Bovine sperm selection procedure prior to cryopreservation for improvement of post-thawed semen quality and fertility
The application of cryopreservation and artificial insemination technology have contributed to the advancement of animal reproduction. However, a substantial proportion of spermatozoa undergoes alterations and loses their fertility during cryopreservation, rendering the frozen-thawed semen impractical for routine use. Cryopreservation is known to reduce sperm lifespan and fertility. Variation in cryosurvival of spermatozoa from different sires and even with the individual sire is common in artificial insemination (AI) centers. Our goal is to improve post-thawed semen quality by optimization of cryopreservation technique through sperm selection prior to cryopreservation process.
Our strategy of sperm selection based on rheotaxis and thermotaxis (SSRT) on macrosale in a rotating fluid flow demonstrated the ability to maintain the original pre-freezing structural integrity, viability and biological function related to fertilization competence. This strategy has a positive effect on the cryosurvival and fertilizing abilities of spermatozoa as supported by the improvement on pregnancy rate of Japanese Black heifers and Holstein repeat breeders. This technique protected further sublethal damage to bovine spermatozoa (higher % cryosurvival than the control) and resulted in the improvement of DNA integrity. Prefreeze selected spermatozoa demonstrated slower and controlled capacitation than unprocessed control which is thought to be related to sperm longevity and consequently to appropriate timing during in vivo fertilization.
These results provide solid evidence that improvement of post-thawed semen quality by SSRT method is beneficial in terms of cryosurvival, longevity of post-thawed sperm, and optimization of in vivo fertilization, embryo development and calving as supported by the favorable results of field fertility study.
KeywordsCryopreservation Fertility Livestock Rheotaxis Spermatozoa Thermotaxis
Artificial reproductive technologies
Computer-assisted sperm analysis
DNA fragmentation index
In vitro fertilization
Mitochondrial Membrane Potential probe (5,5’,6,6’-tetrachloro-1,1’,3,3’-tetrathylbenzimidazolecarbocyanine)
Motility mass score
Radical oxygen species
Sperm-Tyrode’s Albumin Lactate Pyruvate
Sperm selection based on rheotaxis and thermotaxis
Terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase-mediated deoxyuridine triphosphate-nick-end labelling
Average Path Velocity
Following semen ejaculation is the irreversible aging of spermatozoa that will eventually lead to death. It is therefore, the aim of animal breeders to extend the life of the sperm cells. Semen cryopreservation is an important tool in artificial reproductive technologies (ART), propagation of animals with superior genetic traits, clinical medicine, and perpetuation of species. Cryopreserved semen samples have been widely used in the livestock breeding industry for artificial insemination (AI). Selection of genetically superior sires is essential in cattle production. In AI centers, it is a requirement to accurately select animals that possess high quality semen with sufficient post-thaw survival of cryopreserved semen referred to as freezability. However, some bulls with high genetic value produce semen sensitive to cryopreservation . In Japan, only bulls that yield spermatozoa with post-thaw motility up to acceptable level would be considered for preservation. Therefore, collections that are classified as substandard and those that do not cryopreserve well are discarded and replaced by other bulls. Another challenge to semen cryopreservation is the observed seasonal variation in semen quality. There are observed seasonal effects on semen quality and seasonal reduction in sperm function . Ejaculates collected during summer from heat-stressed bull were more sensitive to cryopreservation than those collected in the winter which might explain the decreased conception rate of cows in the summer . Moreover, considerable variation in post thaw semen quality following cryopreservation among different bulls and even among ejaculates collected from the same bull exits. In our previous study, however, we identified the fertile subpopulation based on the kinetic and trajectory patterns, and correlated this subpopulation to field fertility and successful livebirths . Sperm sorting resulted in subpopulation of sperm with improved fertility parameters and such subpopulation is believed to exist within the same sperm samples that resulted in successful pregnancy. However, microfluidic chip sorted sperm will be limited to regional application (to AI centers with appropriate equipment e.g. Microscope) unless sorted sperm can be frozen efficaciously. It is believed that isolation of such fertile subpopulation with desirable characteristics done by bulk sorting could afford greater flexibility in livestock management. Therefore, there is a need for a technology that can mitigate the detrimental effects of dead and damaged sperm by removal of this subpopulation and isolation of motile and fertile subpopulation regardless of season, which will consequently result to enrichment of the semen doses with viable, highly motile, and fertile spermatozoa that will in turn improve pregnancy rate. Moreover, non-viable spermatozoa due to programmed death or apoptosis, more likely prior to ejaculation, and necrosis, resulting from severe cell stress due to an external source, have negative impact on the functional lifespan of contemporary viable spermatozoa which consequently result in irreversible dysfunction that reduces their fertility potential, and ultimately results to death . In addition, the weakened subpopulation in the frozen-thawed semen may die during semen handling while performing assisted reproduction technology (ART) which will add to the existing harmful stresses to the accompanying viable sperm population. It is relevant, therefore, to minimize the toxic effects of dead, senescent, and abnormal spermatozoa by their removal from the semen sample. Previous studies identified ubiquitin-activating enzyme (UBA1) as an enzyme required for sperm capacitation, acrosomal exocytosis and sperm-egg coat penetration during porcine fertilization  and this was followed by an attempt to discard subfertile spem populations by using a dual ubiquitin-PNA sperm quality assay with ubiquitin as a surface marker of defective bull sperm, and PNA-lectin, a surface marker of damaged bull sperm acrosomes, for flow cytometric semen evaluation . Recently, studies on nanotechnology-based approach of enrichment of semen with best spermatozoa by targeting damaged boar sperm and enrichment of semen doses with highly motile, viable, and fertile spermatozoa have been reported [8, 9]. Although the above reports present their own benefits and contributions, there are still some constraints associated with such techniques such as cytotoxicity and requirement for analytical procedure such as flow cytometry which may pose insult to the sperm. Therefore, a facile and non-invasive sperm separation technique that reduces clinician skill requirements for sperm purification process is desirable. Such sperm selection technique prior to cryopreservation; one which can be integrated into the cryopreservation protocol that will affect outcomes in terms of fertilization and pregnancy rates is expected to find wide application in animal reproduction. Our approach based on thermotactic forces and fluid flow satisfies the above requirements.
The goal of cryopreservation is to preserve maximum number of post-thawed viable normal spermatozoa and maintain the original pre-freezing sperm quality parameters including structural integrity, viability, motility, DNA integrity, and biological function related to fertilization competence. However, despite the application of sperm cryopreservation as a routine procedure for AI, approximately 50% of spermatozoa do not survive the freezing-thawing process . The process of cryopreservation impairs sperm function and fertility. Spermatozoa suffer from cold shock during cryopreservation  and this results in lower post-thaw sperm survival, and for those that survive but cryocapacitated, a reduced longevity in the female reproductive tract . The negative effects of cryopreservation on the sperm includes in addition to cold shock, other damages such as osmotic stress, and alterations in membrane fluidity and permeability . Cryopreservation protocols for bull semen to be used for AI in the dairy industry have been developed in the 1950s  and yet advances in cryopreservation techniques have progressed slowly. Moreover, bovine fertility is thought to have declined over the last few decades. An attempt to increase the cryosurvival of bull sperm by the addition of cholesterol to the membrane of bull sperm prior to cryopreservation has been reported to yield a modest 60% motility and 55% viability, and which has not translated into an increased in vivo fertility [14, 15].
Our study presents an approach to reduce sperm damage and improve sperm cryosurvival, and consequently achieve high pregnancy rate by semen processing prior to cryopreservation. We attempted to improve fertility of the cryopreserved sperm by devising a new approach to semen processing in order to mitigate the detrimental effects of cryopreservation on sperm function. A sperm selection procedure based on the combined mechanism of rheotaxis and thermotaxis (SSRT) of high quality spermatozoa confined in a slow rotating flow of non-Newtonian fluid was employed to eliminate the dead, damaged, immotile, or dying spermatozoa. Selection of a distinctive population of motile and viable spermatozoa with intact membranes before subjecting it to the cryopreservation process resulted in a compelling elevation of pregnancy rate of cows.
Our preceding study demonstrated that selection of high quality spermatozoa by microfluidic selection of post-thawed semen by rheotaxis could select superior bovine sperm subpopulations, and subsequent fertility was assessed and validated in vivo by artificial insemination of cows . The selection of high quality spermatozoa prior to cryopreservation is desirable. However, the major downside of microfluidic sperm selection technique is the limitation in sperm volume that could be processed. The technique is best designed for in vitro fertilization (IVF) using frozen-thawed semen and is not practical for large volumes such as raw semen. Nonetheless, we recognized the beneficial effects of freezing selected bovine sperm samples to obtain higher post-thaw quality, and the potential to improve pregnancy rate. This prompted us to develop the current platform of semen processing system based on rheotactic and thermotactic fluid sorting of motile and functional spermatozoa confined in a rotating flow under carefully defined and controlled macroscale conditions to minimize cryoinjury and maximize recovery of viable cells for AI in livestock production. The prefreeze processed cryopreserved semen in straw can be utilized directly for AI without further processing. The utility of the new straw containing the semen subjected to pre-freeze sperm sorting can also be potentially extended beyond AI applications such as IVF.
Materials and methods
All chemicals were reagent grade and were purchased from Sigma-Aldrich Japan (Tokyo, Japan), except for SP-TL buffer which was purchased from Caisson Laboratories, Inc. (Smithfield, UT).
Japanese Black bovine bull semen collection
Bovine bull (Bos taurus) ejaculates from Two Japanese Black AI bulls at Saga Prefectural.
Evaluation of semen quality based on MMS score by quantitative microscopic observation and total motility (%) by CASA
Prefreeze processed by SSRT
Cooled at 4 °C
MS score total motility
70% +++ 87% (221/255)
60% +++ 86% (278/324)
MS score total motility
50% ++ 86% (278/328)
50% ++ 77% (125/163)
Cooled at 4 °C
MS score total motility
80% +++ 93% (339/363)
75% +++ 84% (125/148)
MS score total motility
60% ++ 79% (326/412)
45% ++ 68% (116/171)
Sperm selection based on rheotaxis and thermotaxis (SSRT) platform
Post-thaw evaluation of viability, motility, mitochondrial activity, DNA fragmentation and capacitation status
Evaluation of sperm viability was performed by staining the spermatozoa using the Live/Dead.
Sperm Viability Kit (Thermo Fischer Sci Inc., Molecular Probes, Eugene, OR, USA) as per the manufacturer’s guidelines. The post-thawed samples of prefreeze-SSRT selected spermatozoa and unprocessed control were added with SYBR 14 (final concentration 100 nmol/L), vortexed and incubated for 10 min at 37 °C, followed by the addition of propidium iodide (final concentration 12 μL) then 5 min incubation at 37 °C. Aliquots were placed on a prewarmed slide and each aliquot was covered with a coverslip and assessed under Nikon Ti-U fluorescence microscope.
The total motility of post-thaw sperm was assessed by computer-assisted sperm analysis (CASA). Cryosurvival rate (%CSR) based on motility was calculated using the formula: 100 × post-thaw total motile sperm/pre-freeze total motile sperm.
The effect of prefreeze SSRT method on the motility index of bovine spermatozoa at different post-thaw incubation time was assessed by computing for the motility index data which was derived from multiplication of VAP (Average Path Velocity) over BCF (Beat Cross Frequency). The results were compared with that of the unprocessed control.
To evaluate the mitochondrial activity based on the mitochondria membrane potential, aliquots from the post-thawed samples of the cryopreserved SSRT straw and unsorted control straw were stained by the lipophilic cationic probe 5,5′,6,6′-tetrachloro-1,1′,3,3′-tetrathylbenzimidazolecarbocyanine (JC-1) (MitoProbe JC-1 assay kit; Invitrogen) which differentially label mitochondria with high (orange color of multimeric or J-aggregates) and low membrane potentials (green color for monomeric form) . Subsequent analysis was performed by placing samples under a coverslip and observing with Olympus BX51 fluorescence microscope.
For evaluation of chromatin integrity by measurement of DNA fragmentation, the terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase-mediated deoxyuridine triphosphate-nick-end labelling (TUNEL) assay was employed to assess the nicked DNA in samples from pre-freeze SSRT processed semen and unprocessed control by following the manufacturer’s instruction (In Situ Cell Death Detection Kit, Fluorescein, Roche, Indianapolis, IN, USA) and as published . The method was presented in detail in our previous paper . The DNA fragmentation index determined by the TUNEL assay  referred to as sperm TUNEL index was expressed as a percentage of the total population.
The capacitation status of viable bovine spermatozoa was assessed using the dual staining method by following the procedure described by Fraser et al.  with some modifications. The chlortetracycline (CTC) fluorescent technique detects changes in the plasma membrane of the bovine spermatozoon . Dual staining of spermatozoa with the supravital fluorescent dye (Hoechst 33258) allows for determination of cell viability prior to CTC analysis therefore, avoiding the assessment of dead spermatozoa as acrosome reacted cell . Spermatozoa with CTC fluorescence uniformly over the entire head (F pattern) were classified as intact and non-capacitated while capacitated spermatozoa were characterized by a fluorescence-free band on the post acrosomal region, and acrosome reacted spermatozoa (AR) showed a nonfluorescent head or a thin fluorescent band on the equatorial segment.
Field fertility trials by AI of nulliparous heifers and repeat breeders
To evaluate the effect of semen manipulation and selection based on the SSRT method prior to cryopreservation, straws of SSRT selected sperm were cryopreserved and used in artificial insemination (AI). A total of 12 animals were employed consisting of 4 nulliparous Japanese Black and 8 nulliparous Holstein repeat breeders. A cow is called a repeat breeder when it has failed to conceive from three or more regularly spaced services in the absence of detectable abnormalities. The causes of repeat breeding are fertilization failure and embryonic mortality. The fertility of prefreeze SSRT treated sperm was assessed by a sample size of 12 cows. This field test of small sample size is considered indispensable prior to conduct of any large-scale application.
The cows (4 Japanese Black heifers and 8 Holstein repeat breeders) were observed for natural estrus and inseminated under the am-pm rule. AI was performed using transcervical intrauterine technique by different technicians (n = 3) to eliminate technician bias. AI field experiments were conducted from early to late summer. Pregnancy verification was performed by transrectal ultrasonography after 30 and 50 days of insemination.
Assessment of post-thaw sperm recovery and viability
Evaluation of semen quality by mass sperm motility (motility mass score) and CASA system
Traditional assessment of post-thaw sperm viability and motility by visual measurement based on gross motility (or mass activity) was employed. Gross motility, or the amount of swirling (or wave motion) present in an undiluted semen sample, gives the motility mass score (MMS) and is a function of both sperm concentration and individual motility. This technique is routinely used in livestock breeding centers in Japan and based on the assessment would determine whether to proceed with the cryopreservation or not. The MMS is expressed as the percentage of motile (viable) cells and motility. The percentage of motile cells (%) is estimated by visual measurement, with the number of spermatozoa in all viewing fields taken as 100. The motility is classified as follows: +++ vigorous movement or the greatest forward movement that looks like a vortex or swirling motion, ++ active forward movement, + weak movement. The MMS was assessed by 4 technicians who have sufficient experience in bull semen evaluation and cryopreservation. The effect of sperm preparation on post-cryopreserved sperm was evaluated by comparison of mass sperm motility before and after cryopreservation (Table 1). Evidently, based on MMS, sperm sorting prior to cryopreservation enhanced sperm cryosurvival. Table 1 shows that the prefreeze-processed spermatozoa by SSRT method have higher MMS after cooling to 4 °C than the control group for indicating that tolerance to cooling was enhanced by prefreeze sperm selection compared with the control groups. Freezing induced a 20% decrease in the MMS of SSRT subjected straw for both bulls. The control groups demonstrated a 10% decrease in MMS (Bull #1) and a 30% decrease (Bull #2), suggesting individual bull variation in terms of freezability. It is worthy to note that an improvement in cryopreservation was achieved by prefreeze processing using the SSRT method as evidenced by the enhancement of post-thaw MMS of Bull #2 (45%++ control vs. 60%++ prefreeze processed). In addition, variation in cryopreservation tolerance of the two bulls was observed as depicted by the prefreeze processed and control straws. Cryopreservation reduces survival of spermatozoa to a great extent but this was mitigated by sperm processing using the SSRT method prior to cryopreservation.
Sperm concentration was determined by using cell counter as well as hemocytometer. Moreover, computer-assisted sperm analysis (CASA) system was used for sperm motility analysis.
The viability of cryopreserved bovine spermatozoa from straws containing pre-freeze processed semen by SSRT and the control is presented in Fig. 2a. Significant differences were observed between the two straws in terms of mean percentage of sperm viability at different incubation periods. At 1 h, 7 h, and 24 h incubation time, spermatozoa subjected to prefreeze SSRT showed higher viability than the control however, significant difference was observed particularly at 7 h (P < 0.05). A longer in vitro life span was achieved by prefreeze processed spermatozoa than the control.
Cryosurvival rate (%CSR) based on motility
Cryopreservation rates (% CSR) of semen subjected to sperm selection process prior to cryopreservation
Prefreeze processed by SSRT (% CSR)
Control (% CSR)
Bull # 1
98.6 ± 1.04
88.1 ± 3.03
Bull # 2
88.5 ± 3.70
79.4 ± 1.51
Assessment of the effect of prefreeze SSRT method on the motility index of bovine spermatozoa at different post-thaw incubation time
Assessment of sperm motility has been shown as one of the important factors to predict the functional capacity of bovine sperm cells. The motility index data derived from multiplication of VAP over BCF was used to evaluate the effect of prefreeze SSRT method. Although post-thaw motility index was higher at 1 h incubation for the control straw, considerable reduction was observed at 7 h incubation period, and such reduction was greater in comparison with the control straw (Fig. 2b). At 24 h incubation, the control showed a 98% decrease in motility index while 84.5% reduction was observed in the SSRT method subjected semen straw. Motility index was higher for the prefreeze processed semen than the control suggesting an enhancement in cryosurvival based on motility and improvement of semen quality by motility characteristics.
Evaluation of the effect of prefreeze SSRT method on the post thaw mitochondrial activity
The assessment of mitochondrial membrane potential (MMP) by fluorophore JC-1 revealed no difference in MMP at 1 h post-thaw incubation (Fig. 2c). However, the effect of in vitro incubation time on the survival function of mitochondrial activity was observed at 7 h incubation. Prefreeze SSRT processed semen showed a significantly higher percentage of MMP than the control (P < 0.01). The reduction in the survival function of mitochondrial activity in prefreeze processed semen after exposure time of 7 h (56%) was lower compared with the unprocessed semen (86%). A gradual cessation of mitochondrial activity within the 24 h period was evident in prefreeze processed semen in contrast to the drastic decline in unprocessed control. This reflects that dysfunctional mitochondria were present more in the control group which can be due to the presence of non-viable, damaged and senescent spermatozoa than the prefreeze processed semen and the disparity in the alteration of mitochondrial activity became more evident with incubation time. Selection of high quality and motile sperm had a positive effect as indicated by higher mitochondrial activity in prefreeze sorted compared with the control (Fig. 2d). While time course of the decline of sperm mitochondrial activity was significantly slower in prefreeze-sorted spermatozoa, contrastingly, the control demonstrated a rapid impairment in mitochondrial activity. These results indicate the positive effect of macroscale rheotactic and thermotactic sorting on prolongation of sperm mitochondrial activity life span and maintenance of high sperm quality as assessed by the mitochondrial functionality.
Effect of prefreeze SSRT method on the post thaw DNA integrity
DNA integrity is one of the parameters of sperm quality associated with fertility hence, DNA fragmentation (DFI, %) of post-thawed spermatozoa was evaluated by using the terminal deoxynucleotide transferase-mediated dUTP nick end labelling (TUNEL). The post-thawed DFI of prefreeze SSRT selected spermatozoa was significantly lower than the unprocessed control (2% vs. 5.5%, P < 0.01, Fig. 2d). Such reduction in DNA fragmentation achieved by sperm processing by SSRT before cryopreservation allowed for effective recovery of not only viable and motile but functional and high quality spermatozoa as demonstrated by high DNA integrity. This data supports the significantly higher pregnancy rate of cows inseminated with prefreeze SSRT selected spermatozoa compared with cows inseminated with the conventionally prepared semen (control).
Influence of sperm selection prior to cryopreservation by SSRT method on pregnancy rate of artificially inseminated cattle
Clinical data on pregnancy rate of cows inseminated with semen straw containing sperm cells selected prior to cryopreservation
History of failed reproduction
Japanese Black #1
Japanese Black #2
Japanese Black #3
Japanese Black #4
2 × ET, 2 × AI
2 × ET, 3 × AI
2 × ET, 2 × AI
2 × AI
3 × AI
2 × ET, 3 × AI
4 × AI
2 × ET, 2 × AI
4 × AI
Influence of prefreeze SSRT method on post thaw acrosome reactivity
Animal ejaculates contain non-viable or dead spermatozoa along with damaged and moribund spermatozoa which substantially increase in number when semen is subjected to cryopreservation and thawing that increase risks of damage to these cells. It has been reported that large numbers of non-viable sperm cells has negative influence on the functional lifespan of contemporary viable sperm which consequently result in irreversible dysfunction thus, reducing the fertility potential of the semen . The ejaculates also contain other cells such as leukocytes which may have contributed to radical oxygen species (ROS) generation . Our study aims to highlight the relevance of selecting motile and high quality spermatozoa prior to cryopreservation, assuming that sorting plays relevant effects on the functional lifespan and fertilizing potential of these sorted gametes. Semen processing by rheotactic and thermotactic mechanism prior to cryopreservation was considered as a means to eliminate the damaged and non-viable sperm which has negative influence on the functional lifespan of contemporary viable sperm that eventually cause irreversible dysfunction that consequently reduces their fertility potential and ability to develop healthy embryos. Considering that the number of dead sperm increases in semen over time, and that the presence of dead sperm in the ejaculate to be stored should be considered within the set of harmful stresses posed to the accompanying viable sperm population, we developed a facile but efficient method of motile sperm separation by exposure to slow uniform rotating fluid flow (rhetotaxis) and temperature gradient (thermotaxis) in a macroscale platform. It should also be considered that the motility of sperm is critical to a successful fertilization. Spermatozoa are extremely efficient at swimming against a current just like salmon traveling upstream to spawn [20, 21]. In contrast with dead sperm which resembles passive particles , motile sperm exhibit rheotaxis [23, 24, 25]. Our previous study presented evidence of spermatozoa achieving forward propulsion through fluid in microchanels. Considering this principle but in a macroscale, we created the right velocity of a rotating fluid to elicit upward movement of motile and presumably high quality spermatozoa. The fluid which is composed of semen diluted in Fraction A extender without egg yolk (osmolality = 300 mOsm) is classified as a Newtonian fluid with low viscosity. The flow condition is uniquely defined by the Reynolds number, Re < 1. In synergy with this system is the response of sperm cells to temperature gradient which can also elicit upstream motility of sperm.Under the basic sperm medium, sperm motility has been classified into two types: one type of motion by rolling of the body and another type, by 7 planar beating of the flagellum [26, 27, 28]. The extender medium used in the SSRT method can be classified as basic medium and considering that bull spermatozoa was subjected to slowly rotating bulk fluid condition, they were classified as bulk swimmers , repeatedly rotating their body around its axis that is basically due to propagation of a 3D helical wave along the flagellum . The ascent of shear stress by the uniform flow patterns of the rotating fluid could lead to the increase in the sperm velocity with the direction of the sperm velocity opposite to that of the flow. The fluid flow condition in the SSRT method can be explained by the dynamic “Similitude concept” wherein geometric similarity and kinematic similarity are observed. Another physical environment that worked on to facilitate sperm migration to the upper layer of the conical vessel is thermotaxis It has been reported that the migration of sperm in the female reproductive tract associated with fertilization is regulated by thermotaxis [30, 31]. The temperature gradient allows sperm to orientate their swim away from the utero-tubal junction (low temperature) towards the warmer ampulla where the oocyte awaits [32, 33, 34]. Thermotaxis of bull sperm was confirmed involving both calcium channels and intracellular stored calcium . Our SSRT method utilized this combined mechanisms of migration dynamics sensitive to temperature and rheological stimuli, and the obtained data indicate not only improvement of cryosurvival of prefreeze selected spermatozoa but compelling results in AI provide a solid evidence that pre-selection of high quality spermatozoa prior to cryopreservation by SSRT method is a robust means of improving the fertilization potential of bull semen.
In cattle, bull semen varies widely in terms of freezability outcome. Our SSRT method prior to freezing has been shown to reduce such variation by improving the cryosurvival of spermatozoa via elimination of dead, damaged and dying sperm cells in the ejaculate and their deleterious effects. Such improvement was particularly demonstrated by Bull #2 wherein cryosurvival of 45% (failed to pass for commercial market) was improved to 60% (passed for commercial market). Such data was supported by the higher % CSR of prefreeze-SSRT selected spermatozoa (89%) compared with the control (52%) (Table 2). Moreover, it should be considered that AI was conducted during the summer season when cows were subjected to heat stress. The elimination of bull variability and AI technician variability demonstrated the robustness of the new straw prepared by this strategy. The increased pregnancy rate in repeat breeder cows inseminated with SSRT selected sperm suggests that SSRT method can serve as an excellent tool for improvement of pregnancy rate not only in normal heifers but also repeat breeders. The result also provides insight and opportunities as to the possible role of high quality sperm selection in management of repeat breeding. SSRT is a promising technique that needs large fertility trials.
Sperm motility was evaluated in the analysis of fertilization potential and cryosurvival considering that it is an index of structural integrity and viability of spermatozoa . One of the deleterious effects of cryopreservation is the reduction of sperm motility. Such effect was mitigated by preselection of high quality and motile spermatozoa before cryopreservation. In addition, a longer life span was achieved by prefreeze-SSRT subjected spermatozoa. It has been reported that non-viable spermatozoa due to programmed death or apoptosis, more likely prior to ejaculation, and necrosis, resulting from severe cell stress due to an external source, have negative impact on the functional lifespan of contemporary viable spermatozoa which consequently result in irreversible dysfunction that reduces their fertility potential, and ultimately results to death . Moreover, the weakened subpopulation in the frozen-thawed semen may die during semen handling while performing assisted reproduction technology (ART) which will add to the existing harmful stresses to the accompanying viable sperm population. SSRT method had minimized the toxic effects of dead, senescent, and abnormal spermatozoa by their removal from the semen sample prior to freezing. Elimination of dead and damaged sperm will likely extend the lifespan of the surviving spermatozoa in the cow genitalia. A longer sperm life span would mean wider window for timing of sperm capacitation and ovulation, as reflected by the time relationships among reproductive events and fertile lifespan of bovine spermatozoa and oocyte . The functional integrity and timely transport of spermatozoa in the female genital tract is crucial for maximizing the chance of fertilization and successful pregnancy. This might be one of the factors that could explain the high pregnancy rate observed in prefreeze-SSRT subjected semen.
Alteration in mitochondrial activity was slower in SSRT prefreeze processed semen than the control (Fig. 2c). SSRT had a positive effect, as indicated by higher mitochondrial activity in sorted compared with the unsorted control. The time course of the decline of sperm mitochondrial activity was significantly slower in SSRT preselected semen. Contrastingly, the control demonstrated a rapid impairment in mitochondrial activity. These results indicate the positive effect of SSRT prefreeze processing on prolongation of sperm mitochondrial activity life span and maintenance of high sperm quality as assessed by the mitochondrial functionality. Mitochondria play a vital role as bioenergetic sources for spermatozoa vitality, and motility. The main functional role of sperm mitochondria is related to energy production (by ATP) and sperm mitochondrial functional characteristics are closely associated with spermatozoa motility [37, 38, 39] and better fertilization potential . The changes in the mitochondrial integrity and functionality, namely defects in mitochondrial structure, mitochondrial genome, as well as disturbances in mitochondrial membrane potential or altered oxygen consumption, have been correlated with loss of sperm functions; sperm motility, in particular . The survival function in terms of mitochondrial activity overtime was higher in the prefreeze processed sperm than the control. There are reports on the positive correlation between total motility and MMP [41, 42, 43, 44, 45], and the close relation between integrity of mitochondrial membrane and sperm progressive motility . Because sperm selection was based on motility, it was expected that preselected sperm prior to cryopreservation show a well-maintained motility over time than the unselected sperm. Metabolic energy in the form of ATP acts as a molecular motor to generate force for the flagellar movement. This energy is generated in the mitochondria through oxidative phosphorylation  to facilitate efficient propulsion for the sperm to reach the oocyte and to penetrate through zona pellucida or by anaerobic pathway via glycolysis in the cytoplasm . Bull spermatozoa with high MMP are expected to have high fertilizing potential as evidenced by the compelling high pregnancy rate of prefreeze SSRT selected spermatozoa.
DNA integrity is essential for successful fertilization. However, when ejaculates are cryopreserved using routine procedures, dead, damaged, abnormal and moribund spermatozoa are also cryopreserved along with healthy normal sperm that become inevitable source of reactive oxygen species . Cryopreservation also increases the proportion of these detrimental spermatozoa and consequently results in the decrease of DNA integrity of the post-thawed sperm which will concomitantly decrease the fertility and pregnancy rates [48, 49]. It has been reported that cryopreservation process causes DNA damage to mammalian sperm like bull . Spermatozoa carrying nicked DNA may more likely have a negative effect on fertility, with DNA fragmentation being an uncompensable trait. This may be relevant as suggested by the increasing evidence that the integrity of the sperm chromatin at the actual time of fertilization influences embryo survival . DNA-nicked spermatozoa showed adverse effects on early embryonic development . On the other hand, efficient improvement of cryosurvival and post-thaw semen quality through removal of immotile, dead and abnormal spermatozoa by SSRT method was able to exclude these detrimental cells. Spermatozoa carrying nicked DNA may more likely have a negative effect on fertility, with DNA fragmentation being an uncompensable trait. The prefreeze sperm selection by SSRT allowed recovery of spermatozoa with lower DNA fragmentation (higher DNA integrity). The fragmented DNA accumulated in the non-viable and damaged spermatozoa were likely eliminated by the prefreeze selection process in our study. The relevance of improvement of DNA integrity (Fig. 2d) has been supported by the impressive in vivo fertility results and livebirths using the prefreeze-SSRT processed semen straws (Table 3). Conversely, poor sperm DNA integrity caused by cryopreservation process may account for some of the infertility in cattle.
The cryopreservation processes also induce precocious capacitation termed “cryo-capaciation”  but this does not occur in the entire population as supported by penetration of many oocytes with cryopreserved semen in medium with heparin, a capacitating agent for bull sperm compared with the heparin free . Nonetheless, the cryo-capacitated sperm plasma membrane is fragile and unresistant to spontaneous acrosome reaction and deterioration and finally death in the absence of occurrence of fertilization. Hence, the in vivo fertile lifespan of spermatozoa could be restricted particularly with the high proportion of cryocapacitated sperm in the insemination dose. In the experiment, however, it should be noted that the spermatozoa were suspended in a capacitating medium, modified SP-TALP. We assume that the observed capacitation in the prefreeze SSRT-treated spermatozoa at 1 h was true capacitation and not the premature capacitation induced by membrane modification due to cryopreservation. This is supported by the observed slow and controlled capacitation in prefreeze-SSRT-treated sperm in contrast to the unprocessed control. The intact and uncapacitated percentage of sperm was higher in prefreeze-processed than the control at 8 h incubation time. The drastic reduction of proportion uncapacitated sperm in control at 8 h is an evidence that more sperm which were uncapacitated at first but may have partially damaged plasma membrane will demonstrate cryocapacitation following cryopreservation and this become more evident at 8 h while higher proportion of uncapacitated sperm was maintained by prefreeze-processed at 8 h. Moreover, AR was relatively higher in the control than the prefreeze-treated at 8 h indicating that selection of high quality sperm prior to freezing and subjecting the semen under a slow rotating fluid flow condition somehow protects the plasma membrane by probably by a controlled calcium mechanism involved in the onset of capacitation and AR, and another hypothesis is that the environmental fluid condition in the experiment which created a condition that elicits rheotaxis and thermotaxis not only facilitate separation of high quality and motile sperm but ameliorates plasma membrane irreversible damage and controls the onset of capacitation and AR thus increasing the longevity of sperm until the time of meeting the oocyte. It has been reported that cryo-processes involving change in temperature from body temperature to cooling followed by near freezing represents a major stress to the sperm plasma resulting in the rearrangement and destabilization of membrane components, and calcium influx [52, 53]. Some studies suggest that this increased permeability is due to subtle irreversible structural changes to the membrane architecture due to cooling below the thermotropic phase transition temperature of membrane phospholipids. The susceptibility of the sperm to damage by cold shock and cryopreservation results from the lipid-phase transition temperature of the membrane at nonphysiologic temperatures. In bovine sperm, the lipid-phase transition temperature is about 13 °C; the most critical temperature range for cooling sperm is between 15 °C and 5 °C, which determines cold shock, the most sensitive temperature especially for bovine sperm . This can be reduced to 4 °C by an egg yolk-based extender, that’s why in the conventional cryopreservation protocol, semen extender contains egg yolk. Still, lipid components of the bull spermatozoa are significantly reduced due to freezing . There is a general notion that cold resistance is related to membrane fluidity, therefore changes in the fluidity of sperm plasma membranes could increase their cryoresistance. We hypothesize that exposure to synergistic conditions in the SSRT method (fluid flow, temperature gradient, separation of dead and immobile from viable, motile sperm facilitate a preconditioning that may be associated with higher membrane fluidity and consequently cryosurvival. Fresh semen contains cholesterol that acts as a buffer in the phospholipid membranes. Because the phospholipids are pretty flexible (fluid mosaic model) the cholesterol helps to keep them in place. They are placed in between the hydrophobic tails, and therefore it is hydrophobic interactions that decrease the fluidity. However, cryopreservation injury reduces cholesterol and this affecting membrane fluidity. We are tempted to hypothesize that prefreeze processing by SSRT particularly slowly rotating fluid flow also facilitate increase in the cholesterol content of sperm membranes which may be a strategy that can improve sperm quality after freeze-thawing. Considering that functional integrity of the sperm plasma membrane is of primary importance for the cryosurvival and fertilizing abilities of spermatozoa, both of which are successfully achieved in the experiment, we speculate that sperm that accumulated at the 30 °C zone (upper layer) may have increased cholesterol content which subsequently impart cryosurvival property. This preconditioning treatment can have a positive influence on cryotolerance which maybe related to changes in the overall composition of the cell membrane more likely, of cholesterol having a profound effect on the thermodynamic and mechanical properties of lipid bilayers, and influence on the stability and fluidity of sperm .
In contrast, in unprocessed control the naturally occurring transfer of cholesterol from bovine sperm to the surrounding medium may be present thus, making the sperm lipid membrane susceptible to cryoinjury. In fact, it has been reported that modification of membrane cholesterol in bull spermatozoa improves post-thaw survival and prevents impairment of sperm function after post-thawing . To elucidate the possible role of SSRT method in providing an environment for stability of plasma membrane and clarify the contribution of cholesterol in protecting the sperm from cryoinjury, we need further investigation and supporting evidences.
One of the major results in our study is the high improvement in pregnancy rate (93%, n = 13) of heifers and repeat breeders. The repeat breeders used in the study were female heifers that failed to get pregnant after three or more attempts. Of the 8 repeat breeders, 7 achieved successful pregnancy and livebirths while all nulliparous heifers inseminated with prefreeze processed semen became pregnant which resulted in livebirths (100% calving rate). It is also important to note that the cows were observed for natural estrus and inseminated under the am-pm rule. The robustness of the strategy is also demonstrated by the fact that the new straw produced form this method erased the technician bias as supported by the different technicians (n = 3) that performed the transcervical intrauterine AI technique. The prefreeze SSRT method based on the synergistic effects of slowly rotating fluid flow platform (effect of fluid flow on spermatozoa) and temperature gradient (thermotactic effect on spermatozoa) created an environment that guided motile and viable spermatozoa to self propulsion and migration to the upper layer of the vessel at 30 °C temperature. Therefore, a responsiveness of the sperm to opposite flow and temperature gradient could then be seen as an essential sperm function that can be used at a macroscale to process fresh semen prior to cryopreservation. This strategy attempted to improve fertility of the cryopreserved sperm by reformulating cryopreservation protocols by adding a new but simple approach to enrich semen doses with viable, motile and fertile spermatozoa based on prefreeze SSRT method. This approach results in selected sperm population composed of highly motile and fertile spermatozoa. Our results provide solid evidence that improvement of post-thaw semen quality by motile sperm selection prior to cryopreservation would be beneficial in terms of cryosurvival, and increase in sperm survival and longevity after insemination with frozen-thawed semen in the female reproductive tract thus, optimizing fertilization, embryo development and calving as supported by the favorable results of our field fertility study. Moreover, the SSRT platform eliminates the moribund sperm in the inseminate and improves semen quality and viability, an important contribution to previous works on sperm selection. However, unlike other sperm selection techniques that requires immediate use in AI after the selection procedure, our current method process bull semen and selects motile and fertile sperm prior to cryopreservation; a simple platform integrated to the current cryopreservation procedure used by the AI industry, thus offering a practical but simple way of improving the conception rate. Although our study involves a field test of small sample size, it is considered indispensable prior to conduct of a large-scale application and offers a simple sperm selection technology prior to cryopreservation with a promising means to improve animal conception rate.
MPBN, & K.Yamashita conceptualized and designed the research, developed the prefreeze sperm sorting protocol, performed sperm sorting, analyzed the data, and wrote the manuscript; K.Yamashita coordinated the project; JE, NK, MPBN, & K.Yamashita developed the semen freezing protocol and manufactured the frozen semen straws; KE, performed AI experiments; KO, K.Yamanaka, TY, HM & YH performed cytological studies. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
This research work is supported by the Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries, Japan (MAFF) under the project name “Development of technology for enhancement of livestock lifetime productivity by improving fertility through assisted reproduction” and the JSPS KAKENHI (15H04585).
Ethics approval and consent to participate
Animal ethics committee approvals were not required, because the experiment plan is within the scope of food production. The use of animals was governed by law and notifications of the Japanese Guidelines for Animal Care and Use and under the administrative guidance of the Ministry of Education, the collaborating institutes followed the rules of the Ethics Committee for the Care and Use of Experimental Animal during the conduct of the animal experiments.
Consent for publication
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
- 2.Alam SS, El Makawy AI, Tohamy AA, Abd Elrahman MM. Effect of seasonal variations on semen quality and fertility of Egyptian water Buffalo (Bubalus bubalis) bulls. Research J Pharm Biol Chem Sci. 2015;6:1059–69.Google Scholar
- 6.Yi YJ, Zimmerman SW, Manandhar G, Odhiambo JF, Kennedy C, Jonáková V, et al. Ubiquitin-activating enzyme (UBA1) is required for sperm capacitation, acrosomal exocytosis and sperm-egg coat penetration during porcine fertilization. Int J Androl. 2012;35:196–210.PubMedCrossRefPubMedCentralGoogle Scholar
- 7.Odhiambo JF, Sutovsky M, DeJarnette JM, Marshall C, Sutovsky P. Adaptation of ubiquitin-PNA based sperm quality assay for semen evaluation by a conventional flow cytometer and a dedicated platform for flow cytometric semen analysis. Theriogenology. 2011;76:1168–76.PubMedCrossRefPubMedCentralGoogle Scholar
- 13.Walters EM, Benson JD, Woods EJ, Critser JK. The history of sperm cryopreservation. In: Pacey AA, Tomlinson MJ, editors. Sperm banking: theory and practice. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press; 2009. p. 1–10.Google Scholar
- 40.Sousa AP, Amaral A, Baptista M, Tavares R, Caballero Campo P, Caballero Peregrín P, Freitas A, Paiva A, Almeida-Santos T, Ramalho-Santos J. Not all sperm are equal: functional mitochondria characterize a subpopulation of human sperm with better fertilization potential. PLoS One. 2011;6:e18112.PubMedPubMedCentralCrossRefGoogle Scholar
- 44.Ford WCL, Rees JM. The bioenergetics of mammalian sperm motility. In: Gagnon C, editor. Controls of sperm motility: biological and clinical aspects. Boca Raton: CRC Press; 1999. p. 175–202.Google Scholar
Open AccessThis article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated.