Abstract
With the growing applications of nanofluid flame, the monitoring and controlling of its combustion process is of paramount importance. Thus, it is necessary to develop diagnosing methods which can simultaneously image important parameters such as temperature and volume fractions of soot, metal-oxide nanoparticles. Tomographic emission spectroscopy is an effective method which has been proposed for this purpose. However, the inversion process was only reported with least-squares QR decomposition (LSQR) so far and there are numerous well-established reconstruction algorithms which have not been utilized yet. Thus, this work aims to perform systematic comparative studies on several representative algorithms for the inversion process. In the simulative studies, algorithms including Tikhonov regularization, algebraic reconstruction technique (ART), LSQR, Landweber algorithm, maximum likelihood expectation maximization (MLEM), and ordered subset expectation maximization (OSEM) were discussed. The effects of the number of iterations, the signal-to-noise ratio, and the number of projections and the calibration error in projection angles on the performance of the algorithms were investigated. Advice on selecting the suitable algorithms under different application conditions is then provided according to the extensive numerical studies.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Basu S, Miglani A. Combustion and heat transfer characteristics of nanofluid fuel droplets: A short review. Int J Heat Mass Transfer, 2016, 96: 482–503
Kilian D, Engel S, Borsdorf B, et al. Spatially resolved flame zone classification of a flame spray nanoparticle synthesis process by combining different optical techniques. J Aerosol Sci, 2014, 69: 82–97
Snelling D R, Thomson K A, Smallwood G J, et al. Spectrally resolved measurement of flame radiation to determine soot temperature and concentration. AIAA J, 2002, 40: 1789–1795
Hall R J, Bonczyk P A. Sooting flame thermometry using emission/ absorption tomography. Appl Opt, 1990, 29: 4590–4598
Greenberg P S, Ku J C. Soot volume fraction maps for normal and reduced gravity laminar acetylene jet diffusion flames. Combust Flame, 1997, 108: 227–230
Huang Q, Wang F, Liu D, et al. Reconstruction of soot temperature and volume fraction profiles of an asymmetric flame using stereoscopic tomography. Combust Flame, 2009, 156: 565–573
Liu D, Yan J H, Wang F, et al. Inverse radiation analysis of simultaneous estimation of temperature field and radiative properties in a two-dimensional participating medium. Int J Heat Mass Transfer, 2010, 53: 4474–4481
Liu G, Liu D. Inverse radiation analysis for simultaneous reconstruction of temperature and volume fraction fields of soot and metal-oxide nanoparticles in a nanofluid fuel sooting flame. Int J Heat Mass Transfer, 2018, 118: 1080–1089
Liu G, Liu D. Simultaneous reconstruction of temperature and concentration profiles of soot and metal-oxide nanoparticles in asymmetric nanofluid fuel flames by inverse analysis. J Quantitative Spectr Radiative Transfer, 2018, 219: 174–185
Liu G, Liu D. Inverse radiation problem of multi-nanoparticles temperature and concentration fields reconstruction in nanofluid fuel flame. Optik, 2019, 181: 81–91
Liu G N, Liu D. Reconstruction model for temperature and concentration profiles of soot and metal-oxide nanoparticles in a nanofluid fuel flame by using a CCD camera. Chin Phys B, 2018, 27: 054401
Liu G, Liu D. Treatment of efficiency for temperature and concentration profiles reconstruction of soot and metal-oxide nanoparticles in nanofluid fuel flames. Int J Heat Mass Transfer, 2019, 133: 494–499
Liu G, Liu D. Direct simultaneous reconstruction for temperature and concentration profiles of soot and metal-oxide nanoparticles in nanofluid fuel flames by a CCD camera. Int J Heat Mass Transfer, 2018, 124: 564–575
Liu G, Liu D. Noncontact direct temperature and concentration profiles measurement of soot and metal-oxide nanoparticles in optically thin/thick nanofluid fuel flames. Int J Heat Mass Transfer, 2019, 134: 237–249
Herman G T. Fundamentals of Computerized Tomography: Image Reconstruction from Projection. London: Springer, 2009
Tikhonov A N. Inverse problems in heat conduction. J Eng Phys, 1975, 29: 816–820
Gordon R, Bender R, Herman G T. Algebraic reconstruction techniques (ART) for three-dimensional electron microscopy and X-ray photography. J Theor Biol, 1970, 29: 471–481
Paige C C, Saunders M A. LSQR: An algorithm for sparse linear equations and sparse least squares. ACM Trans Math Softw, 1982, 8: 43–71
Landweber L. An iteration formula for Fredholm integral equations of the first kind. Am J Math, 1951, 73: 615–624
Dempster A. Maximum likelihood from incomplete data via the EM algorithm. J Roy Statist Soc Ser B, 1977, 39: 1–38
Hudson H M, Larkin R S. Accelerated image reconstruction using ordered subsets of projection data. IEEE Trans Med Imag, 1994, 13: 601–609
Liu F, Thomson K A, Smallwood G J. Soot temperature and volume fraction retrieval from spectrally resolved flame emission measurement in laminar axisymmetric coflow diffusion flames: Effect of self-absorption. Combust Flame, 2013, 160: 1693–1705
Ayrancı I, Vaillon R, Selçuk N, et al. Determination of soot temperature, volume fraction and refractive index from flame emission spectrometry. J Quantitative Spectr Radiative Transfer, 2007, 104: 266–276
Sun Y P, Lou C, Zhou H C. Estimating soot volume fraction and temperature in flames using stochastic particle swarm optimization algorithm. Int J Heat Mass Transfer, 2011, 54: 217–224
Liu G, Liu D. Effects of self-absorption on simultaneous estimation of temperature distribution and concentration fields of soot and metal-oxide nanoparticles in nanofluid fuel flames using a spectrometer. J Quantitative Spectr Radiative Transfer, 2018, 212: 149–159
Liu G, Liu D. On the treatment of self-absorption for temperature and concentration profiles reconstruction accuracy for soot and metal-oxide nanoparticles in nanofluid fuel flame using a CCD camera. Optik, 2018, 164: 114–125
Liu G, Liu D. Influence of self-absorption on reconstruction accuracy for temperature and concentration profiles of soot and metal-oxide nanoparticles in asymmetric nanofluid fuel flames. Optik, 2019, 178: 740–751
Modest M F. Radiative Heat Transfer. Amsterdam, Boston: Academic Press, 2003
Liu D, Huang Q X, Wang F, et al. Simultaneous measurement of three-dimensional soot temperature and volume fraction fields in axisymmetric or asymmetric small unconfined flames with CCD cameras. J Heat Transfer, 2010, 132: 061202
Liu D, Yan J H, Wang F, et al. Simultaneous experimental reconstruction of three-dimensional flame soot temperature and volume fraction distributions. Acta Phys Sin, 2011, 60: 060701
Köylü Ü Ö, McEnally C S, Rosner D E, et al. Simultaneous measurements of soot volume fraction and particle size/microstructure in flames using a thermophoretic sampling technique. Combust Flame, 1997, 110: 494–507
Xu Z, Zhao H, Chen X, et al. Multi-parameter measurements of laminar sooting flames using thermophoretic sampling technique. Combust Flame, 2017, 180: 158–166
Xu Z, Zhao H. Simultaneous measurement of internal and external properties of nanoparticles in flame based on thermophoresis. Combust Flame, 2015, 162: 2200–2213
Zhou H C, Han S D, Sheng F, et al. Visualization of three-dimensional temperature distributions in a large-scale furnace via regularized reconstruction from radiative energy images: Numerical studies. J Quantitative Spectr Radiative Transfer, 2002, 72: 361–383
Daun K J, Thomson K A, Liu F, et al. Deconvolution of axisymmetric flame properties using Tikhonov regularization. Appl Opt, 2006, 45: 4638–4646
Daun K J. Infrared species limited data tomography through Tikhonov reconstruction. J Quantitative Spectr Radiative Transfer, 2010, 111: 105–115
Daun K J, Grauer S J, Hadwin P J. Chemical species tomography of turbulent flows: Discrete ill-posed and rank deficient problems and the use of prior information. J Quantitative Spectr Radiative Transfer, 2016, 172: 58–74
Park Y, Reichel L, Rodriguez G, et al. Parameter determination for Tikhonov regularization problems in general form. J Comput Appl Math, 2018, 343: 12–25
Liu D, Wang F, Cen K, et al. Noncontact temperature measurement by means of CCD cameras in a participating medium. Opt Lett, 2008, 33: 422–424
Liu D, Yan J, Cen K. On the treatment of non-optimal regularization parameter influence on temperature distribution reconstruction accuracy in participating medium. Int J Heat Mass Transfer, 2012, 55: 1553–1560
Niu C Y, Qi H, Huang X, et al. Simultaneous reconstruction of temperature distribution and radiative properties in participating media using a hybrid LSQR-PSO algorithm. Chin Phys B, 2015, 24: 114401
Herman G T, Lent A, Lutz P H. Relaxation methods for image reconstruction. Commun ACM, 1978, 21: 152–158
Rossberg A, Funke H. Determining the radial pair distribution function from X-ray absorption spectra by use of the Landweber iteration method. J Synchrotron Rad, 2010, 17: 280–288
Terzija N, Davidson J L, Garcia-Stewart C A, et al. Image optimization for chemical species tomography with an irregular and sparse beam array. Meas Sci Technol, 2008, 19: 094007
Yang W Q, Spink D M, York T A, et al. An image-reconstruction algorithm based on Landweber’s iteration method for electrical-capacitance tomography. Meas Sci Technol, 1999, 10: 1065–1069
Shepp L A, Vardi Y. Maximum likelihood reconstruction for emission tomography. IEEE Trans Med Imag, 1982, 1: 113–122
Lange K, Carson R. EM reconstruction algorithms for emission and transmission tomography. J Comp Assisted Tomography, 1984, 8: 306–316
Gaitanis A, Kontaxakis G, Spyrou G, et al. PET image reconstruction: A stopping rule for the MLEM algorithm based on properties of the updating coefficients. Computized Med Imag Graphics, 2010, 34: 131–141
Verkruysse W, Todd L A. Novel algorithm for tomographic reconstruction of atmospheric chemicals with sparse sampling. Environ Sci Technol, 2005, 39: 2247–2254
Dey J, King M A. Theoretical and numerical study of MLEM and OSEM reconstruction algorithms for motion correction in emission tomography. IEEE Trans Nucl Sci, 2009, 56: 2739–2749
Chang H, Charalampopoulos T T. Determination of the wavelength dependence of refractive indices of flame soot. Proc R Soc Lond A Math Phys Sci, 1990, 430: 577–591
Querry M R. Optical Constants. Contractor Report. Aberdeen Proving Ground: US Army Chemical Research, Development and Engineering Center (CRDC), 1985. 39
Yu T, Cai W. Benchmark evaluation of inversion algorithms for tomographic absorption spectroscopy. Appl Opt, 2017, 56: 2183–2194
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
This work was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant Nos. 51 706141 and 51976122).
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Shui, C., Liu, H. & Cai, W. Benchmark evaluation of tomographic algorithms for simultaneous reconstruction of temperature and volume fraction fields of soot and metal-oxide nanoparticles in non-uniform flames. Sci. China Technol. Sci. 64, 237–250 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11431-019-1507-6
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11431-019-1507-6