Advertisement

Social Theory & Health

, Volume 15, Issue 4, pp 448–464 | Cite as

Communicative validity of health-related promotion of physical activity: A critical analysis of national health strategies

Original Article

Abstract

Presently, the promotion of physical activity (PA) is a core objective of global health governance. The question “How valid are communications concerning the health-related promotion of PA?” is thus assessed here. Against the background of Habermas’ critical theory (The Theory of Communicative Action. Reason and the Rationalization of Society. Boston: Beacon Press, 1984), the article examines health strategies for the promotion of PA by checking for violations of validity and pathologies therein. Through qualitative content analysis (Mayring in Qualitative Content Analysis: Principles and Techniques. Weinheim: Beltz, 2003), twenty documents concerning PA promotion issued by the ministries of health of the USA, Germany, Sweden, and Italy were considered. The following issues were disclosed: (1) comprehensibility: definitions of key terms are rare and recommendations on PA are somewhat ambiguous and contradictory. (2) Sincerity: there is a discrepancy between the utopic goal of the health promotion and the narrow preventive aims of the documents. (3) Legitimacy: some argumentations blame the population for being inactive, enhance the power of medical staff, and diminish that of other experts in this context. (4) Truth: occasionally, scientific knowledge is used in misleading ways, lack of evidence is disregarded, and alternative solutions are encroached on. Ultimately, the underlying mechanisms of these violations of validity and pathologies, their consequences, and the opportunities to overcome them are discussed using Habermas’ critical theory.

Keywords

physical activity health strategy critical theory validity claims 

References

  1. Arts, W. and Gelissen, J. (2002) Three worlds of welfare capitalism or more? A state-of-the-art report. Journal of European Social Policy 12(2): 137–158.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Astrand, P.-O. (1994) Physical activity and fitness: Evolutionary perspective and trends for the future. In: C. Bouchard, R. J. Shephard and T. Stephens (eds.), Physical Activity, Fitness, and Health: International Proceedings and Consensus Statement. Champaign: Human Kinetics, pp. 98–105.Google Scholar
  3. Avery, L., Flynn, D., van Wersch, A., Sniehotta, F.F. and Trenell, M.I. (2012) Changing physical activity behavior in type 2 diabetes. A systematic review and meta-analysis of behavioral interventions. Diabetes Care 35(12): 2681–2689.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Bauman, A. and Craig, C. (2005) The place of physical activity in the WHO global strategy on diet and physical activity. International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity 2(1). Retrieved June 30, 2015 from http://www.ijbnpa.org/content/2/1/10.
  5. Bouchard, C. and Shephard, R.J. (1994) Physical activity, fitness, and health: The model and key concepts. In: C. Bouchard, R.J. Shephard and T. Stephens (eds.), Physical Activity, Fitness, and Health. International Proceedings and Consensus Statement. Champaign: Human Kinetics, pp. 77–88.Google Scholar
  6. Crawford, R. (1977) You are dangerous to your health: The ideology and politics of victim blaming. International Journal of Health Services 7(4): 663–680.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Do Lee, C., Folsom, A.R. and Blair, S.N. (2003) Physical activity and stroke risk a meta-analysis. Stroke 34(10): 2475–2481.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Donaldson, A. and Finch, C.F. (2012) Sport as a setting for promoting health. British Journal of Sports Medicine 46(1): 4–5.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Edwards, G. (2012) Jürgen Habermas: Politics and morality in health and medicine. In: G. Scambler (ed.), Contemporary Theorists for Medical Sociology. New York and London: Routledge, pp. 33–48.Google Scholar
  10. Esping-Andersen, G. (1990) The Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism. Cambridge: Polity Press.Google Scholar
  11. Finlayson, J.G. (2005) Habermas: A Very Short Introduction. Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Forester, J. (1980) Critical theory and planning practice. Journal of the American Planning Association 46(3): 275–286.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Forester, J. (1982) Planning in the face of power. Journal of the American Planning Association 48(1): 67–80.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Forester, J. (1993) The Argumentative Turn in Policy Analysis and Planning. Durham and London: Duke University Press.Google Scholar
  15. Forester, J. (1999) The Deliberative Practitioner: Encouraging Participatory Planning Processes. London: Mit Press.Google Scholar
  16. Foucault, M. (1998) The Will to Knowledge. London: Penguin.Google Scholar
  17. German Health Ministry. (2010a) Advisor on health care. [Ratgeber zur gesundheitlichen Prävention]. Retrieved June 30, 2015 from https://www.bundesgesundheitsministerium.de/fileadmin/dateien/Publikationen/Praevention/Broschueren/150724_BMG_Praevention.pdf.
  18. German Health Ministry. (2010b) Being active for myself. [Aktiv sein – für mich]. Retreived June 30, 2015 from http://www.bmg.bund.de/uploads/publications/BMG-V-07008-Aktiv-sein-fuer-mich_201003.pdf.
  19. German Health Ministry. (2010c) Mentally fit in old age. [Geistig fit im Alter]. Retreived June 30, 2015 from https://www.bundesgesundheitsministerium.de/uploads/publications/BMG-V-10002-geistig-fit-im-alter_201007_01.pdf.
  20. German Health Ministry. (2010d) National health objective. [Nationales Gesundheitsziel]. Retreived June 30, 2015 from https://www.bundesgesundheitsministerium.de/uploads/publications/BMG-G-07014-NationalesGesundheitsziel_Internet.pdf.
  21. German Health Ministry & German Ministry of Nutrition, Agriculture and Consumer P. (2008) IN FORM. [IN FORM]. Retreived June 30, 2015 from http://www.bmg.bund.de/fileadmin/redaktion/pdf_pressemeldungen/2008/081202_PM_Nationaler-Aktionsplan-In-Form.pdf.
  22. Gibala, M.J. and McGee, S.L. (2008) Metabolic adaptations to short-term high-intensity interval training: A little pain for a lot of gain? Exercise and Sport Sciences Reviews 36(2): 58–63.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Guiraud, T., Nigam, A., Gremeaux, V., Meyer, P., Juneau, M. and Bosquet, L. (2012) High-intensity interval training in cardiac rehabilitation. Sports Medicine 42(7): 587–605.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Habermas, J. (1970) On systematically distorted communication. Inquiry 13: 205–218.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Habermas, J. (1979a) Communication and the Evolution of Society. Boston: Beacon Press.Google Scholar
  26. Habermas, J. (1979b) What is universal pragmatics. Communication and the Evolution of Society, 1: 2–4.Google Scholar
  27. Habermas, J. (1984) The Theory of Communicative Action. Reason and the Rationalization of Society. Boston: Beacon Press.Google Scholar
  28. Habermas, J. (1985) The Theory of Communicative Action. Lifeworld and System: A Critique of Functionalist Reason. Boston: Beacon press.Google Scholar
  29. Haskell, W.L., Lee, I.-M., Pate, R.R., Powell, K.E., Blair, S.N., Franklin, B.A. et al (2007) Physical activity and public health: Updated recommendation for adults from the ACSM and the American Heart Association. Circulation 116(9): 1081–1093.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Heinemann, K. (2007) Einführung in die Soziologie des Sports. [Introduction to the Sociology of Sport] (5th ed.). Schorndorf: Hofmann.Google Scholar
  31. Howell, J. and Ingham, A. (2001) From social problem to personal issue: The language of lifestyle. Cultural Studies 15(2): 326–351.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Huber, M., Knottnerus, J.A., Green, L., van der Horst, H., Jadad, A.R., Kromhout, D. et al (2011) How should we define health? BMJ 343: 4163.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Hurrelmann, K. (2006) Gesundheitssoziologie: eine Einführung in sozialwissenschaftliche Theorien von Krankheitsprävention und Gesundheitsförderung. [Health Sociology: An Introduction to Social Science Theories of Disease Prevention and Health Promotion] (6th ed.). Weinheim: Juventa-Verlag.Google Scholar
  34. Ibrahim, E.M. and Al-Homaidh, A. (2011) Physical activity and survival after breast cancer diagnosis: Meta-analysis of published studies. Medical Oncology 28(3): 753–765.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Italian Ministry of Employment Health and Social Policies. (2009) Pages of Health. [Pagine della salute]. Retreived June 30, 2015 from http://www.salute.gov.it/imgs/volume.pdf.
  36. Italian Ministry of Health. (2006) National health plan 2006–2008. [Piano sanitario nazionale 2006-2008]. Retreived June 30, 2015 from http://www.salute.gov.it/imgs/C_17_pubblicazioni_655_allegato.pdf.
  37. Italian Ministry of Health. (2007) Make gains in health. [Guadagnare salute]. Retreived June 30, 2015 from http://www.salute.gov.it/imgs/C_17_pubblicazioni_605_allegato.pdf.
  38. Italian Ministry of Health. (2009) Gaining health in 4 moves. [Guadagnare salute in 4 mosse]. Retreived June 30, 2015 from http://www.salute.gov.it/imgs/C_17_opuscoliPoster_68_allegato.pdf.
  39. Italian Ministry of Health. (2011) National health plan 2011–2013. [Piano sanitario nazionale 2011-2013]. Retreived June 30, 2015 from http://www.ipasvi.it/archivio_news/pagine/28/PIANO%20SANITARIO%20NAZIONALE.pdf.
  40. Janssen, I. and LeBlanc, A.G. (2010) Systematic review of the health benefits of physical activity and fitness in school-aged children and youth. International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity 7(40): 1–16.Google Scholar
  41. Kesaniemi, A.Y., Danforth, E., Jr., Jensen, M.D., Kopelman, P.G., Lefèbvre, P. and Reeder, B.A. (2001) Dose-response issues concerning physical activity and health: An evidence-based symposium. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise 33(6 Suppl): 351–358.Google Scholar
  42. Lee, I.-M., Shiroma, E.J., Lobelo, F., Puska, P., Blair, S.N. and Katzmarzyk, P.T. (2012) Effect of physical inactivity on major non-communicable diseases worldwide: An analysis of burden of disease and life expectancy. The Lancet 380(9838): 219–229.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Leibfried, S. (1993) Towards a European Welfare State. In C. Jones (ed.), New Perspectives on the Welfare State in Europe: London. New York: Routledge, pp. 133–156.Google Scholar
  44. Lupton, D. (1995) The Imperative of Health: Public Health and the Regulated Body. London: Sage.Google Scholar
  45. Lupton, D. (1996) Food, the Body and the Self. London: Sage.Google Scholar
  46. Lupton, D. (2012) Medicine as Culture: Illness, Disease and the Body. London: Sage.Google Scholar
  47. Mayring, P. (2002) Einführung in die qualitative Sozialforschung: eine Anleitung zu qualitativem Denken. [Introduction to Qualitative Research: a Guide to Qualitative Thinking] (5th ed.). Weinheim: Beltz.Google Scholar
  48. Mayring, P. (2003) Qualitative Inhaltsanalyse: Grundlagen und Techniken. [Qualitative Content Analysis: Principles and Techniques] (8th ed.). Weinheim: Beltz.Google Scholar
  49. McDermott, L. (2008) A critical interrogation of contemporary discourses of physical (in) activity amongst canadian children: Back to the future. Journal of Canadian Studies/Revue d’études canadiennes 42(2): 5–42.Google Scholar
  50. Michelini, E. (2015a) Disqualification of sport in health-related promotion of physical activity. A global social phenomenon? European Journal for Sport and Society 12(3): 257–280.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. Michelini, E. (2015b) The Role of Sport in Health-Related Promotion of Physical Activity. The Perspective of the Health System. Berlin and Heidelberg: Springer.Google Scholar
  52. Mishler, E.G. (1984) The Discourse of Medicine: Dialectics of Medical Interviews. Norwood: Ablex Publ. Corp.Google Scholar
  53. Nelson, M.E., Rejeski, W.J., Blair, S.N., Duncan, P.W., Judge, J.O., King, A.C. et al (2007) Physical activity and public health in older adults: Recommendation from the ACSM and the American Heart Association. Circulation 116(9): 1094–1105.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  54. Petersen, A. and Bunton, R. (eds.) (2002) Foucault. Health and Medicine: Routledge.Google Scholar
  55. Popper, K.R. (1965) The Logic of Scientific Discovery. London and New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
  56. President’s Council on Physical Fitness and Sports. (1965) Exercise Programs for Adults. Washington DC: US Government.Google Scholar
  57. Rütten, A., Abu-Omar, K., Gelius, P. and Schow, D. (2013) Physical inactivity as a policy problem: Applying a concept from policy analysis to a public health issue. Health Research Policy and Systems 11: 9.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  58. Sallis, J. F., Bauman, A. and Pratt, M. (1998) Environmental and policy interventions to promote physical activity. American Journal of Preventive Medicine 15(4): 379–397.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. Samitz, G., Egger, M. and Zwahlen, M. (2011) Domains of physical activity and all-cause mortality: Systematic review and dose-response meta-analysis of cohort studies. International Journal of Epidemiology 40(5): 1382–1400.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  60. Sattelmair, J., Pertman, J., Ding, E.L., Kohl, H.W., Haskell, W. and Lee, I.-M. (2011) Dose response between physical activity and risk of coronary heart disease a meta-analysis. Circulation 124(7): 789–795.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  61. Scambler, G. (ed.) (2001) Habermas, Critical Theory and Health. London and New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
  62. Scambler, G. (2002) Health and social change: Critical Theory. Buckingham: Open University Press.Google Scholar
  63. Scambler, G. (2015) Jürgen Habermas: Health and healing across the lifeworld-system divide. In: F. Collyer (ed.), The Palgrave Handbook of Social Theory in Health, Illness and Medicine. London: Springer, pp. 355–369.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  64. Schilling, J.M., Giles-Corti, B. and Sallis, J.F. (2009) Connecting active living research and public policy: Transdisciplinary research and policy interventions to increase physical activity. Journal of Public Health Policy 30(1): 1–15.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  65. Schmid, J. (2010) Wohlfahrtsstaaten im Vergleich. Soziale Sicherung in Europa: Organisation, Finanzierung, Leistungen und Probleme. [Welfare States in Comparison] (3rd ed.). Wiesbaden: Springer-Verlag.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  66. Speck, R.M., Courneya, K.S., Mâsse, L.C., Duval, S. and Schmitz, K.H. (2010) An update of controlled physical activity trials in cancer survivors: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Journal of Cancer Survivorship 4(2): 87–100.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  67. Swedish National Food Administration & Swedish National Institute of Public Health. (2005) Background material to the action plan for healthy dietary habits and increased physical activity. Retrieved December 9, 2013 from http://www.slv.se/upload/nfa/documents/food_nutrition/Theactionplanforhealthdietaryhabitsandincreasephysicalactivity.pdf.
  68. Swedish National Institute of Public Health. (2005a) The 2005 public health policy report. Retrieved June 30, 2015 form http://www.verwaltung.steiermark.at/cms/dokumente/11682570_74835740/449f2adf/The%202005%20Public%20Health%20Policy%20Report.pdf.
  69. Swedish National Institute of Public Health. (2005b) Healthy dietary habits and increased physical activity – The basis for an action plan. Retrieved December 9, 2013 form http://www.fhi.se/PageFiles/4175/healthydietaryhabitsphysicalactivitysummary0502.pdf.
  70. Swedish National Institute of Public Health. (2007) Healthy ageing a challenge for Europe – A short version. Retrieved June 30, 2015 form http://www.cardi.ie/userfiles/file/Healthy_ageing_eng_web.pdf.
  71. Swedish National Institute of Public Health. (2010) Public Health of the Future – Everyone’s Responsibility.. Retrieved June 30, 2015 form http://www.folkhalsomyndigheten.se/pagefiles/12694/Public-health-of-the-future-everyones-responsibility.pdf.
  72. Tobias, D.K., Zhang, C., van Dam, R.M., Bowers, K. and Hu, F.B. (2011) Physical activity before and during pregnancy and risk of gestational diabetes mellitus a meta-analysis. Diabetes Care 34(1): 223–229.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  73. Umpierre, D., Ribeiro, P.A., Kramer, C.K., Leitão, C.B., Zucatti, A.T., Azevedo, M.J. et al (2011) Physical activity advice only or structured exercise training and association With HbA1c levels in type 2 Diabetes a systematic review and meta-analysis. JAMA: The Journal of the American Medical Association 305(17): 1790–1799.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  74. U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2011a) The CDC guide to strategies to increase physical activity in the community. Retrieved June 30, 2015 form http://www.cdc.gov/obesity/downloads/PA_2011_WEB.pdf.
  75. U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2011b) School health guidelines to promote healthy eating and physical activity. Retrieved June 30, 2015 form http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/pdf/rr/rr6005.pdf.
  76. U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2012) Steps to wellness: A guide to implementing the 2008 physical activity guidelines for Americans in the workplace. Retrieved June 30, 2015 form http://www.cdc.gov/nccdphp/dnpao/hwi/downloads/Steps2Wellness_BROCH14_508_Tag508.pdf.
  77. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. (2010) National Physical Activity Plan for the U.S. Retrieved June 30, 2015 form http://www.physicalactivityplan.org/NationalPhysicalActivityPlan.pdf.
  78. U.S. National Physical Activity Plan Alliance. (2008) physical activity guidelines for Americans. Retrieved June 30, 2015 form http://fitprogram.ucla.edu/workfiles/Documents/Fit%20for%20residents%20curriculum/Step_5/2008_Physical_Activity_Guidelines_for_Americans.pdf.
  79. Waddington, I., Malcolm, D. and Green, K. (1997) Sport, health and physical education: A reconsideration. European Physical Education Review 3(2): 165–182.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  80. Wagenaar, H. (2011) “A beckon to the makings, workings and doings of human beings”: The critical pragmatism of John Forester. Public Administration Review 71(2): 293–298.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  81. Warburton, D.E.R., Nicol, C.W. and Bredin, S.S.D. (2006) Health benefits of physical activity: The evidence. Canadian Medical Association Journal 174(6): 801–809.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  82. Wheatley, E.E. (2005) Disciplining bodies at risk: Cardiac rehabilitation and the medicalization of fitness. Journal of Sport & Social Issues 29(2): 198–221.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  83. WHO. (1948) Preamble to the Constitution of the World Health Organization; signed on 22 July 1946 by the representatives of 61 States (Official Records of the World Health Organization, no. 2, p. 100) and entered into force on 7 April 1948 from http://apps.who.int/gb/bd/PDF/bd47/EN/constitution-en.pdf.
  84. WHO. (2004) Global strategy on diet, physical activity and health. Retreived from http://www.who.int/dietphysicalactivity/strategy/eb11344/strategy_english_web.pdf.
  85. WHO. (2008) 2008–2013 Action Plan for the Global Strategy for the Prevention and Control of Noncommunicable Diseases. Geneva: WHO.Google Scholar
  86. WHO. (2016a) Health promotion. Retreived January 22, 2015 from http://www.who.int/topics/health_promotion/en/.
  87. WHO. (2016b) Physical inactivity: A global public health problem. Retreived March 1, 2016 from http://www.who.int/dietphysicalactivity/factsheet_inactivity/en/index.html.
  88. Williams, P.T. (2001) Physical fitness and activity as separate heart disease risk factors: A meta-analysis. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise 33(5): 754.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  89. Winslow, C.-E.A. (1920) The untilled fields of public health. Science 51(1306): 23–33.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  90. Wolin, K.Y., Yan, Y., Colditz, G.A. and Lee, I.-M. (2009) Physical activity and colon cancer prevention: A meta-analysis. British Journal of Cancer 100(4): 611–616.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  91. Yuthas, K., Rogers, R. and Dillard, J.F. (2002) Communicative action and corporate annual reports. Journal of Business Ethics 41(1–2): 141–157.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Macmillan Publishers Ltd 2017

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Institut für Sport und SportwissenschaftTechnische Universität DortmundDortmundGermany

Personalised recommendations