Governance of agro-pesticide through private environmental and social standards in the global cut flower chain from Ethiopia
- 239 Downloads
The international cut flower industry is strongly criticized because of its environmental impacts and unsafe working conditions. Increasing certification of cut flowers is used to improve the growers’ environmental and social performance. But what is the impact of this private governance instrument on regulating the use of pesticides? This paper assesses the potential of private certification on governing the environmental and social problems from pesticide use along the global cut flower supply chain. We use detailed farm-level data to analyse the environmental and social impacts of flower certification in Ethiopia by comparing different national and international certification schemes. Our analysis does not show significant differences between these different private standards for most environmental and health and safety variables. The Ethiopian cut flower industry remains far from improving its sustainability performance through private certification. However, certification schemes may enable farmers to have access to international markets and keep up their reputation.
KeywordsCut flower Ethiopia Pesticide Private certification
Authors are thankful to the participants especially flower farm managers/and owners and pesticide sprayers. We would also like express our gratitude to anonymous referee(s) and editor of the journal for their valuable comments and suggestions on the earlier draft of the paper. This study was financially supported by the by the pesticide risk reduction programme (PRRP)-Ethiopia and Alterra, part of Wageningen UR. Additional support was provided by the Netherlands Fellowship Programme (NFP).
- Belgian Development Agency, Trade for Development Centre, BTC. 2010. The European market for fair and sustainable flowers and plants. Brussels: BTC.Google Scholar
- Büthe, T. 2010. Private regulation in the global economy: A (P)Review. Business and Politics 12: 2.Google Scholar
- David, T. 2002. The Bloom on the rose, looking into the floriculture industry: Environmental health perspectives. Focus 110: 240–247.Google Scholar
- Dolan, C., M. Opondo, and S. Smith. 2002. Gender, rights & participation in the Kenya cut flower industry. Natural Resource Institute. NRI Report No: 2768 SSR Project No. R8077 2002-4. https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/57a08d49ed915d622c0018d5/R8077a.pdf.
- EHPEA. 2015. Export horticulture in Ethiopia, Ethiopian horticulture producers export association code of Practices, Version 4. Unpublished official document, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia.Google Scholar
- Eshetu, S., B. Belete, D. Goshu, B. Kassa, D. Tamiru, E. Worku, Z. Lema, A. Delelegn, and J. Tucker. 2009. Income diversification through improved irrigation schemes: Evidence from Gorogutu Woreda, Eastern Ethiopia. Research Report. Addis Ababa: RiPPLE.Google Scholar
- Ethiopian Horticulture Producer Exporters Association (EHPEA). 2016. EHPEA resource centre. http://www.ehpea.org/.
- EUPDB. 2015. European Union pesticide properties database: http://sitem.herts.ac.uk/aeru/ppdb/en/. Accessed 26 March 2016.
- EUPDB. 2016. European Union pesticide properties database: http://sitem.herts.ac.uk/aeru/ppdb/en/.
- Gebreeyesus, M., and M. Iizuka. 2010. Discovery of the flower industry in Ethiopia: Experimentation and coordination. UNU-MERIT working paper series, no. 2010-025.Google Scholar
- Getu, M. 2009. Ethiopian floriculture and its impact on the environment: Regulation, supervision and compliance. Mizan Law Review 2: 240–270.Google Scholar
- Gibbon, P., and S. Ponte. 2005. Trading down: Africa, value chains, and the global economy. Philadelphia: Temple University Press.Google Scholar
- Jakobasch, S. 1998. Sag, wo sind die Blumen her? In: MorgenWelt Magazin. http://www.morgenwelt.de/magazin/repo55.htm.
- Jansen, H.C., and J. Harmsen. 2011. Pesticide monitoring in the central rift valley 2009–2010: Ecosystems for water in Ethiopia. Alterra Wageningen UR, 44.Google Scholar
- Joosten, F. 2007. Development strategy for the export-oriented horticulture in Ethiopia. http://library.wur.nl/way/bestanden/clc/1891396.pdf.
- Mano, Y., and A. Suzuki. 2011. Agglomeration economies for industrial development: The case of the Ethiopian cut flower industry. Foundation for advanced studies on international development national graduate research institute for policy studies.Google Scholar
- Mena, N., and S. Proaño. 2005. Acoso Sexual Laboral en La Floricultura. Quito: International Labor Rights Forum.Google Scholar
- Ministry of Agriculture (MoA)-Ethiopia. 2014. Pesticide imported for flower production. PHRD of MoA. Unpublished official reports.Google Scholar
- Mmochi, A.J., and R.S. Mberek. 1998. Trends in the types, amounts, and toxicity of pesticides used in Tanzania: Efforts to control pesticide pollution in Zanzibar, Tanzania. Ambio 27: 669–676.Google Scholar
- PAN UK. 2007. The deadly chemicals in cotton. Exposing the human health and environmental cost of pesticide use in global cotton production. A report in collaboration with Environmental Justice Foundation. http://ejfoundation.org/report/deadly-chemicals-cotton.
- PAN UK (2008), Flower farming: Ethiopian NGOS work to improve conditions for flower producers. Pesticide news, 82.Google Scholar
- Ponte, S., P. Gibon, and L. Riisgaard. 2011. Competition, best practices’ and exclusion in the market for social and environmental standards. In Governing through standards: Origins, drivers, and limitations, ed. S. Ponte, P. Gibbon, and J. Vestergaard, 236–265. London: PalgraveMacmillan.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Ponte, S. 2008. Developing a vertical dimension to chronic poverty research: Some lessons from global value chain analysis, Paper 9/2007. Trade law centre for southern Africa, Stellenbosch.Google Scholar
- Riisgaard, L. 2008. Localizing private social standards standard initiatives in Kenyan cut flowers. DIIS working paper 2008: 20.Google Scholar
- Sisay, T. 2007. Assessment of the ecological impacts of floriculture industries using physico-chemical parameters and benthic macro invertebrates metric index along Wedecha River, Debrezeit, Ethiopia.Google Scholar
- Tamirat, A. 2011. Toxication in bits. Flower industry threatens right to water in Ethiopia: Cut flower production practices, the sector‘s socio-economic contribution and environmental Standards, FIAN, Germany.Google Scholar
- Tamiru, S.M. 2007. Assessment of the ecological impacts of floriculture industries using physico-chemical parameters and benthic macro invertebrates metric index along Wedecha river, Debrezeit, Ethiopia. MSc thesis. Addis Ababa University, Ethiopia.Google Scholar
- Tilahun, A. 2013. Environmental impacts of floriculture industry in Debrezeit Town: A need for strategic environmental assessment, M.Sc. thesis, AAU University, EthiopiaGoogle Scholar
- The Reporter. 2014. Ethiopian flower sector: Bloomer or gloomier? English newspaper, Version 1 March 2014.Google Scholar
- Vieira, S., and L. Abarca. 2009. Floriculture waste management practices to Ethiopia. https://repositorio.ufsc.br/bitstream/handle/123456789/124459/171.pdf?sequence=1.
- World Recourse Institute (WRI). 2016. What are the environmental costs of Valentine’s Day flowers? http://www.wri.org/blog/2016/02/what-are-environmental-costs-valentines-day-flowers. Accessed 13 April 2016.