Advertisement

Contemporary Political Theory

, Volume 17, Issue 3, pp 306–330 | Cite as

State power and breastfeeding promotion: A critique

  • Peter Balint
  • Lina Eriksson
  • Tiziana Torresi
Article
  • 123 Downloads

Abstract

State-sponsored breastfeeding promotion campaigns have become increasingly common in developed countries. In this article, by using the tools of liberal political theory, as well as public health and health promotion ethics, we argue that such campaigns are not justified. They ignore important costs for women, including undermining autonomy, fail to distribute burdens fairly, cannot be justified neutrally and fail a basic efficacy test. Moreover, our argument demonstrates that breastfeeding campaigns are a rare case that bridges the fields of public health ethics (which focuses on coercive measures to protect third parties) and the ethics of health promotion campaigns (which focuses on encouraging voluntary change that benefits the target individuals themselves). This demonstrates the need to consider the ethics of state promotion of both voluntary and coercive behavioural change that benefits third parties.

Keywords

breastfeeding liberalism autonomy gender equality public health ethics ethics of health promotion 

References

  1. Ahluwalia, I.B., Morrow, B., Hsia, J. and Grummer-Strawn, L.M. (2003) Who is breastfeeding? Recent trends from the pregnancy risk assessment and monitoring system. Journal of Pediatrics 142(5): 486–493.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Arneil, B. (2000) The politics of the breast. Canadian Journal of Women & Law, 12, 345.Google Scholar
  3. Australian Breastfeeding Association. (2005) Why breastfeeding is important. http://www.breastfeeding.asn.au/bfinfo/general.html.
  4. Australian Breastfeeding Association. (2006) Not enough milk? http://www.breastfeeding.asn.au/bfinfo/lowsupply.html.
  5. Australian Bureau of Statistics. (2001) Breastfeeding in Australia. cat no 001. Canberra.Google Scholar
  6. Australian Government. (2008) Australian Government response to the House of Representatives Standing Committee on Health and Aging Report on the Inquiry into the health benefits of breastfeeding ‘The Best Start’. Canberra.Google Scholar
  7. Australian Institute of Health and Welfare. (2012) Experience of perinatal depression: data from the 2010 Australian National Infant Feeding Survey. Information Paper. Cat. no. PHE 161. Canberra: AIHW.Google Scholar
  8. Balint, P. (2017) Respecting Toleration: traditional liberalism and contemporary diversity. Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Ball, T. and Wright, A. (1999) Health care costs of formula-feeding in the first year of life. Pediatrics 103(Supp 1): 870–876.Google Scholar
  10. Beauchamp, T.L. (1988) Manipulative advertising. In T.L. Beauchamp & N.E. Bowie (eds.) Ethical Theory and Business (3rd ed.) Englewood Cliffs: N J Prentice Hall.Google Scholar
  11. Benet, S., Pitts, R.E. and LaTour, M. (1993) The appropriateness of fear appeal use for health care marketing to the elderly: Is it ok to scare granny? Journal of Business Ethics 12(1): 45–55.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Berk, S.F. (2012) The Gender Factory: The Apportionment of Work in American Households. New York: Springer.Google Scholar
  13. Bianchi, S., Sayer, L., Milkie, M. and Robinson, J. (2012) Housework: Who did, does or will do it, and how much does it matter? Social Forces 91(1): 55–63.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Bruk-Lee, V., Albert, D. and Stone, K.L. (2016) Lactation and the working woman: understanding the role of organizational factors, lactation support, and legal policy in promoting breastfeeding success. In: Research Perspectives on Work and the Transition to Motherhood. New York: Springer International Publishing, pp. 217–239.Google Scholar
  15. Butte, N.F. (2001) The Role of breastfeeding in obesity. Paediatric Clinics of North America 48: 189–198.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Callahan, D. (Ed.) (2000) Promoting Healthy Behaviour: How Much Freedom? Whose Responsibility?. Washington: Georgetown University Press.Google Scholar
  17. Christman, J. (2015) Autonomy in moral and political philosophy. In: The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Spring 2015 Edition), Edward N. Zalta (ed.). http://pofetnlato.stanford.edu/archives/spr2015/entries/autonomy-moral/.
  18. Conroy, S. (2003) Research Report: Health Promotion Messages: To Scare or Not To Scare? National University of Ireland: Department of Health Promotion.Google Scholar
  19. Coons, C. and Weber, M. (2014) Manipulation: Theory and practice. Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Crossley, M. (2009) Breastfeeding as a moral imperative: An autoethnographic study. Feminism & Psychology 19(1): 71–87.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Department of Health. (2000) The NHS Plan. London: The Stationery Office.Google Scholar
  22. Department of Health. (2004) Choosing Health: Making Healthier Choices Easier. London: The Stationery Office.Google Scholar
  23. Duffy, L., Faden, H., Wasielewski, R., Wolf, J. and Krystofik, D. (1997) Exclusive breastfeeding protects against bacterial colonization and day care exposure to otitis media. Pediatrics 100(4): e7.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Duke, C.R., Pickett, G.M., Carlson, L. and Grove, S.J. (1993) A method for evaluating the ethics of fear appeals. Journal of Public Policy and Marketing 12(1): 120–129.Google Scholar
  25. Dworkin, G. (1972) Paternalism. The Monist 56(1): 64–84.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  26. Dworkin, G. (1988) The Theory and Practice of Autonomy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Dworkin, R. (1989) Liberal community. California Law Review 77(3): 479–504.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Dyson, L., McCormick, F. and Renfrew, M. (2005) Interventions for promoting the initiation of breastfeeding. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD001688.pub2.Google Scholar
  29. Dyson, L., Renfrew, M., McFadden, A., McCormick, F., Herbert, G. and Thomas, J. (2006) Promotion of breastfeeding initiation and duration: Evidence into practice briefing. London: National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence, available at http://www.nice.org.uk/niceMedia/pdf/EAB_Breastfeeding_final_version.pdf.
  30. Edelman, C.L. and Mandle, C.L. (2006) Health Promotion Throughout the Lifespan. St Louis, MO: Elsevier Mosby.Google Scholar
  31. Forste, R., Weiss, J. and Lippincott, E. (2001) The decision to breastfeed in the United States: Does race matter? Pediatrics 108(2): 291–296.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Friedman, M. (1997) Autonomy and social relationships: Rethinking the feminist critique. In D. Meyers (Ed.): Feminists Rethinking the Self. Boulder: Westview Press, pp. 40–61.Google Scholar
  33. Gatrell, C. (2007) Secrets and lies: Breastfeeding and professional paid work. Social Science and Medicine 65(2): 393–404.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  34. Gillman, M.W. (2002) Breastfeeding and obesity. Journal of Pediatrics 141(6): 749–750.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Gonzalez, E. (2008) The Role of Information in Contemporary Migration. Working Paper WP08-005. Barcelona UOC.Google Scholar
  36. Gostin, L. (2006) Public health strategies for pandemic influenza: Ethics and the law. JAMA 295: 1700–1704.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Guttman, N. and Zimmerman, D. (2000) Low-income mothers’ views on breastfeeding. Social Science and Medicine 50(10): 1457–1473.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Hauck, F., Thompson, J., Tanabe, K., Moon, R. and Venneman, M. (2011) Breastfeeding and reduced risk of sudden infant death syndrome: a metaanalysis. Pediatrics 128(1): 103–110.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. Hausman, B. (2003) Mother’s Milk: Breastfeeding Controversies in American Culture. New York & London: Routledge.Google Scholar
  40. Heinig, J. (2007) The Burden of proof: A commentary on ‘Is breast really best? Risk and total motherhood in the National breastfeeding awareness campaign. Journal of Human Lactation 32(4): 374–376.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Hopkinson, J. (2007) Response to ‘Is breast really best? Risk and total motherhood in the National breastfeeding awareness campaign. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law, 32(4): 637–648.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Ip, S., Chung, M., Raman, G., Chew, P., Magula, N. and DeVine, D., et al. (2007) Breastfeeding and maternal and infant health outcomes in developed countries. In: Evidence Report/Technology Assessment, 153. Rockville, MD: Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality.Google Scholar
  43. Jaggar, Alison M. (1983) Feminist Politics and Human Nature. Totowa, NJ: Rowman & Allanheld.Google Scholar
  44. Johnston-Robledo, I., Wares, S., Fricker, J. and Pasek, L. (2007) Indecent exposure: Self-objectification and young women’s attitudes toward breastfeeding. Sex Roles 56(7–8): 429–437.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Kass, N.E. (2001) An ethics framework for public health. American Journal of Public Health 91: 1776–1782.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Kelleher, C.M. (2006) The physical challenges of early breastfeeding. Social Science and Medicine 63(10): 2727–2738.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. Kramer, M.S., Aboud, F., Mironova, E., Vanilovich, I., Platt, R.W., et al. (2008) Breastfeeding and child cognitive development: New evidence from a large randomized trial. Archives of General Psychiatry 65(5): 578–584.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  48. Kramer, M.S., Chalmers, B., Hodnett, E.D., Sevkovskaya, Z., Dzikovich, I., et al. (2001) Promotion of breastfeeding intervention trial (PROBIT)’. Journal of the American Medical Association 285(4): 413–420.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  49. Kramer, M.S., Matush, L., Vanilovich, I., Platt, R.W., Bogdanovich, N., et al. (2007) Effects of prolonged and exclusive breastfeeding on child height, weight, adiposity, and blood pressure at age 6.5 Y: Evidence from a large randomized trial. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 86(6): 1717–1721.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. Kramer, M.S., Matush, L., Vanilovich, I., Platt, R.W., Bogdanovich, N., et al. (2009) A randomized breastfeeding promotion intervention did not reduce child obesity in Belarus. Journal of Nutrition 139(2): 417–421.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. Law, J. (2000) The politics of breastfeeding: Assessing risk, dividing labor. Signs 25(2): 417–420.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  52. Lawrence, R. and Pane, C. (2007) Human breast milk: Current concepts of immunology and infectious diseases. Current Problems in Pediatric and Adolescent Health Care 37(1): 7–36.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. Lee, E. (2007) Health, morality, and infant feeding: British mothers’ experiences of formula milk use in the early weeks. Sociology of Health & Illness 29(7): 1075–1090.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  54. Lee, E. (2008) Living with risk in the age of ‘intensive motherhood’: Maternal identity and infant feeding. Health, Risk & Society 10(5): 467–477.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  55. Lee, E. (2011) Infant feeding and problems of policy. In P. Liamputtong (Ed.): Infant Feeding Practices: A Cross-Cultural Perspective. New York: Springer.Google Scholar
  56. Lee, E. and Furedi, F. (2005) Mothers’ experience, and attitudes to, using infant formula in the early months. University of Kent: School of Social Policy, Sociology and Social Research, available at http://www.kent.ac.uk/sspssr/staff/academic/lee/infant-formula-full.pdf.
  57. Lowe, P. (2016) Responsible ‘choices’ and good motherhood. In: Reproductive Health and Maternal Sacrifice. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 17–45.Google Scholar
  58. MacAlister, A., Puska, P., Salonen, J., Tuomilehto, J. and Koskela, K. (1982) Theory and action for health promotion: Illustrations from the North Karelia Project. American Journal of Public Health 72(1): 43–50.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. Mahoney, R. (1995) Kidding Ourselves: Breadwinning, Babies, and Bargaining Power. New York: Basic Books.Google Scholar
  60. Maushart, S. (1997) The Mask of Motherhood. Sydney: Vintage.Google Scholar
  61. Meek, J.Y. (2001) Breastfeeding in the workplace. Pediatric Clinics of North America 48(2): 461–474.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  62. Naidoo, J. and Wills, J. (2000) Health Promotion: Foundations for Practice. Elsevier: Bailliére Tindall.Google Scholar
  63. National Center For Chronic Disease Prevention and Health Promotion. (2014), Breastfeeding Report Card: United States 2014, available at https://www.cdc.gov/breastfeeding/pdf/2014breastfeedingreportcard.pdf.
  64. National Institute for Children’s Health Quality. (2015) Best Fed Beginnings Final Report. Boston: NICHQ.Google Scholar
  65. Okin, S.M. (1989) Justice, Gender, and the Family. New York: Basic Books.Google Scholar
  66. Ottonelli, V. and Torresi, T. (2013) When is migration voluntary? International Migration Review 47(4): 783–813.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  67. Price, J. (1988) Motherhood: What It Does to Your Mind. London: Pandora Press.Google Scholar
  68. Rawls, J. (2005) Political Liberalism (Expanded ed.). New York: Columbia University Press.Google Scholar
  69. Raz, J. (1986) The Morality of Freedom. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  70. Rosin, H. (2009) The case against breastfeeding. The Atlantic Online. Available at http://www.theatlantic.com/doc/200904/case-against-breastfeeding,
  71. Schroeder, D. and Gefenas, E. (2009) Vulnerability: Too vague and too broad? Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics I 18(2): 113–121.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  72. Selgelid, M. (2009a) Promoting justice, trust, compliance and health: the case for compensation. The American Journal of Bioethics 9(11): 22–24.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  73. Selgelid, M. (2009b) A moderate pluralist approach to public health policy and ethics. Public Health Ethics 6(1): 11–20.Google Scholar
  74. Sheeshka, J., Potter, B., Norrie, E., Valaitis, R., Adams, G. and Kuczynski, L. (2001) Women’s experiences breastfeeding in public places. Journal of Human Lactation 17(1): 31–38.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  75. Smale, M. (2001) The stigmatisation of breastfeeding. Ch. 22 In: T. Mason et al. (eds.) Stigma and Social Exclusion in Healthcare. London: Routledge, pp. 234–245.Google Scholar
  76. Spence, H. E. and Moinpour, R. (1972) Fear appeals in marketing – A social perspective. Journal of Marketing 36: 39–43.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  77. Stearns, Cindy A. (1999) Breastfeeding and the good maternal body. Gender & Society 13(3): 308–325.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  78. Strauss, R. (2003) Breast milk and childhood obesity: The Czechs weigh in. Journal of Pediatric Gastroenterology and Nutrition 37(2): 210–211.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  79. Taylor, E.N. and Wallace, L.E. (2017) Risky business: Breastfeeding promotion policy and the problems of risk language. Journal of Women Politics & Policy. doi: 10.1080/1554477X.2016.1268877.Google Scholar
  80. Thomson, J.J. (1971) A defense of abortion. Philosophy & Public Affairs 1(1): 47–66.Google Scholar
  81. UNICEF. (ND) ‘The baby-friendly hospital initiative’: http://www.unicef.org/programme/breastfeeding/baby.htm.
  82. Upshur, R. (2002) Principles for the justification of public health intervention. Canadian Journal of Public Health 93: 101–103.Google Scholar
  83. Van Houtven, C.H., Coe, N.B. and Skira, M.M. (2013) The effect of informal care on work and wages. Journal of Health Economics 32(1): 240–252.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  84. Victora, C.G., Bahl, R., Barros, A.J.D., Franca, G.V.A., Horston, S., Kraseyer, J., et al. (2016) Breastfeeding 1: Breastfeeding in the 21st century: epidemiology, mechanisms, and life-long effects. The Lancet 387: 475–490.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  85. Victora, C.G., Habicht, J.P. and Bryce, J. (2004) Evidence-based public health: Moving beyond randomized trials. American Journal of Public Health 94(3): 400–405.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  86. Wall, S. (2010) Neutralism for perfectionists: The case of restricted state neutrality. Ethics 120(2): 232–256.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  87. Ward, L.M., Merriwether, A. and Caruthers, A. (2006) Breasts are for men: Media, masculinity ideologies, and men’s beliefs about women’s bodies. Sex Roles 55(9–10): 703–714.Google Scholar
  88. Weaver, I.C., Cervoni, G.N., Champagne, F.A., D’Alessio, A.C. and Sharma, S., et al. (2004) Epigenetic programming by maternal behavior. Nature Neuroscience 7(8): 847–854.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  89. WHO. (2000) The World health Report 2000Health Systems: Improving Performance. available at http://www.who.int/whr/2000/en/.
  90. Williams, G. (1984) Health promotion — Caring concern or slick salesmanship? Journal of Medical Ethics 10: 191–195.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  91. Wilson, P. (2006) Breastfeeding diet. Ninemsn 24 August 2006, available athttp://health.ninemsn.com.au/pregnancy/parenthood/694357/breastfeeding-diet.
  92. Witte, K. and Allen, M. (2000) A meta-analysis of fear appeals – Implications for effective public health campaigns. Health Education and Behaviour 27(5): 591–615.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  93. Wolf, J. (2007) Is breast really best? Risk and total motherhood in the National breastfeeding awareness campaign. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law 32(4): 595–636.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  94. Wolf, J. (2011) Is Breast Best? Taking on the Breastfeeding Experts and the New High Stakes of Motherhood. New York: New York University Press.Google Scholar
  95. Wolfe, C. (1994) Liberalism and paternalism: A critique of Ronald Dworkin. Review of Politics 56(4): 615–639.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  96. Zilanawala, A. (2016) Women’s time poverty and family structure differences by parenthood and employment. Journal of Family Issues 37(3): 369–392.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Macmillan Publishers Ltd 2017

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.UNSW CanberraCanberraAustralia
  2. 2.Gothenburg University, Gothenburg, Sweden and Flinders UniversityAdelaideAustralia
  3. 3.University of AdelaideAdelaideAustralia

Personalised recommendations