Rhetoric and Reality in Middle Management: The Role of Heads of Academic Departments in UK Universities

  • Jane CreatonEmail author
  • Karen Heard-Lauréote
Original Article


There is a dissonance between the formal role of head of academic department represented in institutional discourses and the reality of heads’ working practices. This paper provides insight, from the perspective of heads, about how the role is experienced and enacted in one institution. Data are derived from 20 semi-structured interviews with heads of department in a teaching-focussed university in the UK. The findings show that there is autonomy in how individual heads structure, manage and lead their departments, and so the role is performed in significantly different ways. Nevertheless, for all heads, the development of a clearer institutional mission, vision and strategy had meant that the scope for strategic initiatives at departmental level was more circumscribed, and there was a significant issue for many heads about how to make the time and space available for this aspect of the role, given the competing operational demands. Derived from these findings, the paper informs practice by making recommendations about how heads of department may operate more effectively. We suggest that a mesopolitical lens, exploring how social practices are shaped by specific disciplinary and departmental contexts and cultures, may provide a productive perspective on the role of middle leaders and managers.


heads of department middle management organisational culture 



  1. Ashworth, R., Ferlie, E., Hammerschmid, G., Moon, M. J., and Reay, T. (2013) ‘Theorizing contemporary public management: international and comparative perspectives’, British Journal of Management 24: S1–S17.Google Scholar
  2. Bessant, C., and Mavin, S. (2016) ‘Neglected on the front line: tensions and challenges for the first-line manager-academic role in UK business schools’, Journal of Management Development 35(7): 916–929.Google Scholar
  3. Branson, C. M., Franken, M., and Penney, D. (2016) ‘Middle leadership in higher education: a relational analysis’, Educational Management Administration and Leadership 44(1): 128–145.Google Scholar
  4. Bryman, A. (2007) ‘Effective leadership in higher education: a literature review’, Studies in Higher Education 32(6): 693–710.Google Scholar
  5. Bryman, A., and Lilley, S. (2009) ‘Leadership researchers on leadership in higher education’, Leadership 5(3): 331–346.Google Scholar
  6. Burns, T. (1961) ‘Micropolitics: Mechanisms of institutional change’, Administrative Science Quarterly 6(3): 257–281.Google Scholar
  7. Clark, B. (2001) ‘The entrepreneurial university: New foundations for collegiality, autonomy, and achievement’, Higher Education Management 13(2): 9–24.Google Scholar
  8. Clegg, S., and McAuley, J. (2005) ‘Conceptualising middle management in higher education: A multifaceted discourse’, Journal of Higher Education Policy and Management 27(1): 19–34.Google Scholar
  9. Davis, A., Jansen van Rensburg, M., and Venter, P. (2016) ‘The impact of managerialism on the strategy work of university middle managers’, Studies in Higher Education 41(8): 1480–1494.Google Scholar
  10. Deem, R. (1998) ‘‘‘New managerialism” and higher education: The management of performances and cultures in universities in the United Kingdom’, International Studies in Sociology of Education 8(1): 47–70.Google Scholar
  11. Deem, R. (2000) ‘New Managerialism’ and the management of UK universities. End of Award Report of the Findings of an ESRC Funded Project, Lancaster: Lancaster University.Google Scholar
  12. Deem, R. (2006) ‘Changing research perspectives on the management of higher education: can research permeate the activities of manager-academics?’, Higher Education Quarterly 60(3): 203–228.Google Scholar
  13. Deem, R. (2009) ‘Leading and managing contemporary UK Universities: do excellence and meritocracy still prevail over diversity?’, Higher Education Policy 22(1): 3–17.Google Scholar
  14. Deem, R. (2010) ‘Herding the academic cats; The challenges of ‘managing’ academic research in the contemporary UK university’, Perspectives: Policy and Practice in Higher Education 14(2): 37–43.Google Scholar
  15. Deem, R., Hillyard, S., and Reed, M. (2007) Knowledge, Higher Education, and the New Managerialism: The Changing Management of UK Universities, Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  16. Eley, A. (2013) ‘Management training for the university head of department’, International Journal of Educational Management 8(2): 20–22.Google Scholar
  17. Floyd, A. (2009) Life Histories of Academics Who Become Heads of Department: Socialisation, Identity and Career Trajectory, Leicester: University of Leicester.Google Scholar
  18. Floyd, A. (2012) ‘‘‘Turning Points” The Personal and Professional Circumstances That Lead Academics to Become Middle Managers’, Educational Management Administration and Leadership 40(2): 272–284.Google Scholar
  19. Floyd, A. (2016) ‘Supporting academic middle managers in higher education: do we care?’, Higher Education Policy 29(2): 167–183.Google Scholar
  20. Floyd, A., and Dimmock, C. (2011) ‘ ‘‘Jugglers”, “copers” and “strugglers”: academics’ perceptions of being a head of department in a post-1992 UK university and how it influences their future careers’, Journal of Higher Education Policy and Management 33(4): 387–399.Google Scholar
  21. Graham, A. (2016) ‘Role of academic managers in workload and performance management of academic staff’, Educational Management Administration and Leadership 44(6): 1042–1063.Google Scholar
  22. Henkel, M. (2000) Academic Identities and Policy Change in Higher Education, London: Jessica Kingsley.Google Scholar
  23. Henkel, M. (2002) ‘Academic Identity in Transformation?’, Higher Education Management and Policy 14(1): 137–147.Google Scholar
  24. Henkel, M. (2005) ‘Academic identity and autonomy in a changing policy environment’, Higher Education 49(1): 155–176.Google Scholar
  25. Henkel, M., and Vabø, A. (2006) ‘Academic identities’, in M. Kogan, M. Henkel, M Bauer and I. Bleiklie (eds). Transforming Higher Education, Heidelberg: Springer, pp. 127–159.Google Scholar
  26. Jackson, M. P. (1999) ‘The role of the head of department in managing performance in UK universities’, International Journal of Educational Management 13(1): 142–155.Google Scholar
  27. Jarratt, A. (1985) Report of the Steering Committee for Efficiency Studies in Universities, London: Committee for Vice Chancellors and Principals.Google Scholar
  28. Jones, D. (2011) ‘Academic leadership and departmental headship in turbulent times’, Tertiary Education and Management 17(4): 279–288.Google Scholar
  29. Knight, P., and Trowler, P. (2001) Departmental Leadership In Higher Education, Milton Keynes: Open University Press.Google Scholar
  30. Lee, J. (2007) ‘The shaping of the departmental culture: Measuring the relative influences of the institution and discipline’, Journal of Higher Education Policy and Management 29(1): 41–55.Google Scholar
  31. Locke, W. (2013) ‘The intensification of rankings logic in an increasingly marketised higher education environment’, European Journal of Education 49(1): 77–90.Google Scholar
  32. Locke, W., Whitchurch, C., Smith, H., and Mazenod, A. (2016) Shifting landscapes: Meeting the staff development needs of the changing academic workforce, York: Higher Education Academy.Google Scholar
  33. Lumby, J. (2015) In the wings and backstage: exploring the micropolitics of leadership in higher education. Research report, London: Leadership Foundation for Higher Education.Google Scholar
  34. Middlehurst, R. (1993) Leading academics, Buckingham: SRHE and Open University Press.Google Scholar
  35. Naidoo, R. (2005) ‘University in the marketplace: the distortion of teaching and research’, in R. Barnett (ed), Reshaping the university: new relationships between research, scholarship and teaching, Maidenhead: Open University Press, pp. 27–36.Google Scholar
  36. Naidoo, R., and Williams, J. (2015) ‘The neoliberal regime in English higher education: charters, consumers and the erosion of the public good’, Critical Studies in Education 56(2): 208–223.Google Scholar
  37. Nguyen, T. L. H. (2012) ‘Middle-level Academic Management: A case study on the roles of the Heads of Department at a Vietnamese University’, Tertiary Education and Management 19(1): 1–15.Google Scholar
  38. Nixon, E., Scullion, R., and Hearn, R. (2017) ‘Her majesty the student: marketised higher education and the narcissistic (dis)satisfactions of the student-consumer’, Studies in Higher Education 43(6): 927–943.Google Scholar
  39. Sarros, J. C., Gmelch, W. H., and Tanewski, G. A. (2006) ‘The role of Department Head in Australian Universities: tasks and stresses’, Higher Education Research and Development 16(3): 283–292.Google Scholar
  40. Smith, B. (2007) ‘On being a university head of department’, Management in Education 21(1): 4–7.Google Scholar
  41. Smith, R. (2002) ‘The role of the University Head of Department: a survey of two British Universities’, Educational Management Administration and Leadership 30(3): 293–312.Google Scholar
  42. Smith, R. (2005) ‘Departmental Leadership and Management in Chartered and Statutory Universities: a case of diversity’, Educational Management Administration and Leadership 33(4): 449–464.Google Scholar
  43. Spiller, M. (2012) Learning to manage or managing to learn: an exploratory study of how university managers learn within their roles, Stoke on Trent: Staffordshire University.Google Scholar
  44. Stanley, C., and Algert, N. (2007) ‘An exploratory study of the conflict management styles of department heads in a research university setting’, Innovative Higher Education 32(1): 49–65.Google Scholar
  45. Stratford, E. (2012) ‘A genuine career or impossible heroism? Experiencing the role of the Head of School: an Australian case study’, Journal of Higher Education Policy and Management 34(3): 225–238.Google Scholar
  46. Tight, M. (2012) Researching Higher Education (2nd ed.), Maidenhead: McGraw-Hill Education.Google Scholar
  47. Trowler, P., Fanghanel, J., and Wareham, T. (2005) ‘Freeing the chi of change: the Higher Education Academy and enhancing teaching and learning in higher education’, Studies in Higher Education 30(4): 427–444.Google Scholar
  48. Waring, M. (2017) ‘Management and leadership in UK universities: exploring the possibilities of change’, Journal of Higher Education Policy and Management 39(5): 540–558.Google Scholar
  49. Whitchurch, C., and Locke, W. (2016) The implications of a changing academic workforce for the university as a critical institution. Paper presented at the Consortium of Higher Education Researchers 29th Annual Conference; 5–7 September,Cambridge, UK.Google Scholar
  50. Willner, R. (2011) ‘Micro-politics: an underestimated field of qualitative research in political science’, German Policy Studies 7(3): 155.Google Scholar
  51. Winter, R. (2009) ‘Academic manager or managed academic? Academic identity schisms in higher education’, Journal of Higher Education Policy and Management 31(2): 121–131.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© International Association of Universities 2019

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Faculty of Humanities and Social SciencesUniversity of PortsmouthPortsmouthUK

Personalised recommendations