Social Theory & Health

, Volume 15, Issue 4, pp 430–447 | Cite as

Promoting health in schools: Theoretical reflections on the settings approach versus nudge tactics

Original Article

Abstract

This paper compares and contrasts two different concepts of health promotion in schools from a theoretical perspective: on the one hand, nudge tactics seeking to change both students’ eating behaviour and their exercise routine and, on the other hand, the settings approach which focuses on the social determinants of health. After assessing both concepts critically, it is argued that nudge has three drawbacks in comparison to setting-based health promotion: Firstly, in primarily focussing on individual choices, nudge exclusively promotes students’ behavioural prevention while disregarding measures of structural prevention. Secondly, choice architects (nudgers) are likely to enforce cultural homogeneity when defining the meaning of school health, i.e. the right food or dose of exercise, while deviating lifestyles are implicitly judged to be irrational and unhealthy. Thirdly, within a nudge-based approach students are predominantly addressed as consumers (nudgees), while less attention is paid to other social identities such as citizens or co-producers. By investigating the examples of smart lunchrooms and an environment encouraging activity, it is demonstrated that nudge is not perceived as a deliberative and context-bound process but instead displays a selective focus on health issues. Due to these significant concerns, it is concluded that – despite its practical shortcomings – setting-based health promotion is superior to nudge – especially in schools.

Keywords

health promotion school settings approach nudge social identities 

References

  1. Antonovsky, A. (1987) Unraveling the Mystery of Health: How People Manage Stress and Stay Well. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.Google Scholar
  2. Antonovsky, A. (1996) The salutogenic model as a theory to guide health promotion. Health Promotion International 11: 11–18.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Bailes, L.P. and Hoy, W.K. (2014) Designing school contexts for success: Paternalism or libertarianism? International Journal of Educational Management 28(5): 484–497.Google Scholar
  4. Barnekow Rasmussen, V. (2005) The European network of health promoting schools—from Iceland to Kyrgyzstan. Promotion and Education XII: 169–172.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Baum, F. and Fisher, M. (2014) Why behavioural health promotion endures despite its failure to reduce health inequities. Sociology of Health & Illness 36(2): 213–225.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Blumenthal-Barby, J.S. and Burroughs, H. (2012) Seeking better health care outcomes: The ethics of using the “Nudge”. The American Journal of Bioethics 12(2): 1–10.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Bogliacino, F., Codagnone, C. and Veltri, G.A. (2016) An introduction to the special issue on “the behavioural turn in public policy: New evidence from experiments”. Economia Politica 33(3): 323–332.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Bovens, L. (2009) The ethics of Nudge. In T. Grüne-Yanoff & S.O. Hansson (eds.), Preference Change: Approaches from Philosophy, Economics and Psychology (pp. 207–220). Dordrecht: Springer.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Brown, P. (2012) A nudge in the right direction? Towards a Sociological Engagement with Libertarian Paternalism. Social Policy and Society 11: 305–317.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Burgess, A. (2012) Nudging’ healthy lifestyles: The UK experiments with the behavioural alternative to regulation and the market. European Journal of Risk Regulation 1: 3–16.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Carter, E.D. (2015) Making the blue zones: Neoliberalism and nudges in public health promotion. Social Science and Medicine 133(2015): 374–382.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Cohen, G.I., Lynch, H.F. and Robertson, C.T. (2016) Nudging health: Health law and behavioral economics. Baltimore: John Hopkins University Press.Google Scholar
  13. Crawshaw, P. (2013) Public health policy and the behavioural turn: The case of social marketing. Critical Social Policy 33(4): 616–637.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. de Leeuw, E. and Clavier, C. (2011) Healthy public in all policies. Health Promotion International. doi: 10.1093/heapro/dar071.Google Scholar
  15. Dewey, J. (1899) The School and Society. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
  16. Dooris, M. (2009) Holistic and sustainable health improvement: the contribution of the settings-based approach to health promotion. Perspectives in Public Health 129(1): 29–36.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Dooris, M. (2013) Expert voices for change: Bridging the silos – towards healthy and sustainable settings for the 21st century. Health & Place 20(2013): 39–50.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Ewert, B. (2016) Patient, co-producer and consumer in one person: Identity facets of the user in integrated health care. Journal of Integrated Care 24(3): 161–172.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Eyal, N. (2014) Nudging by shaming, shaming by nudging. International Journal of Health Policy Management 3(2): 53–56.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Giddens, A. (1991) Modernity and self-identity: Self and society in the late modern age. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.Google Scholar
  21. Gill, N. and Gill, M. (2012) The limits to libertarian paternalism: Two new critiques and seven best-practice imperatives. Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy 30(2012): 924–940.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Gingerich, J. (2016) The political morality of nudges in healthcare. In G.I. Cohen, H.F. Lynch and C.T. Robertson (eds.), Nudging Health: Health Law and Behavioral Economics (pp. 97–109). Baltimore: John Hopkins University Press.Google Scholar
  23. Hanks, A.S., Just, D.R. and Wansink, B. (2013) Smarter lunchrooms can address new school lunchroom guidelines and childhood obesity. The Journal of Pediatrics 162(4): 867–869.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Héritier, A. and Lehmkuhl, D. (2008) The shadow of hierarchy and new modes of governance. Journal of Public Policy 28(1): 1–17.Google Scholar
  25. John, P., Smith, G. and Stroker, G. (2009) Nudge nudge, think think: Two strategies of changing civic behaviour. The Political Quarterly 80(3): 361–370.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  26. Jones, R., Pykett, J. and Whitehead, M. (2013) Changing Behaviours: On the Rise of the Psychological State. Cheltenham: Edwar Elgar.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Kahneman, D. (2011) Thinking, Fast and Slow. London: Penguin Books.Google Scholar
  28. Khan, F. (2011) Combating Obesity Through the Built Environment: Is There a Clear Path to Success? Journal of Law, Medicine and Ethics 39(2011): 387–393.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Kratzke, C. and Cox, C. (2012) Smartphone technology and apps: Rapidly changing health promotion. International Electronic Journal of Health Education 15(2012): 72–82.Google Scholar
  30. Leggett, W. (2014) The politics of behaviour change: Nudge, neoliberalism and the state. Policy & Politics 42(1): 3–19.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Lewallen, T.C., Hunt, H., Potts-Datema, W., Zaza, S. and Giles, W. (2015) The whole school, whole community, whole child model: A new approach for improving educational attainment and healthy development for students. Journal of School Health 85(11): 729–739.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. MacGregor, S. (2016) Citizenship: Radical, feminist and green. In T. Gabrielson, C. Hall, J.M. Meyer and D. Schlosberg (eds.), The Oxford Handbook of Environmental Political Theory (pp. 608–623). Oxford: OUP.Google Scholar
  33. Macnab, A.J., Gagnon, F.A. and Stewart, D. (2014) Health promoting schools: Consensus, strategies, and potential. Health Education 114(3): 170–185.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  34. Mannix-McNamara, P. and Simovska, V. (2015) Schools for health and sustainability: Insights from the past, present and for the future. In P. Mannix-McNamara & V. Simovska (eds.), Schools for Health and Sustainability. Theory, Research and Practice (pp. 3–17). New York: Springer.Google Scholar
  35. Marmot, M. (2005) Social determinants of health inequalities. Lancet 365(9464): 1099–1104.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. McFerran, B. (2016) Social norms, beliefs and health. In C.A. Roberto & I. Kawachi (eds.) Behavioral Economics and Public Health (pp. 133–160). New York: OUP.Google Scholar
  37. Mittelmark, M.B. (2014) Unintended effects in settings-based health promotion. Scandinavian Journal of Public Health 42(15): 17–24.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Mols, F., Haslam, A., Jetten, J. and Steffens, N.K. (2015) Why a nudge is not enough: A social identity critique of governance by stealth. European Journal of Political Research 54(2015): 81–98.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. Owens, J. and Cribb, A. (2013) Beyond choice and individualism: Understanding autonomy for public health ethics. Public Health Ethics 6(3): 262–271.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Pykett, J., Jones, R., Welsh, M. and Whitehead, M. (2013) The art of choosing and the politics of social marketing. Policy Studies 35(2): 97–114.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Pykett, J., Jones, R., Whitehead, M., Huxley, M., Strauss, K., Gill, N., et al (2011) Interventions in the political geography of ‘libertarian paternalism’. Political Geography 30(2011): 301–310.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Quigley, M. (2013) Nudging for health: On public policy and designing choice architecture. Medical Law Review 21(2013); 588–621.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Rebonato, R. (2012) Taking Liberties. A Critical Examination of Libertarian Paternalism. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.Google Scholar
  44. Rebonato, R. (2014) A critical assessment of libertarian paternalism. Journal of Consumer Policy 37: 357–396.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Roberto, C.A. and Kawachi, I. (2016) Behavioral Economics and Public Health. New York: OUP.Google Scholar
  46. Room, G. (2016) Nudge or nuzzle? Improving decisions about active citizenship. Policy Studies 37(2): 113–128.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. Rosas, S.R. (2015) Systems thinking and complexity: Considerations for health promoting schools. Health Promotion International. doi: 10.1093/heapro/dav109.Google Scholar
  48. Selinger, E. and Whyte, K. (2011) Is there a right way to nudge? The practice and ethics of choice architecture. Sociology Compass 5(10): 923–935.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  49. Shaw, H.J. (2014) The Consuming Geographies of Food: Diet, Food Deserts and Obesity. New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
  50. Smart Lunchroom Movement. (2016) Training. Retrieved July 3, 2016 from http://smarterlunchrooms.org/training.
  51. Stulberg, B. (2014) The key to changing individual health behaviors: Change the environments that give rise to them. Harvard Public Health Review 2(2014): 1–6.Google Scholar
  52. Sunstein, C. (2015) Is behavioural science compatible with democracy?, University College Dublin, October 19, 2015. Retrieved July 3, 2016 from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7UAzskCxdNw.
  53. Thaler, R. and Sunstein, C. (2008) Nudge: Improving Decisions About Health, Wealth and Happiness. New York: Penguin Books.Google Scholar
  54. Torp, S., Kokko, S. and Ringsberg, K.C. (2014) Promoting health in everyday settings: Opportunities and challenges. Scandinavian Journal of Public Health 42(15): 3–6.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  55. Vallgårda, S. (2012) Nudge—A new and better way to improve health? Health Policy 104(2012): 200–203.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  56. Van Den Broucke, S. (2014) Needs, norms and nudges: The place of behaviour change in health promotion (Editorial). Health Promotion International 29(4): 597–600.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  57. White, M.D. (2013) The manipulation of choice. Ethics and libertarian paternalism. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.Google Scholar
  58. White, M.D. (2016) Bad medicine: Does the unique nature of healthcare decisions justify nudges? In G.I. Cohen, H.F. Lynch and C.T. Robertson (eds.), Nudging Health: Health Law and Behavioral Economics (pp. 72–82). Baltimore: John Hopkins University Press.Google Scholar
  59. Whitelaw, S., Baxendale, A., Bryce, C., Machardy, L., Young, I. and Witney, E. (2001) ‘Settings’ based health promotion: A review. Health Promotion International 16(4): 339–353.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  60. WHO. (1986) Ottawa Charter for Health Promotion. Retrieved February 15, 2017 from http://www.euro.who.int/__data/assets/pdf_file/0004/129532/Ottawa_Charter.pdf?ua=1.

Copyright information

© Macmillan Publishers Ltd 2017

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Project heiEDUCATION – Cluster Society & HealthHeidelberg School of Education (HSE)HeidelbergGermany

Personalised recommendations