Efficacy and indication optimization of Chinese medicine (Tiao-Chang Ke-Min granules) for diarrhea-predominant irritable bowel syndrome: study protocol for a randomized controlled trial
- 156 Downloads
Irritable bowel syndrome (IBS) is a chronic, recurring condition, prevalent in the general population. Current medication treatments usually leave patients undertreated. Nowadays, Chinese medicine (CM) is being considered as a promising treatment approach for IBS. However, due to methodological limitations, there is no strong evidence to support CM. Although IBS relapses are common, the relapse assessment has always been neglected in CM study designs. Meanwhile, in clinical practice and studies, it has been found that certain CM formulas can only benefit certain kinds of patients. Discovering what population and illness characteristics likely respond to outcomes may help improve the effectiveness of CM. The aims of this study are to evaluate the efficacy and safety of Tiao-Chang Ke-Min (TCKM) granules for IBS, especially in reducing IBS symptoms’ relapse, by a high-quality randomized controlled trial and then to optimize the indication of the TCKM granules.
This is a parallel-group, randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial embedded with outcome predictive factors. Eligible patients with diarrhea-predominant IBS will be randomized into either a TCKM granule group or a placebo group. Patients from both groups will receive health education. The treatment duration is 4 weeks and the follow-up is 12 weeks. The primary outcome is global improvement measured with adequate relief (AR). The second outcome measures include time until relief, time until first relapse, total relapse times, long-term effectiveness, individual symptoms, IBS-Symptom Severity Score (IBS-SSS), IBS-Quality of Life Questionnaire (IBS-QOL), and Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale (HADS). Predictive factors associated with patient and illness characteristics have been widely collected. These factors will be embedded in this trial for further identification.
This trial may provide high-quality evidence on the efficacy and safety of TCKM granules for IBS and a more accurate indication. Importantly, this trial will provide a new research method for improving the therapeutic effects of CM for clinicians and researchers. To address IBS relapse assessment, a series of special definitions of relapse incidents has been made for this trial.
Chinese Clinical Trial Registry, ID: ChiCTR-IOR-17010600. Registered on 9 February 2017.
KeywordsIrritable bowel syndrome Diarrhea-predominant Randomized controlled trial Prediction of the treatment outcome Indication Tiao-Chang Ke-Min granules Chinese medicine
Data and Safety Monitoring Board
Bristol Stool Form Scale
Case report forms
Good Manufacturing Practice
Guangdong Provincial Hospital of Chinese Medicine
Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale
Irritable bowel syndrome
IBS-Quality of Life Questionnaire
IBS Symptom Severity Score
Severity adverse event
Self-rating Anxiety Scale
Self-rating Depression Scale
Irritable bowel syndrome (IBS) is a chronic, recurrent, and functional gastrointestinal disorder. It is very common, affecting between 5 and 20% of the general population worldwide [1, 2] and 4.6–6% of the population in China [3, 4]. IBS is a heterogeneous disorder with a complex pathogenesis, making treatment challenging . There has been no consensus on the specific and effective strategies for the treatment of IBS. Current medication treatments are mainly based on relieving abdominal symptoms . Therefore, many IBS patients remain undertreated or dissatisfied with their quality of life . In addition, the long-term effectiveness of treatments is not good enough, as a systematic review concluded, through long-term follow-up, that only about 30% of IBS patients’ symptoms improved or disappeared . Recently, more and more IBS patients have sought to treat their symptoms with complementary and alternative medicine .
At present, Chinese medicine (CM) is considered a promising approach in the treatment of IBS. CM is, by nature, multi-targeted. It can manage IBS through simultaneously acting on diversified pathways and mechanisms . Clinical trials of CM for IBS have shown that CM could provide effective improvement in single symptoms, global assessments, and quality of life with few adverse events reported [11, 12]. However, according to current reviews, due to a lack of rigorous larger clinical trials, there is no strong evidence supporting CM in the treatment of IBS [7, 13, 14]. Furthermore, although IBS relapses are common, relapse incident assessment has always been neglected in CM study design .
One thing related to the effectiveness of CM should be given particular attention. CM treatment is a system of individualized medicine. The development of a CM formula is specific for a group of patients who share the common characterizes based on CM theory. In clinical practice and studies, it has been found that CM formulas may lead to a benefit improvement in some of the patients, but not in all. Finding out what patient and illness characteristics likely respond to CM treatment may help to identify a more suitable patient population, and improve the effectiveness of CM . Similar studies have been conducted in psychological therapy for IBS [17, 18, 19]. These studies identified factors predicting a good or poor outcome, which was expected to provide helpful suggestions for clinicians. However, until now, there have been no studies looking specifically at predictive factors of treatment outcome in CM trials for IBS.
Tiao-Chang Ke-Min (TCKM) granules were developed by Luo Yunjian, a famous practitioner of CM in China. They can play a crucial role in addressing the core pathogenesis and causes of IBS, according to CM theory. TCKM granules have an effect on reducing IBS symptom relapse, and its effectiveness and safety have been confirmed through long-term clinical practice. To date, however, there have been no high-quality studies conducted to test its effectiveness.
We plan to perform a randomized controlled trial embedded with comprehensive outcome predictive factors, for the purpose of establishing high-level evidence and setting an example for optimizing the indication of IBS treated with CM.
To assess the efficacy and safety of TCKM granules for IBS, especially in reducing IBS symptom relapse
To investigate what patient and illness characteristics may predict a successful outcome from the treatment of TCKM granules, and optimize the indication.
Setting and recruitment
The trial will be conducted at three branches of the Guangdong Provincial Hospital of Chinese Medicine (GPHCM), Guangzhou, China: (1) Dade Road Hospital, (2) Ersha Island Hospital, and (3) Guangzhou University City Hospital. The recruitment of participants for this trial will be mainly via physician referrals from the gastroenterology clinics. Advertisements and colored fliers will also be placed inside the hospitals. Those who are willing to participant in this trial will need to contact the research assistants by telephone.
Diagnosis of IBS must meet the ROME IV criteria . Among IBS subtypes, participants will be included in the type of diarrhea-predominant IBS. However, CM patterns of patients will not be restricted.
Diagnosis with diarrhea-predominant IBS
18 to 75 years of age, male or female
Signed informed consent
A reported Irritable Bowel Syndromes Symptom Severity Score (IBS-SSS) of > 75
Patients with alarm symptoms such as severe weight loss in the past few months and hematochezia
Patients with history or current evidence of inflammatory bowel disease
Patients with history or current evidence of celiac disease, concurrent enteric infection, hyperthyroidism or other diseases causing diarrhea and abdominal pain
Patients who report a score of > 50 on the Self-rating Anxiety Scale (SAS) or a score of > 53 on the Self-rating Depression Scale (SDS), or patients with other psychiatric disorders
Patients with a history of gastrointestinal surgery causing ailments similar to IBS
Patients who are unable or unwilling to stop taking medication affecting the assessment of experimental drug efficacy and safety
Patients who are pregnant, breastfeeding, or plan to conceive within 3 months
Patients with concurrent serious diseases, such as cancer, serious cardiovascular, respiratory, hepatic, renal, or neurological disease
Patients who are participating or who have participated in another clinical trial within the previous 3 months
Patients who, in the opinion of the researcher, are unsuitable for the trial
A block randomization sequence will be created by an independent statistician, using SAS 9.2 software (SAS Institute Inc., Cary, USA). The randomization will be stratified by site with eligible participants randomly assigned to either the TCKM granule group or the placebo group at a ratio of 1:1. Researchers will access the treatment allocation for each eligible participant through a remote and web-based randomization system, which has been developed by the Key Unit of Methodology in Clinical Research, GPHCM. A label with a serial number based on the randomization schedule will be attached to all drugs. Treatment allocations will be kept in password-protected files and saved by an independent staff member.
Treatment allocations will be blinded to the participants, clinicians, research assistants, drug managers, statisticians, and other staff members, and will not be revealed until the study is completed. After a run-in period, the clinicians will assess whether the patients are still eligible. For each eligible patient, the clinician will apply for a randomized assignment by logging into the web-based randomization system, and write a prescription for “TCKM granules, three bags, twice a day.” Then, accompanied with a research assistant, the patients will be taken to the appointed drug managers at the GPHCM pharmacy. The drug managers are responsible for dispensing medication according to the prescriptions and assignments. During the trial periods, clinicians, research assistants, and drug managers are forbidden from discussing the assignment possibilities with the participants. The placebo granules have an appearance, smell and taste similar to the TCKM granules. All drugs are packaged in an identical manner. The blinding codes will be kept strictly confidential, and will not be broken during the trial unless serious adverse events occur. The date and reason for breaking the blinding code will be recorded in the case report forms (CRFs).
Health education. The participants in both groups will receive a health education course. Health education handbooks will be provided by research assistants, and will include a series of IBS-related information, such as pathophysiological mechanisms, causative factors, and prognosis. After reading their handbooks, the participants can discuss the material with the clinicians. Diet- and stress-related issues among IBS patients will be discussed in details
Experimental drugs and placebo. Participants will receive three bags of either the TCKM granules or the matched placebo granules twice a day for 4 weeks. The placebo consists primarily of lactose, maltodextrin, natural food coloring and sucrose octaacetate. The experimental granules and the placebo granules are identical in appearance, taste, smell, weight, and packaging. Both of them will be provided by the Tianjiang Pharmaceutical Co., Ltd. (Jiangyin, Jiangsu Province, China) which meets the requirements of the Good Manufacturing Practice (GMP). All herbs will be obtained from qualified suppliers in China
Rescue medication. If patents’ diarrhea and abdominal pain are exacerbated beyond a tolerable level, rescue medication will be allowed for relieving abdominal symptoms in both groups. Montmorillonite powder, berberine hydrochloride, and levofloxacin will be allowed for uncontrollable diarrhea; and pinaverium bromide will be allowed for uncontrollable abdominal pain. Concomitant use of two or more rescue medications will also be allowed, and their dosages will depend on the symptoms severity. However, the administration of the rescue medication must be limited within 3 days, or the patients will be considered as withdrawn. In such cases, the name, dosage, and duration of the rescue medication are to be documented in the symptom diaries and CRFs
The primary outcome of this trial is adequate relief (AR), which is usually used to evaluate IBS global symptom improvement . The participants will be asked the following question at each visit during the treatment period: “In the past 7 days, have you had adequate relief of your irritable bowel syndrome pain and discomfort?” Participants will be considered as responders when they answer “yes” at least twice during the 4-week treatment period . Only a follow-up visit and a single positive response will be considered as non-responders.
Relief and relapse incidents
The definition of relapse is the recurrence of abdominal pain/discomfort or diarrhea in IBS patients who have achieved treatment success. Achieving treatment success means that IBS symptoms have been relieved, and the relief has lasted at least 1 week after treatment. Relief and relapse incident outcomes include time until relief, time until first relapse, and total relapse times. Time until relief is defined as the time from patients receiving treatment to achieving treatment success. Time until first relapse is defined as the time from patients achieving treatment success to the recurrence of abdominal pain/discomfort or diarrhea. Total relapse times refer to the sum of relapse times during both the treatment period and the follow-up period.
Participants who will be weekly AR responders for at least six of the 12 weeks during the follow-up period will be considered long-term effectiveness responders .
Throughout the whole study period, patients must record their IBS symptoms on paper diary cards every night before going to sleep. Diaries recorded in the run-in and treatment periods will be used to assess the efficacy and safety of the treatment, while diaries recorded during the follow-up period will be used to avoid potential bias from symptom recall. Individual symptoms are to be recorded as follows: severity of abdominal pain, abdominal discomfort, and abdominal distension evaluated by a 5-point Likert scale (0 = none; 1 = mild; 2 = moderate; 3 = severe; and 4 = intolerable); stool frequency; stool consistency classified by using the Bristol Stool Form Scale (BSFS) ; feelings of incomplete evacuation, urgency, and mucus evaluated on a binary scale (0 = absent; 1 = present).
Other outcomes include the scores of the Irritable Bowel Syndromes Symptom Severity Score (IBS-SSS), Irritable Bowel Syndrome-Quality of Life Questionnaire (IBS-QOL), and Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale (HADS) [25, 26, 27]. The questionnaire and scales above will be completed at the run-in period baseline (week 0), the end of the treatment period (week 4), and during the follow-up period (weeks 8, 12, and 16).
All participants must undergo an electrocardiogram examination and a series of clinical laboratory tests before and after the treatment (weeks 0 and 4). These will include routine blood, urine, stool, and stool occult blood, kidney function, and liver function tests. More attention will be given to the abnormal changes found in the examinations and, when necessary, a re-examination and a causality assessment will be required.
No reports of harm to patients exist from long-term clinical observations with TCKM granule treatment. Nevertheless, participants will still be instructed to report any adverse events (AEs) during the trial. The clinicians will be in charge of managing AEs. An independent Data and Safety Monitoring Board (DSMB) from GPHCM will be in charge of studying each case individually to access any serious adverse event (SAE) and the causality between the SAE and the intervention. AE details including clinical manifestations, severity, occurrence time, recovery time, management and causality will be recorded on CRFs. If any SAE occurs, it must be reported to the principal investigator, DSMB, and the Ethics Committee within 24 h, and any necessary treatment will be provided as soon as possible. When necessary, the blinding will be broken and participants will be provided suitable treatments. All SAEs will be followed up until they have been resolved.
Data management and quality assurance
Before the conduction of the clinical trial, all investigators and relevant staff including clinicians, research assistants, and drug managers will be uniformly trained regarding the trial-specific process. The training will be conducted by the principal investigator, and a study protocol and standard operation procedure documents will be provided. This will ensure consistency among researchers undertaking the same tasks, and ensure that their actions remain in strict accordance with the study protocol. Data collection for this trial will be performed by investigators and research assistants. All collected data will be checked regularly by the data management personnel, and be overseen by monitors from the Guangdong International Clinical Research Center of Chinese Medicine (Guangzhou, China). Double data entry of CRFs will be conducted by two experienced independent data entry clerks. At the time of analysis, outliers in the resulting spreadsheets will be checked to eliminate errors in data entry. All information collected in this trial will be kept in strict confidence, and only authorized staff will have access to the trial data.
Considering that those IBS patients accompanied with psychological symptoms are more likely to withdraw, measures will be taken to facilitate maximization of their compliance. For example, before every visit, a research assistant will contact the patient to confirm the schedule; specialized telephones for this trial will be installed, in order for patients to conveniently contact clinicians or other staff. However, if patients withdraw from the trial, outcome assessment, the last date of patients taking medication, and the reasons for withdrawal will be recorded as soon as possible. We will also take some measures to monitor the drug intake by participants. For example, the participants will be required to record a symptom diary and answer the question: “Did you take the Tiao-Chang Ke-Min granules today?” before going to bed every day. Besides, the research assistants will ask the participants “How many packages of the granules have you taken in the past week?” weekly during the treatment period and complete the CRF.
Sample size calculation
The sample size for this trial was calculated based on the primary outcome—the proportion of responders of AR, using PASS 11.0 software (NCSS, LLC, Kaysville, UT, USA). Combining our previous observational study with similar studies [28, 29], we assume that the proportion of responders of AR in TCKM granule group will be 60%, and in the placebo group 30%. Fifty-seven patients in each group can achieve 90% power and rule out type I error of 5% by using a two-sided test. We expect that 20% of the participants may be lost to follow-up. Therefore, the sample size in each group should be adjusted to 72. In total, 144 participants will be enrolled in this trial.
Design of outcome predictive factors
Outcome predictive factors have been investigated by a series of qualitative methods, including academic literature research, questionnaire survey, and expert consensus conference. Predictive factors were collected mainly around three cores and four levels. The three cores refer to causative and risk factors of an illness, state of an illness, and different classification conventions from both Western medicine and CM. The four levels include demographic characteristics, clinical characteristics, systems biology characteristics, and classification assessments along multiple dimensions. These factors will be embedded in this trial for further observation and analysis. Factors that may predict successful outcome from the treatment will be selected.
Statistical analysis will be performed by blinded specialized statisticians using PASW Statistics 18.0 (IBM SPSS Inc., Armonk, NY, USA) and SAS 9.2 software (SAS Institute Inc., Cary, NC, USA). A level of 5% (two-sided) type I error will be considered as statistically significant. Analysis will be based on both intention-to-treat and per-protocol populations.
Baseline characteristics, which also include predictive factors, will be presented for each group. From baseline to each time point, discrete variables will be described with frequencies and percentages, and continuous variables will be described with either mean and standard deviation for data with normal distribution or median and interquartile range for non-normally distributed data. For comparisons between experiment and control group at each time point, a chi-square test or Fisher’s exact test will be used for discrete variables, and the Student’s t test or Wilcoxon-Mann-Whitney U test will be used for continuous variables.
The analyses of predictive factors will be performed in two steps as follows: The first step is univariate analysis. The AR post-treatment (week 4) and follow-up (week 16) responder rates will be used as dependent variables, and predict factors, such as demographic and clinical characteristics, and key elements of CM patterns, will be used as independent variables. A logistic regression analysis will be conducted. The selection criteria for the independent variable is defined as α = 0.1. The second step is multivariate analysis. Those predictive factors selected through the first step will be entered into two multiple regression models, taking the post-treatment (week 4) and the follow-up (week 16) AR responder rates as the dependent variable. Each model will be conducted to adjust or unadjust for initial baseline level including scores of IBS-SSS, IBS-QOL, and HADS.
We plan to do some sensitivity analyses. Firstly, we will compare the primary and safety outcomes between all randomized patients and unmasking patients. Secondly, we will test the impact of the missing data on our primary outcome. The method of multiple imputations will be used to handle missing data. We will compare the results of primary outcome using the multiple imputed dataset and un-imputed dataset to test robustness.
Planned subgroup analyses will be carried out in relation to the primary outcome—AR. The main analysis for each subgroup will be an unadjusted test of interaction in a logistic model.
Key elements of CM patterns
A formal amendment to the protocol will be required, and must be approved by the principal investigator and the Ethics Committee of the GPHCM prior to implementation, if modifications may affect the conduct of the study, patients’ potential benefit or safety.
As far as we know, this will be the first study to characterize the responders of treatment outcome along multiple dimensions for IBS in the CM field. This will also be the first study to focus on evaluating the recurrence of IBS symptoms with a series of special definitions of relapse incidents. Compared to previous studies of CM for IBS, this study will have more rigorous methodology and quality assurance.
Relapse is frequent among IBS patients, often leading to repeated clinical visits and missed work. Previous studies have usually been interested in evaluating the short-term effectiveness of an intervention, while recently more attention has been transferred to long-term effectiveness . We have yet to find special outcome on the assessment of IBS relapse. Most studies have evaluated long-term effectiveness by repeatedly measuring common outcomes at each visit. However, the variation in conditions between two visits often is not readily available. Based on clinical practice, we make a series of special definitions of relapse incidents, including time until relief, time until first relapse, and total relapse times. These may be more appropriate for relapse assessment.
Some studies have suggested that in order to achieve a better understanding of the variation in patients’ responses to treatment effects, study populations should be described along multiple dimensions . Doing this may also help to identify more suitable patient populations and optimize the indication. Current studies that have investigated predictive factors have usually been interested in gathering conventional variables such as demographic, clinical, and psychological characteristics . Meanwhile, several potential important factors, such as biological characteristics and environmental factors, have been ignored . Compared with previous studies, our study collects predictive factors along the multidimensional nature of IBS. In addition, due to the specificity of CM’s theoretical system, factors associated with CM, including the CM pathogenesis and symptom patterns, are also taken into account in this trial.
According to the CM theory, Gan-qi stagnation and Pi-qi deficiency are the basic pathogenesis for IBS [34, 35]; dietary intolerance and emotional disorders are two main causes, making IBS symptoms occur or recur . TCKM granules are comprised of herbal medicine with the actions of regulating the function of the Gan and Pi, and resisting impacts of dietary and emotional factors. Therefore, TCKM granules could reduce IBS symptom relapse.
The results of this trial should provide high-quality evidence on the efficacy and safety of TCKM granules for IBS and more accurate indication of TCKM granules. Importantly, this trial will provide a novel research method for clinicians and researchers to improve the effectiveness of CM.
Participant recruitment is in preparation.
Many thanks to Prof. Yun-jian Luo, Prof. Xin-feng Guo, Dr. Xiao-jia Ni, Mei-ling Xuan, and Yi-han He from Guangdong Provincial Hospital of Chinese Medicine for their comments and suggestions on this study.
This work was supported by grants from the Guangdong Provincial Science and Technology Program (Grant No. 2013B032500011), and the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant No. 81503458).
XBY is the principal investigator of the study; he proposed the concept for this trial and designed the study. QL participated in planning and designing the study, and was a major contributor in manuscript writing. ZHW helped design the study and revise the manuscript critically. WWOY provided statistical support. BPZ, SGH, and JHX helped draft the manuscript. All authors have read and approved the final manuscript.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
Ethics approval for this trial protocol has been obtained from the Ethics Committee of GPHCM (number: B2016–132-01). Patients will be provided with sufficient time to consider whether to enter the trial or not. The investigators and research assistants must obtain the written informed consent from each participant before randomization.
Consent for publication
All authors have reviewed the final version of the manuscript and approved its publication.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
- 14.Liu JP, Yang M, Liu YX, Wei M, Grimsgaard S. Herbal medicines for treatment of irritable bowel syndrome. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2006;1:CD004116.Google Scholar
- 20.Drossman DA. Functional gastrointestinal disorders: history, pathophysiology, clinical features and Rome IV. Gastroenterology. 2016. doi: https://doi.org/10.1053/j.gastro.2016.02.032.
- 22.Simrén M, Ohman L, Olsson J, Svensson U, Ohlson K, Posserud I, Strid H. Clinical trial: the effects of a fermented milk containing three probiotic bacteria in patients with irritable bowel syndrome—a randomized, double-blind, controlled study. Aliment Pharmacol Ther. 2010;31:218–27.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
Open AccessThis article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated.