Abstract
Purpose
Urban soils may be contaminated not only by industrial activities but also by the materials contained in the anthropogenic deposits. In order to anticipate the management of excavated soils linked to urban redevelopment, their quality and quantities need to be assessed. Urban soils and subsoils contain nevertheless a large variety of anthropogenic deposits and present important geochemical heterogeneities. The paper aims to develop various geochemical types of made grounds relevant for a 3D urban subsurface model.
Materials and methods
To build a 3D urban subsurface model, using geological tools, the challenge is to define a stratigraphic pile both geologically and geochemically relevant. In this frame, we defined a typology of made grounds based on an iterative approach. We used (a) published classifications, (b) a dataset of the study area (Ile de Nantes) comprising the borehole descriptions (2400), and (c) results of analyzed samples (more than 1800), gathered in a georeferenced database. The layers (8400) found in the borehole descriptions were interpreted according to the a priori made grounds typology and to the underneath natural layers. The relevance of the made ground typology proposed was verified by a statistical approach on the representative samples and analyses selected in the database.
Results and discussion
Three types of made grounds have been retained. They show contrasted geochemistry. The made grounds that are comparable to natural subsoils correspond in the case study to alluvial type materials. They show similarity with a typology and geochemistry of alluvial materials. The questionable man-made grounds, containing potentially contaminated anthropogenic materials such as bottom ash or slag, are characterized statistically by higher contaminant levels than other types of made grounds (e.g., PAH, Zn, Pb, Cu,...). The various man-made grounds, corresponding to the remaining materials and containing for instance demolition materials, are characterized statistically by higher levels of PCBs. The typology has been used in a 3D representation of the Ile de Nantes subsoils, which served as a decision aid tool for the developer.
Conclusions
The knowledge on urban subsoil geochemistry may help defining redevelopment projects, by adapting soil use to subsoil quality. In this frame, the development of a geochemically relevant made ground typology taking into account their intrinsic potential of contamination appears useful. A proper description of the intrinsic components of the made grounds is essential. It is indispensable to use some rigorously defined and internationally agreed terms.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Arrêté du 12 décembre 2014 relatif aux conditions d'admission des déchets inertes dans les installations relevant des rubriques 2515, 2516, 2517 et dans les installations de stockage de déchets inertes relevant de la rubrique 2760 de la nomenclature des installations classées. JORF n°0289, 14 décembre 2014, p 21032
Blanc C. (BRGM) with the collaboration of Lefevre F. (MEDDTL), Boissard G, Scamps M (BRGM) and Hazebrouck B (INERIS) (2012) Guide de réutilisation hors site des terres excavées en technique routière et dans des projets d’aménagement. BRGM/RP-60013-FR, 53p
De Beer J, Price S, Ford J (2012) 3D modelling of geological and anthropogenic deposits at the World Heritage Site of Bryggen in Bergen, Norway. Quaternary Int 251:107–116
Ellison RA, McMillan AA, Lott GK (2002) Ground characterisation of the urban environment: a guide to best practice, British Geological Survey Research Report RR/02/05, 37 p
Environmental Protection Agency (2002) European Waste Catalogue and Hazardous Waste List
Ford JR, Kessler H, Cooper AH, Price SJ, Humpage AJ (2006) An Enhanced Classification for Artificial Ground. British Geological Survey, Keyworth, Nottingham, UK. Report IR/04/038
Ford J, Kessler H, Cooper AH, Price SJ, Humpace AJ (2010a) An enhanced classification for artificial ground. British Geological Survey Open Report OR/10/036, 32 p
Ford JR, Mathers SJ, Royse KE, Aldiss DT, Morgan DJR (2010b) Geological 3D modelling: scientific discovery and enhanced understanding of the subsurface, with examples from the UK. Z Dtsch Ges Geowiss 161(162):205–218
Ford JR, Price SJ, Cooper AH, Waters CN (2014) An assessment of lithostratigraphy for anthropogenic deposits. Geol Soc, London, special publications 395:55–89
Jeanniot E, Carreau M, Le Guern C, Baudouin V, Bâlon P, Blanc C, Conil P (2014) La gestion des terres excavées sur les zones d’aménagement de l’Ile de Nantes, Journées Techniques Nationales « Reconversion des friches urbaines polluées », 25–26 mars 2014, Paris
Laurent A, Fondrillon M (2010) Mesurer la ville par l’évaluation et la caractérisation du sol urbain: l’exemple de Tours. Revue archéologique du Centre de la France, Tome 49
McMillan AA, Powell JH (1999) BGS Rock Classification Scheme, Volume 4: Classification of artificial (man-made) ground and natural superficial deposits—applications to geological map and datasets in the UK. British Geological Survey Research Report RR 99–04, 66p
Nirei H, Mezzano A, Satkunas J, Furuno K, Marker B, Mitamura M (2014) Environmental problems associated with man-made strata and their potential management. Episodes 37(1):33–40
Rosenbaum MS, McMillan AA, Powell JH, Cooper AH, Culshaw MG, Northmore KJ (2003) Classification of artificial (man-made) ground. Eng Geol 69:399–409
Royse KR, Rutter HK, Entwisle DC (2009) Property attribution of 3D geological models in the Thames Gateway, London: new ways of visualising geoscientific data. Bull Eng Geol Environ 68:1–16
Samoa (2016) Ile de Nantes–Make the city differently. http://www.iledenantes.com/en/
Tame C, Cundy AB, Royse KR, Smith M, Moles NR (2013) Three-dimensional geological modelling of anthropogenic deposits at small urban sites: a case study from Sheepcote Valley, Brighton, UK. J Env Manag 129:628–634
Villanneau E, Perry-Giraud C, Saby N, Jolivet C, Marot F, Maton D, Floch-Barneaud A, Antoni V, et Arrouays D (2008) Détection de valeurs anomaliques d’éléments traces métalliques dans les sols à l’aide du Réseau de Mesure de la Qualité des Sols, étude et Gestion des Sols, 15(3):183–200
Zalasiewicz J, Williams M, Fortey R, Smith A, Barry TL, Coe AL, Bown PR, Rawson PF, Gale A, Gibbard P, Gregory FJ, Hounslow MW, Kerr AC, Peason P, Knox R, Powell J, Waters C, Marshall J, Oates M, Stone P (2011) Stratigraphy of the Anthropocene. Phil Trans R Soc (Series A) 369:1036–1055
Acknowledgements
This study is funded by Samoa, Ademe, and BRGM. Thanks are addressed to the following students involved in the project: E. Bridier, A. Mouny, and A. Ménoury. Our colleagues Bernard Bourgine and Christelle Loiselet (BRGM) are also warmly thanked for the fruitfull discussions during the 3D model building and their support for the use of the GDM software.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Responsible editor: Maxine J. Levin
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Le Guern, C., Baudouin, V., Sauvaget, B. et al. A typology of anthropogenic deposits as a tool for modeling urban subsoil geochemistry: example of the Ile de Nantes (France). J Soils Sediments 18, 373–379 (2018). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11368-016-1594-z
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11368-016-1594-z