Improving the Police Complaints System: Stakeholder Collaboration as a Vehicle for Systems Change
Systems change efforts seek to alter the status quo by shifting the form and function of a targeted system. Evaluation is a critical component, yet little research has examined a collaborative forum as a vehicle for change in the criminal justice system. Over 150 citizens and police were brought together to work collaboratively at improving a Canadian police complaints system. Using survey, participant observation, and focus group data, this study investigates the perceptions of this Forum as a vehicle for systems change in police oversight mechanisms. We find the Forum provided both opportunities for, and barriers to, collaborative systems change work. However, these findings need to be understood within the context of police-community relations as fear and mistrust of police influence problem definitions and potential solutions. Therefore, the collaboratives model is not a one-size-fits-all approach to systems change work in the criminal justice system.
KeywordsSystems change Police complaints system Police misconduct Police-citizen relations
- CEAPC (2006). Summary analysis of Bill 103: An Act to establish an Independent Police Review Director and create a new public complaints process by amending the Police Services Act. Toronto, ON: Community Education and Access to Police Complaints Demonstration Project.Google Scholar
- Chatterjee, A., & Schulenberg, J.L. (2013). The Ontario police complaints system forum: Perspectives from the community, police and policy-makers. Final report prepared for the Attorney General of Ontario and the Office of the Independent Police Review Director. Available from http://www.scaddingcourt.org/pdflibrary/2013police-forum-report.pdf
- Checkland, P. (1999). Systems thinking, systems practice. New York: John Wiley & Sons.Google Scholar
- Checkland, P., & Scholes, J. (1999). Soft systems methodology in action. New York: John Wiley & Sons.Google Scholar
- Clarke, S. (2009). Arrested oversight: A comparative analysis and case study of how civilian oversight of the police should function and how it fails. Columbia Journal of Law and Social Problems, 43(1), 1–49.Google Scholar
- John Howard Society (2005). An examination of citizen involvement in complaints regarding police. Calgary, AB: John Howard Society of Alberta. Available from http://www.johnhoward.ab.ca/docs/police/police.pdf. Accessed 05 June 2015.
- Miller, J. (2002). Civilian oversight of policing: Lessons from the Literature. Available from http://www.vera.org/publication_pdf/178_338.pdf. Accessed 06 June 2015.
- Mizrahi, T., & Rosenthal, B. B. (1992). Managing dynamic tensions in social change coalitions. In T. Mizrahi & J. Morrison (Eds.), Community organization and social administration: Advances, trends, and emerging principles. New York: Haworth.Google Scholar
- Murphy, C., & McKenna, P. (2012). Police investigating police: Making change happen. Ottawa, ON: Commission for Public Complaints Against the RCMP. Retrieved from http://www.cpc-cpp.gc.ca/cnt/tpsp-tmrs/police/projet-pip-pep-eng.aspx. Accessed 02 Aug 2015.
- OIPRD (2016). OIPRD Annual Report 2014–2015. Toronto, ON: Office of the Independent Police Review Director. Available from: http://www.oiprd.on.ca/EN/PDFs/OIPRD-AnnualReport-2014-2015_E.pdf. Accessed 14 July 2016.
- Schulenberg, J.L., Chenier, A, Buffone, S., & Wojciechowski, C. (2015). An application of procedural justice to stakeholder perspectives: Examining police legitimacy and public trust in police complaints systems. Policing & Society. doi: 10.1080/10439463.2015.1102252