use microscope systems placed at a BSL2 laboratory requires complete inactivation of the virus e.g. prolonged fixation of the infected cells with formaldehyde. This fixation procedure however renders most Ebola antigens inaccessible for antibodies. Immunofluorescence staining of formaldehyde fixed cells requires epitope recovery by means of limited proteolysis  or permeabilization. Here we describe a simple fixation and immunofluorescence staining protocol that allows specific and sensitive detection of three viral proteins (NP, VP35 and VP40) using the corresponding monoclonal antibodies on infected cells that were fixed with formaldehyde for, or in excess of, 48 hours. A subsequent treatment with an acetone:methanol mixture served as permeabilization step. We also carried out double immunofluorescence staining of NP, VP35 and VP40 with promyelocytic leukaemia (PML) associated protein, a major component of the subnuclear organelle nuclear domain 10 (ND10; PML body).
The nuclear PML body was first identified as involved in the pathogenesis of acute promyelocytic leukaemia . These distinct sub-nuclear structures are present in most mammalian nucleated cells and are part of an inducible intracellular defense mechanism . The constitutive PML body expression is enhanced by type I and II IFN (alpha/beta and gamma) and in addition, the expression can be induced by viral infections, thereby displaying a defense mechanism to viruses . Many viral infections results in the PML body disruption or delocalization. Various viral proteins from viruses such as lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus (LCMV) [14, 15], human T-cell leukaemia virus type 1 (HTLV-I) , Rabies virus , Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) [18, 19] and herpes simplex virus (HSV)  have been found to associate with PML bodies and interfere with its innate anti-viral function. Some viral proteins have been found to either physically associate with the PML body  or indirectly relocate its normal intra-nuclear positioning, thereby disrupting the normal PML body function. However, precise mechanisms for "disruption and delocalization" are not well understood.
To date, no data are published on the potential interaction between filovirus proteins and the PML nuclear bodies.
In this study, we report our observations concerning the sub-cellular localization of these proteins in two different cell lines (Vero E6 and MCF7) that show different sensitivity for Ebola infection. We have measured the levels of the viral proteins at different time points post-infection in IFN-alpha treated and non-treated cells using digital image quantification methods. We also correlated the expression of viral proteins with the expression of PML protein.
Immunofluorescence detection of Ebola antigens
Sub-cellular localization of Ebola virus proteins
Viral protein 35 (VP35)
VP35 was primarily associated with distinct NP-like cytoplasmic inclusions. Unlike NP, however, VP35 was also distributed diffusely over the entire cytoplasm (Figure 3 bottom panel). No nuclear staining was detectable.
Viral protein 40 (VP40)
Interferon alpha (IFN-alpha) treatment delays Ebola infection in vitro
PML expression in Ebola infected cultures
We could demonstrate that 4% formaldehyde fixation followed by acetone: methanol (1:1) treatment allowed the immunofluorescence detection of both the Ebola virus proteins NP, VP35, VP40 and the cellular PML protein in the virus infected cells. In fact, the fixation procedure was fully comparable with fixation in acetone alone (data not shown). This method provides an easier, and in routine laboratory procedure more reliable, alternative to the protocols of van der Groen  and Kurata  where the epitope recovery in formaldehyde fixed cells required controlled enzymatic treatment with trypsin or pronase. It gives a comparable result to paraformaldehyde fixation followed by Triton X-100 permeabilization .
Our staining data suggest that for routine detection of infectious virus or titration of virus stocks, immunofluorescence staining of NP protein (since staining of this protein gave rise to the most easily recognizable pattern, clearly differing from existing cellular structures) on formaldehyde fixed and subsequently methanol:acetone treated cells, is a useful tool.
The presence of NP-containing viral inclusions throughout the cell cycle indirectly suggests that Ebola virus does not induce an immediate re-programming of the cells by abruptly shutting down host protein synthesis but prepares for virus replication in a much more stealth-like fashion. The development of huge cytoplasmic inclusions without apparent cellular distress is in line with previous observations that filoviruses induced cytopathic effects may be absent or require several days to manifest .
VP35 is an essential component of the Ebola nucleocapsid . Here we show that VP35 accumulates in cytoplasmic inclusions that are morphologically indistinguishable from NP-containing viral inclusions. Ebola virus replicates in the cytoplasm through double stranded RNA intermediates and it appears that it has evolved a mechanism that interferes with dsRNA induced interferon response . VP35 was shown to be able to rescue NS1 mutant influenza A virus replication arguing that it is a type I IFN antagonist. VP35 could also block dsRNA or virus-mediated induction of IFN responsive promoters . Negative stranded RNA viruses often sequester their dsRNA intermediate into ribonucleoprotein complexes that form cytoplasmic inclusions. The presence of VP35 in the Ebola virus inclusions suggests that it intercepts the dsRNA induced response in a close spatial proximity to the viral RNA.
VP40 showed a completely different sub-cellular localization from NP and VP35. It was primarily associated with the cell membrane. Biochemical studies earlier showed that VP40 is a membrane binding protein that oligomerizes upon interaction with lipid membranes . The oligomerization leads to self assembly into membrane-containing particles  and subsequent release into the cell culture medium . Unlike the Marburg virus encoded VP40 that localized both to the viral inclusions as well as to clusters of intracellular membrane or to plasma membrane protrusions in infected macrophages , Ebola VP40 was primarily associated with the cell membrane. It also entered the nucleus, similarly to the Marburg encoded VP40, raising the possibility that VP40 may play additional, e.g. gene expression regulatory role beside the involvement in virus assembly and budding.
Importantly, the staining with anti-VP40 antibodies on formaldehyde fixed and acetone:methanol treated cells allowed the direct immunofluorescence detection of extracellular virions and/or filamentous virus-like particles. The size of most viruses is regularly below the resolution of the light microscope. Although the spatial resolution of the fluorescence microscope is constrained by the same physical laws as any other light microscopes, e.g. it does not allow the reliable separation of two points that are closer than 0.2 μm, it still allows the detection of light emitting particles on dark background that are far much smaller, e.g. individual protein molecules. Ebola Zaire virions with average length of 1.3 ± 0.7 μm and occasional length up to 14 μm  are well within the limits of fluorescence microscopy. The possibility to carry out 3D reconstitution of fluorescence images picturing nascent virions in combination with staining for additional two or three viral and/or cellular proteins should provide ample amount of information about the molecular mechanism of the egress of Ebola virus.
IFN-alpha appears to play a crucial role in the anti-viral defense in Ebola virus infected experimental animals. Mice lacking the type I IFN receptor, but not wild type mice, died upon subcutaneous inoculation of the virus . The adenosine analogue 3-Deazaneplanocin A was recently shown to protect from Ebola virus induced death of infected mice through massive induction of IFN-alpha .
We found that IFN-alpha treatment decreased Ebola virus protein production in vitro and inhibited the development of cytopathic effects. These data are in line with the findings that IFN-alpha could reduce infection 10 to 100-fold in cell cultures and also delay the death of infected monkeys . One important anti-viral mechanism that is induced as part of the interferon response is the increased expression of the components of the subnuclear organelle ND10 or PML body. A variety of DNA and RNA viruses encode proteins that specifically interact with the PML bodies and regularly destroy them. Rhabdoviruses share several molecular features with filoviruses. The rabies virus encoded P phosphoprotein is a distant homologue of the Ebola VP35. It interacts with and reorganizes PML bodies . Here we show that Ebola virus infection did not dissolve PML bodies. On the contrary, individual cells expressing viral proteins regularly showed increased expression of PML. Moreover, although Ebola virus interferes with the IFN response it could not inhibit the IFN-alpha mediated induction of PML. VP35, a possible candidate for interference with PML function, never entered the nucleus but remained exclusively cytoplasmic. Importantly, Vero E6 cells, that supported Ebola replication very efficiently, expressed low levels of PML and showed much smaller virus-dependent and IFN-mediated increase in PML expression than MCF7 cells that served as a poor host for the virus. Our data suggest that Ebola virus lacks effective anti-PML mechanism. The data are also consistent with the possibility that increased PML expression might hinder virus infection, similarly to what was previously demonstrated for vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) [32, 33], influenza virus , human foamy virus (HFV)  and lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus (LCMV) . Our results lead to the testable hypothesis that introduction of constitutively expressed PML cDNA into Vero E6 cells should inhibit, and inhibitory RNA (RNAi) mediated downregulation of PML in MCF7 cells should promote, the propagation of the Ebola virus in vitro.
A modified fixation procedure allowed us to study the expression levels and sub-cellular localization of Ebola virus encoded proteins as well as the nuclear PML expression using advanced imaging techniques. NP and VP35 accumulated in cytoplasmic inclusion bodies whereas VP40 was mainly membrane associated. The anti-VP40 antibody stained extracellular virions and/or filamentous virus-like particles as well. We showed that the two cell lines studied supported virus propagation on different levels: Vero E6 – high, and MCF7 – low. IFN-alpha treatment delayed virus production in vitro in both lines. MCF7 but not Vero E6 showed efficient virus- and IFN-mediated induction of PML. We suggest that Ebola virus lacks an effective anti-PML mechanism and that intact PML bodies may play an anti-viral role in Ebola virus infected cells.
Cell lines and interferon-alpha treatment
The human epithelial breast carcinoma cell line MCF7 (ATCC no. HTB-22) and the African green monkey kidney cell line Vero E6 (originally named Vero C1008; ATCC no. CRL-1586) were grown on 8-well Lab-Tek II Chamber slides (Nunc, USA) in DMEM medium (high glucose) supplemented with 10% fetal calf serum (Life Technologies), penicillin/streptomycin, L-glutamine (Life Technologies) at 37°C and 5% CO2. Cell cultures were grown to sub-confluence and thereafter used as target cells for the infections. Three hours pre-infection, selected cell cultures were treated with 200 IU/ml of interferon-alpha (Welferon; a generous gift from Dr. Norman Finter, GlaxoWelcome).
All work with infectious material was carried out at the BSL4 laboratory at the Center for Microbiological Preparedness at the Swedish Institute for Infectious Disease Control in Solna, Sweden. Infections were performed with Ebola Zaire subtype Mayinga (kindly provided by Dr Stephan Becker, Marburg, Germany). The virus stock was titrated on Vero E6 cells. For the experiments, the target cells were infected with 2.3 plaque-forming units (PFU) per cell (30,000 cells / well) in the total volume of 0.2 ml for 45 min at 37°C. The supernatant was then removed and 1 ml of fresh medium (D-MEM + 2% FCS) was added. Cultures were incubated further and harvested at 1, 2 and 3 days post-infection. At harvest, chambers were removed, slides were washed twice in PBS and subjected to fixation (and virus inactivation) in 4% formaldehyde (10% NBF) for 48 hr at +4°C.
Infected cell cultures grown on 8-well Lab-Tek II Chamber slides (Nalge Nunc International, IL, USA) were analysed by indirect immunofluorescence 24 hrs, 48 hrs and 72 hrs post-infection. After formaldehyde fixation slides were quickly washed twice in PBS and permeabilized with ice-cold aceton:methanol (1:1) 12–24 hrs at -20°C. Slides were thereafter subjected to re-hydration in 2% FCS in PBS for at least 1.5 hrs at room temperature (RT) before incubated with primary anti-PML by using a rabbit-anti-PML polyclonal (sc-5621, Santa Cruz Biotechnology). Primary antibodies were diluted in blocking buffer (2% BSA / 0.2% Tween-20 / 10% glycerol / 0.05% NaN3 in PBS) and incubated in a moist chamber for 60 min at RT. Cells were then washed five times with cold PBS before incubation with the secondary FITC-conjugated swine-anti-rabbit antibody (Dakopatts). The cells were then blocked (absorbed) for 30 min in normal mouse serum in PBS. Thereafter, Ebola viral proteins were stained by using the following monoclonal antibodies (mouse ascitic fluids from hybridoma cells generously provided by Dr Anthony Sanchez at the Centers for Disease Control, Atlanta, GA ): anti-EBOLA Zaire VP35 (BC03-BD09; EBO-Z-VP35); EBOLA Zaire Nucleoprotein (FB03-BE08; EBO-Z-NP) and EBOLA Zaire VP40 (BO04-BD07; EBO-Z-VP40). Ebola monoclonals were diluted 1:100 in blocking buffer (2% BSA / 0.2% Tween-20 / 10% glycerol / 0.05% NaN3 in PBS) and incubated in a moist chamber for 60 min at RT. Cells were thereafter washed five times in cold PBS and a TRITC-conjugated rabbit-anti-mouse monoclonal antibody (Dakopatts) was added. Single staining of viral proteins was carried out using the FITC-conjugated secondary antibody. For DNA staining, Hoecht 33258 was used. Cover slips were mounted on the glass slides using 70% glycerol containing 2.5% DABCO anti-fading agent (Sigma).
Fluorescence microscopy and digital image analysis
Images were collected using a Leitz DM RB microscope, equipped with Leica PL Fluotar 100×, 40× and PL APO Ph 63× oil immersion objectives. Composite filter cubes were used for the FITC, TRITC and Hoechst 33258 fluorescence, respectively. The pictures were captured with a Hamamatsu dual mode cooled CCD camera (C4880), recorded and analyzed on a Pentium PC computer equipped with an AFG VISIONplus – AT frame grabber board using Hipic4.0.4 (Hamamatsu), Image-Pro Plus (Media Cybernetics). Digital images were assembled using Adobe Photoshop software.
Measurement of protein expression levels was carried out on three randomly selected fields containing around 400 cells each. The slides were processed identically keeping the exposition time, and the upper and lower limits of computer LUT (look-up-table) constant. Fluorescence intensities were calculated for individual cells. Average and standard deviation values were calculated from the three independent measurements.
3D reconstituted images were collected using Zeiss Axiophot microscope equipped with ×63 oil Plan-Apochromat NA 1.4, and ×100 oil Plan-Neofluar NA 0.7–1.3 objectives, illuminated with Osram HBO 200 W mercury short arc lamp. A program, developed by us (RFH_ST_BIN), was used to produce images. This program also gives information about the depth distribution by creating a maximal-intensity projected image pair representing a 3D reconstitution of the original object as single or stereoscopic image. To remove out-of-focus blur, the program uses the nearest-neighbor deconvolution deblurring (NNDC) algorithm. Following excitation filters were used: single band UV exciter for Hoechst (84360), single band Blue exciter for FITC (84490), and single band green exciter for TRITC (84555). The images were captured with a PXL cooled camera (Photometrics, Munich, Germany) and analyzed using the Isee 5.1 graphical programming system (Inovision, Raleigh; NC) on Pentium PC computer with LINUX OS.
Å. S. B. carried out the experiments and drafted the manuscript. L. S. helped with the digital image analysis and together with Å. S. B. conceived the study. F. E. participated in the design and coordination of the study. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Our colleagues at the Centre for Microbiological Preparedness, Swedish Institute for Infectious Disease Control are greatly acknowledged for assistance in- and outside the BSL4 laboratory. This work was funded by the National Board of Health and Welfare (SoS), the Swedish Defence Research Agency (FOI), and the Swedish Institute for Infectious Disease Control (SMI). Å. S. B was in addition supported by a post doctoral funding from the Karolinska Institute.
- 1.Sanchez A, Khan AS, Zaki SR, Nabel GJ, Ksiazek TG, Peters CJ: Filoviridae: Marburg and Ebola viruses. Fields Virology, D.M.Knipe and P.M. Howley, eds. Philadelpia: Lippincotts, Williams and Wilkins. 2001, 1279-1304.Google Scholar
- 4.Villinger F, Rollin PE, Brar SS, Chikkala NF, Winter J, Sundstrom JB, Zaki SR, Swanepoel R, Ansari AA, Peters CJ: Markedly elevated levels of interferon (IFN)-gamma, IFN-alpha, interleukin (IL)-2, IL-10, and tumor necrosis factor-alpha associated with fatal Ebola virus infection. J Infect Dis. 1999, 179 Suppl 1: S188-NaN.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
- 15.Djavani M, Rodas J, Lukashevich IS, Horejsh D, Pandolfi PP, Borden KL, Salvato MS: Role of the promyelocytic leukemia protein PML in the interferon sensitivity of lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus. J Virol. 2001, 75: 6204-6208. 10.1128/JVI.75.13.6204-6208.2001.PubMedCentralCrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
- 20.Everett RD, Earnshaw WC, Pluta AF, Sternsdorf T, Ainsztein AM, Carmena M, Ruchaud S, Hsu WL, Orr A: A dynamic connection between centromeres and ND10 proteins. J Cell Sci. 1999, 112 ( Pt 20): 3443-3454.Google Scholar
- 34.Regad T, Saib A, Lallemand-Breitenbach V, Pandolfi PP, de The H, Chelbi-Alix MK: PML mediates the interferon-induced antiviral state against a complex retrovirus via its association with the viral transactivator. Embo J. 2001, 20: 3495-3505. 10.1093/emboj/20.13.3495.PubMedCentralCrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article: verbatim copying and redistribution of this article are permitted in all media for any purpose, provided this notice is preserved along with the article's original URL.