The Duty to Disregard the Law
In the practice of jury nullification, a jury votes to acquit a defendant in disregard of the factual evidence, on the grounds that a conviction would result in injustice, either because the law itself is unjust or because its application in the particular case would be unjust. Though the practice is widely condemned by courts, the arguments against jury nullification are surprisingly weak. I argue that, pursuant to the general ethical duty to avoid causing unjust harms to others, jurors are often morally obligated to disregard the law.
KeywordsJury nullification Juries Political obligation
- ABC News. 2010. “Feds’ Conviction Rate Bad Sign for Blago,” August 4, http://abclocal.go.com/wls/story?section=news/local&id=7593302. Accessed October 3, 2012.
- Adams, John.  1971. The Works of John Adams, Second President of the United States. New York: AMS Press.Google Scholar
- Allen, Ronald J. and Larry Laudan. 2008. “Deadly Dilemmas,” Texas Tech Law Review 41: 65–92.Google Scholar
- Arnold, Thurman. 1945. Opinion in Holloway v. United States, 148 F.2d 665.Google Scholar
- Babcock, Barbara. 2013. “‘Defending the Guilty’ after 30 Years,” pp. 1–13 in Abbe Smith and Monroe H. Freedman, eds., How Can You Represent Those People? New York: Palgrave Macmillan.Google Scholar
- Bazelon, David L. 1972. Dissenting opinion in United States v. Dougherty, 473 F.2d 1113.Google Scholar
- Biskupic, Joan. 1999. “In Jury Rooms, Form of Civil Protest Grows,” Washington Post, February 8, p. A1. Available at http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/national/jury080299.htm, accessed April 5, 2012.
- Bissell, John W. 1997. “Comments on Jury Nullification,” Cornell Journal of Law and Public Policy 7: 51–56.Google Scholar
- Bork, Robert H. 1999. “Thomas More for Our Season,” First Things: A Monthly Journal of Religion & Public Life 94: 17–21.Google Scholar
- Butler, Paul. 2004. “In Defense of Jury Nullification,” Litigation 31: 46–49, 69.Google Scholar
- Cabranes, Jose A. 1997. Opinion in United States v. Thomas, 116 F.3d 606.Google Scholar
- Crispo, Lawrence W., Jill M. Slansky, and Geanene M. Yriarte. 1997. “Jury Nullification: Law versus Anarchy,” Loyola of Los Angeles Law Review 31: 1–61.Google Scholar
- Dye, Thomas R. and L. Harmon Zeigler. 1984. The Irony of Democracy: An Uncommon Introduction to American Politics, sixth edition. Monterey, Calif.: Wadsworth.Google Scholar
- Estlund, David. 2008. Democratic Authority: A Philosophical Framework. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
- George, Ronald M. 2001. Opinion in People v. Williams, 106 Cal.Rptr.2d 295.Google Scholar
- Greenawalt, Kent. 1987. Conflicts of Law and Morality. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
- Huemer, Michael. 2009. “America’s Unjust Drug War,” pp. 223–236 in The Right Thing to Do, fifth edition, ed. James and Stuart Rachels. New York: McGraw Hill.Google Scholar
- Husak, Douglas. 2002. Legalize This! The Case for Decriminalizing Drugs. London: Verso, 2002.Google Scholar
- Husak, Douglas. 2008. Overcriminalization: The Limits of the Criminal Law. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
- Leventhal, Harold. 1972. Majority opinion in United States v. Dougherty, 473 F.2d 1113.Google Scholar
- Linder, Douglas. 2001. “The Trial of John Peter Zenger: An Account,” http://law2.umkc.edu/faculty/projects/ftrials/zenger/zengeraccount.html, accessed April 5, 2012.
- Matravers, Matt. 2004. “‘More Than Just Illogical’: Truth and Jury Nullification,” pp. 71–83 in The Trial on Trial, vol. 1: Truth and Due Process, ed. Antony Duff, Lindsay Farmer, Sandra Marshall, and Victor Tadros. Oxford: Hart Publishing.Google Scholar
- Markel, Dan. 2012. “Retributive Justice and the Demands of Democratic Citizenship,” Virginia Journal of Criminal Law 1: 1–133.Google Scholar
- Milgram, Stanley. 2009. Obedience to Authority: An Experimental View. New York: Harper.Google Scholar
- Ostrowski, James. 2001. “The Rise and Fall of Jury Nullification,” Journal of Libertarian Studies 15: 89–115.Google Scholar
- Pollingreport.com. 2011. “Illegal Drugs,” poll results reported at http://www.pollingreport.com/drugs.htm, accessed April 7, 2012.
- Ramseyer, J. Mark, Eric Rasmusen, and Manu Raghav. 2008. “Convictions versus Conviction Rates: The Prosecutor’s Choice,” Harvard Law and Economics Discussion Paper No. 611, http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1108813. Accessed October 3, 2012.
- Rawls, John. 1999. A Theory of Justice, revised edition. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
- Ross, W.D. 1988. The Right and the Good. Indianapolis, Ind.: Hackett. Originally published 1930.Google Scholar
- Simmons, A. John. 1979. Moral Principles and Political Obligation. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
- Sobeloff, Simon E. 1969. Opinion in United States v. Moylan, 417 F.2d 1002.Google Scholar
- Steigmann, Robert J. 1998. Concurring opinion in People v. Smith, 296 Ill. Ap. 3d 435.Google Scholar
- Story, Joseph. 1835. Opinion in United States v. Battiste, 24 F.Cas. 1042.Google Scholar
- U.S. Federal Bureau of Investigation. 2010. “Offenses Cleared” in “Crime in the United States 2009,” http://www2.fbi.gov/ucr/cius2009/offenses/clearances/index.html, accessed April 12, 2011.
- Zenger, John Peter. 1736. A Brief Narrative of the Case and Trial of John Peter Zenger. Available at http://law2.umkc.edu/faculty/projects/ftrials/zenger/zengerrecord.html, accessed April 5, 2012.