Advertisement

Scientometrics

, Volume 95, Issue 1, pp 371–384 | Cite as

Inconsistent transliteration of Iranian university names: a hazard to Iran’s ranking in ISI Web of Science

  • Mohammad Reza Falahati Qadimi Fumani
  • Marzieh Goltaji
  • Pardis Parto
Article

Abstract

Today, university ranking has turned into a critical issue in the world. Each university is identified with a surface form under which the whole performance of that university is assessed. This article intends to provide a clear picture of the inconsistencies observed in recording Iranian university titles by their affiliated authors and to clarify the negative impact of such inconsistencies in positioning Iranian universities in global university ranking systems. To collect various surface forms of Iranian university names, use was made of ISI Web of Science through keywords Cu = Iran and py = 2000–2009. Only MSRT universities were considered. Two M.A. experts listed all variant forms of a single university under that name. The form publicized in a university’s website was considered as its entry name. The major sources of variation identified were as follows: Acronyms, misspellings, abbreviations, space variations, syntactic permutation, application of vowels/consonants and vowel/consonant combinations, /a/vs./aa/, Tashdid, Kasra ezafe, redundancy, downcasing, voiceless glottal stop sound /?/, shortening and deletion of titles. It was found that at its present shape Iranian universities are not receiving the rank they really deserve simply because authors affiliated to a university use university title forms inconsistently. It was recommended that authors follow the surface form publicized by universities in their websites, use the help of an editor in their works, and not be credited for their articles in case the forms deviate from those publicized through the websites. A spell checker, as an add-ins software is highly needed to homogenize Iranian university surface forms by replacing the variants by the dominant form proposed.

Keywords

University ranking systems Iranian universities ISI Web of Science Persian-English transliteration Misspellings Information retrieval Persian orthography Downcasing 

References

  1. Ahmadi-Birjandi, A. (1973). Ghesse-ye por ghosse-ye ettesal va enfesal [The sorrowful story of joining and disjoining]. Yaghma, 26(7), 473–475.Google Scholar
  2. Akbarnejad, S. (1997). Fasele-ye khali miyan-e vajeha dar zakhire va bazyabi-ye rayane’i-ye ettela’at [The issue of inner and outer word spaces in information storage and retrieval]. Faslname-ye Ketab (pp. 49–56). Berlin: Spring and Summer Issue.Google Scholar
  3. Behzadi, M. (1996). Shive-ye zabt-e a’lam-e engelisi dar Farsi [A method for recording English proper nouns in Persian]. Tehran: Markaz-e Nashr-e Daneshgahi, Ketabkhane-ye melli-ye jomhoori-ye eslami-ye Iran.Google Scholar
  4. Chung, C.J., & Park, H.W. (2012). Web visibility of scholars in media and communication journals. Scientometrics. doi: 10.1007/s11192-012-0707-8, pp. 1–9.
  5. Emami, K. (1992). Lozoom-e baznegari dar shive-ye khatt-e Farsi [The need to revise Persian writing system]. Adine, 73(74), 18–19.Google Scholar
  6. Falahati Qadimi Fumani, M. R. (2010). Proposing a model of automatic key phrase indexing for a specific type of persian scientific articles based on a linguistically enriched statistical approach. India: Kuvempu Institute of Kannada Studies, University of Mysore.Google Scholar
  7. Falahati Qadimi Fumani, M. R. (2011). The Persian Agrovoc in an indexing context. Int. J. Index. (The Indexing), 29, 23–29.Google Scholar
  8. Falahati Qadimi Fumani, M. R., & Ramachandra, C. S. (2008). The concept of stopwords in Persian chemistry articles: A discussion in automatic indexing. Glossa, 4(1), 146–164.Google Scholar
  9. Feng, L., Yong, Y., Xiaolong, G., & Wei, Q. (2012). Performance evaluation of research universities in Mainland China, Hong Kong and Taiwan: based on a two-dimensional approach. Scientometrics, 90, 531–542. doi: 10.1007/s11192-011-0544-1.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Goltaji, M., & Alinejad Chamazkoti, F. (2011). Motale’e-ye ‘ashoftegi-ye negaresh-e nam-e daneshgahha-ye vezarat-e ‘olum, tahqiqat va fannavari dar paygah-e tamson roiterz va yekdast sazi-ye nam-e ‘anha [Iran’s MSRT university title variations in ISI Web of Science: The need for consistency]. Shiraz: Takht-e Jamshid Publications.Google Scholar
  11. Hendi, S. (2002). Dastoor-e khatt-e Farsi: shive’i dar negaresh-e kalameha-ye morakkab [Persian writing system grammar: a method to write compound terms]. Aamoozesh-e Zaban va Adab-e Farsi, 16(63), 27–31.Google Scholar
  12. Horri, A. (1993). Kampiyuter va rasm-ol-khatt-e Farsi [Computer and Persian writing system]. Payam-e Ketabkhane, 3(1), 6–11.Google Scholar
  13. IAPLL. (2007). Dastoor-e khatt-e Farsi [Persian writing system grammar] (7th ed.). Tehran: Farhangestan Publications.Google Scholar
  14. Jahanshahi, (1981). Rahnamay-e nevisande va virayesh [A guide for writers and editing]. Tehran: Shooray-e Ketab-e Koodak. Farhangname-ye Koodakan va Nojavanan.Google Scholar
  15. Kaboli, I. (1995). Vajesazi va bifasele nevisi [Word formation and joining of compound term elements]. Adine, 97, 56–59.Google Scholar
  16. Mar’ashi, A.A. (2002). Chegoone ba doshvarihay-e khatt-e farsi kenar biya’im? [How to deal with the difficulties in Persian writing system?] Technoloji-ye Amoozeshi, 17(137), 28–32.Google Scholar
  17. Ma’soumi-Hamadani, H. (2002). Khatt-e Farsi va rayane [Persian writing system and computer]. Nashr-e Danesh, 19(2), 2–6.Google Scholar
  18. Morteza’i, L. (2001). Masaa’ele zabaan va khatt-e Faarsi dar zakhire va baazyaabi-ye ettelaa’aat [The problems with Persian orthography in information retrieval and storage]. Faslnaame-ye Ettelaa’resaani [Ettelaa’resaani Quarterly], 17(1,2), 24–29.Google Scholar
  19. Najafi, A. (2005). Ghalat Nanevisim. Farhang-e doshvarihay-e zaban-e Farsi [Let’s write correct Persian. A dictionary of difficulties in Persian writing] (14th ed.). Tehran: Markaz-e Nashr-e Daneshgahi.Google Scholar
  20. Naseh, M. A. (2004). Negahi be Payannamehay-e daneshgahi dar zamine-ye khatte Farsi (1974–2003) [An overview of academic theses on Persian writing system (1974–2003)]. Name-ye Farhangestan, 6(3), 47–50.Google Scholar
  21. Pourjavadi, N. A. (2003). Dar jabolsay-e internet: zaroorat-e khatt-e latini baray-e Farsi [In the Internet: the need for the Penglish]. Nashr-e Danesh, 20(2), 2–5.Google Scholar
  22. Saffarpour, A. (2001). Olgoohaa-ye yaaddehi-yaadgiri- ye gaam be gaam-e enshaa-ye Faarsi [Teaching and learning step-wise patterns of Persian spelling]. Tehran: Mo'aseseGoogle Scholar
  23. Sama’i, S. M. (2004). Karbord-e neshaneha dar khatt-e Farsi [Use of punctuation marks in Persian orthography]. Oloom-e Ettela’ Resani, 19(1/2), 8–12.Google Scholar
  24. Sami’i-Gilani, A. (2000). Negaresh va virayesh [Writing and editting] (2nd ed.). Tehran: SAMT Publications.Google Scholar
  25. San’ati, M. (1992). Doshvariha-ye zaban-e Farsi ba kampiyuter [Difficulties in Persian computing]. Adine, 72, 56–57.Google Scholar
  26. Schulz, P.A., & Manganote, E.J.T. (2012). Revisiting country research profiles: learning about the scientific cultures. Scientometrics. doi: 10.1007/s11192-012-0696-7, pp. 1–15.
  27. Tayyeb, (1992). Homography in Persian. Res. J. Isfahan Univ. (Humanities), 4, 15–38.Google Scholar
  28. Yahaghi, M. J., & Naseh, M. M. (1992). Rahnamay-e negaresh va virayesh [A guide to writing and editing]. Tehran: Astan-e Ghods-e Razavi Publications.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Akadémiai Kiadó, Budapest, Hungary 2012

Authors and Affiliations

  • Mohammad Reza Falahati Qadimi Fumani
    • 1
  • Marzieh Goltaji
    • 2
  • Pardis Parto
    • 3
  1. 1.Faculty of Computational Linguistics Research DepartmentRegional Information Center for Science and Technology, RICeSTShirazIran
  2. 2.Islamic World Science Citation CenterShirazIRAN
  3. 3.Department of Evaluation and Collection Development, RICeSTShirazIran

Personalised recommendations