The Ipswich (Queensland) safe city program: an evaluation
This paper reviews three decades of data associated with a large-scale open street CCTV program introduced in the City of Ipswich, in the state of Queensland, Australia, in 1994. In 2018, there were over 300 cameras in operation with live monitoring and relays to police and security officers on the beat. Over the years a number of dramatic claims have been made about the impact of the program, including an overall reduction in crime of 80% and high rates of crimes being solved. However, the Ipswich City Council, which operates the program, was unable to provide data to support these claims. In response, the researchers accessed all available police data for the area and comparable areas. No evidence could be found for any specific benefits from the program. The findings that add to those from the literature are that CCTV programs often lack a scientifically grounded implementation and evaluation process, and are vulnerable to misuse for political purposes. The paper concludes by reiterating best-practice standards in crime prevention programs, including accountability and transparency, and the use of standard evaluation protocols.
KeywordsCCTV Crime prevention Local government Police Partnerships
Compliance with ethical standards
Research Ethics Approval Reference Number: CCJ/18/09/HREC.
- Adams, J. 2015. http://www.securityelectronicsandnetworks.com/articles/2015/04/24/ipswich-city-council-upgrades-safecity-cctv-system. Accessed 17 June 2017.
- Alexandrie, G. 2017. Surveillance cameras and crime: A Review of randomized and natural experiments. Journal of Scandinavian Studies of Criminology and Crime Prevention 18 (2): 210–222.Google Scholar
- ANAO. 2015. The award of funding under the safer streets program. Canberra: Australian National Audit Office.Google Scholar
- Ashby, M. 2017. The Value of CCTV surveillance cameras as an investigative tool: An empirical analysis. European Journal on Criminal Policy and Research 23 (3): 441–459.Google Scholar
- Aston, H. 2014. Anti-crime funding given to Coalition seats. Sydney Morning Herald, p. 9.Google Scholar
- Aston, H. 2015. Grants for CCTV networks not fully documented. Sydney Morning Herald, p. 7.Google Scholar
- Bates, L., D. Belsham, and T. Miles-Johnson. 2017. Crime prevention: Setting standards. In Understanding crime prevention: The case study approach, ed. T. Prenzler, 1–12. Brisbane: Australian Academic Press.Google Scholar
- Brown, B. 1995. CCTV in town centres: Three case studies. London: Home Office.Google Scholar
- Carr, R. 2016. Surveillance politics and local government: A National Survey of federal funding for CCTV in Australia. Security Journal 29 (4): 683–709.Google Scholar
- Cerezo, A. 2013. CCTV and crime displacement: A Quasi-experimental evaluation. European Journal of Criminology 10 (2): 222–236.Google Scholar
- City of Ipswich. 2010. http://www.ipswich.qld.gov.au/community/safety/safe_city_program/index.php. Accessed 23 Dec 2010.
- Community Profile. 2018. https://profile.id.com.au/ipswich. Accessed 27 Feb 2018.
- Cornish, D., and R. Clarke. 2003. Opportunities, precipitators and criminal decisions: A reply to Wortley’s critique of situational crime prevention. Crime Prevention Studies 16: 41–96.Google Scholar
- Cowan, R. 2010. Security makeover saves city. Security insider 14 (6): 20–23.Google Scholar
- Department of Employment. 2014. https://docs.jobs.gov.au/system/files/doc/other/survey_of_employers_recruitment_experiences_in_ipswich-logan_report.pdf. Accessed 28 Feb 2018.
- Evison, M.P. 2015. The third forensics—Images and allusions. Policing and Society: An International Journal of Research and Policy 25 (5): 521–539.Google Scholar
- Farrington, D., M. Gill, S. Waples, and J. Argomaniz. 2007. The Effects of closed circuit television on crime: Meta-analysis of an English national quasi-experimental multi-site evaluation. Journal of Experimental Criminology 3 (1): 21–38.Google Scholar
- Foley, P. 2014. Making Ipswich a safer city. The Queensland Times, p. 6Google Scholar
- Gerell, M. 2016. Hot spot policing with actively monitored CCTV cameras. International Criminal Justice Review 26 (2): 187–201.Google Scholar
- Grant, D. (2012, 3 March) Big Brother in the burbs. The Gold Coast Bulletin, p. 38.Google Scholar
- Health, Security and Community Safety Committee (Ipswich). 2018. https://www.ipswich.qld.gov.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0004/90742/HSCS-Agenda-23-01-2018.pdf. Accessed 21 Feb 2018.
- Holt, S. 2017. New location for Safe City security headquarters. https://www.ipswichfirst.com.au/new-location-safe-city-security-headquarters/. Accessed 2 Mar 2018.
- Hulme, S., A. Morgan, and R. Brown. 2015. CCTV use by local government: Findings from a National Survey. Canberra: Australian Institute of Criminology.Google Scholar
- Ipswich City Council. 2013. https://www.ipswich.qld.gov.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0015/10185/safe_city_program_fact_sheet.pdf. Accessed 23 June 2017.
- Ipswich City Council. 2014. Community crime prevention and safety plan. Ipswich (Queensland): Ipswich City Council.Google Scholar
- Koch, T. 1999. Assault rate in Ipswich falls sharply. The Courier Mail, no page.Google Scholar
- La Vigne, N., S. Lowry, J. Markman, and A. Dwyer. 2011. Evaluating the use of public surveillance cameras for crime prevention. Washington DC: Urban Institute.Google Scholar
- Lim, C., C. Kim, J. Eck, and J. Kim. 2016. The Crime-reduction effects of open-street CCTV in South Korea. Security Journal 29 (2): 241–255.Google Scholar
- Lim, H., and P. Wilcox. 2017. Crime-reduction effects of open-street CCTV: Conditionality considerations. Justice Quarterly 34 (4): 597–626.Google Scholar
- Maeseele, M. 2009. Safety fears linger as cameras catch crimes. The Queensland Times, p. 3Google Scholar
- Meredith, H. 1995. Shops in high-tech fight against crime. The Australian Financial Review, p. 12Google Scholar
- Owen, C. 2014. Stepping up mall security. The Queensland Times, p. 2Google Scholar
- Piza, E. 2018. The Crime prevention effect of CCTV in public places: A Propensity score analysis. Journal of Crime and Justice 41 (1): 14–30.Google Scholar
- Piza, E., J. Caplan, and L. Kennedy. 2017. CCTV as a tool for early police intervention: Preliminary lessons from nine case studies. Security Journal 30 (1): 247–265.Google Scholar
- Queensland Police Service. 1991–2000. Annual Reports. Brisbane: Author.Google Scholar
- Queensland Police Service. 2017. Annual statistical review 2016-17. Brisbane: Author.Google Scholar
- Sarre, R., T. Prenzler, and B. de Caires. 2011. Private security and public interest: Exploring private security trends and directions for reform in the new era of plural policing. Sydney: The Australian Security Industry Association Limited.Google Scholar
- Sommerfeld, J. 1998. Ipswich leaders hail success of crime-fighting programme. The Courier Mail, no page.Google Scholar
- Spelitis, H. 2018a. Safe City network growing. The Queensland Times, p. 4Google Scholar
- Spelitis, H. 2018b. Safe City hasn’t made you safer. The Queensland Times pp. 1, 6.Google Scholar
- Taylor, E. 2010. Evaluating CCTV: Why the findings are inconsistent, inconclusive and ultimately irrelevant. Crime Prevention and Community Safety 12 (4): 209–232.Google Scholar
- Taylor, E. 2012. https://www.smh.com.au/politics/federal/the-real-cost-of-cctv-might-stop-you-smiling-20121009-27b4m.html. Accessed 2 Mar 2018.
- Watt, A. 2004. Ipswich has designs to fight crime. The Courier Mail, p. 8Google Scholar
- Welsh, B., and D. Farrington. 2009. Public area CCTV and crime prevention: An Updated systematic review and meta-analysis. Justice Quarterly 26 (4): 716–745.Google Scholar
- Wuth, R., and M. Maeselle. 2012. Pisasale candid about Coast’s camera cops. The Gold Coast Bulletin, p. 6.Google Scholar