Abstract
Fan Zhen’s 范縝 (450–515) Shenmielun 神滅論 (On the Extinction of the Soul) is a famous Chinese treatise discussing the body-soul problem. This discussion had been advocated by Huan Tan 桓譚 (43 BCE–28 CE) and Wang Chong 王充 (27–100). However, their views did not receive positive attention: at the beginning of the Eastern Han dynasty, their intellectual weight was far from significant enough to spur the court’s interest in the topic. During the time of Fan Zhen, Emperor Wu of Liang (Liang Wudi 梁武帝, 464–549), a keen protector of the thought of dharma, raised the question of the soul and the body to a political level, making it the focus of academic debate. The aim of this article is to give a comprehensive account on the development of the idea of the nonidentity and inseparability of the body and the soul as promulgated by Fan Zhen and his predecessors from the perspective of the history of ideas.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Cao, Siwen 曹思文. 1936. Refuting Official Fan’s Shenmielun 難范中書神滅論. In Daoxuan 道宣, Illuminating Brightness 弘明集. Sibubeiyao 四部備要 ed., vol. 159. Shanghai 上海: Zhonghua Shuju 中華書局.
Fan, Zhen 范縝. 1936. Answering Official Cao’s Refutation of the Shenmielun 答曹錄事難神滅論. In Daoxuan 道宣, Illuminating Brightness 弘明集. Sibubeiyao 四部備要 ed., vol. 159. Shanghai 上海: Zhonghua Shuju 中華書局.
______. 1973. On the Extinction of the Soul 神滅論. In Yao Silian 姚思廉, The History of the Liang Dynasty 梁書. Beijing 北京: Zhunghua Shuju 中華書局.
Forke, Alfred, tr. 1907. Lun-Heng, Part I, Philosophical Essays of Wang Ch’ung. Leipzig: Harrasowiz.
Gao, Chenyang 高晨陽. 1987. “Fan Zhen’s Ontology and Application on Body, Mind and Metaphysics 范縝的形神論與玄學的體用觀.”Journal of Literature, History and Philosophy 文史哲 3: 12–15.
Huan, Tan 桓譚. 1967. New Treatise 新論. Shanghai 上海: Renmnin Chubanshe 人民出版社.
Huang, Junwei 黃俊威. 1998. “A Study on the Thinking of Interplay between Confucianism and Buddhism in Hongmingji《弘明集》中的儒佛會通問題──「神滅論」與「神不滅論」作為討論中心.” In Compendium of the Papers for the Third Academic Conference on Confucianism and Buddhism. Taipei: Department of Philosophy, Huafan University.
Lau, D. C., tr. 1983. The Analects (Lunyu). Hong Kong: The Chinese University Press.
Li, Hongjun 李紅軍. 1999. “On Fan Zhen’s Atheistic Thought 論范縝和他的無神論思想.” Journal of Qiannan Medical College 黔南民族醫專學報 12.4: 244–245.
Li, Weidong 黎惟東. 1991. “A Study on Fan Zhen’s Shenmielun 范縝「神滅論」之研究.” Journal of the Arts, Huagang Univesity 華崗文科學報 18: 61–80.
Liao, Minghuo 廖明活. 1994. “The Controversy over the Problem of the Immortality of the Soul between Buddhists and Anti-Buddhists in Medieval China 中國佛教徒和反對佛教者之間的神滅神不滅論.” Philosophy and Culture 哲學與文化 21: 329–346.
Lin, Boqian 林伯謙. 2012. “From a Monk to a Hermit: A Study on the Transformation of Liu Xiaobiao’s Viewpoint of Life and Religious Faith 出家到棲隱──論劉孝標命定思想與宗教情懷的轉化.” Literature and Philosophy 文與哲 20: 127–164.
Liu, Liangjian 劉梁劍. 2013. “Uncertain between Body and Mind: One Aspect of Ideology of the Wei Jin Period 「形神」不定:魏晉南北朝思想的一個面向.” Journal of Sun Yat-sen University (Social Science Edition) 中山大學學報 (社會科學版) 53.3: 133–139.
Nylan, Michael, tr. 1994. The Elemental Changes: The Chinese Companion to the I Jing. Albany: State University of New York Press.
Pan, Fu’en 潘富恩, and Ma Tao 馬濤. 1990. Commentaries on F an Zhen 范縝評傳. Nanjing 南京: Nanjing Daxue Chubanshe 南京大學出版社.
Pokora, Timoteus, tr. 1975. Hsin-lun (New Treatise), and Other Writings by H uan T’an (43 B.C.–28 A.D.). Ann Arbor: Center for Chinese Studies, University of Michigan.
Qing, Shangyun 卿上涒. 2001. “A Study on Fan Zhen’s Shenmielun 范縝《神滅論》思想新探.” Journal of Neijiang Teachers College 內江師範學院學報 16.6: 73–78.
Waley, Arthur, trans. 1996. The Book of Songs: The Ancient Chinese Classic of Poetry. New York: Grove Press.
Wu, Yifeng 吳儀鳳. 2001. “Debate over the Extermination and Nonextermination of the Spirit in the the Liang Era 梁代「神滅」與「神不滅」的論辯.” Philosophy and Culture 哲學與文化 28.1: 22–31.
Xiao, Chen 蕭琛. 1936. Challenging the Shenmielun 難神滅論. In Daoxuan 道宣, Illuminating Brightness 弘明集. Sibubeiyao 四部備要 ed., vol. 159. Shanghai 上海: Zhonghua Shuju 中華書局.
Yang, Shixiu 楊世秀. 1994. “Comments on Fan Zhen and His Shenmielun 淺談范縝及其《神滅論》.” Journal of Anshun Teachers College (Social Science Edition) 安順師專學報(社會科學版) 1: 52–58.
Zhang, Guoyi 張國一. 2002. “Arguments about the Existence of Soul—Scientific Reflections on Fan Zhen’s Shenmielun 靈魂有無之爭──范縝 〈 神滅論 〉 之科學省思.” In Compilation of the Essays Presented at the Sixth Symposium of Confucianism/Buddhism Communication 第六次儒佛會通論文集. Taipei 台北: Huafan Daxue 華梵大學.
Zhang, Jian 張踐. 2009. “The Treatise of ‘Nonextinction of the Spirit’ and Its Role in Assisting the Secular Political Order: On Fan Zhen’s Shenmielun 神不滅論對世俗政治秩序的輔助作用──兼論范縝的《神滅論》.” Journal of the CPC Ningbo Municipal Party Committee 中共寧波市委黨校學報 6: 102–106.
Zheng, Hongfeng 鄭紅峰, ed. 2011. History of Chinese Philosophy 中國哲學史. Beijing 北京: Beijing Yanshan Chubanshe 北京燕山出版社.
Zheng, Jiliang 鄭基良. 2002. Ideological Argumentation of the Form of Annihilation or the Form of Immortality in the Wei, Jin, Southern and Northern Dynasties 魏晉南北朝形盡神滅或形盡神不滅的思想論證. Taipei 台北: Wenshizhe 文史哲.
Zou, Dayan 鄒大炎. 1983. “Comments on Fan Zhen’s Idea of Psychology 范縝的心理學思想述評.” Acta Psychologica Sinica 心理學報 2: 150–155.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Fung, Sf. The Development of the Chinese Doctrine of the Nonidentity and Inseparability of the Body and the Soul—The Shenmielun (On the Extinction of the Soul) and Its Origins. Dao 17, 363–379 (2018). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11712-018-9615-9
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11712-018-9615-9