Skip to main content

Advertisement

SpringerLink
Log in

Why Russian anti-corruption policies fail? Examination of corruption in the civil service and the business community

  • Article
  • Published:
Jindal Global Law Review Aims and scope Submit manuscript

Abstract

Corruption is an entrenched phenomenon in Russian society. This article examines factors contributing to corruption in Russian civil service, such as low salaries, non-competitive hiring and promotion process, widespread nepotism and the culture of corruption. It also looks at corruption when it comes to Russian business enterprises and how it has been impacted by the history of questionable privatization deals in the 1990’s as well as the current relationship between business entities and state officials. The article concludes that while combatting corruption is not an easy task, it is not an entirely hopeless undertaking. Reform is still possible despite of multiple problems that currently exist and prevent the effective carrying out of the anti-corruption agenda in Russia. These reforms will depend upon a true partnership being developed between government and various civil society organizations, development of solid opposition parties that can hold government responsible for following through on its anti-corruption agenda and encouraging mechanisms for developing a general intolerance of corrupt practices.

This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.

Access this article

Log in via an institution

Price excludes VAT (USA)
Tax calculation will be finalised during checkout.

Instant access to the full article PDF.

Institutional subscriptions

Similar content being viewed by others

Notes

  1. V. Mau, et. al., Ekonomika perekhodnogo perioda. Ocherki ekonomicheskoi politiki postkommunisticheskoi Rossii 1991-1997 [The economy of the transition period. Essays on the Economic Policy of Post-Communist Russia 1991-1997] (Rus.).

  2. I.G. Dakhov, Protivodeistvie korruptsii v sisteme upravleniia narodnym khoziaistvom: monografiia [Counteraction of corruption in the system of management of the national economy: monograph] (Rus.).

  3. Y.I. Kuzminov, Tezisy o korruptsii [Theses on corruption] (2007) (Rus.).

  4. S.I. Barsukova, Radaev V.V. Neformal'naia ekonomika v Rossii: kratkii obzor, [The Informal Economy in Russia: An Overview] 13 Economic Sociology- European Electronic Newsletter 4, 4-12 (2012) (Rus.).

  5. N.N. Men'shenina, Korruptsiia v Rossiiskoi Federatsii: genezis, formy, tekhnologii, protivodeistvie: monografiia, Ural Federal University, Ekaterinburg [Corruption in the Russian Federation: Genesis, Forms, Technologies, Counteraction (2014) (Rus.).

  6. S.K. Kovbasiuk & M.I. Levin, Posobie po kursu "Ekonomika korruptsii" [A handbook on “The Economics of Corruption"] (2007) (Rus.).

  7. M.V. Shedii, Biurokratiia kak sderzhivaiushchii faktor antikorruptsionnoi politiki Rossii, [Bureaucracy as a Deterrent to Russia's Anti-Corruption Policy] Dialectics of Counteracting Corruption: 5th All-Russian Scientific and Practical Conference with International Participation 183-186 (2014) (Rus.).

  8. N.A. Berdyaev, Philosophy of Creativity, Culture and Art (1994) (Rus.).

  9. L.F. Pisarkova, Kistorii vziatok v Rossii (po materialam «sekretnoi kantseliarii» kn. Golitsynykh pervoi poloviny XIX v.) [To the History of Bribes in Russia (Based on the Materials of the "Secret Office" of Prince Golitsyn of the First Half of the Nineteenth Century)] (Rus.). See also, Berlin P. Russkoe vziatochnichestvo, kak sotsial'no-istoricheskoe iavlenie [Russian bribery, as a socio-historical phenomenon], 8 Modern World 12-13 (2009) (Rus.).

  10. G.A. Satarov, et al., Zarabotnaia plata i korruptsiia: Kak platit' rossiiskim chinovnikam [Wages and Corruption: How to pay Russian Officials], INDEM Foundation: Analytical Report (2002) (Rus.); Stimuly, effektivnost', korruptsiia [Incentives, Efficiency, Corruption], INDEM Foundation: Analytical Report (2004) (Rus.); Rose-Ackermann, Korruptsiia i gosudarstvo. Prichiny, sledstviia, reformy [Corruption and the State: Reasons, Consequences, Reforms] (Rus.).

  11. S.S. Sulakshin, et al., Gosudarstvennaia politika protivodeistviia korruptsii i tenevoi ekonomike v Rossii [State policy of counteracting corruption and shadow economy in Russia] (2008) (Rus.).

  12. E.V. Miuller, Upravlenie personalom i problemy minimizatsii vliianiia korruptsionnykh protsessov [Personnel management and problems of minimizing the impact of corruption processes] (2015) (Rus.).

  13. Satarov G.A. supra note 10.

  14. See Vito Tanzi, Corruption Around the World: Causes, Consequences, Scope, and Cure, 45 IMF Staff Papers 559, 570 (1998).

  15. S.B. Ivanov, et al., Protivodeistvie korruptsii: novye vyzovy [Anti-corruption: new challenges] (2016) (Rus.).

  16. Lavrent'ev A. R., et al., Uchastie institutov grazhdanskogo obshchestva v preduprezhdenii korruptsii, [Participation of Civil Society Institutions in Preventing Corruption] Science Thought 24-29 (2016) (Rus.).

  17. A.V. Kurakin, Gosudarstvennaia sluzhba i korruptsiia [Public Service and Corruption] (2009) (Rus.); Obolonsky A.V. Krizis biurokraticheskogo gosudarstva: Reformy gosudarstvennoi sluzhby: mezhdunarodnyi opyt i rossiiskie realii, [The Crisis of the Bureaucratic State: Reforms of the Civil Service: International Experience and Russian Realities] Liberal Mission Foundation (2011) (Rus.); Melnikov V.P., Gosudarstvennaia sluzhba v Rossii: istoricheskii opyt [Public service in Russia: historical experience] (2005) (Rus.).

  18. M.N. Afanasiev, Klientelizm i rossiiskaia gosudarstvennost': Issledovanie klientarnykh otnoshenii, ikh roli v evoliutsii i upadke proshlykh form rossiiskoi gosudarstvennosti, ikh vliianiia na politicheskie instituty i deiatel'nost' vlastvuiushchikh grupp v sovremennoi Rossii [Clientelism and Russian statehood: The study of client relations, their role in the evolution and decline of past forms of Russian statehood, their influence on political institutions and the activities of ruling groups in modern Russia] (Rus.).

  19. Gaman-Golutvina & A.Oleynik , Administrativnye reformy v kontekste vlastnykh otnoshenii. Opyt postsotsialisticheskikh transformatsii v sravnitel'noi perspektive ) [Administrative reforms in the context of power relations. The experience of post-socialist transformations in a comparative perspective] (2008 (Rus.).

  20. L.A. Lomakina, Rotatsiia gosudarstvennykh grazhdanskikh sluzhashchikh v kontekste preodoleniia korruptsii, [Rotation of State Civil Servants in the Context of Overcoming Corruption] 4 J. Rus. L., 43-50 (2013) (Rus.).

  21. Satarov G.A. Korruptsionnye otnosheniia: agentskaia model' i smezhnye podkhody [Corruption Relations: Agency Model and Related Approaches], Social Sciences & Modernity, 60-69 (2004) (Rus.).

  22. O gosudarstvennoi grazhdanskoi sluzhbe Rossiiskoi Federatsii [On the Civil Service of the Russian Federation], Federal Law No. 79-FZ, (2004) (Rus.).

  23. M.V. Kostennikov & A.V. Kurakin, Administrativno-pravovoe regulirovanie protivodeistviia korruptsionnym riskam v sisteme gosudarstvennoi grazhdanskoi sluzhby Rossiiskoi Federatsii [Administrative and legal regulation of counteraction to corruption risks in the system of the state civil service of the Russian Federation: monograph] (2011) (Rus.).

  24. N.L. Zakharov, Sotsial'nye reguliatory deiatel'nosti rossiiskogo gosudarstvennogo sluzhashchego [Social regulators of the Russian civil servant] (2002) (Rus.).

  25. S.P. Peregudov, Novyi rossiiskii korporatizm: ot biurokraticheskogo k oligarkhicheskomu? [New Russian Corporatism: From Bureaucratic to Oligarchic?] 4 Policy 114-116 (1998) (Rus.).

  26. L.Ya. Kosals, Klanovyi kapitalizm v Rossii [Clan Capitalism in Russia], Involuntary Supply, 179-199 (2006) (Rus.).

  27. O.N. Val'kovich & V.I. Kolokolova , Korruptsiia kak sderzhivaiushchii faktor kadrovogo mekhanizma v sisteme gosudarstvennoi sluzhby v Rossiiskoi Federatsii [Corruption as a Deterrent Factor of the Personnel Mechanism in the Public Service in the Russian Federation], Humanitarian Scientific Research (2016)

  28. D.A. Medvedev, Vstupitel'noe slovo na soveshchanii po voprosam formirovaniia rezerva upravlencheskikh kadrov [Opening address at the meeting on the formation of the reserve of management personnel], (Jul. 23, 2008), http://www.kremlin.ru/catalog/keywords/92/events/859 (Rus.).

  29. S.S. Sulakshin et al., Gosudarstvennaia politika protivodeistviia korruptsii i tenevoi ekonomike v Rossii [State policy of counteracting corruption and shadow economy in Russia] (2008) (Rus.).

  30. Doklad Obshchestvennoi palaty ob effektivnosti provodimykh v Rossiiskoi Federatsii antikorruptsionnykh meropriiatii i uchastii institutov grazhdanskogo obshchestva v realizatsii antikorruptsionnoi politiki, [Report of the Public Chamber on the Effectiveness of Anti-Corruption Measures in the Russian Federation and the Involvement of Civil Society Institutions in Implementing Anti-Corruption Policies], Public Chamber of the Russian Federation (2008) (Rus.).

  31. Korruptsiya: mirovoy opyt uspeshnoy bor'by i realii sovremennoy Rossii, Stenogramma diskussionnogo kluba «Modernizatsiya Rossii: novyy vektor», zasedaniye 6-ye. «Korruptsiya: mirovoy opyt uspeshnoy bor'by i realii sovremennoy Rossii», [Corruption: The World Experience of Successful Struggle and the Realities of Modern Russia] (Dec. 1, 2005), http://forum-msk.org/material/economic/5793.html (Rus.).

  32. K.O. Magomedov, Ob effektivnosti protivodeistviia korruptsii v gosudarstvennykh organakh vlasti [On the Effectiveness of Anti-Corruption in Public Authorities] (2014) (Rus.).

  33. A.L. Zhuravlev, et al., Psikhologicheskie faktory korruptsii [Psychological Factors of Corruption], 1 Applied Legal Psychology 8-12 (2012) (Rus.).

  34. M.V. Shedii, Korporativnaia kul'tura gosudarstvennoi sluzhby: retrospektiva i perspektiva [Corporate Culture of Public Service: A Retrospective Perspective], Cent. Rus. Herald Soc. Sci., 44-51 (2007) (Rus.).

  35. Voslenskii M.S., Nomenklatura. Gospodstvuiushchii klass Sovetskogo Soiuza [Nomenclature. The ruling class of the Soviet Union] (1991) (Rus.).

  36. Satarova G.A., Rossiiskaia korruptsiia: uroven', struktura, dinamika. Opyty sotsiologicheskogo analiza [Russian Corruption: Level, Structure, Dynamics. Experiments of Sociological Analysis], Lib. Miss. Found. (2013) (Rus.).

  37. L.P. Goverdovskoy, Mezhsektornoe vzaimodeistvie vlasti, biznesa i NKO v konsolidatsii usilii grazhdanskogo obshchestva po bor'be s korruptsiei : sbornik statei [Intersectoral Interaction of Government, Business and NGOs in Consolidating the Efforts of Civil Society to Combat Corruption], Intl. Market Inst. (2013) (Rus.).

  38. M. Pit, Prekratim prezhniuiu praktiku vedeniia biznesa. Bor'ba so vziatochnichestvom i korruptsiei, [We Will Stop the Old Practice of Doing Business: Combating Bribery and Corruption], OECD, (2001) (Rus.).

  39. S.A. Orekhov, Organizatsionno-upravlencheskii mekhanizm bor'by s korruptsiei kak uslovie obespecheniia ekonomicheskoi bezopasnosti strany [Organizational-Management Mechanism of Fighting Corruption as a Condition for Ensuring Economic Security of the Country] (Rus.).

  40. N.A. Simoniia, O biurokraticheskom kapitalizme v Rossii [About bureaucratic capitalism in Russia] (1996) (Rus.).

  41. A.I. Misery, Grazhdane i eksperty o korruptsii [Citizens and Experts on Corruption], Socio’l. Res., 86-94 (1999) (Rus.).

  42. Obolonskii A.V., Biurokratiia: v poiskakh novoi modeli (Evoliutsiia teorii i praktiki gosudarstvennogo upravleniia v poslednie desiatiletiia [Bureaucracy: In Search of a New Model (Evolution of Theory and Practice of Public Administration in Recent Decades], 3 Social Sci. & Modernity 5-22 (2014) (Rus.).

  43. M.A. Cheshkov, O pol'ze i ogranichennosti starykh poniatii v novoi situatsii [On the benefits and limitations of old concepts in the new situation] (1996) (Rus.).

  44. A.I. Sidorov, Korruptsiia kak monopoliia: osushchestvima li ee likvidatsiia [Corruption as a Monopoly: Is it Possible to Liquidate it], Soci’y. Wednesday Dev. 8-15 (2010) (Rus.).

  45. Zinoviev A., Na puti k sverkhobshchestvu [On the way to the super exchange] (2004) (Rus.).

  46. Bor'ba s vetrianymi mel'nitsami? Sotsial'no-antropologicheskii podkhod k issledovaniiu korruptsii, Redaktsiia [Fighting windmills? Socio-Anthropological Approach to the Study of Corruption] (I.B. Olimpieva, eds. et. al, 2007) (Rus.).

  47. Boldyrev Iu.Iu. Korruptsiia kak sistemnyi porok rossiiskogo kapitalizma [Corruption as a Systemic Breakdown of Russian Capitalism], Inst. Econ. Strat. (2010) (Rus.).

  48. U.T. Saigitov, Kriminal'noe reiderstvo v Rossii [Criminal raiding in Russia] (2013) (Rus.).

  49. P.A. Kabanov, Politicheskaia korruptsiia v Rossii: poniatie, sushchnost', prichiny, preduprezhdenie [Political corruption in Russia: the concept, essence, causes, warning] (2004) (Rus.).

  50. Konflikt interesov po-rossiiski – srashchivanie biurokratii i biznesa [Conflict of interests in Russian - the merging of bureaucracy and business] (Rus.); Gosudarstvennaia politika protivodeistviia korruptsii i tenevoi ekonomike v Rossii [State policy of combating corruption and the shadow economy in Russia] (Rus.).

  51. M.V. Shedi, Korruptsionalizatsiia vlasti kak faktor deformatsii gosudarstvennogo upravleniia [Corruption of Power as a Factor in the Deformation of Public Administration], Bull. State &Muni. Admin. 68-84 (2015)(Rus.).

  52. S.A. Orekhov, Organizatsionno-upravlencheskii mekhanizm bor'by s korruptsiei kak uslovie obespecheniia ekonomicheskoi bezopasnosti strany [Organizational-Management Mechanism of Fighting Corruption as a Condition for Ensuring Economic Security of the Country] (Rus.).

  53. Transparency International, Corruption Perceptions Index (1995), http://transparency.org.ru/indeks-vospriiatiia-korruptcii/blog.

  54. Sostoyaniye bytovoy korruptsii v Rossiyskoy Federatsii na osnovanii rezul'tatov sotsiologicheskogo issledovaniya, provedennogo vo vtorom polugodii 2010 g [State of Everyday Corruption in the Russian Federation Based on the Results of a Sociological Survey Conducted in the Second Half of 2010], (2011), http://fom.ru/uploads/files/doklad. pdf (Rus.).

  55. Burtsev Iu.A., Korruptsiia v Rossii: prichiny vozniknoveniia i metody bor'by [Corruption in Russia: the causes and methods of fighting], 66-67 (2017) (Rus.).

  56. Ugolovnyi kodeks Rossiiskoi Federatsii [The Criminal Code of the Russian Federation], June 13, 1996 No. 63-FZ (Rus.).

  57. O ratifikatsii Konventsii Organizatsii Ob"edinennykh Natsii protiv korruptsii: Federal'nyi zakon Rossiiskoi Federatsii [On the ratification of the United Nations Convention against Corruption: the Federal Law of the Russian Federation], No. 40-FZ (2006) (Rus.).

  58. G.A. Satarov & V.L. Rimskii, Blagoveshchenskii Iu.N. Sotsiologicheskoe issledovanie rossiiskoi sudebnoi vlasti [Sociological study of the Russian Judiciary] (2010) (Rus.).

  59. S.N. Naumov, Antikorruptsionnye osnovy v sisteme gosudarstvennoi sluzhby Rossiiskoi Federatsii [Anti-corruption bases in the system of the public civil service of the Russian Federation] (2011) (Rus.).

  60. O parlamentskom rassledovanii Federal'nogo Sobraniia Rossiiskoi Federatsii [On the Parliamentary Investigation of the Federal Assembly of the Russian Federation], No. 169 – FZ (2005) (Rus.).

  61. Uchastie institutov grazhdanskogo obshchestva v bor'be s korruptsiei: Nauchno-prakticheskoe posobie [Participation of Civil Society Institutions in The Fight Against Corruption: A Scientific And Practical Guide], Inst. Leg. & Comp. Juris. (2013) (Rus.).

  62. Bor'ba s korruptsiei i modernizatsiia gosudarstvennogo upravleniia: opyt Rossii: analiticheskii otchet [Anti-Corruption and Modernization of Public Administration: Experience of Russia: Analytical Report], Rus. Presidential Aca’my. Nat. Econ. & Pub. Admin. (2011) (Rus.).

  63. D. Davydov, Putin: raboty po bor'be s korruptsiyey ochen' i ochen' mnogo [Putin: Very Much and There as a Lot of Work on Fight Against Corruption], (Jan. 26, 2016), http://www.vesti.ru/doc.html?id=2712740 (Rus.).

  64. Korruptsiia v Rossiiskoi Federatsii: proiskhozhdenie, formy, tekhnologii, protivodeistvie [Corruption in the Russian Federation: genesis, forms, technologies, counteraction] (2014) (Rus.).

  65. A.L. Semenikhin , Formirovanie antikorruptsionnoi kul'tury [Formation of anti-corruption culture] (2016) (Rus.).

  66. Otchet Obshchestvennoy palaty ob effektivnosti provodimykh v Rossiyskoy Federatsii antikorruptsionnykh meropriyatiy i uchastii institutov grazhdanskogo obshchestva v realizatsii antikorruptsionnoy politiki [The Report of Public Chamber on Efficiency of the Anti-Corruption Events Held in the Russian Federation and Participation of Institutes of Civil Society in Realization of Anti-Corruption Policy], (2011) (Rus.).

  67. Doklad Obshchestvennoi palaty Rossiiskoi Federatsii ob effektivnosti provodimykh v Rossiiskoi Federatsii antikorruptsionnykh meropriiatii i uchastii institutov grazhdanskogo obshchestva v realizatsii antikorruptsionnoi politiki [Report of the Public Chamber of the Russian Federation on the Effectiveness of Anti-Corruption Measures Carried Out in the Russian Federation and the Involvement of Civil Society Institutions in Implementing Anti-Corruption Policies] (2011), http://www.oprf.ru/files/dokument2011/dokladantikorrupciya.pdf (Rus.).

  68. Protivodeistvie korruptsii: novye vyzovy [Counteraction to corruption: new challenges] (2016), http://www.izak.ru/upload/iblock/422/422c8c5fce68531640045a101aa2be3e.pdf (Rus.).

  69. S.N. Bratanovskii & M.F. Zelenov, Administrativno-pravovye aspekty bor'by s korruptsiei v sisteme ispolnitel'noi vlasti RF [Administrative and legal aspects of the fight against corruption in the executive branch of the Russian Federation] (2016) (Rus.).

  70. A.V. Gabov, et. al., Gosudarstvo i biznes v sisteme pravovykh koordinat [State and business in the system of legal coordinates] (2014) (Rus.).

  71. V.G. Popov & V.N. Umnikov, Korruptsiia: osnovnye ugrozy i mery protivodeistviia [Corruption: the main threats and countermeasures] (2012) (Rus.).

Author information

Authors and Affiliations

  1. Central Russian Institute of Management, Russian Presidential Academy of National Economy and Public Administration, Moscow, Russia

    Pavel A. Merkulov

  2. Department of Political Science and Public Policy, Central Russian Institute of Management, Russian Presidential Academy of National Economy and Public Administration, Moscow, Russia

    Maria V. Shedij

Authors
  1. Pavel A. Merkulov
    View author publications

    You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar

  2. Maria V. Shedij
    View author publications

    You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar

Corresponding author

Correspondence to Pavel A. Merkulov.

Rights and permissions

Reprints and permissions

About this article

Check for updates. Verify currency and authenticity via CrossMark

Cite this article

Merkulov, P.A., Shedij, M.V. Why Russian anti-corruption policies fail? Examination of corruption in the civil service and the business community. Jindal Global Law Review 9, 29–42 (2018). https://doi.org/10.1007/s41020-018-0061-7

Download citation

  • Published:

  • Issue Date:

  • DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s41020-018-0061-7

Keywords

Search

Navigation