Use of ivacaftor in late diagnosed cystic fibrosis monozygotic twins heterozygous for F508del and R117H-7T – a case report
- 224 Downloads
CFTR modulator therapy with ivacaftor is a treatment option for Cystic Fibrosis (CF) patients with at least one copy of a R117H-7T mutation in the CFTR gene. Desirable effects of this therapy are improvement of lung function, decrease in exacerbation rate, normalization or reduction of sweat chloride and weight gain. Monogenetic CF-twins carry identical genetic information, so therapy response and side effects are expected to be nearly identical under this specific therapy.
In monozygotic twins, at the age of 55, two pathogenic variants in the CFTR gene (F508del and R117H-7T) were detected. Both patients presented with a borderline sweat test (30–59 mmol/L) and despite the same genetic information and similar life circumstances the disease proceeds completely different. While one patient has severe pulmonary involvement with chronic P. aeruginosa infection, her twin sister is almost unimpaired. Liver or pancreatic involvement was not seen in either patient. Due to the presence of one copy of a R117H-7T mutation, CFTR modulator therapy with ivacaftor was initiated in both. Response and side effects were significantly different. In the less affected patient, we observed an improvement in lung function and a normalization of sweat chloride. In the severely affected patient, no functional response to treatment was seen, but stabilization of the disease state with a decrease in exacerbation and hospitalization rate and weight gain as well as a normalization of sweat chloride. There was an increase in liver enzymes in the less affected patient, which normalized after halving the dose of ivacaftor, while the therapeutic effect was maintained.
Despite nearly identical genetic information, as in monogenetic twins, therapy response and onset of side effects of CFTR modulating therapy are very different. In patients with late diagnosis and severe pulmonary involvement, ivacaftor does not seem to improve lung function, whereas in patients with late diagnosis and low disease severity a relevant therapy response was obtained. In addition to lung function, additional clinical parameters such as reduction of exacerbation and hospitalization rate and weight gain should be used to assess therapy response, especially in severely affected patients.
KeywordsCystic fibrosis Monogenetic twins Heterozygous F508del R117H-7T Elderly Late diagnosis Ivacaftor
Airway clearance techniques
Congenital bilateral absence of vas deferens
Cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator
Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
U.S. Food and Drug Administration
Million international units
Nasal potential difference
Randomized controlled trial
Cystic fibrosis (CF) is the most common life limiting mono-genetic disorder in Caucasian with an incidence of approximately 1:2500 . Over 2000 pathogenic variants have been detected which cause a defect in CFTR (cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator) protein synthesis and/or function but only a few hundred are pathogenic variants as underlying reason for CF disease. Those mutations were classified in seven classes dependant on their mechanisms by which they produce quantitative or qualitative changes in CFTR-function .
Identical twins arise from one zygote that, at an early stage of development, separated into independently growing cell aggregations giving rise to two individuals of the same sex and identical genetic constitution. Because of this, it is expected that patients with two CF-defining mutations will have nearly the same phenotype. However, it comes despite identical genetic information to a different extent of the disease. In addition to the genetic defect there are non-genetic (environmental) factors and modifier genes which define the phenotypic heterogeneity of CF disease [3, 4]. Even among siblings and twins with the same CFTR mutations substantial discordance regarding the phenotype can be observed [5, 6].
F508del (p.Phe508del) is the most prevalent CFTR-mutation in Caucasians . It is defined as a class II mutation that leads to a trafficking defect of the CFTR protein. The exon 4 missense mutation R117H (p.Arg117His) was initially discovered in 1990  and describes a class III (gating) and class IV (conductance) defect . This CFTR-mutation is found in 0.4% of all German  and 3% of all CF-patients in the US . There is an exchange of arginine for histidine at the 117th position in the CF transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) protein. There is a great variability in phenotypic expression of CF disease in patients carrying a R117H mutation, depending on the intron 8 polythymidine tract length of the CFTR gene in cis [12, 13, 14]. Variants in the length of the polythymidine tract repeat in intron 8 of the CFTR gene influences the activity of the CFTR protein and thus the phenotype. The most common polythymidine morphisms are the 5 T, 7 T and 9 T variants. The combination of a severe CFTR-mutation and a short-ended poly-T-sequence may lead to the development of classic CF with early pulmonary involvement, pancreatic insufficiency, and male infertility  while the clinical variability of the 7 T variant appears much more complex. This includes negative to borderline sweat tests, early or late onset CF, congenital bilateral absence of vas deferens (CBAVD) to no disease activity [16, 17].
In 2011, ivacaftor (formerly known as VX-770), was the first small molecule to be effective in CF patients with a G551D genotype, a severe class III mutation affecting the opening of the CFTR channel . The positive results of ivacaftor in clinical trials led to the approval of patients with at least one copy of the G551D allele. Other studies, initially performed in vitro, also showed an effect of ivacaftor on other gating mutations, including R117H . In a following multicenter, phase 3, double-blind, placebo-controlled, parallel-group study, the effect of ivacaftor on the mutation R117H was investigated, followed by the approval extension for this mutation .
We would like to present the case of late diagnosed monozygotic twins with compound heterozygosity for F508del and R117H-7T and the influence of ivacaftor on disease progression.
In a 55-year-old female patient (Patient 1, see Table 1), a sweat test was performed due to recurrent pneumothoraces and bilateral bronchiectasis with mucoid impaction apparent in thoracic computed tomography (CT). Sweat test showed borderline values of sweat chloride two times (52 and 41 mmol/L); therefore, genetic testing for mutations in the CFTR gene was initiated. Indeed, two mutations, F508del and R117H-7T, were detected. Pulmonary function testing revealed a severe obstructive ventilation disorder with a FEV1 (forced expiratory volume in 1 sec) of 27% predicted and respiratory failure with the need for oxygen therapy. Indications of the presence of a liver or pancreas involvement in the context of the underlying disease were not found. The repeatedly determined pancreatic elastase was in normal range (> 200 μg/g). In sputum samples, P. aeruginosa was cultured several times. Serologically, antibodies (Elastase and Exotoxin A) against P. aeruginosa were significantly increased as an indication of chronic respiratory tract infection. The patient reports a long history of disease with shortness of breath, productive cough and recurrent pulmonary infections with frequent antibiotic therapies until the final diagnosis was made. She had used bronchodilators (short- and long-acting beta 2-sympathomimetic agents) and inhaled corticosteroids for many years assuming she suffers from a chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) although she was non-smoking and was not exposed to occupational hazards. Due to severe obstructive pulmonary disease the patient has been repeatedly treated with systemic corticosteroids in the past.
In addition to pulmonary involvement, the patient also had a long-standing affection of the paranasal sinuses. Due to chronic infection of the respiratory tract with P. aeruginosa, we initiated an inhalative antibiotic therapy with tobramycin 300 mg twice a day and later changed to colistin 2 MIU twice a day because of an increase of bronchial obstruction. Hypertonic saline 3% and Dornase alfa were introduced for improving airway clearance. Furthermore, with help of the respiratory therapists, the patient learned airway clearance techniques (ACT) to perform this independently. At that time, nearly monthly hospitalization was necessary as the clinical condition worsened.
After diagnosis of the index patient, her twin sister (Patient 2, see Table 1) was introduced to us for further diagnostics. Here, too, a borderline sweat test was found (sweat chloride 44 mmol/L). A repeated sweat test showed a nearly normal value (33 mmol/L). Subsequent genetic testing also revealed a compound heterozygosity for F508del and R117H-7T.
This patient had markedly less symptoms such as cough and shortness of breath. Also, no recurrent pulmonary infections were reported. However, chronic nasal congestions and recurrent sinusoidal infections were reported. A CT-scan of the upper respiratory tract revealed chronic pansinusitis with accentuation of the maxillary sinus. The patient has undergone sinus surgery multiple times in the past. In addition, the patient reported to suffer from allergic bronchial asthma, especially in spring. In this regard, there exists an on-demand therapy with an inhaled corticosteroid and a long-acting beta-agonist bronchodilator.
Pulmonary function showed only a moderate obstructive ventilation disorder (FEV1 = 74%pred.). A CT-scan of the chest revealed bronchiectasis in both upper lobes and a consolidation in middle lobe. In repeated sputum samples, Staphylococcus aureus was detected. Serologically, the reciprocal antibody-titres against P. aeruginosa were all negative. Notes on exocrine or endocrine pancreatic insufficiency or liver involvement were not documented.
Both patients grew up together under the same conditions and in the same area. Both were non-smokers and were not exposed to any substances harmful to the lungs, privately and professionally. There was no family history. Because of the severity of the lung disease, Patient 1 was unable to do any work and was retired while her twin sister was doing a full-time job.
After diagnosis, both patients were placed on ivacaftor. Initially, the drug was well tolerated by both. Patient 2 showed two to three times elevated liver enzymes (ASAT, ALAT) shortly after administration of ivacaftor 150 mg twice a day, which is why we were forced to reduce the dose of ivacaftor. At half the dose, a normalization of the liver function was recognized. Patient 1 initially complained of a bronchial tightness, which could not be detected any more after approximately 14 days under symptomatic therapy.
Baseline characteristics of both patients at time of diagnosis
F508del and R117H-7T
MMEF 75/25 (%pred.)
Sweat chloride (mmol/L)
Elastase (μg/g stool)
The pulmonarily less affected twin sister showed improvement in lung function with an increase in FEV1 and FVC after initiation of therapy (see Fig. 1). In the repetition of the sweat test, a normal value could be determined (19 mmol/L), as with the sister, even under half the dose of ivacaftor. The existing chronic paranasal sinus complaints were also declining. In addition, the patient reported an improved daily workload. Inpatient treatment was not necessary before or after treatment initiation with ivacaftor.
Phenotypic variability is not a new phenomenon in monogenic diseases. A number of modifying genes have been identified alongside the disease-causing genes that influence the phenotype [21, 22, 23]. This finding not only affects CF, but can also be demonstrated in other monogenetic disorders .
Our case shows the late diagnosis of CF in identical twins with compound heterozygosity for F508del and R117H-7T and a pronounced phenotypic variability. Both patients have borderline sweat tests, are pancreatic-sufficient and have no liver involvement. The difference shows in pulmonary involvement with severe obstructive ventilation disorder with chronic pulmonary infection with P. aeruginosa in one patient and only minor obstruction with missing proof of P. aeruginosa in her twin sister. Both have chronic pansinusitis as an expression of the contribution of the upper respiratory tract. Late diagnosis of CF is more common in women, less common with liver and pancreatic involvement, and less frequent chronic P. aeruginosa infection . The combination of F508del and R117H-7T shows mild disease progression, often completely asymptomatic .
With ivacaftor there is a drug available to correct the base defect of the disease. Ivacaftor was initially approved for the treatment of patients with a G551D mutation. The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) granted extended approval for the treatment of patients with a R117H mutation in December 2014 for individuals aged 6 years and older. This was based on a randomized controlled trial (RCT) that examined the efficacy of ivacaftor versus placebo in 69 patients with at least one copy of a R117H mutation . The efficacy of ivacaftor was demonstrated in both 5 T and 7 T variants. As a result, the recommendation for ivacaftor therapy exists in adult patients with evidence of at least one copy of R117H, regardless of whether a 5 T or 7 T variant is present . The aim of this therapy is to slow down disease progression, to stabilize the state of health and to improve lung function. A positive aspect of stabilization of health status can be found in a decrease in hospitalization rate . Especially in patients with preserved lung function, therapy with ivacaftor makes sense, as the goal should be to keep lung function stable for as long as possible . However, ivacaftor has also been shown to be a treatment option for patients with severe lung involvement or patients on the lung transplantation waiting list [30, 31].
The use of ivacaftor can result in a decrease of sweat chloride, an increase of lung function and reduction of pulmonary exacerbations in many patients [32, 33]. However, the clinical response to ivacaftor is very heterogeneous and shows great variability. Repeated pulmonary function measurements with determination of FEV1 are usually the primary endpoint in clinical trials for assessing treatment response. However, the measurement of FEV1 varies at each single measurement so it seems difficult at short time intervals to make an appropriate statement about addressing response and non-response of a therapy . In addition, as in our case, an already existing, irreversible structural lung damage can be regarded as a cause why response of lung function during therapy with ivacaftor, despite identical genetic information, is so different. In addition, there seem to be other factors influencing the potential response of CFTR modulator therapy. Variants in the Solute Carrier Family 26 Member 9 gene, SLC26A9, which encodes an alternative chloride channel, may influence the response of ivacaftor therapy to gating mutations and may be a possible explanation why patients respond differently to CFTR modulator therapy despite identical mutations in the CFTR gene .
It seems difficult to find a single marker which serves as an efficiency outcome parameter for therapy response. Sweat chloride changes are controversial as a marker for response to CFTR-modulating therapy, because repeated sweat chloride measurements show great variability [36, 37] and no correlation with FEV1 changes . Other methods, e.g. NPD (nasal potential difference) measurements can be considered to assess CFTR function as a marker for response . The safety profile of ivacaftor proved to be very good. However, there is also a very heterogeneous occurrence of side effects with different degrees of severity [20, 40].
In addition to the existing CFTR base defect, there seem to be other factors that influence not just the phenotype and the disease severity but also the response and onset of side effects . In addition to the desired improvement in pulmonary function parameters, other clinical parameters such as reduction of exacerbation rate, weight gain or improved airway clearance appear equally important. The clinical efficacy of CFTR modulator therapy should not be assessed solely based on lung function, but should be evaluated individually. In the context of precision medicine attention should also be paid to the resulting costs for the health system of each country [42, 43]. Only the long-term use of these drugs will show cost-benefit effectiveness.
The presence of two mutations in the CFTR gene, one of them R117H-7T, may be associated with late diagnosis of CF. The phenotype of the disease is very variable even in monogenetic twins. As with phenotypic variability, there appears to be a wide range of possible response to CFTR modulator therapy, also concerning side effects. Late diagnosis with advanced lung disease appears to be a reason for poor response. Therapy response can not only be identified by an improvement in lung function or reduction of sweat chloride. Weight gain, reduction of exacerbation and hospitalization rate as well as improvement in airway clearance may also be seen as a successful response to therapy. Especially in patients with advanced age by the time of diagnosis, regardless of the severity of pulmonary involvement, we consider ivacaftor a therapeutic option to supplement the generally accepted standard of care.
The authors thank the two patients and their families for approval for publication.
Availability of data and materials
All the data supporting our findings is contained within the manuscript.
MW analysed and interpreted the patient data, performed the literature review and drafted the manuscript. SStraßburg performed the literature review and participated the drafting of the manuscript. CT and SSutharsan critically revised the manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
Consent for publication
Written informed consent for publication in BMC Pulmonary Medicine was obtained from both patients.
MW has participated in advisory boards and has served as an investigator in Vertex Pharmaceuticals Incorporated clinical studies. SS has served as a principal investigator in Vertex Pharmaceuticals Incorporated clinical studies; has participated in advisory boards or as a consultant for Vertex Pharmaceuticals Incorporated. SSt and CT declare that they have no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
- 10.Nährlich L., Burkhart M., Wiese B.. German cystic fibrosis register. https://www.muko.info/fileadmin/user_upload/angebote/qualitaetsmanagement/register/annual_report_2016.pdf. Accessed 02 Apr 2019.
- 11.Cystic Fibrosis Foundation Patient Registry. 2016 Patient Registry Annual Data Report. https://www.cff.org/Research/Researcher-Resources/Patient-Registry/2016-Patient-Registry-Annual-Data-Report.pdf. Accessed 02 Apr 2019.
- 20.Moss RB, Flume PA, Elborn JS, Cooke J, Rowe SM, McColley SA, et al. Efficacy and safety of ivacaftor in patients with cystic fibrosis who have an Arg117His-CFTR mutation: a double-blind, randomised controlled trial. Lancet Respir Med. 2015;3:524–33. https://doi.org/10.1016/S2213-2600(15)00201-5 .CrossRefPubMedPubMedCentralGoogle Scholar
- 27.Ren CL, Morgan RL, Oermann C, Resnick HE, Brady C, Campbell A, et al. Cystic fibrosis foundation pulmonary guidelines. Use of cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator modulator therapy in patients with cystic fibrosis. Ann Am Thorac Soc. 2018;15:271–80. https://doi.org/10.1513/AnnalsATS.201707-539OT .CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
- 34.Taylor-Robinson D, Whitehead M, Diderichsen F, Olesen HV, Pressler T, Smyth RL, Diggle P. Understanding the natural progression in %FEV 1 decline in patients with cystic fibrosis: a longitudinal study. Thorax. 2012;67:860–6. https://doi.org/10.1136/thoraxjnl-2011-200953 .CrossRefPubMedPubMedCentralGoogle Scholar
- 39.Mesbahi M, Shteinberg M, Wilschanski M, Hatton A, Nguyen-Khoa T, Friedman H, et al. Changes of CFTR functional measurements and clinical improvements in cystic fibrosis patients with non p.Gly551Asp gating mutations treated with ivacaftor. J Cyst Fibros. 2017;16:45–8. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jcf.2016.08.006 .CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
- 42.Whiting P, Al M, Burgers L, Westwood M, Ryder S, Hoogendoorn M, et al. Ivacaftor for the treatment of patients with cystic fibrosis and the G551D mutation: a systematic review and cost-effectiveness analysis. Health Technol Assess. 2014. https://doi.org/10.3310/hta18180 .
Open AccessThis article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated.